Welcome, Guest: Register On Nairaland / LOGIN! / Trending / Recent / New
Stats: 3,208,371 members, 8,002,386 topics. Date: Thursday, 14 November 2024 at 10:04 AM

Argument: Are African Americans Their Own Ethnic Group? I Say Yes. - Culture (2) - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum / Nairaland / General / Culture / Argument: Are African Americans Their Own Ethnic Group? I Say Yes. (10669 Views)

List Of 371 Ethnic Groups In Nigeria / Are African Americans The Chosen People? / Some Nigerian Ethnic Groups And Their Dressing Styles (pictures) (2) (3) (4)

(1) (2) (3) (Reply) (Go Down)

Re: Argument: Are African Americans Their Own Ethnic Group? I Say Yes. by Supper: 7:58pm On Feb 02, 2015
muafrika:
Good point on distance. But the East Coast Arabs reached as far as the Congo, though am not sure they got slaves too. How does genetics prove? I thought many AAs were Nilotic while South Americans and islanders were mostly Bantu thanks to the Portuguese dealing with mostly East and Central African slaves while Brits dealt with W. Africa?

AAs possess a higher concentration of Upper West African Sudanic/Sahelian ancestry from the interior of Africa while Caribbeans & South Americans possess higher concentrations of Lower West African and Central African ancestry from the coastal regions.

FYI, Terry Carr is obviously completely clueless on this subject.
Re: Argument: Are African Americans Their Own Ethnic Group? I Say Yes. by Fulaman198(m): 8:06pm On Feb 02, 2015
Supper:


Thanks. And I am aware of some of sub-groups and relatives of the Fulani. And yes, being from the Futo Tooro, he's probably from the Toucouleur sub-group, which also has relations with the Serer people. Fula captives in America hailed from many different nations. And North American slavers, in particular, like James Hamilton Couper seemed to hold them in relatively high regard(in comparison to other slaves), often entrusting them with task of micro-managing the plantations of the owners.

Many freed AAs of Fulani ancestry who returned to Africa reintegrated with the Fulani-proper, creating the Fulani-Krio people in Serria Leone.


Nicely done
Re: Argument: Are African Americans Their Own Ethnic Group? I Say Yes. by Supper: 8:08pm On Feb 02, 2015
KidStranglehold:
@Supper what is your take on this?

http://genealogytrails.com/scar/negro_law.htm

I know its a bit off topic but it seems to hint that during the period of slavery, "negro" was not only synonymous with "Berber", but most of the slaves were Berbers. shocked

I've seen quotes like this before of early Africans & AAs being described as Moors, Ethiopians, and Berbers. The trouble is trying to link them with the people who are identified as such in the modern day when there may not be a connection. The only true-blue without a doubt North African slave that ever made it to America(Texas) was Estevanico "the moor".
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Estevanico

I've looked into this before. And I have some other information I want to share with you in a coli pm later.

1 Like

Re: Argument: Are African Americans Their Own Ethnic Group? I Say Yes. by Nobody: 8:10pm On Feb 02, 2015
TerryCarr:

still not nilotic though
Re: Argument: Are African Americans Their Own Ethnic Group? I Say Yes. by TerryCarr(m): 8:10pm On Feb 02, 2015
muafrika:
Good point on distance. But the East Coast Arabs reached as far as the Congo, though am not sure they got slaves too. [b]How does genetics prove? I thought many AAs were Nilotic [/b]while South Americans and islanders were mostly Bantu thanks to the Portuguese dealing with mostly East and Central African slaves while Brits dealt with W. Africa?
who told you that? AA's are mostly of west/central Africa
Re: Argument: Are African Americans Their Own Ethnic Group? I Say Yes. by Nobody: 8:15pm On Feb 02, 2015
Supper:


I've seen quotes like this before of early Africans & AAs being described as Moors, Ethiopians, and Berbers. The trouble is trying to link them with the people who are identified as such in the modern day when there may not be a connection. The only true-blue without a doubt North African slave that ever made it to America(Texas) was Estevanico "the moor".
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Estevanico

I've looked into this before. And I have some other information I want to share with you in a coli pm later.

Already thanks. smiley

Also not surprised about AA's being labeled "Moor" since the term was synonymous with negro/black. At least earlier periods.
Re: Argument: Are African Americans Their Own Ethnic Group? I Say Yes. by Fulaman198(m): 8:16pm On Feb 02, 2015
hey Kid, I hope you don't mind me asking, I know that Supper is, but are you AA? I respect AA's a lot.
Re: Argument: Are African Americans Their Own Ethnic Group? I Say Yes. by Nobody: 8:22pm On Feb 02, 2015
TerryCarr:

who told you that? AA's are mostly of west/central Africa
Genetic studies have shown that. Its also quite obvious. We are tribal people. The first thing we notice about all Africans whereever they are is their features as we try to place them with a known tribe.
Re: Argument: Are African Americans Their Own Ethnic Group? I Say Yes. by Supper: 8:25pm On Feb 02, 2015
TerryCarr:

who told you that? AA's are mostly of west/central Africa

No we're not.

"It is estimated that over 50% of the slaves imported to North America came from areas where Islam was followed by at least a minority population. Thus, no less than 200,000 came from regions influenced by Islam."
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Islam_in_the_United_States#Slaves

Islam, historically, has had virtually no presence in lower Central Africa(what you're probably referring to as modern day Angola & the Congo). Which, is not to downplay the significance that had here(they kicked off one of our most ground breaking slave rebellions), but they were not the majority as north American slave masters came to despise them.

Just stop speaking on what you have no clue about.
Re: Argument: Are African Americans Their Own Ethnic Group? I Say Yes. by TerryCarr(m): 8:28pm On Feb 02, 2015
anyway black culture

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1hWWVrEHaRA

the banjo


despite it being a redneck stereotype it has African origins

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ea9GzQ7331w

"There are several theories concerning the origin of the name banjo. It may derive from the Kimbundu term mbanza. Some etymologists believe it comes from a dialectal pronunciation of the Portuguese "bandore" or from an early anglicisation of the Spanish word bandurria, though other research suggests that it may come from a West African term for a bamboo stick formerly used for the instrument's neck.

Various instruments in Africa, chief among them the kora, feature a skin head and gourd (or similar shell) body. The African instruments differ from early African American banjos in that the necks do not possess a Western-style fingerboard and tuning pegs, instead having stick necks, with strings attached to the neck with loops for tuning. Banjos with fingerboards and tuning pegs are known from the Caribbean as early as the 17th century. 18th- and early 19th-century writers transcribed the name of these instruments variously as bangie, banza, banjer, and banjar. Instruments similar to the banjo (e.g., the Japanese shamisen, Persian tar, and Moroccan sintir) have been played in many countries. Another likely banjo ancestor is the akonting, a spike folk lute played by the Jola tribe of Senegambia, and the ubaw-akwala of the Igbo. Similar instruments include the xalam of Senegal and the ngoni of the Wassoulou region including parts of Mali, Guinea, and Côte d'Ivoire, as well as a larger variation of the ngoni developed in Morocco by sub-Saharan Africans known as the gimbri."


akonting

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Pc9Y_uu1KH8
Re: Argument: Are African Americans Their Own Ethnic Group? I Say Yes. by Nobody: 8:30pm On Feb 02, 2015
Fulaman198:
hey Kid, I hope you don't mind me asking, I know that Supper is, but are you AA? I respect AA's a lot.

I believe I told you and everyone else here that I'm AA/Haitian. grin grin

Thought it was known. Also I respect Fulanis too. You people have an awesome and rich history.

1 Like

Re: Argument: Are African Americans Their Own Ethnic Group? I Say Yes. by Fulaman198(m): 8:32pm On Feb 02, 2015
KidStranglehold:


I believe I told you and everyone else here that I'm AA/Haitian. grin grin

Thought it was known. Also I respect Fulanis too. You people have an awesome and rich history.

Sorry bro, I get sidetracked with a lot of things going on in this site. That's cool do you speak Haitian Creole? What about French?
Re: Argument: Are African Americans Their Own Ethnic Group? I Say Yes. by Nobody: 8:34pm On Feb 02, 2015
Fulaman198:


Sorry bro, I get sidetracked with a lot of things going on in this site. That's cool do you speak Haitian Creole? What about French?

Nope I'm Americanized. undecided
Re: Argument: Are African Americans Their Own Ethnic Group? I Say Yes. by Fulaman198(m): 8:37pm On Feb 02, 2015
KidStranglehold:


Nope I'm Americanized. undecided

LOL no worries man

1 Like

Re: Argument: Are African Americans Their Own Ethnic Group? I Say Yes. by Nobody: 8:38pm On Feb 02, 2015
By guess working me thinks I may have Fulani ancestry or at least ancestry from the Sahel on my maternal side. Not only is the root of my family from NC, which I just read a number of Senegambians were imported. Also I can go for days with out eating and can not "bulk up" like those Sahelian nomads. grin But most importantly these Ethiopians said said my sister and mother look Ethiopian. Just realized it, my mother does look Fulani/Mandinka mixed.

But who knows? This is why I want to take a genetic test.

1 Like

Re: Argument: Are African Americans Their Own Ethnic Group? I Say Yes. by Fulaman198(m): 8:39pm On Feb 02, 2015
KidStranglehold:
By guess working me thinks I may have Fulani ancestry or at least ancestry from the Sahel on my maternal side. Not only is the root of my family from NC, which I just read a number of Senegambians were imported. Also I can go for days with out eating and can not "bulk up" like those Sahelian nomads. grin But most importantly these Ethiopians said said my sister and mother look Ethiopian. Just realized it, my mother does look Fulani/Mandinka mixed.

But who knows? This is why I want to take a genetic test.

Very cool
Re: Argument: Are African Americans Their Own Ethnic Group? I Say Yes. by Nobody: 8:42pm On Feb 02, 2015
Fulaman198:


Very cool

Yeah my sister is constantly being mistaken for Ethiopia. When she tells them she's AA they're surprised. When she showed them a pic of my mother they immediately assumed she was Ethiopia, which surprised me...

But anyways there could be a chance, because a good number of Sahelian ethnic groups were imported to NC.
Re: Argument: Are African Americans Their Own Ethnic Group? I Say Yes. by TerryCarr(m): 8:42pm On Feb 02, 2015
Supper:


No we're not.

"It is estimated that over 50% of the slaves imported to North America came from areas where Islam was followed by at least a minority population. Thus, no less than 200,000 came from regions influenced by Islam."
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Islam_in_the_United_States#Slaves

Islam, historically, has had virtually no presence in lower Central Africa(what you're probably referring to as modern day Angola & the Congo). Which, is not to downplay the significance that had here(they kicked off one of our most ground breaking slave rebellions), but they were not the majority as north American slave masters came to despise them.

Just stop speaking on what you have no clue about.
in some areas

here is a are the Africans black Americans are made out of

Senegambia—13 percent (coast between present day Senegal and Gambia)
Gold Coast—16 percent (most of present day Ghana)
Bight of Biafra—23 percent (most of present day Nigeria and Cameroon))
Windward Coast—11 percent (present day Liberia and Ivory Coast)
Region between Angola and Congo—25 percent (present day Congo, Zaire, Angola, Namibia)

South Carolina

40 percent of all Africans arrived through Charleston, SC from the following areas:

Angola/Congo represented 40 percent
Senegambia represented 19 percent
Windward Coast represented 16 percent
Gold Coast represented 13 percent
Re: Argument: Are African Americans Their Own Ethnic Group? I Say Yes. by Fulaman198(m): 8:45pm On Feb 02, 2015
KidStranglehold:


Yeah my sister is constantly being mistaken for Ethiopia. When she tells them she's AA they're surprised. When she showed them a pic of my mother they immediately assumed she was Ethiopia, which surprised me...

But anyways there could be a chance, because a good number of Sahelian ethnic groups were imported to NC.

Yes, I have read about that, it was mainly for their rice growing skills. I'm not much of a basketball person or fan, but Kevin Garnett for example looks like a dark complexioned Fulani guy.

1 Like

Re: Argument: Are African Americans Their Own Ethnic Group? I Say Yes. by Nobody: 8:47pm On Feb 02, 2015
Fulaman198:


Yes, I have read about that, it was mainly for their rice growing skills. I'm not much of a basketball person or fan, but Kevin Garnett for example looks like a dark complexioned Fulani guy.

Indeed.

1 Like

Re: Argument: Are African Americans Their Own Ethnic Group? I Say Yes. by Supper: 8:55pm On Feb 02, 2015
TerryCarr:

in some areas

here is a are the Africans black Americans are made out of

Senegambia—13 percent (coast between present day Senegal and Gambia)
Gold Coast—16 percent (most of present day Ghana)
Bight of Biafra—23 percent (most of present day Nigeria and Cameroon))
Windward Coast—11 percent (present day Liberia and Ivory Coast)
Region between Angola and Congo—25 percent (present day Congo, Zaire, Angola, Namibia)

South Carolina

40 percent of all Africans arrived through Charleston, SC from the following areas:

Angola/Congo represented 40 percent
Senegambia represented 19 percent
Windward Coast represented 16 percent
Gold Coast represented 13 percent

Overall, yes. Not just in some areas.

First all only 32 percent of SC slaves came from Angola/Congo. Plus, SC is an outlier.

Second of all, FYI, just because a slave didn't come through a Senegambian port doesn't mean that the slave didn't from the Sudan or Sahel, as a Hausa slave from modern day Niger or Northern Nigeria would be more likely to come through a port from the Windward Coast or Bight of Biafra. And, as I've already shown slave catchers had no problems venturing far into the interior of Africa to capture people for enslavement(the way North American planters preferred it).

For instance, enslaved Fulani Abdul-Rahman, came through a Sierra Leonean port to Mississippi, not a senegambia one. But, his nation of origin Futa Jallon, was located in the Sahel.

Third of all, those numbers are completely wrong.
Re: Argument: Are African Americans Their Own Ethnic Group? I Say Yes. by Fulaman198(m): 8:58pm On Feb 02, 2015
Supper:


Overall, yes. Not just in some areas.

First all only 32 percent of SC slaves came from Angola/Congo. Plus, SC is an outlier.

Second of all, FYI, just because a slave didn't come through a Senegambian port doesn't mean that the slave didn't from the Sudan or Sahel, as a Hausa slave from modern day Niger or Northern Nigeria would be more likely to come through a port from the Windward Coast or Bight of Biafra. And, as I've already shown slave catchers had no problems venturing far into the interior of Africa to capture people for enslavement(the way North American planters preferred it).

For instance, enslaved Fulani Abdul-Rahman, came through a Sierra Leonean port to Mississippi, not a senegambia one. But, his nation of origin Futa Jallon, was located in the Sahel.

Whilst I do agree with you, I also want to inform you that Fouta Djallon is located in 3 countries (present day Guinea, present day Sierra Leone and present day Guinea-Bissau).
Re: Argument: Are African Americans Their Own Ethnic Group? I Say Yes. by Nobody: 8:58pm On Feb 02, 2015
Supper:


Overall, yes. Not just in some areas.

First all only 32 percent of SC slaves came from Angola/Congo. Plus, SC is an outlier.

Second of all, FYI, just because a slave didn't come through a Senegambian port doesn't mean that the slave didn't from the Sudan or Sahel, as a Hausa slave from modern day Niger or Northern Nigeria would be more likely to come through a port from the Windward Coast or Bight of Biafra. And, as I've already shown slave catchers had no problems venturing far into the interior of Africa to capture people for enslavement(the way North American planters preferred it).

For instance, enslaved Fulani Abdul-Rahman, came through a Sierra Leonean port to Mississippi, not a senegambia one. But, his nation of origin Futa Jallon, was located in the Sahel.

JESUS CHRIST! I NEVER took the bolded into account. *face/palm*
Re: Argument: Are African Americans Their Own Ethnic Group? I Say Yes. by Supper: 9:03pm On Feb 02, 2015
Fulaman198:


Whilst I do agree with you, I also want to inform you that Fouta Djallon is located in 3 countries (present day Guinea, present day Sierra Leone and present day Guinea-Bissau).

Correct me if I'm wrong, but Futa Jallon was located in the Sahelian/Savannah region of those countries right?
Re: Argument: Are African Americans Their Own Ethnic Group? I Say Yes. by Supper: 9:08pm On Feb 02, 2015
KidStranglehold:


JESUS CHRIST! I NEVER took the bolded into account. *face/palm*

Right, just think about, Mahommah Gardo of the Zarma people of Northern Benin & Burkina Faso, he came through a port in modern day Benin, not senegambia.

1 Like

Re: Argument: Are African Americans Their Own Ethnic Group? I Say Yes. by Fulaman198(m): 9:18pm On Feb 02, 2015
Supper:


Correct me if I'm wrong, but Futa Jallon was located in the Sahelian/Savannah region of those countries right?

That's correct it's a bit forested, but still a bit of a Savannah, for the Fulani it's a promising land because the region was more fertile than most regions in the Sahel. The grass was good for the cattle to thrive on.
Re: Argument: Are African Americans Their Own Ethnic Group? I Say Yes. by Supper: 9:22pm On Feb 02, 2015
Fulaman198:


That's correct it's a bit forested, but still a bit of a Savannah, for the Fulani it's a promising land because the region was more fertile than most regions in the Sahel. The grass was good for the cattle to thrive on.

Funny thing is Abdul eventually made it to Freetown, Sierra Leone, with his AA wife. But, they never made it back to Futa Jallon and he was so close. lol

I wonder if he just gave up the idea of living there, honestly couldn't find it, or was banished.
Re: Argument: Are African Americans Their Own Ethnic Group? I Say Yes. by Fulaman198(m): 9:24pm On Feb 02, 2015
Supper:


Funny thing is Abdul eventually made it to Freetown, Sierra Leone, with his AA wife. But, they never made it back to Futa Jallon and he was so close lol

I wonder if he just gave up the idea of living there, honestly couldn't find it, or was banished.

That's a good question, if he was so close, why didn't he go back to Fouta Djallon which extends pretty far. Maybe his AA wife would have had to learn how to speak our language, I don't know. Wish we could travel back in time to find out.

Today, many Fulani live in Freetown.
Re: Argument: Are African Americans Their Own Ethnic Group? I Say Yes. by Supper: 9:26pm On Feb 02, 2015
Fulaman198:


That's a good question, if he was so close, why didn't he go back to Fouta Djallon which extends pretty far. Maybe his AA wife would have had to learn how to speak our language, I don't know. Wish we could travel back in time to find out.

Today, many Fulani live in Freetown.

Yeah, I was going to say that perhaps him and his wife were the predecessors to the Fulani-Krio communities of Freetown.
Re: Argument: Are African Americans Their Own Ethnic Group? I Say Yes. by Fulaman198(m): 9:27pm On Feb 02, 2015
Supper:


Yeah, I was going to say that perhaps him and his wife were the predecessors to the Fulani-Krio communities of Freetown.

That's possible
Re: Argument: Are African Americans Their Own Ethnic Group? I Say Yes. by Nobody: 9:34pm On Feb 02, 2015
I'm aware genetic studies on AA's vary a lot, but this chart shows that AA's have VERY significant amount of genetic ancestry from Sahelian regions.


Can't find the source of where this chart is from sadly.

1 Like

Re: Argument: Are African Americans Their Own Ethnic Group? I Say Yes. by BlackKenichi(m): 4:40pm On Sep 28, 2016
"Argument: Are African Americans Their Own Ethnic Group? I Say Yes"

Of course Aframs are their own distinct ethnic group.

Ethnicity/Ethnic Group
An ethnic group or ethnicity is a category of people who identify with each other based on similarities, such as common language, ancestral, social, cultural, or national experiences.[1][2] Unlike other social groups (wealth, age, hobbies), ethnicity is often an inherited status based on the society in which a person lives. In some cases, it can be adopted it a person moves into another society. Membership of an ethnic group tends to be defined by a shared cultural heritage, ancestry, origin myth, history, homeland, language or dialect, symbolic systems such as religion, mythology and ritual, cuisine, dressing style, art, and physical appearance.

An Afram is simply a person predominately of SSA descent that are descended the enslaved Africans that came to the territories that became the USA.

1 Like

(1) (2) (3) (Reply)

If You Can Speak French (les Haut-parleurs Français Laisse Le Rassemblement Ici) / Yoruba History Supported By DNA. The Eurasia connection / Idoma Names And Meaning

(Go Up)

Sections: politics (1) business autos (1) jobs (1) career education (1) romance computers phones travel sports fashion health
religion celebs tv-movies music-radio literature webmasters programming techmarket

Links: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10)

Nairaland - Copyright © 2005 - 2024 Oluwaseun Osewa. All rights reserved. See How To Advertise. 84
Disclaimer: Every Nairaland member is solely responsible for anything that he/she posts or uploads on Nairaland.