Welcome, Guest: Register On Nairaland / LOGIN! / Trending / Recent / NewStats: 3,221,745 members, 8,049,872 topics. Date: Saturday, 11 January 2025 at 07:19 AM |
Nairaland Forum / Nairaland / General / Religion / Why So Many Versions Of The Quran - Quranic Corrections (8508 Views)
See Una Useless Jesus Of Many Versions Here / Why Should The Bible Have Many Versions ? / Pastor Caught Tearing And Burning The Quran In Kogi (Photos) (2) (3) (4)
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (Reply) (Go Down)
Re: Why So Many Versions Of The Quran - Quranic Corrections by Empiree: 6:32pm On Jul 31, 2019 |
sagenaija:Deaf, dumb and blind. Quran is the only authority and hadith will forever be considered in as much it is in harmony with it. No difference here. 1 Like |
Re: Why So Many Versions Of The Quran - Quranic Corrections by sagenaija: 6:48pm On Jul 31, 2019 |
Empiree:Empiree, did you finish your primary school? |
Re: Why So Many Versions Of The Quran - Quranic Corrections by Empiree: 7:07pm On Jul 31, 2019 |
sagenaija:No, I dropped out |
Re: Why So Many Versions Of The Quran - Quranic Corrections by Empiree: 7:55pm On Jul 31, 2019 |
true2god: 3 Likes
|
Re: Why So Many Versions Of The Quran - Quranic Corrections by sagenaija: 8:38pm On Jul 31, 2019 |
Empiree:NO wonder! Look at your last post. Let me tell you why it belongs to class of those who drop out of primary school Christians DO NOT make the kind of claims Moslems make about the Koran with regards to their Bible. So, do you see why trying to use the same claim to evaluate both is as ridiculous as a primary school drop-out's reasoning? It is YOU MOSLEMS who claim that the Koran has remained the same in every respect from day one. When we now SHOW you guys that it's not so all you can do is post SCREENSHOT of Bible versions? Did any Christian ever tell you that we don't have the Bible in different versions? So what do you hope to achieve in posting a list of Bible versions? You don fall your people hand O, Empiree! The Koran has variant renditions. Islam will eventually diminish. Jesus said "I will build my church and the gates of hades shall not prevail over it " The choice is yours on which side you want to be. |
Re: Why So Many Versions Of The Quran - Quranic Corrections by sagenaija: 10:57pm On Jul 31, 2019 |
Quranic Corrections Ep. 5 - Inserting Allah into the Quran and Other Changes CIRA International Published on Jul 29, 2019 We continue in this episode with four examples of corrections taken from Dr Brubaker's book, entitled, 'Correction in Early Qur'an Manuscripts'. Example 2: This second example Dr Brubaker provides is an erasure from Surah 42:21 found in the Petropolitanus Manuscript, situated in Paris, France (BnF Arabe 328, fol. 58v.). Pictured in the book is the second of three instances where the word ‘Lahum’ (‘to them’ or ‘for them’) is used. Originally the phrase used the word ‘lahu’ (‘to him’ - singular) but was erased and then written over top with ‘lahum’, making it plural. So, while it used to say, ‘Or do they have associates who enacted for him’, it now says ‘Or do they have associates who enacted for them’. While both phrases are correct grammatically, it seems that the only reason this was changed was in order to make the existing text correspond to the 1924 Hafs text. Remember, this is the text chosen by Muhammad b. ‘Ali al-Husayni al-Haddad from Al Azhar university in Cairo as the standard for all of the high schools in the city of Cairo, so that they could have standardized answers to the exams on the Qur’an. This became so successful that in 1936 they made this ‘Hafs’ text the standard for all of Egypt, naming it the ‘Faruq edition’ to commemorate king Faruq who was crowned that year. In 1985, King Fahd, of Saudi Arabia, noticed how successful the Egyptian model was, and so decided to make the ‘Hafs’ text standard for all the world. So, the Qur’an we are using today, was first created by a student in Kufa in 796 AD, then became the standard in Cairo in 1924, and the standard for Egypt it 1936, and finally became standard for the whole world in 1985, just 34 years ago; proving that our current Qur’an is a very new creation. Example 3: Here we have examples of 9 different instances with insertions of the word ‘Allah’ (the word for god), inserted mostly in the Fustat Umayyad Codex. All of them were added either above the line, or within the text, squeezed between other words, and often written in a different ink, proving that they were all added at a later date, and by a different scribe. In every case the word ‘Allah’ was not really needed, but the fact that they were added, proves that the reason was to correspond with the 1924 ‘Hafs’ text. Example 4: In this example we find a definite erasure of a word in Surah 30:9, which Dan photographed in the Marcel 2 manuscript, located in the National Library of Russia (NLR), in St. Petersburg (folio 30v), where Dr Brubaker went personally to investigate and take the pictures. A later scribe erased the word but had nothing to replace it. The erasure is located between the words ‘aqibatu’ (‘the fate’) and ‘alladhina’ (‘of those’). The size of the erasure suggests a word with around 4-6 letters, and Dr Brubaker surmises that it could have been a number of possibilities, including ‘kullu min’ (‘all of’), or ‘kathiran min’ (‘most of’), or even ‘al-yahud’ (‘the Jews’), or possibly ‘al-nas’ (‘the people’). We’ll never know, since one cannot see what they have erased. We do know, however, that by erasing the word, the remaining text now corresponds to the 1924 ‘Hafs’ canonized text. Example 5: These corrections, five in total, are the same ones pictured on the cover of his book, and are found between Surah 6:91 – 6:97. They are located in the manuscript housed in the Museum of Islamic Art in Doha, Qatar (MS. 474.2003, fol. 9v). In the first correction the word ‘alayhi’ (‘against him’) has been written over an erasure in Q6:93, following the words ‘bima kuntum taqulun’ (for what you (pl.) used to say’). Yet, alayhi is not in the 1924 ‘Hafs’ text. With the second correction the words ‘ala allah’ (‘about Allah’) has been written out in the margin, but oddly without erasing the ‘alayhi’ (‘against him’) which it is intended to supplant. Either the later scribe was just inept, or he simply didn’t care that others saw the correction. In the third correction the word ‘alladhina’ (‘whom’) has been inserted where it was at first omitted. With the fourth correction the word ‘ya’lamun’ (‘they know’) has been written over an erasure. The shadow of the original text can still be seen and appears to be ‘BHMWN’, though we will never know. The fifth and final correction has not yet been studied by Dr Brubaker, though it is obvious that a later scribe has inserted a word which was not there originally. In every case we find that these corrections were intentional attempts by later scribes to standardize the existing text so that they would correspond with that which we have today, proving once again that the Qur’an was maintained, corrected and standardized by human hands. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IxQgyk7gqHY |
Re: Why So Many Versions Of The Quran - Quranic Corrections by Amujale(m): 11:42pm On Jul 31, 2019 |
The Quran is a fraud. Let the words sink into the condons of my mind and set me free. The Quran is a fraud. The Quaran is not what it claims to be, instead its a bibliography; a compilation of religious text from all accross the globe, the contents of which have been repackaged, plagerised, sexed-up or outrightly fabricated. |
Re: Why So Many Versions Of The Quran - Quranic Corrections by Amujale(m): 11:55pm On Jul 31, 2019 |
Similar to Eurocentric institutions, West Asian institutions peddle false history. African historians are able to conclude that all Abrahamic religious text are book of fiction that bears no relevance to real history. |
Re: Why So Many Versions Of The Quran - Quranic Corrections by Amujale(m): 11:57pm On Jul 31, 2019 |
All Abrahamic text are silent Weapons Of Mass Destruction. |
Re: Why So Many Versions Of The Quran - Quranic Corrections by Nobody: 1:16am On Aug 01, 2019 |
Amujale:You LIAR!! "You're WRONG!! You're a A RACIST!! You thrive on HATE!! You're joyful only where there's DIVISION!! You're SAD, you're BORED, and DEPRESSED!! SOUR LOSER, YOU'VE BEEN EXPOSED 1 Like |
Re: Why So Many Versions Of The Quran - Quranic Corrections by Nobody: 1:17am On Aug 01, 2019 |
Amujale: You LIAR!! "You're WRONG!! You're a A RACIST!! You thrive on HATE!! You're joyful only where there's DIVISION!! You're SAD, you're BORED, and DEPRESSED!! SOUR LOSER, YOU'VE BEEN EXPOSED 2 Likes |
Re: Why So Many Versions Of The Quran - Quranic Corrections by Nobody: 1:17am On Aug 01, 2019 |
Amujale: You LIAR!! "You're WRONG!! You're a A RACIST!! You thrive on HATE!! You're joyful only where there's DIVISION!! You're SAD, you're BORED, and DEPRESSED!! SOUR LOSER, YOU'VE BEEN EXPOSED 1 Like |
Re: Why So Many Versions Of The Quran - Quranic Corrections by Nobody: 1:20am On Aug 01, 2019 |
sagenaija: You've been successfully deceived bro: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fJYQaX5CntQ 1 Like 1 Share |
Re: Why So Many Versions Of The Quran - Quranic Corrections by sagenaija: 1:40pm On Aug 01, 2019 |
The Mysterious Letters in the Quran Apostate Prophet Published on Jul 31, 2019 Alif Lam Meem, no one knows what these letters mean. The Quran has numerous "openers", letter combination that interpreters of the Quran argued about for over 1000 years. But why is there such an inconclusive mystery in a book for humans? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GDYS1lM_T2A |
Re: Why So Many Versions Of The Quran - Quranic Corrections by Amujale(m): 9:09pm On Aug 01, 2019 |
PresterrJohnn: Jog a long you are a faker. Amujale: |
Re: Why So Many Versions Of The Quran - Quranic Corrections by Amujale(m): 9:30pm On Aug 01, 2019 |
Under what circumstance is it permitable for a bunch of unethical warmongers to be claiming to know anything about virtousness. Instead of the Arabians to concentrate on apologising to Africans for all the looting, stealing, so-called 'holy war', that are infact part of the evil Arabian crusades of their recent past; they're there peddling falsity and fakery. 2 Likes |
Re: Why So Many Versions Of The Quran - Quranic Corrections by Nobody: 9:38pm On Aug 01, 2019 |
sagenaija: Theriously!!?? Lol Having attempted to set you free from the trap, fraud, deception, and folly of Jay Smith and his minions (including Brubaker's); I would have expected that you would choose to be set free. Nay! You (on your own volition) scouted hard for the next available trap to fall into and then you did the "needful", Lol! But be rest assured that Jay Smith is not to blame no more for your error. And "alif-lam-mim"; etc. (as the Quran states) are not the crux, cornerstone, foundation, or salvation-theme of the book of guidance (i.e. the Quran). Clearly people can only engage in academic and intellectual guesses and speculations of what they signify. Only God knows with absolute certainty what they mean, and he only can bestow such knowledge on whomsoever he chooses among people. Just to give you something to respond to: God's eternal personal name according to the Judeo-Christian scripture and tradition is Y-H-W-H. Although there are a couple of informed guesses (such as "Yahweh", "Jehovah", etc.) today, as to how to articulate/pronounce this eternal name of God.. The reality, however, is that no one knows for certain how to articulate/pronounce this tetragrammaton (i.e. God's eternal name). The question, then, becomes one of why this God bothered to reveal this eternal name of his at all, knowing perfectly well that its actual pronunciation would later be lost, and his children would be left with guesses of his eternal name. 2 Likes 1 Share
|
Re: Why So Many Versions Of The Quran - Quranic Corrections by Nobody: 9:41pm On Aug 01, 2019 |
Amujale: You LIAR!! "You're WRONG!! You're a A RACIST!! You thrive on HATE!! You're joyful only where there's DIVISION!! You're SAD, you're BORED, and DEPRESSED!! SOUR LOSER, YOU'VE BEEN EXPOSED 1 Like |
Re: Why So Many Versions Of The Quran - Quranic Corrections by Nobody: 9:43pm On Aug 01, 2019 |
Amujale: You LIAR!! "You're WRONG!! You're a A RACIST!! You thrive on HATE!! You're joyful only where there's DIVISION!! You're SAD, you're BORED, and DEPRESSED!! SOUR LOSER, YOU'VE BEEN EXPOSED 1 Like |
Re: Why So Many Versions Of The Quran - Quranic Corrections by Amujale(m): 9:43pm On Aug 01, 2019 |
The Arabians are no different to Romans, they are influenced by one another. They peddle the same fake history. |
Re: Why So Many Versions Of The Quran - Quranic Corrections by Nobody: 9:45pm On Aug 01, 2019 |
Amujale: You LIAR!! "You're WRONG!! You're a A RACIST!! You thrive on HATE!! You're joyful only where there's DIVISION!! You're SAD, you're BORED, and DEPRESSED!! SOUR LOSER, YOU'VE BEEN EXPOSED 1 Like |
Re: Why So Many Versions Of The Quran - Quranic Corrections by Amujale(m): 10:07pm On Aug 01, 2019 |
PresterrJohnn: Jog along you're a faker. Most historians agree that Abrahamic religions are number one on the list of causes of global violence. African people have been in existence long before people starting living in Asia. |
Re: Why So Many Versions Of The Quran - Quranic Corrections by Nobody: 11:21pm On Aug 01, 2019 |
Amujale:You LIAR!! "You're WRONG!! You're a A RACIST!! You thrive on HATE!! You're joyful only where there's DIVISION!! You're SAD, you're BORED, and DEPRESSED!! SOUR LOSER, YOU'VE BEEN EXPOSED 1 Like |
Re: Why So Many Versions Of The Quran - Quranic Corrections by Empiree: 11:39pm On Aug 01, 2019 |
Amujale:this niggah here keeps getting angry at himself at all time let me console you small...kpele 2 Likes |
Re: Why So Many Versions Of The Quran - Quranic Corrections by Nobody: 7:54am On Aug 02, 2019 |
Empiree:In your mind Christianity is going down? Go to the north east and north central of Nigeria n see for yourself how Muslims are seeking Christ Jesus |
Re: Why So Many Versions Of The Quran - Quranic Corrections by sagenaija: 7:55am On Aug 02, 2019 |
Changes the Koran and Islam have Undergone Moslems claim PERFECT preservation of the Koran. That it has remained unchanged, even to a dot. When it is now shown that there are differing versions of the Koran the same apologists resort to all kinds of gimmicks to resolve the obvious problem with such a claim. These apologists cannot prove that all the versionsof the Koran available today are the same in every respect. They know that it is not so. Where you have differences involving: - Extra Words - Graphical/Basic Letter Differences - Diacritical Differences - Vowel Differences - Basmalah Difference then the claim that there has been no change does not hold water. It has been shown that there are up to five different Basmalah in Islamic history. So, there has been either modifications or varying adoptions of this singular item in Islam. |
Re: Why So Many Versions Of The Quran - Quranic Corrections by Nobody: 7:58am On Aug 02, 2019 |
Empiree:Qoran keeps conflicting itself |
Re: Why So Many Versions Of The Quran - Quranic Corrections by true2god: 8:37am On Aug 02, 2019 |
Empiree:He is saying nothing but the truth. Arab-muslims, using the quran and the hadith, invaded and destroyed Africa long before the imperial europeans came to africa. |
Re: Why So Many Versions Of The Quran - Quranic Corrections by Empiree: 11:17am On Aug 02, 2019 |
otuekong1:this one doesn't even know which is Qur'an and which is Hadith. Big waste of time 2 Likes 1 Share |
Re: Why So Many Versions Of The Quran - Quranic Corrections by Amujale(m): 10:11pm On Aug 02, 2019 |
All Abrahamic religious text are fake, false and counterintuitive. |
Re: Why So Many Versions Of The Quran - Quranic Corrections by Nobody: 11:56pm On Aug 02, 2019 |
Amujale: You LIAR!! "You're WRONG!! You're A RACIST!! You thrive on HATE!! You're joyful only where there's DIVISION!! You're SAD, you're BORED, and DEPRESSED!! SOUR LOSER, YOU'VE BEEN EXPOSED 2 Likes |
Re: Why So Many Versions Of The Quran - Quranic Corrections by Nobody: 12:12am On Aug 03, 2019 |
true2god: Did you mean: ... long before the grand slave masters came with their biblical destruction ?? 4 Likes 1 Share |
Dr Martin Luther King Jr The False Prophet God Spoke About Specifically / Interview Of Sheik Sani Haliru (boko Haram Member) Now A Christian / Bible Study On Nairaland - The New Testament
Viewing this topic: 1 guest(s)
(Go Up)
Sections: politics (1) business autos (1) jobs (1) career education (1) romance computers phones travel sports fashion health religion celebs tv-movies music-radio literature webmasters programming techmarket Links: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) Nairaland - Copyright © 2005 - 2025 Oluwaseun Osewa. All rights reserved. See How To Advertise. 95 |