Stats: 3,190,299 members, 7,940,187 topics. Date: Wednesday, 04 September 2024 at 06:59 PM |
Nairaland Forum / Nairaland / General / Politics / The Biafra Question: Is Secession The Answer? (2981 Views)
After Secession, The NC And Middle Belt Must Follow The South: FFK / Avengers Threaten Secession As Militants Bomb NPDC Facilities / Falae: Yoruba Leaders Threaten Secession From Nigeria If… (2) (3) (4)
The Biafra Question: Is Secession The Answer? by helinues: 7:19pm On Sep 20, 2015 |
Over four decades after the devastating secession bid by the Igbos through the Nigerian civil war, many Igbos are still vigorously pursuing the actualization of the Biafran dream. So much so that a radio station called “Radio Biafra” broadcasts hate messages against the Nigerian government. Efforts to close down the broadcasts have proved unsuccessful. It turns out that quite a number of Igbos tune-in to the station and agree with the message. The Nigerian Constitution in Section 39 (1): ‘Every person shall be entitled to freedom of expression, including freedom to hold opinions and to receive and impart ideas and information without interference. There is nothing wrong with wanting to secede. This piece is just to examine the feasibility of the whole idea. One thing I would like to point out is that secession is hardly done peacefully. No nation will let go of a territory perceived to be theirs without a fight, especially with the fact that crude oil, the bulk of the nation’s foreign exchange earner comes from there. The least of wars is extremely devastating. The horrors of war are far better imagined than experienced. The bloodshed, widespread devastation, destruction, displacement and resultant famine are not worth it. There is no justification for inciting the public, or attempting to instigate violence. War is never pretty. It is only glamorous in movies, not in real life. Let us assume that the Biafra advocates intend to do it peacefully, by means of a referendum. What exactly is their game plan? What really do they want? Let’s get real. MASSOB is agitating for a sovereign state. If Biafra is allowed to exist, what then happens to Igbos scattered across the country? What would become of their various businesses? Many Igbos will automatically become foreigners in Nigeria, requiring visas and passports to travel and requiring permits to continue to operate their businesses. Many of them would be at the mercy of immigration officers who would order their deportation at will. How feasible is that? How many Igbos would surrender their property acquired in Lagos and Abuja to the government of Nigeria? How would Biafra compensate them in return? Let us not forget that majority of people in the “clearing and forwarding, importer and exporter business” are the Igbos. So all these successful people will leave the big cities- Lagos, Abuja, Kano, Kaduna etc. to live in that small niche of land? Remember that it was land constraints that forced them out in the first place. Another bone of contention is the extent of Biafra land. We all know for sure that it comprises the Igbo-speaking states. One does not know what would become of the South-South states, or Delta state which has a small Igbo population. Instead of clamouring for a Biafran state, it would be wise for Biafran agitators to focus on fighting for a level playing field in Nigeria. For instance, it’s only the South East region that has 5 states, all other regions have 6 states, and one region has 7. This has immense implications because the Federal Accounts Allocation Committee (FAAC) is shared by many criteria including number of Local Governments in a state. More revenue would translate to more funds at their disposal. This should be a focal point for those fighting for the Biafran cause. Let the Biafra agitators fight for capital projects that would benefit their people. The South East has no Federal steel rolling mill, a region which has Aba, Nnewi and Onitsha, three manufacturing and industrial hubs. Even more astonishing is the fact that there was no sea port or international airport in decades. Those clamouring for Biafra will do well to make demands on the executive and the legislative arms of government. These are legitimate demands. Why can’t the agitators hold each State Governor in the South East accountable for the infrastructure in those states? For instance, most South Eastern roads are in a terrible state. It isn’t too much for them to build standard multiple-lane expressways with rail services that would link all South Eastern states. How about education? How about healthcare? How about welfare? How about employment? How about crime? How about human rights? How about erosion control? What have the Biafran agitators done to improve the lot of their people in these key areas? It is very foolhardy to believe that all these issues will miraculously be solved when Biafra comes to existence. Biafran agitators make Biafra seem like Paradise, a place where things could never go wrong. Whether you like it or not, if you don’t tackle your problems now, your problems would multiply when you have your separate country. It is your governors that you fail to task on good governance that would still rule you in Biafra. You will have it rougher because Nigeria would be as hostile as your other neighbor, Cameroon. I believe those that want Biafra should work towards improving the lot of their people… simple. Biafra should be a fight for good governance and improved lifestyle. Source: https://www.facebook.com/forum9ja/posts/957349230993544 3 Likes |
Re: The Biafra Question: Is Secession The Answer? by Agbalanze(m): 7:36pm On Sep 20, 2015 |
If u ask me, na who I go ask ![]() ![]() ![]() |
Re: The Biafra Question: Is Secession The Answer? by Nobody: 7:41pm On Sep 20, 2015 |
Yes secession is the answer! 8 Likes |
Re: The Biafra Question: Is Secession The Answer? by sdindan: 7:43pm On Sep 20, 2015 |
Yes Biafra is the Answer 7 Likes |
Re: The Biafra Question: Is Secession The Answer? by Bunducisco: 7:47pm On Sep 20, 2015 |
Yes my brother and i think it can be delayed not stopped, give us presidency, still Biafra will be roaming around us,we want it to rest okay ITS COMING 10 Likes
|
Re: The Biafra Question: Is Secession The Answer? by 9jii(m): 7:48pm On Sep 20, 2015 |
Its plssss 4 god sake. The only problem is They are not serious about it. |
Re: The Biafra Question: Is Secession The Answer? by Nobody: 7:50pm On Sep 20, 2015 |
Biafra it is for me. Thank you very much. 2 Likes |
Re: The Biafra Question: Is Secession The Answer? by Nobody: 8:04pm On Sep 20, 2015 |
After fighting for the SE states to have one to state that will make it six, you will fight for LGs to be increased, after fighting that one you will fight for improved allocation for the resources drilled from you land, after that you will fight for Federal presence, after fighting all these useless battles you still fight for uniform cut off marks for FG Unity colleges, after that another fight will come up, haba na only fight you come Nigeria come fight. At the end of everything if there is Cartoon of a dead Arabian man in Denmark you will be killed, if US invaded Afghanistan or Iraq you will be lynched, if Israel fought Hamas in Middle East you will clubbed to death after that one. If you vote your candidate you will be drown in Lagoon or you won't be treated similar those that voted for the winner is treated. Nigeria is doomed 6 Likes
|
Re: The Biafra Question: Is Secession The Answer? by c33b33(m): 8:19pm On Sep 20, 2015 |
How will people of no common ideology live together? This article smirks of ignorance,please make a good research about secession especially concerning properties and business because that seems to be you lots problem. Though you are right about no peaceful secession but that is peculiar with uncivilized country like nigeria. As for politicians the only action to deal with them now is a revolution. We need Biafra to deal with them. You talk about healthcare, education etc but you are ignorant of the reports of the two national conference that has been thrown into aso rock dustbin. If a national confab report cannot be implemented,what will be implemented? If I may ask,can you give us convincing reasons why nigeria will work soon so we can stop clamoring for secession. IPOB Youth 6 Likes |
Re: The Biafra Question: Is Secession The Answer? by brize(m): 8:51pm On Sep 20, 2015 |
Everybody knows we are not one people, so lets forget about one Nigeria nonsense and focus on dividing this zoo so that everybody will go his way........... Divide the Nigeria, #freeBiafra 3 Likes |
Re: The Biafra Question: Is Secession The Answer? by Duru1(m): 9:00pm On Sep 20, 2015 |
One of the answers to the question is YES!!! In case of the zoo called Nigeria, secession is certainly the solution. Sure, secession is hardly peaceful yet there are peaceful secessions or total breakup of countries around the world. Nigeria shall not be the first or last. Please acknowledge that plebiscite is not the most important route to national self-determination. 3 Likes |
Re: The Biafra Question: Is Secession The Answer? by Nobody: 9:04pm On Sep 20, 2015 |
Biafra will come at the right time but first we have to do what the OP is saying |
Re: The Biafra Question: Is Secession The Answer? by coolitempa(f): 9:04pm On Sep 20, 2015 |
Yes to Biafra......no to Internet Biafra....like yesterday sef........but these guys are just not serious....that is the issue..... ![]() ![]() 2 Likes |
Re: The Biafra Question: Is Secession The Answer? by kenny987(f): 9:16pm On Sep 20, 2015 |
Don't cry more than the bereaved. The concerned persons (Biafrans) have counted the costs and are willing to proceed for the greater good. This is the period of sensitization and awareness so stakeholders have a clear understanding and get involved. There are millions of Nigerians scattered in other countries. They are doing just fine and there is no rule that says that all Biafrans must reside in Biafra just like there are Nigerians in diaspora. To answer your question, secession/separation is the best solution. If for 100 + years of existence we are still the way we are then it is time to pursue an alternative more decisively than previous times. If the CONFAB cannot be implemented and all the calls for restructuring cannot be heeded what extra fight do u want? Nigeria is a forceful and inorganic creation. That in itself in a fundamental issue. 5 Likes 1 Share |
Re: The Biafra Question: Is Secession The Answer? by kernel501: 9:18pm On Sep 20, 2015 |
I have lots of respect for the writer of this article. But l want to correct a lot of impressions. 1. You talked about Biafra having small space of land Nigeria 923,768 France 551,500 Japan 377,915 Germany 357,022 New Zealand 270,467 From the above data you will understand that Nigeria is larger in Land mass and population, yet there economy is not half compared to ours. Japan doesn't have any mineral resources yet there GDP per capital is more 800% better than ours, why? Simple... they are hard working people,same with Germans. Secondly, Abia State alone is bigger than Lagos twice, use Google search and check the size, yet Lagos has 20 million people now, while Abia has 5 million now... that means only Abia alone can house 30-40 million people. 2. I can assure you that if there is a referendum today for secession, 90% Igbos will sign-up for that. Look after the war we had nothing, today... we are far better off. 3. 80% of oil wells are owned by Northerners, and you are asking us to keep quite? 4. They want us in Nigeria, but we don't deserve to be president, right? On top our Oil shaiiii !!! 3 Likes |
Re: The Biafra Question: Is Secession The Answer? by Nobody: 9:30pm On Sep 20, 2015 |
kernel501: We should gift the presidency to the igbos on a platter of gold? if you want presidency won't you work towards it? Igbos should be allowed to leave jareee, we sef don tire for them. |
Re: The Biafra Question: Is Secession The Answer? by PentiumPro(f): 9:30pm On Sep 20, 2015 |
Nigerians,please for the sake of progress, let Biafrans go! 1 Like |
Re: The Biafra Question: Is Secession The Answer? by kernel501: 9:33pm On Sep 20, 2015 |
Alcatraz001: I like what you said... That you are tired of them, and they are tired of you too and so... marriage over !!! |
Re: The Biafra Question: Is Secession The Answer? by Nobody: 9:36pm On Sep 20, 2015 |
IS ONE NIGERIA BY FORCE We seek freedom .? |
Re: The Biafra Question: Is Secession The Answer? by Nobody: 9:54pm On Sep 20, 2015 |
begging the biafrans to continue in same cespit country with them using cheap blackmails. telling them about there properties and wealth but when u ask them they will never agree biafrans are wealthy people. for your information we have calculated the risk and we are ready to take the risk. 2 Likes |
Re: The Biafra Question: Is Secession The Answer? by Nobody: 9:57pm On Sep 20, 2015 |
Nigeria seize to exist since 2014. It is a crime to say that there is a country called Nigeria. Me? A Nigerian? God forbid. 2 Likes |
Re: The Biafra Question: Is Secession The Answer? by Nobody: 9:59pm On Sep 20, 2015 |
PentiumPro: Abi ooooo, I think the problem lies with ibo leaders and the hausas. if the leaders can key into the biafrans dream and the majority of ibos demonstrate their seriousness by pulling out of Nigeria back into the east, they will have their Biafra in less than a month. All thus internet issue is for kids. 1 Like |
Re: The Biafra Question: Is Secession The Answer? by Nobody: 10:00pm On Sep 20, 2015 |
PentiumPro: Abi ooooo, I think the problem lies with ibo leaders and the hausas. if the leaders can key into the biafrans dream and the majority of ibos demonstrate their seriousness by pulling out of Nigeria back into the east, they will have their Biafra in less than a month. All thus internet agitation is for kids. 1 Like |
Re: The Biafra Question: Is Secession The Answer? by Nobody: 10:03pm On Sep 20, 2015 |
helinues: |
Re: The Biafra Question: Is Secession The Answer? by Nobody: 10:08pm On Sep 20, 2015 |
I know OP is yoruba. As usual looking to covet Biafrans' properties and businesses upon secession. Biafra will secede and Biafrans with businesses and properties will still own what rightfully belongs to them in Nigeria as protected by international laws. Just as you Yorubas own properties in UK, US, e.t.c., so shall Biafrans continue to own and acquire properties in Nigeria. This is common sense...bunch of uncivilized, lazy black people. 4 Likes 1 Share |
Re: The Biafra Question: Is Secession The Answer? by Nobody: 10:40pm On Sep 20, 2015 |
Yes secession is the answer. Please give the Igbos Biafra. self determination is the right of any group and people shouldn't be forced into a relationship they don't wanna be in. Yorubas support their peaceful exit from Nigeria. and we will do everything in our power to help them achieve this, as long as it is by peaceful means. The earlier, the better. this is no longer the 20th century, this is the 21st century. No need for war. If the South-south tribes want to join them, odabo, we wish them well. God bless the peoples of Nigeria. 3 Likes |
Re: The Biafra Question: Is Secession The Answer? by c33b33(m): 12:05am On Sep 21, 2015 |
Some educated morons call it internet agitation but they read the brown envelope journalists newspapers and all the effort of their B.oohari using military might,killing and detaining of IPOB members and threatening every satelite carrier of Radio Biafra. Lol Only those that can reason will understand. IPOB Youth 1 Like |
Re: The Biafra Question: Is Secession The Answer? by c33b33(m): 12:08am On Sep 21, 2015 |
Ioannes: Can you ask the mod to close it down and please nothing like south south. IPOB Youth |
Re: The Biafra Question: Is Secession The Answer? by Scholes007(m): 12:35am On Sep 21, 2015 |
Peaceful Biafran secession should be view as a long time struggle which shouldnot be over politised... To me biafra dream should be a success but for now i think it just beyond the stage of enlightenment As we could notice from the amount of awareness & response of many people in the target population. Hence this should be the period of preparation and planning in terms of provision of quality basic amenity, resources, stratagy, policies and planning. Here is where the state governors in the included states, organisations (like ohaneze ndiigbo and other groups) and individuals should bring their cards together and work to build a viable ground for the actualisation of the said country without heating up polity... It should include creation of peaceful & economicaly viable states, improving on infrastructal and basic amenity deficit, creation and funding of black ops specially designed to take on international,domestic,dirty and cyber politics then should the real Agitation start |
Re: The Biafra Question: Is Secession The Answer? by Nobody: 12:47am On Sep 21, 2015 |
helinues: Ukraine split n some regions left the country... No one had yo forfeit anything. |
Re: The Biafra Question: Is Secession The Answer? by coolitempa(f): 12:58am On Sep 21, 2015 |
Ibos must be serious about Biafra.......nothing for them in 'hateful' ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() 1 Like |
Re: The Biafra Question: Is Secession The Answer? by Scholes007(m): 1:29am On Sep 21, 2015 |
coolitempa:ibo or igbo? I dont think there are the only ones in this ok |
Breaking News: Jonathan Replies Obasanjo Vanguard / Caption Theses Photos Of Osinbajo And A Woman In Ekiti / All D Way For APC To Clear Delta State On Saturday
(Go Up)
Sections: politics (1) business autos (1) jobs (1) career education (1) romance computers phones travel sports fashion health religion celebs tv-movies music-radio literature webmasters programming techmarket Links: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) Nairaland - Copyright © 2005 - 2024 Oluwaseun Osewa. All rights reserved. See How To Advertise. 82 |