Welcome, Guest: Register On Nairaland / LOGIN! / Trending / Recent / New
Stats: 3,206,881 members, 7,997,118 topics. Date: Thursday, 07 November 2024 at 11:20 PM

Fg Picks Geregu, Itu As 2,400mw Nuclear Power Sites - Politics (3) - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum / Nairaland / General / Politics / Fg Picks Geregu, Itu As 2,400mw Nuclear Power Sites (35977 Views)

Fashola: How We Added 400MW To Power Nat Grid Despite Sabotage / Nationwide Darkness Looms As Electricity Supply Drops To 1,400MW / FG To Build 2,400MW Nuclear Plants In Kogi, A' Ibom States (2) (3) (4)

(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (Reply) (Go Down)

Re: Fg Picks Geregu, Itu As 2,400mw Nuclear Power Sites by Okijajuju1(m): 11:20am On Jun 17, 2015
elohorayodele:
Nuclear power ke!

next chernobyl disaster site loading coz Nigerians lack maintenance culture


Once people hear Nuclear Power, they scream Chernobyl or Fukushima.. Forgetting that the causes of both are not grounds enough for us not to have either as the both causes are controllable factors.

If Nigeria continues solely on this path of Gas and Hydro turbines, then the Power crisis may carry on even to 2050.

3 Likes

Re: Fg Picks Geregu, Itu As 2,400mw Nuclear Power Sites by Reference(m): 11:20am On Jun 17, 2015
Kogi state is legendary for hosting white elephants.
Re: Fg Picks Geregu, Itu As 2,400mw Nuclear Power Sites by Nobody: 11:20am On Jun 17, 2015
GodMode:
Where's VickJames bushdoc9919

Remember this quotes



Then you said



Now your govt is paying $20B for 4000MW..

HOW WISE IS THAT

Well, a nuclear power station is not a dam, you know.
Re: Fg Picks Geregu, Itu As 2,400mw Nuclear Power Sites by felifeli: 11:21am On Jun 17, 2015
vanunu:
Buhari should stop this ruffplay, when other countries ara moving away from nuclear power, he wants to build one. He should site it in daura.

Absolutely! Let the nuclear plants go to Daura.
Re: Fg Picks Geregu, Itu As 2,400mw Nuclear Power Sites by MINISTER2000: 11:22am On Jun 17, 2015
homerac7:


No river in West Africa can give you such hydro capacity sir! Closest you can get is the Grand Inga dam project on the Congo in Congo DR.

You can chose to build 100,000MW nuclear power plant is anywhere in Nigeria (in you can raise the fund required), but you can't build any MW above what the river sources around you can provide for hydro power. Even having the water flow does not mean the topology will give you favourable location.

So China building 3 Gorges dam on the Yanges does not mean Nigeria, or West Africa has a "Yanges" to build her own.

1 Like

Re: Fg Picks Geregu, Itu As 2,400mw Nuclear Power Sites by Nobody: 11:23am On Jun 17, 2015
homerac7:


No river in West Africa can give you such hydro capacity sir! Closest you can get is the Grand Inga dam project on the Congo in Congo DR.

You can chose to build 100,000MW nuclear power plant is anywhere in Nigeria (in you can raise the fund required), but you can't build any MW above what the river sources around you can provide for hydro power. Even having the water flow does not mean the topology will give you favourable location.

So China building 3 Gorges dam on the Yanges does not mean Nigeria, or West Africa has a "Yanges" to build her own.

In addition, the Yanges river is hardly a small stream.....it is quite a BIG river.

2 Likes

Re: Fg Picks Geregu, Itu As 2,400mw Nuclear Power Sites by Nobody: 11:24am On Jun 17, 2015
felifeli:


Absolutely! Let the nuclear plants go to Daura.

Then Daura will have 24 hour light....and a host of industries.

And you people will be grumbling about ''political patronage''.

Nuclear power is here to stay. And yes...if GEJ had suggested it...I would have supported it.
Re: Fg Picks Geregu, Itu As 2,400mw Nuclear Power Sites by DeLaRue: 11:25am On Jun 17, 2015
Another phantom project to get long suffering Nigerians excited about 'constant power.'


Nigerian politicians are clever...when they sense tension and frustration building up amongst the millions of long suffering ordinary people, they throw another phantom project (that will never happen) up in the air to get people excited and hopeful and divert their attention from the latest bad news, ie N9 billion naira agbada allowance for legislators.

This strategy works like a treat. The politicians know it. And they will continue to use it. The only people who dont see the diversion are naive youths.

4 Likes 1 Share

Re: Fg Picks Geregu, Itu As 2,400mw Nuclear Power Sites by slap1(m): 11:27am On Jun 17, 2015
They should take both projects to the north, I don't want to think about what could happen as a result of bad maintenance.

2 Likes 1 Share

Re: Fg Picks Geregu, Itu As 2,400mw Nuclear Power Sites by Nobody: 11:27am On Jun 17, 2015
Nuclear energy has given us the power to produce more weapons than to produce things that can make the world a better place to live in. We have to become more careful and responsible while using nuclear energy to avoid any sort of major accidents. They are hot targets for militants and terrorist organizations. Security is a major concern here. A little lax in security can prove to be lethal and brutal for humans and even for this planet. BH undecidedNuclear energy has given us the power to produce more weapons than to produce things that can make the world a better place to live in. We have to become more careful and responsible while using nuclear energy to avoid any sort of major accidents. They are hot targets for militants and terrorist organizations. Security is a major concern here. A little lax in security can prove to be lethal and brutal for humans and even for this planet. BH

1 Like 1 Share

Re: Fg Picks Geregu, Itu As 2,400mw Nuclear Power Sites by Nobody: 11:28am On Jun 17, 2015
Nuclear energy has given us the power to produce more weapons than to produce things that can make the world a better place to live in. We have to become more careful and responsible while using nuclear energy to avoid any sort of major accidents. They are hot targets for militants and terrorist organizations. Security is a major concern here. A little lax in security can prove to be lethal and brutal for humans and even for this planet. BH
Re: Fg Picks Geregu, Itu As 2,400mw Nuclear Power Sites by mickyeddi(m): 11:28am On Jun 17, 2015
GogetterMD:
Issues
1- is it just a Nigerian situation or why are all contracts in Nigeria overly inflated? $20billion USD for just 4800 MW of electricity?
2- I am afraid for Maintenance culture here. Nigerians can know how to vandalize and steal anything, electricity cables, transformer parts, blow up gas pipelines etc. Their ignorance won't make them realise the importance of staying away from a nuclear power plant. Even Japan is shutting down all her nuclear reactors after the calamity that came last decade

I'ld like to see the thugs vandalize a nuclear reactor, they' ll explain to God what happened to their vaporised body.

2 Likes

Re: Fg Picks Geregu, Itu As 2,400mw Nuclear Power Sites by GodMode: 11:28am On Jun 17, 2015
bushdoc9919:


Well, a nuclear power station is not a dam, you know.

Hahaha, I was expecting vickjames gringringrin

Read this

GodMode:


For the last 50 years Nigeria's MW has been below 3000MW...

Must Nigeria spend $2.5B

If $2.5B will build 3000MW then $10B will build 12000MW in 5 yearsangryangry

You need to start thinking outside the box and how to build better things instead of thinking with what people give you..

Read the article.. It said


“With NAEC’s plan to inject 1,200mw from
first nuclear power plant in 2025 and
increase to 4,800mw in 2035, the energy
mix is expected to have increased to about
20 percent power generation from clean
sources,” Igali said.

I'm sure by 2025 and 2035 you'll be a grand fathergringringrin

Stop defending this your backward thinking leadersgringringrin

1 Like 1 Share

Re: Fg Picks Geregu, Itu As 2,400mw Nuclear Power Sites by mickyeddi(m): 11:30am On Jun 17, 2015
givan:
Please this project shouldn't be sited anywhere 1000 nautical miles away from the east. Itu isn't a good choice. Mr Buhari please site your Nuclear project either around the Saraha states or 1000 nautical mile into the Atlantic.

#LessonsFromJapan
#ProudlyAnambay

You need a location with regular flow of water to cool the nuclear reactors.
Re: Fg Picks Geregu, Itu As 2,400mw Nuclear Power Sites by mathskill: 11:30am On Jun 17, 2015
.

8 Likes 1 Share

Re: Fg Picks Geregu, Itu As 2,400mw Nuclear Power Sites by Nobody: 11:31am On Jun 17, 2015
GodMode:


Hahaha, I was expecting vickjames gringringrin

Read this



Read the article.. It said



I'm sure by 2025 and 2035 you'll be a grand fathergringringrin

Stop defending this your backward thinking leadersgringringrin

Well if PDP had done something more about power .....perhaps we won't have had to wait that long.

At least we know when APC will give us power. Unlike PDP that promised us 24 hours light in 2013....and then told us 'Sorry, we did not really mean that'' by 2014.

At least I am realistic that Nigeria won't solve its power supply problems now....I just don't like the lies we were told in 2013 that by now power would be sorted.
Re: Fg Picks Geregu, Itu As 2,400mw Nuclear Power Sites by homerac7: 11:31am On Jun 17, 2015
MINISTER2000:
What I meant is we can have more of hydropower dams to increase our power generation. pls sir, why r developed nations considering a move frm nuclear plants?

No sir! We can't go about building dams everywhere. Mind you, I don't in any way mean that we have "enough" dams in Nigeria or Africa yet, but there's limit to how much power we can practically depend on dams for. Yes they look beautiful and support agriculture, but they are highly environmentally destructive, particularly in their downstream communities.


Developed nations are shutting down SOME of their nuclear power plants because of age, mainly. Every plant has a lifetime. When an equipment or plant approaches its lifetime, reliability reduces and cost of operation rises. Based on several technical, risk, economic, social and environmental analysis, the equipment or plant may be given a life extension (retrofitting) or wound down (obsolescence).

Note that UK and Germany are shutting down because they are investing more in offshore wind generation power systems, while Japan is constrained because of seismic risks. So everybody makes such decisions bases on individual's peculiar risks and conditions. So what's necessary for Germany/US might not be for Nigeria/China/SA/Indonesia/Brazil

2 Likes

Re: Fg Picks Geregu, Itu As 2,400mw Nuclear Power Sites by Nobody: 11:31am On Jun 17, 2015
mathskill:
Why do Nigerians have a penchant for the absurdity.
Why go for Russian technology that is archaic,unreliable and prone to disaster, Chernobyl is an example.
Why not go for Areva,the French nuclear giant that is the best on the industry.
Moreover why nuclear energy that will take a span of 10 yrs to come on stream, at the exhorbitant cost of $20,000,000,000 and the attendant risk associated with that industry. Ajaokuta,a steel mill that we cant complete and maintain but want to venture into nuclear.
For $3,000,000,000 Nigeria can build 6 gas powered stations for each of the geographical zones within 2yrs.
Buhari should better take charge and remove the remainder of Gej team that are still hell bent on shaping a dark path for this country

While I agree with you...Chernobyl was caused by human errors....not by mechanical fault.
Re: Fg Picks Geregu, Itu As 2,400mw Nuclear Power Sites by Coldfeets: 11:33am On Jun 17, 2015
Nuclear power!!! This is a very welcome development. We are finally going nuclear!!!
Re: Fg Picks Geregu, Itu As 2,400mw Nuclear Power Sites by GodMode: 11:33am On Jun 17, 2015
DeLaRue:

Another phantom project to get long suffering Nigerians excited about 'constant power.'


Nigerian politicians are clever...when they sense tension and frustration building up amongst the millions of long suffering ordinary people, they throw another phantom project (that will never happen) up in the air to get people excited and hopeful and divert their attention from the latest bad news, ie N9 billion naira agbada allowance for legislators.

This strategy works like a treat. The politicians know it. And they will continue to use it. The only people who dont see the diversion are naive youths.


Have you looked at the location

Kogi and Awka ibom

Kogi is a central state
Awka ibom is a SE state

If this two "projects" blows up Nigeria is destroyed..

1 Like 1 Share

Re: Fg Picks Geregu, Itu As 2,400mw Nuclear Power Sites by harveyspec: 11:37am On Jun 17, 2015
homerac7:
Aaaargh! Too much ignorance here !

Read again, it is a BOOT arrangement, meaning it will be built , owned, operated by the Russians before being transferred to Nigeria after a stipulated period.

Mr knowledge!! what happens if the "stipulated period" elapses, can Nigeria still maintain it?

Before you answer, remember our refineries were BOOT too


Scientists don't maintain plants, technicians[b][/b] do.


Mr knowledge, you would have replaced the scientist with technicians besides there is no way a nuclear power station will run without a scientist in its employs

Why spend that much to build something that carries much risk, it's not as though its establishment is a complete solution to our power problems

We haven't been able to maintain our roads, our gas plants, our power plants, our refineries, even traffic light or street light yet we want to go nuclear

with our penchant for cutting corners, how do you think the nuclear waster will be disposed?

we have abundant gas reserve, why not focus on Gas plant construction/power station

Can't more hydro stations be built

1 Like 1 Share

Re: Fg Picks Geregu, Itu As 2,400mw Nuclear Power Sites by GodMode: 11:37am On Jun 17, 2015
bushdoc9919:


Well if PDP had done something more about power .....perhaps we won't have had to wait that long.

At least we know when APC will give us power. Unlike PDP that promised us 24 hours light in 2013....and then told us 'Sorry, we did not really mean that'' by 2014.

At least I am realistic that Nigeria won't solve its power supply problems now....I just don't like the lies we were told in 2013 that by now power would be sorted.

If ethiopia can use $2.5B to create 3000MW in 5 years

Why should Nigeria use $20B to create 4800MW in 20 years...

Note: $2.5B = 3000MW using dams in 5yrs
$20B = 24000MW using dams in 5yrs

2 Likes 1 Share

Re: Fg Picks Geregu, Itu As 2,400mw Nuclear Power Sites by Nobody: 11:39am On Jun 17, 2015
GodMode:


Have you looked at the location

Kogi and Awka ibom

Kogi is a central state
Awka ibom is a SE state

If this two "projects" blows up Nigeria is destroyed..

Nuclear power plants do not just ''blow up'' like that.

And if you are thinking of Chernobyl....that was human error.

Fukushima happened because the earthquake of 2011 damaged the nuclear power plant's cooling system (and we do not have earthquakes in Nigeria. At least none of magnitude 7 and above on the Richter scale).
Re: Fg Picks Geregu, Itu As 2,400mw Nuclear Power Sites by mathskill: 11:40am On Jun 17, 2015
.

1 Like 1 Share

Re: Fg Picks Geregu, Itu As 2,400mw Nuclear Power Sites by Nobody: 11:41am On Jun 17, 2015
They should be sited in Yobe & Bauchi please... embarassed
Re: Fg Picks Geregu, Itu As 2,400mw Nuclear Power Sites by MINISTER2000: 11:42am On Jun 17, 2015
homerac7:


No sir! We can't go about building dams everywhere. Mind you, I don't in any way mean that we have "enough" dams in Nigeria or Africa yet, but there's limit to how much power we can practically depend on dams for. Yes they look beautiful and support agriculture, but they are highly environmentally destructive, particularly in their downstream communities.

Developed nations are shutting down SOME of their nuclear power plants because of age, mainly. Every plant has a lifetime. When an equipment or plant approaches its lifetime, reliability reduces and cost of operation rises. Based on several technical, risk, economic, social and environmental analysis, the equipment or plant may be given a life extension (retrofitting) or wound down (obsolescence).

Note that UK and Germany are shutting down because they are investing more in offshore wind generation power systems, while Japan is constrained because of seismic risks. So everybody makes such decisions bases on individual's peculiar risks and conditions.
I'm not disposed to hydro power only, that is I hv been saying other sources. Germany is tapping frm solar n others r tapping frm wind. why can't we consider other options; must we mortgage our lives for disaster waiiting to happen.

1 Like 1 Share

Re: Fg Picks Geregu, Itu As 2,400mw Nuclear Power Sites by Nobody: 11:43am On Jun 17, 2015
GodMode:


If ethiopia can use $2.5B to create 3000MW in 5 years

Why should Nigeria use $20B to create 4800MW in 20 years...

Note: $2.5B = 3000MW using dams in 5yrs
$20B = 24000MW using dams in 5yrs


Because right now, we do not have the type of river that we can dam to produce electricity....plus topography is important. Ethopia is a mountainous country....with rugged rivers flowing from a height downwards. Nigeria? We don't have that kind of topography or even rivers.(We have a potential river in Cross River....but its source is in Cameroon....and if we do a dam there...the Cameroonians would promptly dam the river).

And yes...Nuclear costs money. Hence the expense.

Or else...we build six-seven gas stations...at the same cost....and producing the same amount of power.
Re: Fg Picks Geregu, Itu As 2,400mw Nuclear Power Sites by free13: 11:43am On Jun 17, 2015
Hmmm.......
Re: Fg Picks Geregu, Itu As 2,400mw Nuclear Power Sites by GodMode: 11:43am On Jun 17, 2015
bushdoc9919:


Nuclear power plants do not just ''blow up'' like that.

And if you are thinking of Chernobyl....that was human error.

Fukushima happened because the earthquake of 2011 damaged the nuclear power plant's cooling system (and we do not have earthquakes in Nigeria. At least none of magnitude 7 and above on the Richter scale).

I guess you're a paid e-ratgringringringrin

You're defending your pay masters even if it will lead to the death of your family...

1 Like

Re: Fg Picks Geregu, Itu As 2,400mw Nuclear Power Sites by bogolobango(m): 11:45am On Jun 17, 2015
Bros na dat hypertension go kill u
Re: Fg Picks Geregu, Itu As 2,400mw Nuclear Power Sites by GodMode: 11:46am On Jun 17, 2015
bushdoc9919:


Because right now, we do not have the type of river that we can dam to produce electricity....plus topography is important. Ethopia is a mountainous country....with rugged rivers flowing from a height downwards. Nigeria? We don't have that kind of topography or even rivers.(We have a potential river in Cross River....but its source is in Cameroon....and if we do a dam there...the Cameroonians would promptly dam the river).

And yes...Nuclear costs money. Hence the expense.

Or else...we build six-seven gas stations...at the same cost....and producing the same amount of power.

There's also solar, wind, waste, glass e.t.c that can generate thousands of megawatts before 2035 gringringrin

Hope they're paying you well Oooo.

1 Like 1 Share

Re: Fg Picks Geregu, Itu As 2,400mw Nuclear Power Sites by chinae(m): 11:48am On Jun 17, 2015
Keneking:
Great
- 2016 is too far for licensing - what is the role of Nigerian engineers and scientists - I believe in this project because its coming from Buhari - Since it's coming from Russia, I support the big dream - Meanwhile can generators be banned undecided
Sai Buhari
it's gud to note that GEJ is the initiator of this program.

(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (Reply)

The Set Stage Of The FEC Banquet Ahead Of Cabinet Swearing In / Buhari Cabal Eyeing Interim Government – El-Rufai / Abdullahi Mahuta Shares His Jordan Trip Experience (Photos)

(Go Up)

Sections: politics (1) business autos (1) jobs (1) career education (1) romance computers phones travel sports fashion health
religion celebs tv-movies music-radio literature webmasters programming techmarket

Links: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10)

Nairaland - Copyright © 2005 - 2024 Oluwaseun Osewa. All rights reserved. See How To Advertise. 74
Disclaimer: Every Nairaland member is solely responsible for anything that he/she posts or uploads on Nairaland.