Welcome, Guest: Register On Nairaland / LOGIN! / Trending / Recent / New
Stats: 3,217,607 members, 8,034,822 topics. Date: Sunday, 22 December 2024 at 01:07 PM

Why Would An Innocent Baby Go To Hell In Islam? - Islam for Muslims (2) - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum / Nairaland / General / Religion / Islam for Muslims / Why Would An Innocent Baby Go To Hell In Islam? (759 Views)

Saying That Specific People Are Going To Paradise Or Hell in Islam / Some Acts That Make A Muslim Forbidden To Hell / Your Phone May Lead You To HELL FIRE. (2) (3) (4)

(1) (2) (3) (4) (Reply) (Go Down)

Re: Why Would An Innocent Baby Go To Hell In Islam? by budaatum: 8:58pm On Dec 18
TenQ:

How do you know that Judaism told a lie? How do you know who Adam was?

What is your own source of evidence?

Listen to you being Islamically asking for an hadith, lol, even after Christianity has taught you to be ministered to by a holy spirit.

It is a lie that Adam's eating of the fruit of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil would kill him because in their very own book we can clearly see that he did not die after eating it!

A person who chooses to use their own brain would understand that depriving people of knowledge as that story suggests, would only make those deprived people slaves to those who do not deprive themselves of knowledge. After all, some in that same story must have been eating the fruit that Adam was farming but was forbidden to eat. Or are you one of those who have been made to believe that the Adam that was made from mud is the same creation in God's Image?

Thankfully, the story also shows how to free oneself from the ignorance of slavery and go on to live about a 1000 years and populate the entire earth.

The entire story is mythical, as in made up and never happened, but one must be aware of its potential to program your mind so your mind is not adversely programmed.
Re: Why Would An Innocent Baby Go To Hell In Islam? by TenQ: 9:07pm On Dec 18
budaatum:


Sorry TenQ, but from where I am looking, you are practising your own private understanding of Islam while insisting you are not allowed or that the understanding you have adopted is the only understanding allowed.

You have after all come across various hadiths by various people that contradict each other and therefore show private interpretation is very much done in Islam, and that's apart from the various diverse interpretations presented to you here. You're even likely aware that there are various different sects of Islam too, which is clear evidence of private interpretation. Or would you like to argue that the boko haram interpretation is accepted by all Muslims?
I have not said anything different from what their hadiths say
BUT
They disagree




So, interpret the hadith below

Sunan Abi Dawud 4717
‘Amir reported the Messenger of Allah (May peace be upon him) as saying :
The woman who buries alive her new-born girl and the girl who is buried alive both will go to Hell. This tradition has also been transmitted by Ibn Mas’ud from the Prophet (May peace be upon him) to the same effect through a different chain of narrators




What is your understanding of this Hadith?
Is it that Babies will not go to Hell for being buried alive?
Re: Why Would An Innocent Baby Go To Hell In Islam? by TenQ: 9:09pm On Dec 18
RealLordZeus:

This made me realise he's a kid just throwing tantrums
Unlike the general view, I don't have any issues questioning our beliefs.
By questioning, you either derail or grow stronger.

God gave us free will and the grey matter between our skulls for a purpose and its a sin not to utilise it.

I welcome every enlightening debates not stereotypes trying to force their view or insult peoples faith based on their own perception.
And when you attack their faith, it will falter under scrutiny
His verse of truth, I requested for like 10 posts up he's yet to reply.

It's amazing when the pillars of your faith is written by unknown authors without any straight line to the source.
I have asked you a simple question but your love for self deception would not allow you answer it.

Again:


Why where you afraid to translate the phrase and answer my question
What is the الْمَوْءُودَةُ (Al-maw’ūdatu)


Does it mean
1. The girl who was buried
OR
2. The midwife who buried her



By the way, the phrase in contention is
"الْوَائِدَةُ وَالْمَوْءُودَةُ فِي النَّارِ."
Re: Why Would An Innocent Baby Go To Hell In Islam? by TenQ: 9:13pm On Dec 18
budaatum:


Listen to you being Islamically asking for an hadith, lol, even after Christianity has taught you to be ministered to by a holy spirit.

It is a lie that Adam's eating of the fruit of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil would kill him because in their very own book we can clearly see that he did not die after eating it!

A person who chooses to use their own brain would understand that depriving people of knowledge as that story suggests, would only make those deprived people slaves to those who do not deprive themselves of knowledge. After all, some in that same story must have been eating the fruit that Adam was farming but was forbidden to eat. Or are you one of those who have been made to believe that the Adam that was made from mud is the same creation in God's Image?

Thankfully, the story also shows how to free oneself from the ignorance of slavery and go on to live about a 1000 years and populate the entire earth.

The entire story is mythical, as in made up and never happened, but one must be aware of its potential to program your mind so your mind is not adversely programmed.
I ask again, what is your source?

How do you know that Judaism told a lie? How do you know who Adam was?

What is your own source of evidence?
Re: Why Would An Innocent Baby Go To Hell In Islam? by budaatum: 9:15pm On Dec 18
TenQ:

What is your understanding of this Hadith?
Is it that Babies will not go to Hell for being buried alive?

My understanding of the hadith is that it is the same nonsense as me telling kids that Father Christmas would not bring them presents if they continue to be naughty. And I'd consider those kids rather stupid and ignorant if when they become grown ups do not realise it was just a tool to control them.

Both Father Christmas and hell do not exist, and I'd expect you to put away such childish beliefs eventually. But if you do become an adult and start arguing about presents from father Christmas, I'm bound to form a particular opinion about the non-development of your mind.
Re: Why Would An Innocent Baby Go To Hell In Islam? by AntiisIam(m): 9:19pm On Dec 18
AntiChristian:


The hadith has a Tafsir which defines those going to hell!
So the rightful translation of the hadith is The one who buried the infant girl and the one who had her buried will both enter Hell.

If you don't hide under surat tafsir you go hide under surat comprehension kilode gan self
Re: Why Would An Innocent Baby Go To Hell In Islam? by budaatum: 9:24pm On Dec 18
TenQ:

I ask again, what is your source?

How do you know that Judaism told a lie? How do you know who Adam was?

What is your own source of evidence?

What is my hadith? Lol.

Genesis 1 to 5 is mythological. The story itself shows it is made up mythology since no one could have possibly been there recording what happened and nor did God write it since its not in the first person.

That mythical Adam himself in the story was lied to is also obvious from the fictional story since he did not die on eating the fruit that was claimed would kill him. And that's apart from numerous verses in the same book that show that it is the opposite of knowledge that kills.

As for how I know, that's by doing what Christ taught, ask and knock and seek with ones whole heart and soul and mind and being. Its called, research. You don't only acquire knowledge if you do as he taught, but also understanding and eventually, wisdom.
Re: Why Would An Innocent Baby Go To Hell In Islam? by budaatum: 9:29pm On Dec 18
TenQ:

Unfortunately, the Muslims I am addressing know that Hell exists.

To you who thinks that the Uncaused First Cause of everything aka God doesn't exist, what lie and deception can be greater than this?

Do you seriously believe your imaginary Uncaused First Cause of everything is uncaused by something?

I don't, because I happen to know the human mind is capable of causing a lot of causes, even imaginary ones like hell and gods.
Re: Why Would An Innocent Baby Go To Hell In Islam? by TenQ: 9:43pm On Dec 18
budaatum:


My understanding of the hadith is that it is the same nonsense as me telling kids that Father Christmas would not bring them presents if they continue to be naughty. And I'd consider those kids rather stupid and ignorant if when they become grown ups do not realise it was just a tool to control them.

Both Father Christmas and hell do not exist, and I'd expect you to put away such childish beliefs eventually. But if you do become an adult and start arguing about presents from father Christmas, I'm bound to form a particular opinion about the non-development of your mind.
So you agree that the hadith says that both the mother and the buried baby will go to hell?
OR
Only the mother and the one who buried the child will go to hell?



Sunan Abi Dawud 4717
‘Amir reported the Messenger of Allah (May peace be upon him) as saying :
The woman who buries alive her new-born girl and the girl who is buried alive both will go to Hell. This tradition has also been transmitted by Ibn Mas’ud from the Prophet (May peace be upon him) to the same effect through a different chain of narrators
Re: Why Would An Innocent Baby Go To Hell In Islam? by TenQ: 9:45pm On Dec 18
AntiisIam:


If you don't hide under surat tafsir you go hide under surat comprehension kilode gan self
Later they will come out to tell us that it was the Jews that wrote the hadith and Tafsir.

SMH!!
Re: Why Would An Innocent Baby Go To Hell In Islam? by AntiisIam(m): 9:46pm On Dec 18
TenQ:

Later they will come out to tell us that it was the Jews that wrote the hadith and Tafsir.

SMH!!

grin Oh my God grin grin
Re: Why Would An Innocent Baby Go To Hell In Islam? by TenQ: 9:46pm On Dec 18
budaatum:


What is my hadith? Lol.

Genesis 1 to 5 is mythological. The story itself shows it is made up mythology since no one could have possibly been there recording what happened and nor did God write it since its not in the first person.

That mythical Adam himself in the story was lied to is also obvious from the fictional story since he did not die on eating the fruit that was claimed would kill him. And that's apart from numerous verses in the same book that show that it is the opposite of knowledge that kills.

As for how I know, that's by doing what Christ taught, ask and knock and seek with ones whole heart and soul and mind and being. Its called, research. You don't only acquire knowledge if you do as he taught, but also understanding and eventually, wisdom.
Sorry!
Since you do not practice either Judaism, Christianity or Islam, you need to present your source of knowledge that counters what you read in the scripture.

Is your source your feeling?
Re: Why Would An Innocent Baby Go To Hell In Islam? by TenQ: 9:47pm On Dec 18
budaatum:


Do you seriously believe your imaginary Uncaused First Cause of everything is uncaused by something?

I don't, because I happen to know the human mind is capable of causing a lot of causes, even imaginary ones like hell and gods.
The Human mind and EVERYTHING else came out of NOTHING!?

How do you know this wonderful information?
Re: Why Would An Innocent Baby Go To Hell In Islam? by AntiisIam(m): 9:48pm On Dec 18
AntiChristian:



Bobo ti jakpa, slave context oya come and finish what you started
Re: Why Would An Innocent Baby Go To Hell In Islam? by TenQ: 9:50pm On Dec 18
AntiisIam:


grin Oh my God grin grin
Just imagine how they find it convenient to read what doesn't exist into the plain text of the hadith.

I read it again and ai wonder where they saw it that the Babygirl would not go to hell.

Sunan Abi Dawud 4717
‘Amir reported the Messenger of Allah (May peace be upon him) as saying :
The woman who buries alive her new-born girl and the girl who is buried alive both will go to Hell. This tradition has also been transmitted by Ibn Mas’ud from the Prophet (May peace be upon him) to the same effect through a different chain of narrators
Re: Why Would An Innocent Baby Go To Hell In Islam? by budaatum: 9:54pm On Dec 18
TenQ:

The Human mind and EVERYTHING else came out of NOTHING!?

How do you know this wonderful information?

The human mind did not come out of nothing, TenQ. You'd know this if you went and studied some history and biology instead of living by one book alone.

Even those who sold you that book are moving on, but here you are, stuck, sadly.
Re: Why Would An Innocent Baby Go To Hell In Islam? by budaatum: 9:57pm On Dec 18
TenQ:

Sorry!
Since you do not practice either Judaism, Christianity or Islam, you need to present your source of knowledge that counters what you read in the scripture.

Is your source your feeling?

Scripture and the Quran both tell you to read much more widely, and I'd suggest you obey one at least instead of merely believing what you refuse to practice.

Re: Why Would An Innocent Baby Go To Hell In Islam? by TenQ: 10:14pm On Dec 18
budaatum:


The human mind did not come out of nothing, TenQ. You'd know this if you went and studied some history and biology instead of living by one book alone.

Even those who sold you that book are moving on, but here you are, stuck, sadly.

My little science tells me that time, mass, energy and the laws of physics,and chemistry came after the 13.8 billion years ago

Therefore, prior to this time NOTHING existed.

Thus, if there is no Uncaused First-Cause of everything, the conclusion is that everything including the chemicals that made up biological beings came out of NOTHING!

By the way, you should be able to tell us how life with it's information came about.


I am waiting!
Show us how
The Human mind and EVERYTHING else came out of NOTHING!?
Re: Why Would An Innocent Baby Go To Hell In Islam? by ConDawah: 10:16pm On Dec 18
TenQ:

The reason is because the Allah of the Muslims is satan himself and Mohammed is one of the greatest Antichrists of all times. Islam is primarily anti-salvation in Christ.

Thus
YHWH is replaced by the Al-Makr
Jesus is replaced by Mohammed
The Holy Spirit is replaced with Jibril

And droves are going to hell oblivious of the pit of 419 they have fallen into.
The
It's not a surprise that the religion's primary purpose is attacking the only hope of salvation for mankind (The atonement of sin by the death and resurrection of Jesus Christ).
This epidemy has been sustained till now only by deception and outright perversion of truth and making sure the teeming followers are kept ignorant of the real face of the religion. If all these fail, they resort to coercion. No wonder the penalty for apostasy is death in Islam.
These people literally pray towards are black stone in Mecca and kiss it when they go there on pilgrimage, but somehow still convinced they're worshipping the God of Abraham?
If time permits, I'll create threads to address the absurdities in this religion to open the eyes of those who are blindly following.
Re: Why Would An Innocent Baby Go To Hell In Islam? by TenQ: 10:18pm On Dec 18
budaatum:


Scripture and the Quran both tell you to read much more widely, and I'd suggest you obey one at least instead of merely believing what you refuse to practice.
Anyone can say anything or have opinions about anything. Thus, I ask for your source and authority for your position.

Don't you want me to scrutinize it?

I want to be able to quote your source and see if you are consistent with what you claim
Re: Why Would An Innocent Baby Go To Hell In Islam? by budaatum: 10:24pm On Dec 18
TenQ:

Anyone can say anything or have opinions about anything. Thus, I ask for your source and authority for your position.

Don't you want me to scrutinize it?

I want to be able to quote your source and see if you are consistent with what you claim

My source is your Holy Bible.

Read it and show me where Adam died from eating a fruit of the tree of knowledge of good and evil!

And while you are scrutinising it, kindly show me your source for not believing in loving your neighbour just because they read a different book to your own. Or is it that you believe but do not need to practise?
Re: Why Would An Innocent Baby Go To Hell In Islam? by budaatum: 10:31pm On Dec 18
TenQ:

My little science tells me that time, mass, energy and the laws of physics,and chemistry came after the 13.8 billion years ago

Therefore, prior to this time NOTHING existed.

Think just a little. You don't know what existed 100,000 years ago, but you are here confidently claiming to know nothing existed 13.8 billion years ago?

Even science does not make such a stupid claim, and recognises something must have existed for something to go bang!
Re: Why Would An Innocent Baby Go To Hell In Islam? by TenQ: 10:34pm On Dec 18
ConDawah:

It's not a surprise that the religion's primary purpose is attacking the only hope of salvation for mankind (The atonement of sin by the death and resurrection of Jesus Christ).
This epidemy has been sustained till now only by deception and outright perversion of truth and making sure the teeming followers are kept ignorant of the real face of the religion. If all these fail, they resort to coercion. No wonder the penalty for apostasy is death in Islam.
These people literally pray towards are black stone in Mecca and kiss it when they go there on pilgrimage, but somehow still convinced they're worshipping the God of Abraham?
If time permits, I'll create threads to address the absurdities in this religion to open the eyes of those who are blindly following.


Jesus described the situation perfectly

John 3:19:
"And this is the condemnation, that the Light has come into the world, and men loved darkness rather than the Light, because their deeds were evil."


This person coming in his own name is obviously Mohammed
John 5:43:
"I am come in my Father's name, and you receive me not: if another shall come in his own name, him you will receive."


Muslims normally first come with deceit:
1. Claim to come in peace
2. Claim that we serve the same God
3. Claim that we share many of the same prophets
4. Claim that they believe in our scriptures as well as theirs
5. Claim that they believe in All the earlier prophets sent it us Christians and Jews. In particular, they love Mary and Jesus
6. Claim that all the earlier prophets were Muslims
7. Claim that Mohammed is the final prophet when has come to correct the deviations from the true religion of Islam

But what they ultimately want to do is to steal , kill and destroy the faith of Christians by replacing the Original with Counterfeits!
Re: Why Would An Innocent Baby Go To Hell In Islam? by TenQ: 10:38pm On Dec 18
budaatum:


Think just a little. You don't know what existed 100,000 years ago, but you are here confidently claiming to know nothing existed 13.8 billion years ago?

Even science does not make such a stupid claim, and recognises something must have existed for something to go bang!
Tell me that science is wrong because these I obtained from scientists who are far much more brilliant than 10 of us combined.

Just tell me that it is UNTRUE according to science that the universe began about 13.8billion years ago, then I will surrender as there will be no point continuing any further discussions
Re: Why Would An Innocent Baby Go To Hell In Islam? by budaatum: 10:39pm On Dec 18
TenQ:


By the way, you should be able to tell us how life with it's information came about.

13.8 billion years ago?

You must want me to lie to you, but I refuse.
Re: Why Would An Innocent Baby Go To Hell In Islam? by ConDawah: 10:41pm On Dec 18
TenQ:



Jesus described the situation perfectly

John 3:19:
"And this is the condemnation, that the Light has come into the world, and men loved darkness rather than the Light, because their deeds were evil."


This person coming in his own name is obviously Mohammed
John 5:43:
"I am come in my Father's name, and you receive me not: if another shall come in his own name, him you will receive."


Muslims normally first come with deceit:
1. Claim to come in peace
2. Claim that we serve the same God
3. Claim that we share many of the same prophets
4. Claim that they believe in our scriptures as well as theirs
5. Claim that they believe in All the earlier prophets sent it us Christians and Jews. In particular, they love Mary and Jesus
6. Claim that all the earlier prophets were Muslims
7. Claim that Mohammed is the final prophet when has come to correct the deviations from the true religion of Islam

But what they ultimately want to do is to steal , kill and destroy the faith of Christians by replacing the Original with Counterfeits!


Our job as the latter days believers is to expose the deceit of the devil (Islam) and I believe reasonable people among them shall be saved.
Re: Why Would An Innocent Baby Go To Hell In Islam? by TenQ: 10:44pm On Dec 18
budaatum:


My source is your Holy Bible.

Read it and show me where Adam died from eating a fruit of the tree of knowledge of good and evil!

And while you are scrutinising it, kindly show me your source for not believing in loving your neighbour just because they read a different book to your own. Or is it that you believe but do not need to practise?
Sorry, please give me YOUR source of knowledge.
You know that
The source of Christians is their Bible
The source of Muslims is their Qur'an, Hadiths , Tafsirs and Sirah
Even traditional worshippers have their narrative, chants and poetries

What is YOUR own standard by which I can measure your beliefs?



Do you think that whatever you think is a standard I should judge your beliefs by!?
Re: Why Would An Innocent Baby Go To Hell In Islam? by TenQ: 10:46pm On Dec 18
ConDawah:

Our job as the latter days believers is to expose the deceit of the devil (Islam) and I believe reasonable people among them shall be saved.
Exactly!
And I pray that God release the Grace that we might be effective in this work of the ministry in Jesus mighty Name.

Have a beautiful night rest Bro!
Re: Why Would An Innocent Baby Go To Hell In Islam? by budaatum: 10:48pm On Dec 18
TenQ:

Tell me that science is wrong because these I obtained from scientists who are far much more brilliant than 10 of us combined.

Just tell me that it is UNTRUE according to science that the universe began about 13.8billion years ago, then I will surrender as there will be no point continuing any further discussions.

Put "when did the universe begin" into Google, and you'd get "The Big Bang Theory suggests that the universe began about 13.8 billion years ago".

Hopefully you are not ignorant enough to accept a "suggestion" as fact, though, you being a believer would not surprise me in the least since you can help but believe something

No one knows how the universe began, or what existed before its current form started. And I suggest you stop treating those "scientists who are far much more brilliant than 10 of us combined" like the only prophets of the gods.
Re: Why Would An Innocent Baby Go To Hell In Islam? by TenQ: 10:50pm On Dec 18
budaatum:


13.8 billion years ago?

You must want me to lie to you, but I refuse.
Google is your friend except you are adverse to knowing

Re: Why Would An Innocent Baby Go To Hell In Islam? by TenQ: 10:52pm On Dec 18
budaatum:


Put "when did the universe begin" into Google, and you'd get "The Big Bang Theory suggests that the universe began about 13.8 billion years ago".

Hopefully you are not ignorant enough to accept a "suggestion" as fact, though, you being a believer would not surprise me in the least since you can help but believe something

No one knows how the universe began, or what existed before its current form started. And I suggest you stop treating those "scientists who are far much more brilliant than 10 of us combined" like the only prophets of the gods.
It seems you disagree with this claim of the universe being about 13.8 billion years old, therefore

Interestingly, the argument for such a claim makes sense to me from my little knowledge.

Can you please give me your own sources estimate and why!
Re: Why Would An Innocent Baby Go To Hell In Islam? by budaatum: 11:00pm On Dec 18
TenQ:

Sorry, please give me YOUR source of knowledge.
You know that
The source of Christians is their Bible
The source of Muslims is their Qur'an, Hadiths , Tafsirs and Sirah
Even traditional worshippers have their narrative, chants and poetries

What is YOUR own standard by which I can measure your beliefs?

Do you think that whatever you think is a standard I should judge your beliefs by!?

Typical believer of you to want to judge beliefs instead of judging understanding!

In your own Bible, it is written that humans should not live by bread alone, yet here you are asking me to live by one book. And even your own one book, you seem to fail to understand!

Would your God create you, TenQ, in God's own image to be fruitful and rule and and subdue and multiply and eat every seed-bearing plant on the face of the whole earth and every tree that has fruit with seed in it, then rest on 5he sixth day after seeing all it created was good, and them wake up on the eight day after resting on the seventh to create you from mud to work naked in a tiny garden and not eat the fruit of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil?

How are you supposed to 'Be fruitful and increase in number; fill the earth and subdue it. Rule over the fish in the sea and the birds in the sky and over every living creature that moves on the ground' if you do not nourish yourself with fruits of knowledge?

Do you think those who came to rule and subdue you and teach you to believe you descended from Adam did not eat the fruit of the tree of the knowledge before they came to enslave you?

My standard is your ability to use your own mind to reason, but I'm aware how powerful that which is called Satan is.

(1) (2) (3) (4) (Reply)

Afghan Protests Over Florida Koran Burning Continue For Third Straight Day / Mohammed's Penchant For Violence / Ebola Scare:an Islamic Perspective

(Go Up)

Sections: politics (1) business autos (1) jobs (1) career education (1) romance computers phones travel sports fashion health
religion celebs tv-movies music-radio literature webmasters programming techmarket

Links: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10)

Nairaland - Copyright © 2005 - 2024 Oluwaseun Osewa. All rights reserved. See How To Advertise. 112
Disclaimer: Every Nairaland member is solely responsible for anything that he/she posts or uploads on Nairaland.