Welcome, Guest: Register On Nairaland / LOGIN! / Trending / Recent / New
Stats: 3,206,139 members, 7,994,879 topics. Date: Tuesday, 05 November 2024 at 11:27 PM

Why Did God Create The Tree Of Good and evil If He Didn't Want Man To Sin - Religion (9) - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum / Nairaland / General / Religion / Why Did God Create The Tree Of Good and evil If He Didn't Want Man To Sin (36628 Views)

Why Is Sex Attached To Sin By Most Religion? / Why Does God Create People When He Knows They Are Going To Hell? / Is Grace A License To Sin? - Paul Ellis (2) (3) (4)

(1) (2) (3) ... (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) (11) (12) (Reply) (Go Down)

Re: Why Did God Create The Tree Of Good and evil If He Didn't Want Man To Sin by Martartins(m): 7:49pm On Apr 10, 2016
Read Mattew 13. you will understand better.
Re: Why Did God Create The Tree Of Good and evil If He Didn't Want Man To Sin by achorladey: 7:51pm On Apr 10, 2016
Because we read God made Pharaoh's heart hardened. Have you ever asked was Pharaoh himself willing to let the Israelites go despite all the trials Egyptians faced? God only used Pharaoh stubborn tendency to show his mightiness not a case of God making him hard hearted.

1 Like

Re: Why Did God Create The Tree Of Good and evil If He Didn't Want Man To Sin by Volksfuhrer(m): 7:57pm On Apr 10, 2016
achorladey:
@volksfuhrer now you are almost there read Genesis 22:12 Then he said: “Do not harm the boy, and do not do anything at all to him, for now I do know that you are God-fearing because you have not withheld your son, your only one, from me.”

I got the point, but I put no stock in it. We must be very careful when we interpret Bible verses literally. Mind you Genesis was translated from ancient Scholastic Hebrew, a language that was written without vowels. The Masoretes centuries later added vowels to it to make sense of it. Therefore, we need to put everything in proper context.

The above quote need not imply that God didn't know Abraham would obey him, perhaps what He said was to comfort Abraham for the anguish he just experienced. Or better still, He said all those things for posterity's sake. God sees everything.

The logic of an Eternal Being with eternal knowledge can appear absurd to a mortal. The point I'm making is that, everything God allowed to happen aligns to His eternal plan for mankind. Every detail did not escape His consciousness!
Re: Why Did God Create The Tree Of Good and evil If He Didn't Want Man To Sin by thrudave(m): 7:58pm On Apr 10, 2016
booqee:
I keep wondering why did God even create the tree of life in the garden of Eden in the first place if He didn't want man to sin..

Some say its intentional... if it is, why was He so displeased to the extent of placing a curse on them...

He created us as man.. not as gods or heavenly creatures.. so of course he was easy and prone to falling for temptation.. so I assumed He knew from the start while creating him, that man would fall by eating the forbidden fruit...

so why bother creating it and then cursing man when it is believed He knew he would fall.. (that's the part that makes it look unfair) .. its similar to setting a concealed trap right in front of us..


I'm confused honestly ..

contributions are welcome
Bro..
Good and evil has been in existence even before Adam..

And its all about our CHOICES

like in the beginning when God created the heavens,earth and all there is He saw that twaz GOOD..

lucifer..the bright morning star thought high of himself and WANTED the glory of God for himelf;he CHOOSED to belike God
Re: Why Did God Create The Tree Of Good and evil If He Didn't Want Man To Sin by analice107: 8:03pm On Apr 10, 2016
oglalasioux:
Why I believe the biblical stories are lies;

1. God knows all things and even the future. So he knew before hand that Satan will fall and Adam and Eve will eat the forbidden fruit. So why create Satan and why plant the fruit?

2. God so love the world that He gave His son to the world to die. So why did Jesus weep in the garden and why is Judas Iscariot not a saint for helping to make the salvation of the world possible?

Let me stop and wait for the bashings before I continue.
Hahahahahahahaha. You are waiting for the bashing.
Re: Why Did God Create The Tree Of Good and evil If He Didn't Want Man To Sin by witnezHD(m): 8:06pm On Apr 10, 2016
Tjayjosh:
@Op. The bible says, God created man in his own image, in the image of God created he him; male and female created he them. And God blessed them, and God said unto them, Be fruitful, and multiply, and replenish the earth, and subdue it: and have dominion over the fish of the sea, and over the fowl of the air, and over every living thing that moveth upon the earth (Genesis 1:27-28 KJV). And then here God commanded the man saying, Of every tree of the garden thou mayest freely eat: "But of the three of the knowledge of good and evil, thou shalt not eat of it: for in the day that thou eatest thereof thou shalt surely die" (Genesis 2:16-17). God gave man everything, and wanted something back in return. Let me brake this down. God put the tree of knowledge of good and evil in the Garden of Eden to give Adam and Eve a choice to obey Him or disobey Him. Adam and Eve were free to do anything they wanted, except eat from the tree of knowledge of good and evil. If God had not given Adam and Eve the choice, they would have essentially been robots, simply doing what they were programmed to do. God created
Adam and Eve to be free beings, able to make decisions, able to choose between good and evil. In order for Adam and
Eve to truly be free, they had to have a choice. Hear this, the bible let us to know that God is omniscient, omnipotent and omnipresent. With all this power, knowledge and versatility that God posseses. He cannot control you or alter your freewill. The tree of the knowledge of good and evil was a. symbol. God said, "if ye love me, keep my commandments" (John 14:15). That tree was the only way God could get love back from the man He loved and gave everything.
don't you think that God is an "all knowng God" not God of probability... ..that he knew that adam fail despite all his warning...

1 Like

Re: Why Did God Create The Tree Of Good and evil If He Didn't Want Man To Sin by thrudave(m): 8:10pm On Apr 10, 2016
DonaldGenes:

In essence, what's your main point Bruh?
Re: Why Did God Create The Tree Of Good and evil If He Didn't Want Man To Sin by witnezHD(m): 8:15pm On Apr 10, 2016
themosthigh:
Because jehovah is a wicked being who is looking for reasons to punish man and not blame himself...that is why he came down to earth to claim that he died for our sins out of his love for us only to wake up in three days,return back to heaven and claim he can now punish man in ethernal fire if we refuse to believe he died for our sins.....he gives us no evidence and punish us for saying it us a lie....he is worst than the devil and i will march out against him on armagadon carrying the black flag of lucifer...we will finally defeat him and lock him up in the bottomless pit which he created for his beloved creation...we almost did it during the tym.of the fallen angels and later when we where lead by the prince of persia to defeat all his angels and prevent daniels prayer from reaching God and we will succeed this tym around and end his reign of tyranny..


he a mastermind wit a masterplan for us all
Re: Why Did God Create The Tree Of Good and evil If He Didn't Want Man To Sin by sandygechy(f): 8:15pm On Apr 10, 2016
What's this one saying
sonOfLucifer:
Read the full story here tongue
- God Knows Everything.
- God created the Universe.
- God knew what would happen if Adam ate from the tree.
- God didn't plant the tree on Mars or Jupiter.
- He put the tree, in the same garden, with Adam..

See setup. grin

@op there are many African myths to believe that make more sense than that of the Israeli's... who dont even care about most of this nonsense y'all bother your minds with. There was no tree. Your ancestors weren't Adam and Eve.

You won't put a knife near a baby, then blame the baby for playing with the knife. A responsible God would have built a huge Trump size wall around that motherfucking tree. But, it's Yahweh. He just like fucking human beings up. Like his twin brother Allah who is trying desperately to catch up with his killer numbers..
Re: Why Did God Create The Tree Of Good and evil If He Didn't Want Man To Sin by analice107: 8:15pm On Apr 10, 2016
Nmeri17:
Abeg! The thread is asking "why there was bread in the first place". Why are you recounting the Fall story all over? This is like reading a translation named Standard Bakery Version.
It's called allusion. Imagery
Re: Why Did God Create The Tree Of Good and evil If He Didn't Want Man To Sin by thrudave(m): 8:15pm On Apr 10, 2016
Re: Why Did God Create The Tree Of Good and evil If He Didn't Want Man To Sin by Godrep: 8:16pm On Apr 10, 2016
Teempakguy:
you should think also.

Now as the mother, when you return, and you find out that your child has indeed disobeyed you, I guess your next move will be to banish your own child to the harsh world, curse him or her with death and pain, wait for 3000 years, give birth to another child and have that one killed and resurrected before you can allow the erring one back into your house.

Instead of just chastising them like a normal parent. If you can't see the absurdity even with your own example, your brain wash, no be small.

1corinthians 1 vs 18-31
Re: Why Did God Create The Tree Of Good and evil If He Didn't Want Man To Sin by achorladey: 8:16pm On Apr 10, 2016
@ volksfuhrer I love your last line in particular the use of the words 'allow and consciousness'.
Re: Why Did God Create The Tree Of Good and evil If He Didn't Want Man To Sin by witnezHD(m): 8:23pm On Apr 10, 2016
oglalasioux:
Why I believe the biblical stories are lies;

1. God knows all things and even the future. So he knew before hand that Satan will fall and Adam and Eve will eat the forbidden fruit. So why create Satan and why plant the fruit?

2. God so love the world that He gave His son to the world to die. So why did Jesus weep in the garden and why is Judas Iscariot not a saint for helping to make the salvation of the world possible?

Let me stop and wait for the bashings before I continue.
your truth pass mtn true talk #kudos
Re: Why Did God Create The Tree Of Good and evil If He Didn't Want Man To Sin by analice107: 8:24pm On Apr 10, 2016
emmykk:
i better question is why.did.adam and eve didnt go for there tree of life
Thank you my dear. This is the question no Satanist wants to ask. After all the tree of life was also there, why didn't Adam go for it. Or better put, why didn't the servant cajole them into eating from it. Why the other tree?
Re: Why Did God Create The Tree Of Good and evil If He Didn't Want Man To Sin by benedictgold(m): 8:29pm On Apr 10, 2016
analice107:

Create this scenarios in your mind's eyes.

Am your Mum, sovery rich. Everything you want you can get, I have a mansion which you live in it with me. One day i call you into a room empty, I mean nothing to eat in it, and then I give you an instruction saying, "Am going out my son, see that you touch nothing in this room till I return.
Remember, it's an empty room, and am telling you not to touch anything. What's is there to touch?

Again, I am your parent, am very wealthy. You of course is my child, and so lives in my mansion full of everything. But I call you and instructs you and say "Son, you can make use of everything in the freezer, every thing, only just this "wheat Bread", pls don't touch it", and I went out.
I left everything to your disposal, no restrains. There's assorted of everything. All kinds of breads, eat your fill, but don't touch the Wheat Bread. But you left every other thing you are free to touch and eat, but went to the only one I instructed you don't touch.
In your head or mind's eye, what do you see?

Let me help you. God Wanted to teach Adam Obidience and control.

In the first scenario, the room was empty, so Adam would of course have nothing to touch. If he touched nothing, because there was nothing to touch, would you call that Obidience? Will he be exercising any control? No.

The second scenario. Every thing but ONE is given to you. BUT you are instructed, leave the Wheat Bread alone. But u left the flour bread or corn bread and went for the wheat bread. Would you say Adam did well?
Can you obey instructions without control? No.
If you love me, you will respect me, if you respect me, you will obey me. Finish.
When you ask questions first think.

This answers your question. To add to it, there is no true obedience without the option to disobey, if there was nothing to disobey then we cannot really say they obeyed God cos they could not do otherwise. But God gave them the freewill to choose cos He didn't want to create robots programmed to do whatever He ask but free people who will obey His commandments out of love they have for God and not cos they are compelled to.
Re: Why Did God Create The Tree Of Good and evil If He Didn't Want Man To Sin by witnezHD(m): 8:33pm On Apr 10, 2016
mannatech:
The ever knowing and ever seeing god who never makes error. To me , if going by the Bible's version of Creation, his expectation did not tally with the outcome. Man sinned, and god was sleeping then, Choi!
Upon all his power, I wonder why the world is what it is today. This whole humanity, earth Creation bs crappy story is enough, he hasn't woken up since eve's disobedience.
guy you funny
Re: Why Did God Create The Tree Of Good and evil If He Didn't Want Man To Sin by analice107: 8:35pm On Apr 10, 2016
benedictgold:


This answers your question. To add to it, there is no true obedience without the option to disobey, if there was nothing to disobey then we cannot really say they obeyed God cos they could not do otherwise. But God gave them the freewill to choose cos He didn't want to create robots programmed to do whatever He ask but free people who will obey His commandments out of love they have for God and not cos they are compelled to.
Very true sir.
Re: Why Did God Create The Tree Of Good and evil If He Didn't Want Man To Sin by witnezHD(m): 8:50pm On Apr 10, 2016
I think the truth of the matter is that God has a perfect blueprint for mankind....#stop tryin to judge to God
Re: Why Did God Create The Tree Of Good and evil If He Didn't Want Man To Sin by icybeth(m): 9:25pm On Apr 10, 2016
He wanted to c if Adam could b obedient to Him d creator
Re: Why Did God Create The Tree Of Good and evil If He Didn't Want Man To Sin by lauskidlala(m): 9:30pm On Apr 10, 2016
have you forgotten that the serpent convinced eve...eve convinced Adam...Adam ate and eve ate...God wasn't around....it wasn't Adam's will to eat the out of the forbidden tree...remember Satan's word are so sweet and deceptive....
Re: Why Did God Create The Tree Of Good and evil If He Didn't Want Man To Sin by holyokoto(m): 9:44pm On Apr 10, 2016
booqee:
I keep wondering why did God even create the tree of life in the garden of Eden in the first place if He didn't want man to sin..

Some say its intentional... if it is, why was He so displeased to the extent of placing a curse on them...

He created us as man.. not as gods or heavenly creatures.. so of course he was easy and prone to falling for temptation.. so I assumed He knew from the start while creating him, that man would fall by eating the forbidden fruit...

so why bother creating it and then cursing man when it is believed He knew he would fall.. (that's the part that makes it look unfair) .. its similar to setting a concealed trap right in front of us..


I'm confused honestly ..

contributions are welcome

The Bible has already place the story of Adam 6000 years ago calculating from When Nebuchadnezzar destroyed Jerusalem, And Genealogy in Luke 3:23 down. The Egyptian were as old as 10000 years ago plus many other clans. Hence The Story of Adam is a myth . Adam and Eve never existed
Re: Why Did God Create The Tree Of Good and evil If He Didn't Want Man To Sin by smexy(m): 9:51pm On Apr 10, 2016
booqee:
I keep wondering why did God even create the tree of life in the garden of Eden in the first place if He didn't want man to sin..

Some say its intentional... if it is, why was He so displeased to the extent of placing a curse on them...

He created us as man.. not as gods or heavenly creatures.. so of course he was easy and prone to falling for temptation.. so I assumed He knew from the start while creating him, that man would fall by eating the forbidden fruit...

so why bother creating it and then cursing man when it is believed He knew he would fall.. (that's the part that makes it look unfair) .. its similar to setting a concealed trap right in front of us..


I'm confused honestly ..

contributions are welcome
it was never a trap. in choice lies our ability to be the sons of God. Adam and eve had the choice to obey or not to obey. They chose disobedience. God created the planets, trees and others without giving them the freewill to choose. The planets does not choose the number of times to orbit. It has no choice of its own, so it cannot be a child of God. If God made us robotic beings of some sort, it will be so unfair on his path so he used 'choice' to make us his own.
Re: Why Did God Create The Tree Of Good and evil If He Didn't Want Man To Sin by Aizenosa(m): 9:52pm On Apr 10, 2016
EdwardRandy:
...
Fool!!! Since u are filled with holy spirit and knw the answer why nt say it??... the way u christians dodge questions most times baffles me

Lol let me ask u a question it's very simple, "how are you sure God is the one who planted the tree there?"
Also, I gave you a challenge if u couldn't understand at least pass, insults will do u no good it only shows ignorance.
Re: Why Did God Create The Tree Of Good and evil If He Didn't Want Man To Sin by Myde4naija(m): 9:52pm On Apr 10, 2016
analice107:

No dear, God didn't dig a hole for us to fall into.
The sin of Adam is still seen in us individually today.
CHOICE. The choices we are making today. Are those choices in line with what God instructed?
We should not always look at the finished product of a thing, look at the process sometimes.
Let me ask you, would u have liked if you were created a robot? Do as u r programmed. No questions asked? But God needed a family, a relationship. He couldn't have a relationship with Robots, that's why u are human with the power to choose. But most of us, just like Adam chose to be God to ourselves.
There's the issue of choice, Obidience and control.
Have you asked yourself the origin of atheism? Adam originated atheism. He wanted to be God for himself. So pls...
chaiiii you sabi lie

1 Like

Re: Why Did God Create The Tree Of Good and evil If He Didn't Want Man To Sin by Myde4naija(m): 9:56pm On Apr 10, 2016
lauskidlala:
have you forgotten that the serpent convinced eve...eve convinced Adam...Adam ate and eve ate...God wasn't around....it wasn't Adam's will to eat the out of the forbidden tree...remember Satan's word are so sweet and deceptive....
you cant be serious with this childish thought of yours, "God wasn't around"
you need to flush those rubbish out of your brain and learn fresh things.

1 Like

Re: Why Did God Create The Tree Of Good and evil If He Didn't Want Man To Sin by favourmic(m): 10:06pm On Apr 10, 2016
booqee:
I keep wondering why did God even create the tree of life in the garden of Eden in the first place if He didn't want man to sin..

Some say its intentional... if it is, why was He so displeased to the extent of placing a curse on them...

He created us as man.. not as gods or heavenly creatures.. so of course he was easy and prone to falling for temptation.. so I assumed He knew from the start while creating him, that man would fall by eating the forbidden fruit...

so why bother creating it and then cursing man when it is believed He knew he would fall.. (that's the part that makes it look unfair) .. its similar to setting a concealed trap right in front of us..


I'm confused honestly ..

contributions are welcome

Where you see positive definitely you we see negative
Re: Why Did God Create The Tree Of Good and evil If He Didn't Want Man To Sin by Kunzee2304(m): 10:22pm On Apr 10, 2016
One important thing to consider...is d story of d fall of Lucifer. Lucifer claimed tht God created slaves as angels...with jobs basivally to serve and praise God. Thus he began d rebellion stating that God was a autocratic leader that didnt give anyone choices. The first deception ensued...because Lucifer succeeded in convincing other angels of this fact.

Now thinking from my perspective...if there was an embargo on angels making choices...God must ve released this at this point in time. So when humans were created...Lucifer must have taunted God again that all creations if opportuned to choose...will choose d "power to know good and evil." This must be why God created man and had the scenario setup. Man fell has expected.

My thoughts tell me...that Life was created to re-populate Heaven all over again. But this time with beings that will become angels that had a choice. Your position and status in d bew life will be based on how well you stayed on that right path all through your journey on earth.

So God is a fair God. We are only victims of d tussle between Good and evil.
Re: Why Did God Create The Tree Of Good and evil If He Didn't Want Man To Sin by analice107: 10:25pm On Apr 10, 2016
Myde4naija:
chaiiii you sabi lie
It's not enough to say 'you sabi lie', point out the lies.
Re: Why Did God Create The Tree Of Good and evil If He Didn't Want Man To Sin by LastSurvivor: 10:30pm On Apr 10, 2016
analice107:

Create this scenarios in your mind's eyes.

Am your Mum, sovery rich. Everything you want you can get, I have a mansion which you live in it with me. One day i call you into a room empty, I mean nothing to eat in it, and then I give you an instruction saying, "Am going out my son, see that you touch nothing in this room till I return.
Remember, it's an empty room, and am telling you not to touch anything. What's is there to touch?

Again, I am your parent, am very wealthy. You of course is my child, and so lives in my mansion full of everything. But I call you and instructs you and say "Son, you can make use of everything in the freezer, every thing, only just this "wheat Bread", pls don't touch it", and I went out.
I left everything to your disposal, no restrains. There's assorted of everything. All kinds of breads, eat your fill, but don't touch the Wheat Bread. But you left every other thing you are free to touch and eat, but went to the only one I instructed you don't touch.
In your head or mind's eye, what do you see?

Let me help you. God Wanted to teach Adam Obidience and control.

In the first scenario, the room was empty, so Adam would of course have nothing to touch. If he touched nothing, because there was nothing to touch, would you call that Obidience? Will he be exercising any control? No.

The second scenario. Every thing but ONE is given to you. BUT you are instructed, leave the Wheat Bread alone. But u left the flour bread or corn bread and went for the wheat bread. Would you say Adam did well?
Can you obey instructions without control? No.
If you love me, you will respect me, if you respect me, you will obey me. Finish.
When you ask questions first think.

9z one but mind you, God is not ur mother who is just trying to know if you will touch the Wheat Bread without being sure, we are talking about a God that knows fully well from onset that u gonna take the bread.. Remember he is all knowing not like he's trying to ascertain unlike my mum who is not really sure what am gonna do..

So the question is why is he trying Adam since he already knows the outcome before the trial..

1 Like

Re: Why Did God Create The Tree Of Good and evil If He Didn't Want Man To Sin by lookingfly: 10:36pm On Apr 10, 2016
analice107:

No dear, God didn't dig a hole for us to fall into.
The sin of Adam is still seen in us individually today.
CHOICE. The choices we are making today. Are those choices in line with what God instructed?
We should not always look at the finished product of a thing, look at the process sometimes.
Let me ask you, would u have liked if you were created a robot? Do as u r programmed. No questions asked? But God needed a family, a relationship. He couldn't have a relationship with Robots, that's why u are human with the power to choose. But most of us, just like Adam chose to be God to ourselves.
There's the issue of choice, Obidience and control.
Have you asked yourself the origin of atheism? Adam originated atheism. He wanted to be God for himself. So pls...
make me believe Adam is the origin of atheism.
Re: Why Did God Create The Tree Of Good and evil If He Didn't Want Man To Sin by Myde4naija(m): 10:42pm On Apr 10, 2016
analice107:

It's not enough to say 'you sabi lie', point out the lies.
you will run away if the proof is out, you will surely dodge the questions that will arise from it.

(1) (2) (3) ... (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) (11) (12) (Reply)

A Governor May Die Next – Suleiman Who Prophesied Death For Buhari’s Ministers / How God's Decision To Elevate Man Above Angels Caused The War In Heaven / Peter Okpaleke Resigns As Bishop Of Ahiara Diocese, Mbaise In Imo

Viewing this topic: 1 guest(s)

(Go Up)

Sections: politics (1) business autos (1) jobs (1) career education (1) romance computers phones travel sports fashion health
religion celebs tv-movies music-radio literature webmasters programming techmarket

Links: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10)

Nairaland - Copyright © 2005 - 2024 Oluwaseun Osewa. All rights reserved. See How To Advertise. 85
Disclaimer: Every Nairaland member is solely responsible for anything that he/she posts or uploads on Nairaland.