Welcome, Guest: Register On Nairaland / LOGIN! / Trending / Recent / New
Stats: 3,206,174 members, 7,994,994 topics. Date: Wednesday, 06 November 2024 at 06:44 AM

Ruling Concerning Post Burial Gathering Is Bidi'a In Islam - Islam for Muslims - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum / Nairaland / General / Religion / Islam for Muslims / Ruling Concerning Post Burial Gathering Is Bidi'a In Islam (5600 Views)

Types Of Wives At Ileya Family Gathering / What Is The Ruling Concerning A Husband Calling His Wife "Ummuh" ? / Ruling Concerning Congregational Prayer (2) (3) (4)

(1) (Reply) (Go Down)

Ruling Concerning Post Burial Gathering Is Bidi'a In Islam by Bimpe29: 7:18pm On Oct 31, 2018
SHEIKH IBN BAAZ RAHMUHULLAH WAS ASKED:

What is the ruling concerning what is known as al-ma`tim, in which people gather for three days after the burial in order to recite the Quran?

He Responded:

The gathering in the house of the deceased to eat, drink and recite the Qur'an is an innovation. Similarly, their getting together to pray for the person and make supplications for him are also innovations. There is no source for it. All that should be done is that, people come to pay condolences, pray for the person, ask for mercy for them, console their grieving and encourage them to be patient.

To gather for what they call al- ma'tim, to make particular supplications, particular prayers or reading of the Quran has no basis whatsoever. If that were a good act, our pious predecessors would have done it.

The Messenger of Allaah (p b u h) did not do it. When Jaafar ibn Abee Taalib, Abdullaah ibn Rawaaha and Zaid ibn Haaritha were killed at the Battle of Mu'tah and the Prophet (p b u h) received the news through revelation, the Prophet announced that to the Companions and told them their news. He supplicated for them and asked Allah to be pleased with them. He did not make a gathering, He did not prepare a meal or have a ma'tim. All of that he did not do even though the three who died were from the most virtuous of the Companions.

When Abu Bakr (r a) died, also no one made a ma'tim, even though he was the best of the Companions. When Umar (r a) was killed, no one made a ma'tim. The people did not gather to pray or read the Qur'aan for him.

Uthman and Ali (r a) were killed and the people did not gather after a specific time to pray for them, ask mercy for them or prepare food for them. It is, however, recommended for the relatives or neighbors of the deceased to prepare food for the deceased's family and to send that food to them. This is similar to what the Prophet (p b u h) did when the news of Jaafar's death came to him. He said to his family,

"Prepare food for the family of Jafar as something has occurred to them that is preoccupying them."'

The family of the deceased are preoccupied with their loss. To prepare food for them and send it to them is what is legal sanctioned. However, to add to their affliction and to put more responsibilities on their shoulders by making them prepare food for the people goes completely against the sunnah. In fact, it is an innovation.

Jareer ibn Abdullaah al-Bajali said, "We used to consider gathering with the family of the deceased and preparing food after the burial as a kind of lamentation." And lamentation is forbidden. This is to raise one's voice, while the deceased is punished in the grave due to the wailing over him. One must avoid such practices. However, there is no harm in crying in silence with tears.

Please when one dies and you come to condole do not stay longer than necessary .

May Allah give us the better understanding and ability to comply with the Islamic rulings Aameen.

8 Likes 3 Shares

Re: Ruling Concerning Post Burial Gathering Is Bidi'a In Islam by Nobody: 7:38pm On Oct 31, 2018
Jareer ibn Abdullaah al-Bajali said, "We used to consider gathering with the family of the deceased and preparing food after the burial as a kind of lamentation." And lamentation is forbidden.
forbidden?
Does that mean it’s haram ?
And whoever do such will be punished by Allah? shocked
Re: Ruling Concerning Post Burial Gathering Is Bidi'a In Islam by baysan(m): 3:19pm On Nov 01, 2018
Yes ooo you are right i don't think there a sin for it if practices.
Re: Ruling Concerning Post Burial Gathering Is Bidi'a In Islam by princeSammyz: 10:11am On Nov 09, 2018
I'm single too... And searching too. Please hook me up with here

1 Like

Re: Ruling Concerning Post Burial Gathering Is Bidi'a In Islam by FiftyFifty(m): 10:15am On Nov 09, 2018
JazakalLahu Khairan.

2 Likes

Re: Ruling Concerning Post Burial Gathering Is Bidi'a In Islam by kaycious: 10:16am On Nov 09, 2018
Jazakumllahu khairan, this is quite educating. may Almighty Allah guide us against innovative ideas that are not in line with sunah.
Re: Ruling Concerning Post Burial Gathering Is Bidi'a In Islam by developed: 10:16am On Nov 09, 2018
LET’S TRAIN YOU TO TAME 3D CHARACTER ANIMATIONS IN 3 WEEKS! WE WILL TRAIN YOU TO CREATE THE IMPOSSIBLE.

Imagine yourself creating emotive characters, stunning worlds and compelling stories for games, film or commercial projects? Get those cutting-edge, relevant skills that will allow you to enter an exciting creative industry that make you go from strength to strength in the world of 3D CHARACTER ANIMATION. Here’s a bit about the animation chops you can will learn from this training program

FEES: N35,000 - DISCOUNT FOR EARLY PAYMENT
N40,000 - PAYMENT ON TRAINING DAY

DATE: TUESDAY 20TH OF NOVEMBER, 2018

VENUE: ADDRESS OF OUR TRAINING CENTER ON OUR WEBSITE

REQUIRED: Just Your Laptop and passion for Creative Designs

ITEM 7: Daily Lunch meal of real Nigerian dishes for participants – CONFIRMED!

OUR FIRM GUARANTEE: At the end of this training, we guarantee that you would be able to design 3D CHARACTER ANIMATIONS!
We even offer the first training day FREE for those interested to come and taste the awesome practical 3D Animations training we offer. But if after the one day free training you would like to commence the full training, you will be paying the full payment of N40,000!
THIS IS A GUARANTEE AT THE END OF THE TRAINING

Re: Ruling Concerning Post Burial Gathering Is Bidi'a In Islam by rhajaan(m): 10:17am On Nov 09, 2018
3 days, 7 days, 40 days fidau are all forbidden...If you want to commiserate with the bereaved...visit immediately you hear...and if you can....assist them financially in meeting their needs...No matter how old a person is...we dont rejoice or celebrate their deaths...

And no gathering for prayers is allowed in such cases...
May Allah grant us Hikma and ilma

5 Likes

Re: Ruling Concerning Post Burial Gathering Is Bidi'a In Islam by TBerg01: 10:20am On Nov 09, 2018
baysan:
Yes ooo you are right i don't think there a sin for it if practices.
If something is forbidden in Islam, definitely there will be punishment if you crossed the line. we have all fallen victims of this in one way or the other. what is best to do after gaining more knowledge about something we have been doing wrongly is to seek Allah's forgiveness and never indulge in such practices again. Surely, Allah forgives all sins.

3 Likes

Re: Ruling Concerning Post Burial Gathering Is Bidi'a In Islam by Quality20(m): 10:21am On Nov 09, 2018
May Allah save us from these innovations. Many afas and malams make money through these innovations, hence the reason they keep quiet and not speak against them, but instead encourage and wish more ppl take to them

2 Likes

Re: Ruling Concerning Post Burial Gathering Is Bidi'a In Islam by doffman: 10:23am On Nov 09, 2018
Jazakallah khairan.

This is a good example... You present your case with unthentic backing ..

Kudos
Re: Ruling Concerning Post Burial Gathering Is Bidi'a In Islam by oyebolaidris: 10:27am On Nov 09, 2018
may Allah increase us in understanding. Amin

1 Like

Re: Ruling Concerning Post Burial Gathering Is Bidi'a In Islam by Nobody: 10:42am On Nov 09, 2018
4601CE:
forbidden? Does that mean it’s haram ? And whoever do such will be punished by Allah? shocked
innovations in Islam is haram. Innovators would be punished by ALlaah

2 Likes

Re: Ruling Concerning Post Burial Gathering Is Bidi'a In Islam by ismailajala: 10:53am On Nov 09, 2018
May ALLAH increase us in knowledge

1 Like

Re: Ruling Concerning Post Burial Gathering Is Bidi'a In Islam by sanusikebbe(m): 11:08am On Nov 09, 2018
May Allah (SWT) continue guiding us. Aamiin
Re: Ruling Concerning Post Burial Gathering Is Bidi'a In Islam by Bimpe29: 11:13am On Nov 09, 2018
FiftyFifty:
JazakalLahu Khairan.

Wa iyaka

1 Like

Re: Ruling Concerning Post Burial Gathering Is Bidi'a In Islam by Bimpe29: 11:14am On Nov 09, 2018
sanusikebbe:
May Allah (SWT) continue guiding us. Aamiin
Aameen
Re: Ruling Concerning Post Burial Gathering Is Bidi'a In Islam by Bimpe29: 11:15am On Nov 09, 2018
bamidelee:

innovations in Islam is haram. Innovators would be punished by ALlaah
That's it.
Re: Ruling Concerning Post Burial Gathering Is Bidi'a In Islam by Bimpe29: 11:15am On Nov 09, 2018
oyebolaidris:
may Allah increase us in understanding. Amin
Aameen
Re: Ruling Concerning Post Burial Gathering Is Bidi'a In Islam by Bimpe29: 11:15am On Nov 09, 2018
doffman:
Jazakallah khairan.

This is a good example... You present your case with unthentic backing ..

Kudos

Wa iyaka
Re: Ruling Concerning Post Burial Gathering Is Bidi'a In Islam by Bimpe29: 11:17am On Nov 09, 2018
That's the fitnah being faced now.
Quality20:
May Allah save us from these innovations. Many afas and malams make money through these innovations, hence the reason they keep quiet and not speak against them, but instead encourage and wish more ppl take to them
Re: Ruling Concerning Post Burial Gathering Is Bidi'a In Islam by Bimpe29: 11:18am On Nov 09, 2018
Well said.
TBerg01:

If something is forbidden in Islam, definitely there will be punishment if you crossed the line. we have all fallen victims of this in one way or the other. what is best to do after gaining more knowledge about something we have been doing wrongly is to seek Allah's forgiveness and never indulge in such practices again. Surely, Allah forgives all sins.
Re: Ruling Concerning Post Burial Gathering Is Bidi'a In Islam by Leiman100(m): 11:18am On Nov 09, 2018
Of all what you said you still contradict yourself by this
"All that should be done is that, people come to pay condolences, pray for the person, ask for mercy for them, console their grieving and encourage them to be patient." to say the prophet didn't do it is not enough prove to forbid any act, unless you present unequivocally where the prophet (pbuh) forbids it.
Re: Ruling Concerning Post Burial Gathering Is Bidi'a In Islam by Nobody: 11:28am On Nov 09, 2018
Leiman100:
Of all what you said you still contradict yourself by this
"All that should be done is that, people come to pay condolences, pray for the person, ask for mercy for them, console their grieving and encourage them to be patient." to say the prophet didn't do it is not enough prove to forbid any act, unless you present unequivocally where the prophet (pbuh) forbids it.


Islam is a culture. A complete way of life. In the prophet is the best example and all Muslims are enjoined to follow and adhere to it. When you can emulate the best example y doing the way round?

2 Likes

Re: Ruling Concerning Post Burial Gathering Is Bidi'a In Islam by mutvy: 1:13pm On Nov 09, 2018
So because Ibn Baaz ruled against gathering to pray for the dead ,we should not pray for them again?
Assuming we want to recite a whole Qur'an for the dead now that means only one person should do it.
I don't agree with Ibn Baaz.
Re: Ruling Concerning Post Burial Gathering Is Bidi'a In Islam by dragnet: 2:54pm On Nov 09, 2018
mutvy:
So because Ibn Baaz ruled against gathering to pray for the dead ,we should not pray for them again?
Assuming we want to recite a whole Qur'an for the dead now that means only one person should do it.
I don't agree with Ibn Baaz.
why must you recite quran for the dead?
who told you to do it?
is it part of the deeds that the prophet said can help the dead?

1 Like

Re: Ruling Concerning Post Burial Gathering Is Bidi'a In Islam by Empiree: 4:32pm On Nov 09, 2018
Please people,

The issue of reciting or not reciting Quran on the dead is not halal or Haram. Becareful when you Haram something that Allah and His messanger did not Haram.

Reciting Quran on the dead is a matter of iktilaf on the side of Rahma of Allah. Both sources of Islam are silent on it. Everyday, we actually recite Quran after the mention of Prophets and messangers, sohaba and dead scholars when we say "rodiyaAllah anihu" or "Rohumohu'Lahu". These are Quranic phrases.

Sheik bin Baz's opinion was in accordance with his school of Law. So leave your dead in the grave and not offer prayers for them just because in your imaginary world, prayers don't reach the dead.

If you can perform Hajj, zakat, Ramadan on behalf of the dead and they reach them, how dare someone says recitation of Quran can't reach them?. Quran is dua

Why do you say "rodiyaAllah anihu" after mention of sohaba?. Isn't rodiyaAllah anihu a Dua offered by Allah onto the Sahaba?.

Think people think.

(1) (Reply)

Allah Is Above His Throne And He Is Close To Us By His Knowledge / The Mutah Pimps / The Shia Versus Sunni Debates Are Getting Very Ridiculous

(Go Up)

Sections: politics (1) business autos (1) jobs (1) career education (1) romance computers phones travel sports fashion health
religion celebs tv-movies music-radio literature webmasters programming techmarket

Links: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10)

Nairaland - Copyright © 2005 - 2024 Oluwaseun Osewa. All rights reserved. See How To Advertise. 41
Disclaimer: Every Nairaland member is solely responsible for anything that he/she posts or uploads on Nairaland.