theTranslator:

you should go to the beginning of the argument to understand what we talking about

that just30 guy is an illiterate

imagine saying Hausa is made up of different "tribes"
very dumb

Just30:
Actually they do....

Go and learn, the internet is a free tool for you to use and see all the Romanic conquest which are well documented.

You are really dumb, do you mean that the Celtic and Slavic are extinct ? Or do you mean the Franks and the Saxons are extinct?

You think they study history in their country for nothing ? Even their names have origin to pinpoint a particular tribe..

Don't be dumb, history is how the US has managed to hold Europe with a firm grip by playing on their tribal fears.


The highlighted comment above is super dumb

The Western Sahara civilization and Northern Saharan civilization had very little contact ...

You haven't finish with one dumb argument and you are already making another dumb argument.

vankelvin:
[/b]

That's in Ghanaian context Ghanaian Hausa people are not considered an ethnic group. We consider them as a Tribe not an Ethnic group

vankelvin:
[/b]

That's in Ghanaian context Ghanaian Hausa people are not considered an ethnic group. We consider them as a Tribe not an Ethnic group

theTranslator:

those groups are extinct
they've mixed out and they are no longer functional

you're stupid bro
if you don't know that almost all of west Africa was barren until migration from north and east Africa

you're very delusional
you create your history and you believe it at the same time

theTranslator:

oh!

so ghana Hausa is a combination of different "tribes"?

you're just as dumb as dumb30

Mkenya2019:
No country has developed on a foundation of flea market. Your informal retail and wholesale need to give way to formal retails - I mean supermakets and malls - because it benefits the consumers, the retailers, the manufacturers and gov better when things are organized. With a supermarket - a manufacturer knows he can get large order so they produce more - the consumers will get very low prices (this what is drawing kenyans away from small retailers) because discounts in there are bigger and shopping way better experience - the retailer hire more people and generate more profit selling more - the gov get way more taxes - than trying to chase a million informal traders around town.

The same for all other sectors - agricluture, services, industries, ICT, housing, name it - they need to formalize - because of ECONOMIES OF SCALES - if not you should at least try cooperatives - which give you communism like bargaining power.

Just30:
Actually they do....

Go and learn, the internet is a free tool for you to use and see all the Romanic conquest which are well documented.

You are really dumb, do you mean that the Celtic and Slavic are extinct ? Or do you mean the Franks and the Saxons are extinct?

You think they study history in their country for nothing ? Even their names have origin to pinpoint a particular tribe..

Don't be dumb, history is how the US has managed to hold Europe with a firm grip by playing on their tribal fears.


The highlighted comment above is super dumb

The Western Sahara civilization and Northern Saharan civilization had very little contact ...

You haven't finish with one dumb argument and you are already making another dumb argument.

Lunacy Is doing you

Abohboy:


The problem is you claimed 90% how does that work? Undoubtedly populations from large African civilizations migrated to different areas after the collapse and influenced the cultures of said areas but these places already had people living there so to say 90% can trace their origin to one place is stupid

The Nok were in Nigeria and The Sao in Chad and Niger before the Ancient Ghana empire was even in existence a few refugees from these empires could have assimilated but not 90% as yoou wrongly claimed

vankelvin:


Let say Nigeria have
Ethnic groups and their sub groups whereas
Ghana have Ethnic groups and their Tribes.

Is that simple?
This shouldn't be a debate

Just30:
How are entire ethnic groups across the entire West Africa just a few refugees?

Abohboy:


I'm talking about the people from Ancient Ghana, Or Ancient Nubia, Or Ancient Kemet or which society you want to claim as origin only a few people from there actually left their homeland to other places in Africa the vast majority of these ethnic groups populations were already established before Ancient Ghana was even made

Just30:
None of those groups are extinct... If you don't know, just say you don't know.


Everyone knows that West Africa was barren and all the people here migrated from within the Sahara and not North Africa...
Change in climate conditions and constant attacks is what drove them south to West Africa.

Don't make those dumb mistakes again.


Go and learn proper history and stop delving in lies and stupid arguments.

vankelvin:


[s]Smart people ignore comments, they don't waste time to cancel comments.. Asylum seeker
You must have been pained by my comment that's why you made time to even read and cancel...

Ekwensu[/s]

Just30:

Let me help you here

The vast majority of ethnic groups in today west Africa were in the Ancient Ghana empire area..
Saying this does not mean that Small villages like Timbuktu Gao and Nok did not exist.
That Ghana empire later became the Songhai Mali empire which established Timbuktu, Gao and Nok under it leadership.

And all those happened before the great exedos South wards

theTranslator:

can you explain why many ethnicities claim origin from the nile valley?

and most of the Sahara is in north Africa
you this illiterate

Just30:
How are entire ethnic groups across the entire West Africa just a few refugees?
Even Timbuktu existed before Gao and Nok

But the majority of people existed in the Empire while Timbuktu, Gao and Nok were small villages

Tibimabln:
Mynd44

Mkenya2019:
Kenya has issues - hyperinflation is one one of them. We have very stable macro-econonomics but we have a big problem with debt - that is dangerously on the cliff. We simply need to stop borrowing - and focus on refinancing - and on PPP for financing infrastracture. We need to sell more than 200 SOES that kenya gov owns.

theTranslator:

can you explain why many ethnicities claim origin from the nile valley?

and most of the Sahara is in north Africa
you this illiterate

Abohboy:


You clearly don't know anything about history

Ancient Ghana empire was founded or at least as far as we know actually became large around 300AD

Meanwhile Nok had already covered land the northern extremities of Nigeria past the confluence and had been working Iron and clay since about 1000BC

Nsibidi script has been found on over a thousand monoliths spread out in an area that covers Cameroon, Cross River State and Abia State in Nigeria and they date to about 2000BC

Both are way way older then the Ancient Ghana empire the most likely case is that these people already lived there and already had established nations and languages then those from Ancient Ghana came as refugees and brought aspects of their culture into other parts of Africa

The Ancient Ghana empire is too young for you to be claiming that it is the origin of All West African groups maybe it's the origin of the Asante but it isn't the origin of any ethnic group in Nigeria or Benin and that includes the Fon and the Ga.

Just30:


The Nile valley was fertile ground and Many East African and South African tribes claim origin from around it, as it was closer to many other civilization for trade.

You dumb illiterate , learn