Welcome, Guest: Register On Nairaland / LOGIN! / Trending / Recent / New
Stats: 3,205,221 members, 7,991,576 topics. Date: Friday, 01 November 2024 at 09:39 PM

Opinion: Should Euthanasia Be Legal Or Illegal? - Health (2) - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum / Nairaland / General / Health / Opinion: Should Euthanasia Be Legal Or Illegal? (18085 Views)

Should Euthanasia Be Legalised In Nigeria.........? / Should Euthanasia Be Legalized In Nigeria? / Opinion: Should Women Be Entitled To Menstrual Leave? (2) (3) (4)

(1) (2) (3) (4) (Reply) (Go Down)

Re: Opinion: Should Euthanasia Be Legal Or Illegal? by UncleLondon: 4:15pm On Jan 02, 2016
If for some reasons life is not bearable why not? People have the right to live and people should have rights to choose otherwise if.

Prognosis of some diagnosis is death. Assisted suicide or mercy kiling should not be criminalized in clinical sphere if the right consent are sought.
Re: Opinion: Should Euthanasia Be Legal Or Illegal? by cococandy(f): 4:18pm On Jan 02, 2016
but the nurses wheeling him into the surgical theatre under the guise of negligence gave him mercy killing. My family went indignant and we stopped the emergency unit of that hospital from functioning on that very day.

[size=18pt]WTH!!!![/size]
Re: Opinion: Should Euthanasia Be Legal Or Illegal? by zolajpower: 4:21pm On Jan 02, 2016
the case of Christy bobby brown
Re: Opinion: Should Euthanasia Be Legal Or Illegal? by bqlekan(m): 4:21pm On Jan 02, 2016
If suicidal thought/ attempt is a crime and murder itself is a crime, why legalize euthanasia or better still mercy killing? Which is a combination of suicide and murder..
Re: Opinion: Should Euthanasia Be Legal Or Illegal? by iamzeekie(m): 4:23pm On Jan 02, 2016
Euthanasia, is simply the quiet, painless and intentional putting to death of another by artificial means upon persons with incurable and extremely painful diseases or illnesses, it is classified into active, passive, voluntary and involutary euthanasia. This act, is illegallised in Nigerian legal system, under Section 306, 308 and 209 of the criminal code respectively. However the posture of our legal system and our laws in rendering this act illegal is consequent upon the fact that this act is a complete breach of any such persons Fundamental right to life, as entrenched under Section 33 of the constitution of the federal republic of Nigeria.
Although, there are various arguements in favour of its legalisation in our legal system, it is the liberalists views that offenders who commits this acts, do it out of love and compassion for the individuals who are suffering under such extreme pains and incurable disease. Just as King saul in the bible sought after an amalekite to help in ending his life in 2 Samuel 1:6-10.
It is however my humble opinion that the posture of the law remains quite adequate for the nigerian society, and that the sanctity of human life must be proctected at all cost, regardless of what other legal systems like canadaa and the rest may decide to follow. Check out the case of CATAR V. A.G CANADA.

1 Like

Re: Opinion: Should Euthanasia Be Legal Or Illegal? by Nobody: 4:23pm On Jan 02, 2016
Lordave:
You gotta be kidding me!

You are the first person I'm hearing such a thing from. Why do you wish so?

Believe by then Im done with this earth
Achieved it all
What's there to live for
What can I honestly enjoy at that age
Meen its time to sign off
Re: Opinion: Should Euthanasia Be Legal Or Illegal? by cococandy(f): 4:24pm On Jan 02, 2016
@topic, I'm swaying towards voluntary euthanasia but then I think about it again , if the patient's pain can be reduced to the most minimal where they don't have to suffer (which is possible I think) why agree to aid them die in the first place?

It's really dicey.
I'd root for it in a situation where the patient will surely die,is in horrendous painful misery and nothing can be done to ease his suffering.
If something can be done about the pain, then just let him live even if he wants to die.
Re: Opinion: Should Euthanasia Be Legal Or Illegal? by bovamm(f): 4:24pm On Jan 02, 2016
Flygeriansteve:
shocked I'm genuinely shocked that an intelligent issue like this is being diskcussed on nairaland.






The mods made a mistake.

Euthanasia shouldn't be legalized in a country like Nigeria. Patients would be killed anyhow even if they have a chance at survival

2 Likes

Re: Opinion: Should Euthanasia Be Legal Or Illegal? by Afam4eva(m): 4:25pm On Jan 02, 2016
If someone has even 0.5% of surviving, then the person should be given a chance and nobody has the right to decide who lives or who dies except the dying person explicitly requests for Euthanasia.
Re: Opinion: Should Euthanasia Be Legal Or Illegal? by Bollinger(m): 4:27pm On Jan 02, 2016
Akin1212:


Nice quota, but don't you think voluntary euthanasia is more or less suicide/assisted suicide? I don't think suicide is a good way to go. Let death come naturally, in fact I am beginning to move towards the scrapping of euthanasia no matter which category. No matter how long a person has been ill, let death have the final say. We as humans do not possess the right to decide who dies or who doesn't.

That's easy for you to say. God forbid you were in an accident and from your stomach down you were crushed and the doctors had to sever it. You are on life support and your family is spending thousands of dollars per month to keep you alive. Your wife has sold your two houses plus your cars and now she has to move in with your brothers family. This along with your children. Let's see if you won't take the option if presented to you. I know i would.
Re: Opinion: Should Euthanasia Be Legal Or Illegal? by Nobody: 4:34pm On Jan 02, 2016
Hell yes
Re: Opinion: Should Euthanasia Be Legal Or Illegal? by cococandy(f): 4:34pm On Jan 02, 2016
Afam4eva:
If someone has even 0.5% of surviving, then the person should be given a chance and nobody has the right to decide who lives or who dies except the dying person explicitly requests for Euthanasia.
Voluntary euthanasia
Re: Opinion: Should Euthanasia Be Legal Or Illegal? by Lordave: 4:35pm On Jan 02, 2016
BUTCHCASSIDY:


Believe by then Im done with this earth
Achieved it all
What's there to live for
What can I honestly enjoy at that age
Meen its time to sign off
Not even in Israel have I seen a man so 'greediless' like you.
Re: Opinion: Should Euthanasia Be Legal Or Illegal? by Flygeriansteve: 4:40pm On Jan 02, 2016
bovamm:







The mods made a mistake.

Euthanasia shouldn't be legalized in a country like Nigeria. Patients would be killed anyhow even if they have a chance at survival
The patients themselves only will elect to continue to live or die. That's why its assisted suicide. Sufferers can usually do this even when their condition renders them completely paralysed. They may blink to show approval.
Re: Opinion: Should Euthanasia Be Legal Or Illegal? by czarlawzy(m): 4:42pm On Jan 02, 2016
chillybrandy:
In my opinion it shouldn't be legalised. Everyone has the right to life even in critical conditions. Besides that miracle still happens.
Assuming miracle was not forthcoming,who takes the blame for d prolonged excruciating pain the person would have undergone until his/her death?
Re: Opinion: Should Euthanasia Be Legal Or Illegal? by c0mrade: 4:43pm On Jan 02, 2016
voluntary euthanasia should be an important part of life as far as It allows people to be free of unending physical pain and mental suffering.
Re: Opinion: Should Euthanasia Be Legal Or Illegal? by Nobody: 4:46pm On Jan 02, 2016
This is very interesting.



When someone has gone through so much e.g a terrible burn that will leave one to suffer excruciating pain for life, I think mercy killing is not bad.

I really wish to read religious views,
medical views and legal views on this issue.
Re: Opinion: Should Euthanasia Be Legal Or Illegal? by 0gbeni(m): 4:54pm On Jan 02, 2016
Voluntary euthanasia can be legalized, frees greviously injured /terminally ill patients from a lot of pain and stress and also helps the financial situation of the family that the patient leaves , what's the point of paying 40,000/day in an ICU if the patient is already brain dead and will most likely never wake up again?

Sorry about your uncle @op but i don't think the nurses did euthanasia, he must have died enroute the theatre, most non-medical people dont understand how a lot of things work ( esp in our health system here) and they wrongly accuse health workers, pls Google things at the minimum before concluding

1 Like

Re: Opinion: Should Euthanasia Be Legal Or Illegal? by teebaxy(m): 4:59pm On Jan 02, 2016
Akin1212:

smiley In medicine, I don't think there is anything such as 'miracle'. Sometimes it happens right there before their eyes and they try to find another explanation to it. But the fact is miracle happens, but no one can tell when it will happen, so since it doesn't depend on a constant they don't really expect it in medicine except there is a sign. My mother still claims my uncle was killed by the nurses, you know. His brain's right hemisphere was already dead, but still they didn't have the right to remove his breathing aid. A lot of people really need to know about euthanasia. I am actually waiving on this issue, I don't know where to stand. Thanks for your opinion though.
have u forgotten that most doctors will tell the patients guardian that they are mere Attendants that only God heals, ask Doctor like Ben carson
Re: Opinion: Should Euthanasia Be Legal Or Illegal? by 7footre(m): 5:03pm On Jan 02, 2016
We over argued this with our philosophy lecturer in year one and didn't come to a conclusive end! I'm a protagonist to mercy killing
Re: Opinion: Should Euthanasia Be Legal Or Illegal? by ShammahBarnabas(m): 5:06pm On Jan 02, 2016
This will be a very good topic for discussion in the USA, but not in Nigeria, yet. We are still fighting infant mortality, malaria, and the likes. So "Mercy killing" should not even cross our minds yet.
Re: Opinion: Should Euthanasia Be Legal Or Illegal? by Akin1212(m): 5:19pm On Jan 02, 2016
0gbeni:
Voluntary euthanasia can be legalized, frees greviously injured /terminally ill patients from a lot of pain and stress and also helps the financial situation of the family that the patient leaves , what's the point of paying 40,000/day in an ICU if the patient is already brain dead and will most likely never wake up again?

Sorry about your uncle @op but i don't think the nurses did euthanasia, he must have died enroute the theatre, most non-medical people dont understand how a lot of things work ( esp in our health system here) and they wrongly accuse health workers, pls Google things at the minimum before concluding
Actually that part was not a mere conclusion, it was a form of non voluntary euthanasia. They didn't care about our presence, my mum was accompanying them when they acted. They did as if the breathing aid was faulty and they removed and kept checking it until my uncle suffocated and died. Even if euthanasia would be Legalized, it has to be dependent on many factors. Non voluntary and Involuntary euthanasia should not be allowed, to an extent I can agree with voluntary euthanasia
Re: Opinion: Should Euthanasia Be Legal Or Illegal? by Akin1212(m): 5:21pm On Jan 02, 2016
7footre:
We over argued this with our philosophy lecturer in year one and didn't come to a conclusive end! I'm a protagonist to mercy killing
What are your reasons?
Re: Opinion: Should Euthanasia Be Legal Or Illegal? by Karleb(m): 5:23pm On Jan 02, 2016
No!
Re: Opinion: Should Euthanasia Be Legal Or Illegal? by Frankiss44(m): 5:27pm On Jan 02, 2016
Until you can create a life, you don't have any right to take one...
Re: Opinion: Should Euthanasia Be Legal Or Illegal? by structurem(m): 5:30pm On Jan 02, 2016
I don't think it's an option to be considered. God is the only one that has the right to take one's life, cos, He created it after all.
Re: Opinion: Should Euthanasia Be Legal Or Illegal? by waice6571: 5:51pm On Jan 02, 2016
Ymodulus:
And how many people have been healed by miracles?
I am living witness to the goodness Of God.
Re: Opinion: Should Euthanasia Be Legal Or Illegal? by 0gbeni(m): 5:52pm On Jan 02, 2016
Akin1212:

Actually that part was not a mere conclusion, it was a form of non voluntary euthanasia. They didn't care about our presence, my mum was accompanying them when they acted. They did as if the breathing aid was faulty and they removed and kept checking it until my uncle suffocated and died. Even if euthanasia would be Legalized, it has to be dependent on many factors. Non voluntary and Involuntary euthanasia should not be allowed, to an extent I can agree with voluntary euthanasia

Okay.. the breathing aid could have been faulty bro, you'd be surprised at the amount of basic emergency/elective equipment our hospitals lack in Nigeria, most Nigerians are very religious people who take the sanctity of life very seriously.
Ehat I will just suggest is that let's pressure the government to overhaul our hospitals
Re: Opinion: Should Euthanasia Be Legal Or Illegal? by Tingles(m): 6:01pm On Jan 02, 2016
Let's take sentiments out of this.

A baby with a serious congenital disorder should be euthanized before we get too attached to it, Down's Syndrome has no cure.

In cases where keeping the patient alive would subject the family to a lifetime of poverty and hardship (paying hospital bills running into millions of naira), euthanasia should be considered.

Hard choices, I know.

2 Likes

Re: Opinion: Should Euthanasia Be Legal Or Illegal? by Ymodulus: 6:02pm On Jan 02, 2016
waice6571:


I am living witness to the goodness Of God.


Which God?

Your God? If your God then he his a very wicked one as he sent me down, to suffer humiliation.

Seizures and collapse in public that brought shame to me. Regrets to point of dieing.

If there is a God, he is definitely not a good God.

God committed genocide and killed millions in the bible. Yet you tell me he his good?.

He should be tried for genocide. I will personally put otapiapia in his food , that's if he exist

2 Likes

Re: Opinion: Should Euthanasia Be Legal Or Illegal? by waice6571: 6:12pm On Jan 02, 2016
Ymodulus:


Which God?

Your God? If your God then he his a very wicked one as he sent me down, to suffer humiliation.

Seizures and collapse in public that brought shame to me. Regrets to point of dieing.

If there is a God, he is definitely not a good God.

God committed genocide and killed millions in the bible. Yet you tell me he his good?.

He should be tried for genocide. I will personally put otapiapia in his food , that's if he exist

No offense sir, God is absolutely good and merciful to me. Could you believe I lived about 14 years without visiting any doctor or any hospital after my encounter. late 1995 -2005. Till today I take paracetamol for Maleria fever. God is VERY REAL.
Re: Opinion: Should Euthanasia Be Legal Or Illegal? by olalerey(m): 6:13pm On Jan 02, 2016
Life is a sanctity. Right to Life is the most fundamental of all Rights in Human existence. Why should we then try to extend Right to life to Right to due when we cannot create one all in the name of easing the victim's sufferings?....




















Don't forget Attempted Murder is a criminal offence in Nigeria so also all forms of Euthanasia

(1) (2) (3) (4) (Reply)

Surrogacy, How Effective Is It In Nigeria? / Which Toothpaste Is The Best / Governor Otti Commissions Hospital In Ugwunagbo L.G.A

(Go Up)

Sections: politics (1) business autos (1) jobs (1) career education (1) romance computers phones travel sports fashion health
religion celebs tv-movies music-radio literature webmasters programming techmarket

Links: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10)

Nairaland - Copyright © 2005 - 2024 Oluwaseun Osewa. All rights reserved. See How To Advertise. 53
Disclaimer: Every Nairaland member is solely responsible for anything that he/she posts or uploads on Nairaland.