Welcome, Guest: Register On Nairaland / LOGIN! / Trending / Recent / New
Stats: 3,175,472 members, 7,894,996 topics. Date: Friday, 19 July 2024 at 07:24 PM

Who Has The Strongest Military In Africa? - Foreign Affairs (2012) - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum / Nairaland / General / Politics / Foreign Affairs / Who Has The Strongest Military In Africa? (4487343 Views)

Iran Vs Israel: Who Has The Strongest Military ? / Evidence That Putin Is Strongest Man And Obama Is A Filthy Whimpering Dog / Which Country Has The Strongest Economy In Africa. (2) (3) (4)

(1) (2) (3) ... (2009) (2010) (2011) (2012) (2013) (2014) (2015) ... (2991) (Reply) (Go Down)

Re: Who Has The Strongest Military In Africa? by lezz(m): 10:01pm On Apr 04, 2015
jln115:

Its ok the rest of the world thinks otherwise than your socalled umpire of world press.

"Your own press think otherwise."
Uhm....No they dont!!
Your press coined the phrase "humiliating defeat" as a result of that war.

1 Like

Re: Who Has The Strongest Military In Africa? by Nobody: 10:16pm On Apr 04, 2015
lezz:
Your press coined the phrase "humiliating defeat" as a result of that war.
"Your press coined the phrase "humiliating defeat" as a result of that war."
Which South African press? and when?
Re: Who Has The Strongest Military In Africa? by Nobody: 10:18pm On Apr 04, 2015
Henry120:


Also try using the google search right here on nairaland.
Yes mate, only Janes source i found, is the one Augustine posted in September, and it doesnt work!
Re: Who Has The Strongest Military In Africa? by EVarn(m): 10:26pm On Apr 04, 2015

2 Likes 2 Shares

Re: Who Has The Strongest Military In Africa? by lezz(m): 11:01pm On Apr 04, 2015
jln115:

"Your press coined the phrase "humiliating defeat" as a result of that war."
Which South African press? and when?
https://www.nelsonmandela.org/omalley/index.php/site/q/03lv03445/04lv04015/05lv04051/06lv04056/07lv04057.htm
Re: Who Has The Strongest Military In Africa? by Nobody: 11:20pm On Apr 04, 2015
lezz:
https://www.nelsonmandela.org/omalley/index.php/site/q/03lv03445/04lv04015/05lv04051/06lv04056/07lv04057.htm
Firstly mate, look at the date: JAN 11 1988
Secondly the article barley even touches on any Border War events and definitely not any ,were it says they demolished the SADF!

1 Like

Re: Who Has The Strongest Military In Africa? by lezz(m): 11:45pm On Apr 04, 2015
jln115:

Firstly mate, look at the date: JAN 11 1988
Secondly the article barley even touches on any Border War events and definitely not any ,were it says they demolished the SADF!
An oversight.


With Cuban reinforcements, the Angolans withstood major assaults on January 23, February 25, and March 23. The South Africans were repulsed with heavy losses, and the Angolan/Cuban forces seized the initiative. For the first time since 1981, the Angolan army was able to reoccupy the area adjacent to Namibia. So confident were the Angolans and Cubans, that in the space of less than three months they built two air strips to consolidate their recapture of the southern province of Cunene. Trapped by the rainy season, bogged down by the terrain, and encircled, the South Africans made one desperate attempt to break out on June 27 and were again defeated. One South African newspaper called the defeat “a crushing humiliation.”
http://monthlyreview.org/2013/04/01/the-military-defeat-of-the-south-africans-in-angola/
Re: Who Has The Strongest Military In Africa? by Nobody: 11:59pm On Apr 04, 2015
lezz:
An oversight.


With Cuban reinforcements, the Angolans withstood major assaults on January 23, February 25, and March 23. The South Africans were repulsed with heavy losses, and the Angolan/Cuban forces seized the initiative. For the first time since 1981, the Angolan army was able to reoccupy the area adjacent to Namibia. So confident were the Angolans and Cubans, that in the space of less than three months they built two air strips to consolidate their recapture of the southern province of Cunene. Trapped by the rainy season, bogged down by the terrain, and encircled, the South Africans made one desperate attempt to break out on June 27 and were again defeated. One South African newspaper called the defeat “a crushing humiliation.”
http://monthlyreview.org/2013/04/01/the-military-defeat-of-the-south-africans-in-angola/
So you only have 1 source!Nice
I provided 3.
Re: Who Has The Strongest Military In Africa? by agaugust: 1:49am On Apr 05, 2015
andrewza:


Does that matter. Denel is state owned. All so the only defence company to show there stuff was paramount. That means those mokape belong to the SANDF.

Nope, SANDF does NOT get free weapons form DENEL, you make purchase order, sign contract of sale, pay cash and buy.

You guys ruined DENEL financially few years ago with poor management at DENEL lost all it's cash, almost collapsed , and government had to pay cash for bail out. DENEL cannot, CANNOT afford to give away free missiles or equipment to SANDF.

Government ownership does NOT = Charitable organization like Red Cross !

Mokopa missile is NOT wanted by SANDF according to your own SAAF Brigadier General, who gave technical reasons, I psoted the long interview here from defenseweb. NO NEED TO REPEAT SAME STORY AGAIN AND AGAIN !

Mokopa missile NOT in service.

CASE CLOSED grin grin
.
Re: Who Has The Strongest Military In Africa? by agaugust: 1:53am On Apr 05, 2015
andrewza:


Why would you think Germany though? Any case the engines are built local we even sell Ford USA engines built by Ford SA.

You have this craaazy idea that people own what does not belong to them.

Ford is an American company with branch in South Africa. Does it make Ford a Southie brand and product ?

Kia motors have opened factory to make cars in Nigeria, so does Nigeria now own Kia automobile brand ?

You must be insaane grin grin

Ford is an American product
.
Re: Who Has The Strongest Military In Africa? by agaugust: 1:55am On Apr 05, 2015
jln115:
Denel gets A-Darter production contract

http://www.janes.com/article/50334/denel-gets-a-darter-production-contract


Missile range of A-Darter is worse than IRIS-T.

SAAF A-Darter 20 km

NAF PL-9C BVR 35 km

Sorry, NAF has to shooot down all SAAF jets before you can launch any A-Darter.....Gripen/Hawk die from 35 km away grin grin
.
Re: Who Has The Strongest Military In Africa? by agaugust: 2:04am On Apr 05, 2015
EVarn:


Africa's superpower rising.


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0LBn2S3mgjo




https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0LBn2S3mgjo

[size=16pt]

Bwahahaahhahaha grin grin grin

South Africa had to bring a white-man, one of their apartheid masters to face Nigeria's black-man economic expert on technical issues, the black Soweto brains are so dull, their coloureds too so dumb....they always rely on the white man to save them.

Nigeria is Africa's black power !

We have the best brains, we don't get jobs by ANC type of BEE programme for putting people in top positons with their bottom level brains grin grin

Shame on you dullard blacks and cloured m.orons of South Africa....

Permanent dullards and dundee domingos grin grin
[/size]

3 Likes 2 Shares

Re: Who Has The Strongest Military In Africa? by Nobody: 2:17am On Apr 05, 2015
agaugust:


Missile range of A-Darter is worse than IRIS-T.

SAAF A-Darter 20 km

NAF PL-9C BVR 35 km

Sorry, NAF has to shooot down all SAAF jets before you can launch any A-Darter.....Gripen/Hawk die from 35 km away grin grin
.
"PL-9C BVR 35 km"
Your quoting the ground based missile.
The PC-9 air to air missile has a range of 22km

"A-Darter 20 km"
Still not confirmed but lets take it as 20km.

For someone who claims he is a defence expert, you ought to know that the range of a missile doesnt mean f@ck if it is easily countered.
The A-Darter is a fifth generation missile and one of the best , if not thee best in its class.

So you might think, what are the advantages of a fifth gen missile?

The latest generation of short-range missiles again defined by advances in seeker technologies, this time electro-optical imaging infrared (IIR) seekers that allow the missiles to "see" images rather than single "points" of infrared radiation (heat). The sensors combined with more powerful digital signal processing provide the following benefits:

greater infrared counter countermeasures (IRCCM) ability, by being able to distinguish aircraft from infrared countermeasures (IRCM) such as flares.
greater sensitivity means greater range and ability to identify smaller low flying targets such as UAVs.
more detailed target image allows targeting of more vulnerable parts of aircraft instead of just homing in on the brightest infrared source (exhaust).

1 Like

Re: Who Has The Strongest Military In Africa? by Nobody: 2:20am On Apr 05, 2015
agaugust:




https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0LBn2S3mgjo

[size=16pt]

Bwahahaahhahaha grin grin grin

South Africa had to bring a white-man, one of their apartheid masters to face Nigeria's black-man economic expert on technical issues, the black Soweto brains are so dull, their coloureds too so dumb....they always rely on the white man to save them.

Nigeria is Africa's black power !

We have the best brains, we don't get jobs by ANC type of BEE programme for putting people in top positons with their bottom level brains grin grin

Shame on you dullard blacks and cloured m.orons of South Africa....

Permanent dullards and dundee domingos grin grin
[/size]

Re: Who Has The Strongest Military In Africa? by Nobody: 2:29am On Apr 05, 2015
agaugust:


Nope, SANDF does NOT get free weapons form DENEL, you make purchase order, sign contract of sale, pay cash and buy.

You guys ruined DENEL financially few years ago with poor management at DENEL lost all it's cash, almost collapsed , and government had to pay cash for bail out. DENEL cannot, CANNOT afford to give away free missiles or equipment to SANDF.

Government ownership does NOT = Charitable organization like Red Cross !

Mokopa missile is NOT wanted by SANDF according to your own SAAF Brigadier General, who gave technical reasons, I psoted the long interview here from defenseweb. NO NEED TO REPEAT SAME STORY AGAIN AND AGAIN !

Mokopa missile NOT in service.

CASE CLOSED grin grin
.
"you guys ruined DENEL financially few years ago with poor management at DENEL lost all it's cash, almost collapsed , and government had to pay cash for bail out. DENEL cannot, CANNOT afford to give away free missiles or equipment to SANDF."

Thought we cleared up this argument?

Firstly Denel never gave free weapons to the SANDF
Secondly the Government never bailed Denel out!
Lastly making a loss doesnt mean your financially ruined there are many other factors that need to be taken into account, as i mentioned in previous posts.Thought you said you were an accounting expert aswell?

Now go read the source you posted on this subject again and very carefully:
http://m.mg.co.za/article/2005-06-17-rescue-plan-for-denel-takes-shape
Re: Who Has The Strongest Military In Africa? by saengine: 2:35am On Apr 05, 2015
agaugust:


Missile range of A-Darter is worse than IRIS-T.

[s]SAAF A-Darter 20 km

NAF PL-9C BVR 35 km

Sorry, NAF has to shooot down all SAAF jets before you can launch any A-Darter.....Gripen/Hawk die from 35 km away grin grin[/s]
.

Nigeria has no 35km air to air missile. Only in your head it is real. But let's pretend.....

A Darter is a 5th generation missile with self defence capability. PL-9 has NO/ZERO self defence capability. Gripen and Hawk will defend themselves and proceed to turn your F-7 jets into scrap metal. Only one dying will be F-7 pilots. Iris-T and A Darter....self defence capability. By the way...where are your JF-17's? You said you would have them by the time Denel starts producing A Darter for SAAF.


http://www.janes.com/article/50334/denel-gets-a-darter-production-contract

"Denel Dynamics was awarded a five-year production contract on 19 March by Armscor for the A-Darter air-to-air missile.

Developed under Project Kamas, the missile will initially arm the South African Air Force's (SAAF's) Saab Gripen C/D fighters, complementing the small batch of IRIS-T missiles acquired as interim armament from Diehl BGT Defence.

The A-Darter will also be integrated with the SAAF's Hawk Mk 120 jets, giving the advanced trainers a self-defence capability and allowing their use in some airspace patrol roles.
"


Game over. Find a hole to crawl into.
Re: Who Has The Strongest Military In Africa? by Patchesagain: 4:24am On Apr 05, 2015
agaugust:


You were mature enough to notice imminent defeat of your argument, and adjust your 66 years down to 25 years to avoid humiliation grin

We have 46 mobile air search radars with 20 km range and all are armed to destroy air or ground target detected by the radars.

SANDF has NOTHING like that, your radars have no weapons for attack.

Full Data-link is NOT a weapon, and is NOT compulsory, even SANDF does NOT have 100% data-link, you are just starting with SAAF jets, etc, your army does NOT have data-link on all equipment, no money.

Data-link exists on many Nigerian weapons individually, it's no magic wand to have datalink everywhere every platform, there are other communication equipment, ATR-42 has ELINT and superior data-link to Direct NA battles. Videos have shown that in Boko war.

66 years ? SANDF has 1980s radars according to SIPRI.....you are ahead of Lesotho NOT Nigeria, we both parade 1980s radar
.


Your rant reminds me of my 8 year old nephew when he doesnt get his way.

Your air search radars are ancient nodes and do not have synergy. They are obsolete and ancient.

As I showed you with citations - all platforms have ever been upgraded in the 2000's or purchased in the 2000's under Project Rossma while we developed our own mobile radar the Kameelperd under Project Bioskoop
http://itweb.co.za/mobilesite/defenceweb/home/item_id-6479/


Data-link is not a weapon - but it makes your weapons 100X more effective and with better situational awarness you can defeat your foe with ease and is fully intergrated into the SANDF. And yes - datalinks are compulsory for modern militarys

“It allows them to easily and seamlessly exchange information which enhances command and control, it shortens the sensor to shooter time loop, thereby enhancing weapon control and it boosts situational awareness by helping answer the critical battlefield questions of ‘where am I?’, ‘where are my buddies?’, ‘where is the enemy?’, and ‘what next?’” For the artillery, it has brought down the time from when an observer spots a target to when the first round is fired at it from six to 10 minutes to just 90 seconds. “You can just about hit a moving truck,” says Hanley.
http://www.defenceweb.co.za/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=6184:zz&catid=79:fact-files&Itemid=159

Nigeria only has individual assets you do not have an intergrated system that brings together ground and air radar search platforms, targetting systems, air defence systems, artillery systems, aircraft and army formations.

Your military is an obsolete 1980's army.
Re: Who Has The Strongest Military In Africa? by Patchesagain: 4:25am On Apr 05, 2015
agaugust:


Mokopa missile from DENEL laboratory....NOT in service....not ordered by SAAF or SANDF
.

Says who? your link from many years ago?

Why would the SANDF display weapons it does not have??

Lol
Re: Who Has The Strongest Military In Africa? by Patchesagain: 4:34am On Apr 05, 2015
agaugust:


Your 14 Thales air search radars are short ranged, toys on human backpack, no armour, no weapons to attack the enemy they detect. They are NOT part of SNADF datalink, they are tiny infantry radars, all 14 CANNOT kill a pigeon in the air after detecting it.

46 Nigerian Shilka and Rolands will radar detect the enemy on ground and air and kill the enemy IMMEDIATELY !

SANDF is 66 years behind Nigeria, we have ISTAR + WEAPONS integrated
.

Augustus. This is truly getting pathetic.

I admire your efforts to defend your obsolete military, but it is really boring.

Our 14 thales radars have longer range than your RASIT system. Their intergration into LinkZA has allready been posted many times. And they are practically invisible.

Your Rolands and Shilka are not ground observation radars.

Your Rolands and Shilka are easy to detect - both visually and by the signals they send out.

Your Rolands and Shilka do not share information with command posts and each other - they can only see what is happening in their tiny bubble.

Your military has no situational awareness, no ground based ISTAR, no data-sharing.

We have dedicated platforms such as Starstreak and CRAM which do the killing - both of which are intergrated into LinkZA

In terms of mobile air-search radar Nigeria is 1000 years behind the SANDF. In terms of ground based ISTAR 30 years behind the SANDF - and with only 2 units to our 14!!

Re: Who Has The Strongest Military In Africa? by Patchesagain: 4:35am On Apr 05, 2015
agaugust:


[size=16pt]

According to SIPRI final authority, South Africa has 1980s old generation radars tongue tongue

Supplier/ Year Year(s) No.
recipient (R) No. Weapon Weapon of order/ of delivered/
or licenser (L) ordered designation description licence deliveries produced Comments



United Kingdom

R: South Africa 12 AR-3D Air search radar 1981 (12) $64 m 'Operation Rodent' deal; officially delivered for air-traffic control
(1) S-711 Air search radar 1985 (1)


http://armstrade.sipri.org/armstrade/page/trade_register.php

. [/size]

[size=20pt]According to the SANDF they have been upgraded in the 2000's.[/size]
Re: Who Has The Strongest Military In Africa? by Patchesagain: 4:39am On Apr 05, 2015
agaugust:


[size=16pt]

American Research Project Case Study Of Africa's Biggest War :

Nigerian army Biafra war = 250,000 soldiers without counting Nigerian navy and air force.

Biafra too has army, navy, air force.

100,000 troops died in the war.

"HIGH: full-scale civil war, the Biafran war, 1967-1970, resulted in 100,000 military casualties. However, between 500,000 and 2 million Biafran civilians died from starvation during the war.

Outnumbered and outgunned, the rebel troops had the advantage of excellent leadership and morale. However, the FMG of Nigeria invaded Owerri, an oil rich area of the Niger delta, in 1968 and increased the Nigerian army to 250,000 men. The Biafran rebels liberated Owerri. However, but a new federal offensive in the south forced the rebels into submission."

http://www1.american.edu/ted/ice/biafra.htm[/size]

.

Ok, lets count the other wars then:

Angola: 300 000
War between Ethiopia and Etritrea: 300 000 dead.

What equipment was used in the war? huh? tell us of tank battles and air battles! Tell us of paratrooper jumps! Tell us of advanced air defence networks?

Oh, you cant can you?
Re: Who Has The Strongest Military In Africa? by Patchesagain: 4:41am On Apr 05, 2015
agaugust:




DENEL marketing show is what you saw.

Algeria paid cash for Mokopa, Algeria ordered for it. SAAF did NOT order any Mokopa !

We have seen photos of Rooivalk firing Mokopa missile before, yet still NOT ordered !
.

You know that is not the official SAAF website right?

Has it occurred to you that your information may be out of date?

Henry120 allways demands pictures, now you have them!

SANDF has the Mokopa - confirmed by pictures!
Re: Who Has The Strongest Military In Africa? by Patchesagain: 4:43am On Apr 05, 2015
agaugust:


The Biafra war has the ONLY amphibious combined Navy, Army, Air force large scale assault in African history and one of the biggest in the world in jet age. The SADF Bush was just war inside dry bush and nothing more grin grin

That sea to land amphibious assault alone was a whole Division of Nigerian troops, bigger than the whole SADF army inside Angola grin grin

Yes, no comparison !
.

Operation Torch was the biggest amphibious operation in Africa. Citation about your landings.

Quito Cuanaval was the biggest conventional battle in Africa since WW2

We had dog-fights, tank battles, artillery duels, advanced air defence networks on both sides, electronic warfare, drones, ATGM's!

What did you have? Biafran Cessna's humiliating your airforce? A bunch of igbo's throwing cassava at each other?
Re: Who Has The Strongest Military In Africa? by Patchesagain: 4:45am On Apr 05, 2015
Henry120:


You don't have them in service. It's just a mock up.


Says who?
Re: Who Has The Strongest Military In Africa? by Patchesagain: 4:46am On Apr 05, 2015
jln115:


"DENEL marketing show is what you saw."
Market to who exactly?
The Rand show is a civilian consumer exhibition(Largest in the world outside the US) not a Defence exhibition, the SANDF is a very very small part of the Rand show!

So tell me ,why would Denel market the mokopa at the Rand show?


Lol.
Re: Who Has The Strongest Military In Africa? by Patchesagain: 4:48am On Apr 05, 2015
agaugust:


Your people here said the 14 toy radars will be carried by foot soldiers inside backpacks into the bush or mountain top for hiding out of enemy view....your artillery drives with them inside the bush and climbs mountains ?

They left the open field to hide on mountains for fear of Nigerian Shilka radar + multi-barrel cannon grin grin
.


1. Still waiting for a source that says Shilka radar can detect ground targets
2. Our "toy radars" are better than your RASIT system in every single way - what does that make the Rasit then?
3. LinkZA intergration for all systems has been posted many times. Stop wasting time.
Re: Who Has The Strongest Military In Africa? by Patchesagain: 4:49am On Apr 05, 2015
agaugust:


Looking for more customers like Ageria.....simple marketing strategy os to place Mokopa beside Rooivalk.

Or you think DENEL marketing manager will stand there in the show carrying Mokopa on top of his head ? Like a statue ?
.

Hey

Chucklefuck

Algeria is not at the Rand show.

Its not an arms expo. Its a civilian fair.
Re: Who Has The Strongest Military In Africa? by Patchesagain: 4:49am On Apr 05, 2015
agaugust:


Defencweb interviewed South African Brigadier General who explained that SANDF or SAAF does NOT need Mokopa missile when they have Ingwe, I posted that article here many times.....your problem not mine
.

Is that exactly what he said?

Post it again little boy - time for another english lesson
Re: Who Has The Strongest Military In Africa? by Patchesagain: 4:50am On Apr 05, 2015
Henry120:


Nope, because IHS Janes Defence says so.

provide citation then.
Re: Who Has The Strongest Military In Africa? by Patchesagain: 4:51am On Apr 05, 2015
Henry120:


Done that on many occasions, last time was in December of 2014.

The SAAF has no mokopa in service.

Post it again for examination.

SAAF just provided you with what you desperatly crave - a picture of the Mokopa.

You have no argument - 2015 photographic evidence has been provided.
Re: Who Has The Strongest Military In Africa? by Patchesagain: 4:53am On Apr 05, 2015
Re: Who Has The Strongest Military In Africa? by Patchesagain: 4:54am On Apr 05, 2015
lezz:
An oversight.


With Cuban reinforcements, the Angolans withstood major assaults on January 23, February 25, and March 23. The South Africans were repulsed with heavy losses, and the Angolan/Cuban forces seized the initiative. For the first time since 1981, the Angolan army was able to reoccupy the area adjacent to Namibia. So confident were the Angolans and Cubans, that in the space of less than three months they built two air strips to consolidate their recapture of the southern province of Cunene. Trapped by the rainy season, bogged down by the terrain, and encircled, the South Africans made one desperate attempt to break out on June 27 and were again defeated. One South African newspaper called the defeat “a crushing humiliation.”
http://monthlyreview.org/2013/04/01/the-military-defeat-of-the-south-africans-in-angola/

This is hilarious.

Same guy who claims we lost 10 000 men and 500 tanks and aircraft?

(1) (2) (3) ... (2009) (2010) (2011) (2012) (2013) (2014) (2015) ... (2991) (Reply)

African Militaries/ Security Services Strictly Photos Only And Videos Thread / Kenya Is Ahead of Nigeria In All Aspect (Facts Don't Lie)

Viewing this topic: 1 guest(s)

(Go Up)

Sections: politics (1) business autos (1) jobs (1) career education (1) romance computers phones travel sports fashion health
religion celebs tv-movies music-radio literature webmasters programming techmarket

Links: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10)

Nairaland - Copyright © 2005 - 2024 Oluwaseun Osewa. All rights reserved. See How To Advertise. 75
Disclaimer: Every Nairaland member is solely responsible for anything that he/she posts or uploads on Nairaland.