hardeycute:
You also decide on that.

Current squad is fine by me, You can also use any time frame as long as we are using same for both. If you dont have any objection to that start listing the Bayern players from other Bundesliga teams

raumdeuter:


Arsenal is almost 30points behind in the league, Spurs is 20 points behind are these also competing for the league?

If 30points behind is the standard for compete then I have 15 teams with 30point or less behind Bayern currently

So by Arsenals standard, Bundesliga dont have a top 6, they have a top 15

lol so you agree say arsenal na small uncompetitive team. but yet them big pass dortmund

MoR2:
lol so you agree say arsenal na small uncompetitive team. but yet them big pass dortmund

Dortmund has won 1 CL, Arsenal has won 0 CL
Dortmund made a CL final 5yrs ago Arsenal made a CL final 12yrs ago
Dortmund made a CL quarters last yr, Arsenal made a CL quarters 8yrs ago

So how Arsenal take big pass Dortmund

raumdeuter:


Current squad is fine by me, You can also use any time frame as long as we are using same for both. If you dont have any objection to that start listing the Bayern players from other Bundesliga teams

I will say no to that of the current squad.5yrs

hardeycute:
I will say no to that of the current squad.5yrs

Ok go ahead 5yrs and list all players that have played for Bayern since 2013 till date that they got directly from other Bundesliga teams

hardeycute vs raumdeuter

this is gonna be interesting

and hey am the ref . so i will be the judge of fouls, fair play and whose point counts. ok

raumdeuter:


Ok go ahead 5yrs and list all players that have played for Bayern since 2013 till date that they got directly from other Bundesliga teams

K,no significance role?

..

raumdeuter:


Dortmund has won 1 CL, Arsenal has won 0 CL
Dortmund made a CL final 5yrs ago Arsenal made a CL final 12yrs ago
Dortmund made a CL quarters last yr, Arsenal made a CL quarters 8yrs ago

So how Arsenal take big pass Dortmund

auba moved to a bigger club na

bwehehehehehe

if na by recent success over the past 5 to 8 years then chelsea is the biggest club in england.

Sandro Wagner,Niklas Sule, Matt Hummels, Mario Goetze,Serge Gnabry, Ulreich,Lewndowski,Josh Kimmich,Mandzukic,Dante,Neur,Pizzaro,Tom Starke,Sebastian Rudy

diggz:



Thunder fire your hands wey u use type this rubbish

Cc airmark

Lordfalcaos, elrony na troublemaker.

MoR2:
auba moved to a bigger club na

bwehehehehehe

if na by recent success over the past 5 to 8 years then chelsea is the biggest club in england.

Neymar moved from Barcelona to PSG

Can we also say PSG is bigger than Barcelona?

hardeycute:
Sandro Wagner,Niklas Sule, Matt Hummels, Mario Goetze,Serge Gnabry, Ulreich,Lewndowski,Josh Kimmich,Mandzukic,Dante,Neur,Pizzaro,Tom Starke,Sebastian Rudy

Valencia - Wigan
Young - Aston Villa
Jones - Blackburn
Smalling - Fulham
Mata - Chelsea
Carrick - Spurs
Alexis - Arsenal
Shaw - Southampton
Lukaku - Everton
Fellaini - Everton
Matic - Chelsea
Schneidelin - Southampton
Rooney - Everton
Van Persie - Arsenal
Zaha - Crystal Palace

hardeycute:
K,no significance role?

What does significant role mean?

raumdeuter:

What does significant role mean?

Talking about appearances

hardeycute:
Talking about appearances

Whats the benchmark for significant appearance?

raumdeuter:


Valencia - Wigan
Young - Aston Villa
Jones - Blackburn
Smalling - Fulham
Mata - Chelsea
Carrick - Spurs
Alexis - Arsenal
Shaw - Southampton
Lukaku - Everton
Fellaini - Everton
Matic - Chelsea
Schneidelin - Southampton
Rooney - Everton
Van Persie - Arsenal
Zaha - Crystal Palace

Valencia - 2009

Smelling - 2010?

Carrick -2006?


[s]was Fulham playing top flight football during that time?[/s]

raumdeuter:


Whats the benchmark for significant appearance?

Don't worry because all your mentions passed the minimum requirements which is 5 apps

hardeycute:
Valencia - 2009

Smelling - 2010?

Carrick -2006?


[s]was Fulham playing top flight football during that time?[/s]

They are currently in Man Utd squad

Neuer that you mentioned was bought in 2011, Dante in 2011 Pizarro 2012and Mandzukic 2012

Kimmich was bought from division 2 also

raumdeuter:


They are currently in Man Utd squad

Neuer that you mentioned was bought in 2011, Dante in 2011 Pizarro 2012and Mandzukic 2012

Kimmich was bought from division 2 also

2012/2013 season + 5seasons =2017/2018

Dante and Manduckic arrived at the same time which is 2012 summer window

Neuer is still active

Kimmich from Stuttgart is 2nd division?Also Ulreich

hardeycute:
2012/2013 season + 5seasons =2017/2018

Dante and Manduckic arrived at the same time

Neuer is still active

Valencia Smalling are still active too

raumdeuter:


Valencia - Wigan
Young - Aston Villa
Jones - Blackburn
Smalling - Fulham
Mata - Chelsea
Carrick - Spurs
Alexis - Arsenal
Shaw - Southampton
Lukaku - Everton
Fellaini - Everton
Matic - Chelsea
Schneidelin - Southampton
Rooney - Everton
Van Persie - Arsenal
Zaha - Crystal Palace

hardeycute mentioned 14players (why you no add gotezka)
you mentioned 15players.

since you guys are not considering the cost it's a tie. you both mentioned 3 illegal players in your lists that didn't match the agreed parameters.

raumdeuter:


Valencia Smalling are still active too

I was aware of the fact and failed to remember 'active' here

@raumdeuter

Dayo, do you see why I said Sterling is not anywhere close to Sane in terms of quality? and more importantly, why Pep is going to hold strongly to Sane? I believe Sterling is having a magnificent season, however, most are blinded by the number of goals he has scored. I doubt he would have a better season than this.

Dayo what is Rooney doing on your list?

hardeycute:
Dayo what is Rooney doing on your list?

What is Gotze or Pizzaro doing on your list? Wasn't Rooney a Man Utd player in the past 5yrs

Roland17:
@raumdeuter

Dayo, do you see why I said Sterling is not anywhere close to Sane in terms of quality? and more importantly, why Pep is going to hold strongly to Sane? I believe Sterling is having a magnificent season, however, most are blinded by the number of goals he has scored. I doubt he would have a better season than this.

Who is better between Sane and Sterling is arguable. Sterling has the advantage of being a quota player and City will keep him to meet their quota moreover Sterling is improving and still young

Sterlings return is something many strikers would be proud of

The point I will take away from Sterling is that when people moan about players missing chances, Ronaldo Suarez Lewandoski Cavani top top players have missed such chances. Sterling with his sterling season still misses unbelievable chances

MoR2:
hardeycute mentioned 14players (why you no add gotezka)
you mentioned 15players.

since you guys are not considering the cost it's a tie. you both mentioned 3 illegal players in your lists that didn't match the agreed parameters.

What was the agreed parameters violatedand as at today Goretzka isnt a Bayern player. He will be in 6months time. In 6months time, We don't know how many EPL bought players would also be in Man Utd

You can remove Zaha pending the time he adds another Bayern player.

raumdeuter:


What is Gotze or Pizzaro doing on your list? Wasn't Rooney a Man Utd player in the past 5yrs

Pizzaro,Starke and Goetze fall in the 5yrs column same as Mandukic.

Rooney a man united player in the past 5yrs?

raumdeuter:


What is Gotze or Pizzaro doing on your list? Wasn't Rooney a Man Utd player in the past 5yrs

Pizzaro,Starke and Goetze fall in the 5yrs column same as Mandukic.

When was Rooney signed?

hardeycute:
Pizzaro,Starke and Goetze fall in the 5yrs column same as Mandukic.

When was Rooney signed?

Rooney played for Man Utd in the past 5yrs. Ok if you remove Rooney, Zaha still dey

So at this point you havent been able to prove that Bayern buys from their league more than Man utd does

raumdeuter:


What was the agreed parameters violatedand as at today Goretzka isnt a Bayern player. He will be in 6months time. In 6months time, We don't know how many EPL bought players would also be in Man Utd

You can remove Zaha pending the time he adds another Bayern player.

violated = players gotten beyond the last 5years