Welcome, Guest: Register On Nairaland / LOGIN! / Trending / Recent / NewStats: 3,218,406 members, 8,037,850 topics. Date: Thursday, 26 December 2024 at 06:42 PM |
Nairaland Forum / Nairaland / General / NYSC / The Minimum Wage Of N17, 000 Is Nonsense (10564 Views)
The Minimum Wage Should Be Implemented Now For Serving Nysc Members / The Minimum Wage Should Be Implemented Now For Serving Nysc Members / The Minimum Wage Should Be Implemented Now For Serving Nysc Members (2) (3) (4)
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (Reply) (Go Down)
Re: The Minimum Wage Of N17, 000 Is Nonsense by Kobojunkie: 6:00pm On Jul 14, 2010 |
Hi @Agibecky, what ISP do you use? |
Re: The Minimum Wage Of N17, 000 Is Nonsense by samdigo(m): 10:35pm On Jul 14, 2010 |
nigeria currency is useless, 17k is like 150 dollars per mont, dats crap |
Re: The Minimum Wage Of N17, 000 Is Nonsense by Nobody: 11:23pm On Jul 14, 2010 |
Agibecky:Touche. . . |
Re: The Minimum Wage Of N17, 000 Is Nonsense by tayoTFC(m): 10:48am On Jul 15, 2010 |
[s]minimum wages explains its self. . .its the lowest amount of money that will get you through. . .minimum wage is ment for your NEEDS in life. . .such as paying for food, Water, bills, Cheap Clothes, etc. . .It Is NOT MEANT FOR LUXURIES WANTS. . . .Such as TV, car, fine clothes, etc. . . .Minimum wage is just so you can get by through life until you can find a job. . .so why the complaining?[/s] good talk @femmmy why dont u depend on minimum wages rather than hussle in cotonu? 17K Naira to someone in a month after doing all you have listed is ought to be termed slavery.even giving that to a gate-man, security and all those uh ave mentioned is nonsense. how could a man secure the gate of the govt when he is hungry, how cld a gardener cut the grass well, when the school fees of his kids are yet to be paid, tell a cleaner to clean when how he or she will eat dinner is still a misery. tell ur them to go and update and upgrade them self if the what to earn above 17k period abi u go school? |
Re: The Minimum Wage Of N17, 000 Is Nonsense by Pappij: 12:20pm On Jul 15, 2010 |
Are u agitating for a ' Agibecky:Are u agitating for a 'coup d etat' now, the economy is messed up alright. We dont have to compound our lives with any form of further unrest. |
Re: The Minimum Wage Of N17, 000 Is Nonsense by agitator: 2:54pm On Jul 15, 2010 |
People should know that it's parent's of people like Ikengawo who destroy this country and because he is privileged to enjoy from the loot. He's always on nairaland talking rubbish. Continue, when the french revolution happened it didn't select people |
Re: The Minimum Wage Of N17, 000 Is Nonsense by agitator: 2:55pm On Jul 15, 2010 |
GAR3TH: So what is the wage for, social support? |
Re: The Minimum Wage Of N17, 000 Is Nonsense by agitator: 3:05pm On Jul 15, 2010 |
Bawss1: You are telling somebody who's job can't even pay is transport fare and feed him to improve. How, by stealing/embezzling? |
Re: The Minimum Wage Of N17, 000 Is Nonsense by GAR3TH(m): 3:15pm On Jul 15, 2010 |
agitator: sorry im edited my first response. . .i confused myself with unemployement checkes lol, . .each country has its own minimum wage. . .Luxembourg has a wage of $2416/m and other countries have 200/m. . .its what the government feels the lowest wage should be giving the economical situation. . .in my opinion, as of right now I feel that the minimum wage should increase slightly to N20,000. . .Increase enough so it can grow the econmy but not to much that it will hurt job creation. |
Re: The Minimum Wage Of N17, 000 Is Nonsense by Kobojunkie: 3:18pm On Jul 15, 2010 |
GAR3TH: hhmm . . . We know what minimum wage is but how exactly does this particular wage go to supplying for the NEEDs it is meant for? How? I know it is too easy to take SIDES on a subject without even trying to put oneself in the shoes of those affected. But could you pretend to know what people are complaining about for one second and please help them understand why, according to you, they should not complain anymore . . . Before you turn this into an US vs THEM debate, i tell you this . . . I am not going to get into that with anyone here. Just deal with that which was asked please. |
Re: The Minimum Wage Of N17, 000 Is Nonsense by GAR3TH(m): 3:44pm On Jul 15, 2010 |
Kobojunkie: Nigerians dont have a choice. . .the minimum wage is what it is and from what i hear it was lower before. . .I know I sound mean but The Minimum wage in my opinion, under the circumstances. . .is somewhat justified. . .the wage in my opinion can only rise to 20,000-30,000. . .if you increase the minimum wages you would hurt job growth. . .as we know right now. . .there are alot of unemployed people in Nigeria. Nigeria is not a developed country we all have to remember that. . .we all act like Nigeria is with all our demands. . .and stop comparing it to the likes of america. . .Look at china a developing economic superpower that is more develop than nigeria. . .they also have a large labor pool that needs jobs just like nigeria. . .do you know what there minimum wage is. . .US$140/M. . .About the same as Nigeria's. . . |
Re: The Minimum Wage Of N17, 000 Is Nonsense by Kobojunkie: 3:52pm On Jul 15, 2010 |
GAR3TH:No, you are not answering the question. You suggested they stopped complaining because this minimum wage out to provide for all their needs, yes or no? The question is not on how much it can rise or how much the government can afford. We are going off of the meaning you volunteered on the concept of minimum wage here. When it was lower, they complained it was not enough. Granted, it is higher now, but according to many, it is still not enough so the reason why they continue to complain. You however, suggest they STOP complaining because, according to your def. minimum wage ought to be used just for NEEDs and not for Luxuries and I am guessing you believe this minimum wage ought to provide for all their needs. Hence the reason why I ask that you help us understand exactly how that will work. GAR3TH:I am sorry? you all act . . . who are the you? GAR3TH:Who? Are you sure you are speaking to the right person here? You used the UNIVERSAL meaning here and all you are asked to do is provide more details as to how you justify this minimum wage by that. GAR3TH:First you say do not compare this with the US but you now want to compare this with China? And on what basis is this comparison being made? That cost of living in China is about the same as cost of living in Nigeria? |
Re: The Minimum Wage Of N17, 000 Is Nonsense by GAR3TH(m): 4:20pm On Jul 15, 2010 |
No, you are not answering the question. You suggested they stopped complaining because this minimum wage out to provide for all their needs, yes or no? First I Dont Believe this (nigeria's) minimum wage is ought to provide all your needs. . .But What Im saying is that this is what your going to get so try and make with it. many Nigerian companies cannot afford higher minimum wages. . .complaining wont help any body. I am sorry? you all act . . . who are the you? Nairalanders Who? Are you sure you are speaking to the right person here? You used the UNIVERSAL meaning here and all you are asked to do is provide more details as to how you justify this minimum wage by that. Once Again Nairalanders. . .this is a public forum. . .Im not just posting to you. . . First you say do not compare this with the US but you now want to compare this with China? And on what basis is this comparison being made? That cost of living in China is about the same as cost of living in Nigeria? First the U.S. is a develope country. . .Nigeria is not. . .we are not the same. . .The U.S. can afford a $7.50/hour wage. . .If nigeria offers that wage companies wont make a profit. . . Thats why I said stop comparing Nigeria to the U.S. and start comparing it to countries in similar situations such as china. [quote][/quote] |
Re: The Minimum Wage Of N17, 000 Is Nonsense by Kobojunkie: 4:28pm On Jul 15, 2010 |
GAR3TH: How do you know complaining will not help anybody? You admit that this is probably not going to help much but in the same breath you urge them to stop complaining? Come on now!! Have you ever had to live on Naira 20,000 or less a month in Nigeria? When I say live, I mean( Pay Rent, Feed self, afford transport, fuel, etc)? Do you understand the frustrations here? First the U.S. is a develope country. . .Nigeria is not. . .we are not the same. . .The U.S. can afford a $7.50/hour wage. . .If nigeria offers that wage companies wont make a profit. . . Thats why I said stop comparing Nigeria to the U.S. and start comparing it to countries in similar situations such as china. But again, why is China supposedly in similar situation that Nigeria is in. Apart from the fact that both are developing/underdeveloped. What else do the two countries have in common? Is cost of living in China same as that in Nigeria? Is the average Chinese more likely to face the same problems the average Nigerian does on a daily basis? What is the real basis of this comparison? Is it that you think the average Nigerian who is having to deal with life on minimum wage is concerned with what minimum wage is in other developing countries? We are not speaking of lazy bums but of some of most hardworking people in the nation as a whole. SOme of them work over 50 hour weeks and still struggle to make ends meet. They sit back wondering how come their bosses can afford to live lavishly while they can barely put food in their mouths. They read stories of reps being paid so many millions of naira, the worst in the world, and wonder why they cannot get a few naira more than what they currently get. And you are here to tell them they should no longer complain? |
Re: The Minimum Wage Of N17, 000 Is Nonsense by Nobody: 4:35pm On Jul 15, 2010 |
GAR3TH:do the maths by yourself if this amount is '' somewhat justifed'' in your own word. A man of 30 years with a wife and three kids living in a one bedreoom flat and he's expected to feed 5 people including himself,send his 3 children to school up to university level,transport the family,provide shelter,take care of his extend family responsiblities all on 17 thousand and he's expected to pay for his flat with atleast 70 thousand naira per annum.theoritically the money may sound big to some people,but practically on a daily basis is absoulte nothing. the most interesting part is that the civil service rules does not allow for workers to source income from others means.what do you expect the poor man to do ? |
Re: The Minimum Wage Of N17, 000 Is Nonsense by xterra2(m): 4:39pm On Jul 15, 2010 |
Kobojunkie:Hi @ Kobojunkie no offence intended but why were you asking |
Re: The Minimum Wage Of N17, 000 Is Nonsense by Kobojunkie: 4:40pm On Jul 15, 2010 |
I am inquiring about reliable ISPs |
Re: The Minimum Wage Of N17, 000 Is Nonsense by GAR3TH(m): 4:41pm On Jul 15, 2010 |
, Kobojunkie: Complaining NEVER SOLVES ANYTHING. . .Nigerians Have been Complaining for 50 Years about electricity, nothing happened, Water, nothing happened, Better leader, nothing happens, roads, nothing happened. . .If you want something stop complaining and actually deal with the problem with some action. . .dont just talk. . .If nigerians did not complain an actually did something we could as well be a develop country by know. And no I have not lived with N20,000/M But again, why is China supposedly in similar situation that Nigeria is in. Apart from the fact that both are developing/underdeveloped. What else do the two countries have in common? Is cost of living in China same as that in Nigeria? Is the average Chinese more likely to face the same problems the average Nigerian does on a daily basis? What is the real basis of this comparison? Is it that you think the average Nigerian who is having to deal with life on minimum wage is concerned with what minimum wage is in other developing countries? The Large Unemployed labor pool. . .Thats why china has a low minimum wage because their are a large number of unemployed people. . .and by having a low minimum wage you can increase job growth. . .Thats why you hear that american jobs are going over seas to china. . .A low minimum wage can be a good thing sometimes. . .it can help with job growth as nigeria really needs |
Re: The Minimum Wage Of N17, 000 Is Nonsense by xterra2(m): 4:42pm On Jul 15, 2010 |
Kobojunkie:Ok Thank you , Which do you use ?? |
Re: The Minimum Wage Of N17, 000 Is Nonsense by GAR3TH(m): 4:44pm On Jul 15, 2010 |
~Bluetooth: I never said that the minimum wage was ethically right. . .what i said was giving the circumstances that nigeria is in the minimum wage is about at the right amount, though it could be higher. |
Re: The Minimum Wage Of N17, 000 Is Nonsense by Kobojunkie: 4:50pm On Jul 15, 2010 |
Complaining NEVER SOLVES ANYTHING. . .Nigerians Have been Complaining for 50 Years about electricity, nothing happened, Water, nothing happened, Better leader, nothing happens, roads, nothing happened. . .If you want something stop complaining and actually deal with the problem with some action. . .dont just talk. . .If nigerians did not complain an actually did something we could as well be a develop country by know.Wait a second . . . they complained and got an increase, but instead you are here telling us complaining does not solve anything? You mean people around the world should stop protesting, stop petitioning for change, stop complaining about their salaries, and how a raise in necessary, to their bosses, and stop trying to get their complaints heard simply because you have concluded in your world that complaining does not work? ROFLMAO!!! Since you have not lived on less than Naira 20,000 a month, can I then conclude that you probably have no idea as well why these people are so frustrated and want to complain and get someone to do something extra about this while they are doing something now? The Large Unemployed labor pool. . .Thats why china has a low minimum wage because their are a large number of unemployed people. . .and by having a low minimum wage you can increase job growth. . .Thats why you here that american jobs are going over seas to china. . .A low minimum wage can be a good thing sometimes. . .it can help with job growth as nigeria really needsYou say not to compare with US but yet you keep comparing with America. Sigh! Can you please answer the questions asked? I did not ask you of benefits of minimum wage or low minimum wage. I asked you direct questions about conclusions you made earlier and would appreciate it if you spent time actually answering those please. |
Re: The Minimum Wage Of N17, 000 Is Nonsense by xterra2(m): 4:51pm On Jul 15, 2010 |
Okay i think this is the right step Re-read my earlier post Re: The Minimum Wage Of N17, 000 Is Nonsense « #65 on: July 13, 2010, 03:29 PM » Quote from: xterra2 on July 13, 2010, 02:20 PM I dont why People are criticising this as to it is too small Firstly the former minimum wage is N5,500 and for it to be N17,000 is good news now people get this it is minimum wage not your monthly wage And though currently it is not enough it would go a long way to some people and no countries minimum wage is ever enough Take this for example in US you have five kids and your minimum wage is $400 and after four years you get 3 children again which means more food,school fees,a bigger house,more clothes,and a new car mini bus like toyota sienna,to accomodate the children while a person on the same minimum wage of $400 with one or no children would be better off , so really size matters , what am saying is that to SOME people it would be okay for them and SOME would still be inadequate but would help in a way, And the N52,000 minimum wage they demanded is unrealistic as we have millions of workers and multiply it with N52,000 and see , Now if they government does what is right by building trains and better transport also by building good and cheap affordable schools and helping farmers which would in turn make food prices cheap * and also transport when government builds rail all over instead of spending about N100 or N200 normally you would spend just N20 and like i said help farmers food would be cheaper and also bring back industrIES Plural some would come and bring competition which would bring down the price of just about anything from cloth,furniture,school books and so on, that N17,000 would be enough for MANY people IF NOT all But this N17,000 is enough for SOME people and people it is not more N17,000 it would be N18,000 when Justice Belgore Alfa recommendation is accepted and Legislated |
Re: The Minimum Wage Of N17, 000 Is Nonsense by Kobojunkie: 4:51pm On Jul 15, 2010 |
xterra2: why? |
Re: The Minimum Wage Of N17, 000 Is Nonsense by Nobody: 4:58pm On Jul 15, 2010 |
GAR3TH:so why arguing about it if you know it's ethically wrong ? The point is that the review of workers' salaries which ought to be an annual thing is done only when election period is at the corner.the last one was done is 2006 when the 2007 election was approaching and no review was made in 2007,2008,2009,only for the federal government to add peanut to the existing peanut and we are praising the FG as if it has done something special. |
Re: The Minimum Wage Of N17, 000 Is Nonsense by Kobojunkie: 5:00pm On Jul 15, 2010 |
~Bluetooth:BAM!! |
Re: The Minimum Wage Of N17, 000 Is Nonsense by agitator: 5:09pm On Jul 15, 2010 |
~Bluetooth: You didn't even mention the increase in prices as a fallout of this announcement which may only be implemented at least three months from the announcement. plus the states will pay lower than this amount being argued about |
Re: The Minimum Wage Of N17, 000 Is Nonsense by GAR3TH(m): 5:11pm On Jul 15, 2010 |
Kobojunkie: I Thought it was the gov. that just increased the wage. . .if it was 'cause of their complaining then i stand corrected. . .But you do realized that complaining and Petitioning are two different things along with the others in bold. . .Complaining is talking while the other are doing action. And I Know how its like to be poor. . . You say not to compare with US but yet you keep comparing with America. Sigh! I did Answer them |
Re: The Minimum Wage Of N17, 000 Is Nonsense by Kobojunkie: 5:18pm On Jul 15, 2010 |
GAR3TH:It was the complaining -- it has been going on for decades. Even the protests and many strikes. GAR3TH:That is not true. Petitions are the "NEW AGE" way of complaining. People who do not have access to internet and petition services can complain their way to change. It is the same thing only one seems more SOPHISTICATED than the other but the results are usually linked. GAR3TH:You do? How poor? Naira 20,000(or less) a month poor? Naira 50,000 - 20000 a month poor? Naira 100,000 - 50000 a month poor? Naira 250,000 - 100000 a month poor? How poor? GAR3TH:Where? You mean you answered the following questions? Apart from the fact that both are developing/underdeveloped. What else do the two countries have in common? Is cost of living in China same as that in Nigeria? |
Re: The Minimum Wage Of N17, 000 Is Nonsense by GAR3TH(m): 5:18pm On Jul 15, 2010 |
~Bluetooth: lol I'm not arguing about it. . .my point is that yes it ethically wrong. . .but at the same time its technically right considering nigeria's circumstances. . .I really don't know why Kobo keeps replying to everything i say. . .making it seem like an argument. . .I'm on the same side as her saying that its to low. |
Re: The Minimum Wage Of N17, 000 Is Nonsense by Kobojunkie: 5:25pm On Jul 15, 2010 |
GAR3TH: I am trying to understand the reasoning behind your argument is why. Yes, minimum wage is to help provide for the basics but even this increase does not considering the true reality of life in Nigeria and I wondered why you would expect people not to continue complaining until they get better deals/benefits. You might have figured that Nigeria cannot afford to pay them more but I don't think the average worker out there who works labouring under the sun to feed his family and self wants to concern himself with that. He sees how the leaders share money the way they want . . he sees how billions supposed to be spent to improve living for him are wisked away to foreign accounts and pockets of the rich and fat and he wonders why it seems the harder he works, the more expensive life gets for him. He has a right to be frustrated and complain the way he knows how to. |
Re: The Minimum Wage Of N17, 000 Is Nonsense by GAR3TH(m): 5:36pm On Jul 15, 2010 |
Kobojunkie: LOL NEW AGE . . . People with out computers lol. . .People have been petitioning for thousands of years. . .Face it complaining(talk) is different from petitioning(action). . . You do? about N50,000 and that was when i was in maryland, USA. . .but My family is doing better now. . . You mean you answered the following questions? just like India its The large Unemployed Labor Pool Is the average Chinese more likely to face the same problems the average Nigerian does on a daily basis? Yes they have the same problems as we. . .Not all of china is developed you know. . .maybe I should Have used India. What is the real basis of this comparison? To show an example of another country in a similar position. . .showing that the amount is technical right when compared to similar countries.
I was just backing up my claim of "technically right" by giving examples and comparisons of other countries |
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (Reply)
What Can I Do With My LL.B & B.L & No NYSC? / Bayelsa B15 Lets Meet Here / Meaning And Process Of NYSC Remobilization.
(Go Up)
Sections: politics (1) business autos (1) jobs (1) career education (1) romance computers phones travel sports fashion health religion celebs tv-movies music-radio literature webmasters programming techmarket Links: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) Nairaland - Copyright © 2005 - 2024 Oluwaseun Osewa. All rights reserved. See How To Advertise. 116 |