Stats: 3,190,083 members, 7,939,382 topics. Date: Wednesday, 04 September 2024 at 01:44 AM |
Nairaland Forum / Nairaland / General / Religion / Can You Marry Someone Who Doesn't Believe In God? (17600 Views)
Poll: He/she is your ideal soulmate but doesn't believe in God. Can you marry him/her?Yes: 31% (31 votes)No: 69% (69 votes) This poll has ended |
Ese Walter Denounces Jesus, Says She No Longer Believes In God / Pope Francis To Atheists: You Dont Have To Believe In God To Go To Heaven / Can God Lead You To Marry Someone You Don't Love? (2) (3) (4)
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (Reply) (Go Down)
Re: Can You Marry Someone Who Doesn't Believe In God? by nferyn(m): 10:57am On Aug 20, 2006 |
chinani:Obviously it's a value judgement. Whether I'm more or less equiped that e.g. the pope to make such a judgement is really not relevant. I personally [/b]see far less value in the morality of people that act good [b]out of fear than in that of those that do so out of their own free will. You have to admit that there are a considerable number of theists that are steered by fear of the adverse consequences of sin. I don't know how many times I've heard Nigerians proclaim they are looking for a god[b]fearing [/b]partner to share their life with (and then settle for something not quite like thatThis freedom allows amore genuine besis for a humanistic morality, as it is not something absolute, instituted from above, but a personal choice.This is a value judgment. While I may agree with it, I don't think that you are more equipped than the Pope or Al haji to decide which peoples are more genuine. As long as one views his life meaningfully, isn't the source of meaning secondary? ![]() chinani:Still, hell is a central concept in Christian theology. Few Christians will claim not to believe in hell without separating them from their fellow Christians.Let me turn the argument around, what is the value of moral behaviour if it is borne out of fear for eternal damnation?I think the concept of hell has little moral value. I think it's primarily negative and antithetical to God. I don't believe in hell. chinani:I guess that's a classical example of observer bias and the influence of secundary cultural factors (as I pointed out in my reply to Nia). I would like to see some hard data to support that last assumptionNow, why would you assume that atheism would lead to a higher proportion of nihilistic or apathetic thinking than among theists? It might very well be possible that the exact opposite is true (Calvinistic determinism, End Times prophecies, etc)Well I did not assume. I interpret the views of atheists as nilhistic and sometimes apathetic. (Not all of them.) Your post made me realize that maybe this is a value judgment borne out of my subjectivity. This may be true but even when I try to be neutral that is my interpretation. Again, let me stress, I do not be all or most. . .a better way to think of it is greater than the percentage you'd find in a random sampling of the population and greater than the percentage you'd find in a sampling among believers alone. |
Re: Can You Marry Someone Who Doesn't Believe In God? by nferyn(m): 11:12am On Aug 20, 2006 |
Nia:Why do you assume that so many atheists think that anything goes? When there's no external, unquestionable basis for morality, there's room for rational situational ethics. There is a sound evolutionary basis for human altruism, even without divine commands.@Nia,I know. I actually wanted to include that in my post. That my background in a deeply religious society might have been at work when I perceive this people in their natural elements and everyday lives. Hmnn, I suspect that would prolly be the case for a while. I do like that Atheists tend to be more laid back and relaxed about many things, but i'm just not sure the belief that "anything goes" necessarily makes the world a better place (of course neither does the extreme opposite). I personally am a weak utilitarian humanist and I am every bit as moral as your average theist, definitely far more than the average Nia:That all depends on the source of their opinion of specific issues. If there is no rational basis for a specific moral position, I tend to discard it. An example: most theist objections against suicide are religious in nature and not really rational. In this specific case, I would say, as long as one hasn't made any lasting commitments like having children or marrying, one is free to decide what to do with his own life, even if it means terminating it. Nia:Happy to hear that ![]() |
Re: Can You Marry Someone Who Doesn't Believe In God? by chinani(f): 10:09pm On Aug 20, 2006 |
nferyn:My point of calling it a value judgment was not to put the pope of anyone else's value judgment above your own but rather to point out that no one substitute's anyone else's value for their own. So if you have your subjective view, based on your subjective values, how can you reach one, teach one? I don't disagree with you but I think your value judgment rife examples do not convince anyone who does disagree with you. nferyn:Well I always take the "Godfearing" thing with a grain of salt. Most of the Nigerian I know think in more than one language. If you ask, "Don't you mean such & such" They will say "Yes that's what I said". Anyhow, that comment I ignore. nferyn:I'll have to get back to you on this one. I think I have a counter point. . .I think. |
Re: Can You Marry Someone Who Doesn't Believe In God? by goodguy(m): 11:18pm On Aug 20, 2006 |
chinani:Jehova's Witness, eh? nferyn:This issue of 'godfearing' is quite controversial. As chinani implied, most people interprete it differently. I personally do not believe 'godfearing' or 'fear of God' means one has to tremble whenever anything 'God' is mentioned (as you have assumed, indirectly). Otherwise, it wouldn't have been stated in the Bible as 'The beginning of wisdom'. |
Re: Can You Marry Someone Who Doesn't Believe In God? by nferyn(m): 11:47pm On Aug 20, 2006 |
chinani:It wasn't really my intention to convince anyone, only to clarify my position. chinani:Don't feel offended, it wasn't the core of my argument anyway |
Re: Can You Marry Someone Who Doesn't Believe In God? by Nia: 7:03pm On Aug 21, 2006 |
nferyn:Nferyn, I stated earlier that I am only speaking from my experience. I don't know what percentage of atheist have that outlook on life, but my personal interactions with those have met have often left me with that impression. It's not that they lack the abilty to make logic based decisions about ethics or morality. But lack of belief in a deity does not stop you from being a human being with emotions and decisions made based on what they feel is right (with no reference to logic but on emotions) is what i'm reffering to. About your take on suicide, I'll have to say that that's a low requirement for something so permanent. At the least, I think it is best that something like suicide is not done as a permanent solution to a temporary problem and all other avenues have been thoroughly exhausted. |
Re: Can You Marry Someone Who Doesn't Believe In God? by nferyn(m): 7:49pm On Aug 21, 2006 |
Nia:I know, I was only adding this to make a point. Ultimately the decision is up to the individual who needs to decide whether or not his life is worth living. That person will probably take the feelings of others (e.g. parents) into consideration, but, as long as the person did not make any long term commitments to the well-being of others (like having children), the autonomy over his life lies only with him. What may seem like a weak reason for you or me can be strong enough for that person and we're not in a position to oppose that decision. |
Re: Can You Marry Someone Who Doesn't Believe In God? by angelchi2(f): 9:50am On Sep 14, 2006 |
[flash=200,200][/flash] The bible says marry only in the Lord,what that means is that you have to marry only those that share your believe,this will help to eliminate heartache in the home
|
Re: Can You Marry Someone Who Doesn't Believe In God? by Chiori(m): 7:35pm On Sep 14, 2006 |
Anyone who believes not in God cannot live under same roof with me. So the answer is 'NO'. |
Re: Can You Marry Someone Who Doesn't Believe In God? by Nobody: 4:12pm On Dec 10, 2006 |
Chiori: But the question says "who doesn't believe in God". |
Re: Can You Marry Someone Who Doesn't Believe In God? by ThoniaSlim(f): 9:05pm On Dec 10, 2006 |
NO NO AND NO ![]() |
Re: Can You Marry Someone Who Doesn't Believe In God? by goodguy(m): 10:07pm On Dec 10, 2006 |
Why no? Don't you think can influence the person's belief? |
Re: Can You Marry Someone Who Doesn't Believe In God? by ThoniaSlim(f): 11:04pm On Dec 11, 2006 |
i don't think so ![]() |
Re: Can You Marry Someone Who Doesn't Believe In God? by babe1(f): 12:21am On Dec 12, 2006 |
I will not marry such a person but thanks thanks though, I am happily married. |
Re: Can You Marry Someone Who Doesn't Believe In God? by CrazyMan(m): 8:54pm On Aug 18, 2007 |
I can't do that. |
Re: Can You Marry Someone Who Doesn't Believe In God? by Chiori(m): 9:44pm On Aug 18, 2007 |
thonia, i 've corrected the mistake. i meant to say 'who doesn't' |
Re: Can You Marry Someone Who Doesn't Believe In God? by cgift(m): 4:20pm On Sep 06, 2007 |
it ain't wotit |
Re: Can You Marry Someone Who Doesn't Believe In God? by geegee(f): 7:35pm On Sep 06, 2007 |
my dear, there nothing a woman wants more than a man with all these qulities you have listed christan or not what has your belief got to do with it or is god going to live with both of you? as for me i'll say yes, as long as you are a good husband and father the rest is histry. |
Re: Can You Marry Someone Who Doesn't Believe In God? by mishooo(m): 7:44pm On Sep 06, 2007 |
There's always an ANCHOR for every great SHIP. So, every relation[b]SHIP[/b] need an ANCHOR because of turbulent times - which will certainly come. If God aint your ANCHOR, then forget it - its not STRONG enough to HOLD you during crises. Meaning you cant have HEAVEN ON EARTH in your marriage. It doesnt matter if you are christian, muslim or traditionalist. At least you believe in the SOVEREIGN BEING. |
Re: Can You Marry Someone Who Doesn't Believe In God? by spikedcylinder: 8:11am On Sep 07, 2007 |
Why should I even marry an illusional person who believes in god? |
Re: Can You Marry Someone Who Doesn't Believe In God? by alexj(m): 10:43am On Sep 07, 2007 |
mashoo? why are you stressing the SHIP & ANCHOR? are you a saillor? |
Re: Can You Marry Someone Who Doesn't Believe In God? by yogun(f): 3:24pm On Sep 07, 2007 |
nope even some xtian denominations, i cant go near |
Re: Can You Marry Someone Who Doesn't Believe In God? by mishooo(m): 6:50pm On Sep 07, 2007 |
alexj: LOL ![]() ![]() ![]() |
Re: Can You Marry Someone Who Doesn't Believe In God? by ssRhino: 1:18am On Sep 08, 2007 |
nopeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee |
Re: Can You Marry Someone Who Doesn't Believe In God? by keeptalkin(m): 11:27pm On Nov 16, 2008 |
well since she thinks i believe in God because i pretend to she hasn't got a choice. When she finds out that i'm an atheist it will be too late |
Re: Can You Marry Someone Who Doesn't Believe In God? by wirinet(m): 11:36am On Nov 19, 2008 |
I am an atheist and my wife is a born again (redeem), and we have have three wonderful years of marriage with no problems what so ever. In the beginning here church could not understand why her husband do not follow her to church and she tries to explain my position. One day the head pastor came to my house to talk to me and i explain to him that the way i am made up do not allow me to accept things on faith, we had a long chat and in the end he understood that we cannot all see things the same way, and he has left me alone since. Even the assistant pastor has come to talk to me and we agreed to disagree. I just had my first child and the pastor is coming to perform the naming. So i do not see why people with different faiths cannot have a successful marriage if there is love, fidelity and mutual respect. |
Re: Can You Marry Someone Who Doesn't Believe In God? by meexteriox(m): 11:45am On Nov 19, 2008 |
The question is very clear: Can you marry someone who doesn't beleive in God? My answer is very clear: No, Never |
Re: Can You Marry Someone Who Doesn't Believe In God? by wirinet(m): 11:52am On Nov 19, 2008 |
I honestly do not think that the reason we have high divorce rate is due to differences in beliefs. Marriages of people from the same faith and church fail as much (if not more) than people from different faiths or belief systems. |
Re: Can You Marry Someone Who Doesn't Believe In God? by Chiori(m): 8:44pm On Jun 03, 2009 |
Impossican't |
Re: Can You Marry Someone Who Doesn't Believe In God? by Nobody: 6:13pm On Feb 03, 2010 |
No I can't. Because I am still striving to attain the point of holiness in my Christian race. Even though it seems impossible, the last thing I need is a setback from any avenue, including marriage. Sorry if my so-called "soul mate" is still galavanting in sin, your loss. The only good I can do for you is witness to you. If you like receive it, if you don't like abhor it, but as for marriage, rara o! |
Re: Can You Marry Someone Who Doesn't Believe In God? by Obelomo: 7:18pm On Feb 03, 2010 |
God Forbid! |
Re: Can You Marry Someone Who Doesn't Believe In God? by mabell: 9:50pm On Feb 03, 2010 |
NO! i wouldn't do that. what will be the faith of my children? i dare not think of converting him after i marry him cos it won't work moreover my faith in God wouldn't allow me do that rather it would allow me bring him to christ and probably help him grow if someone like that approaches me for marriage, what i owe him is to tell him about the one who loved him and died for him which is JESUS CHRIST! ![]() |
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (Reply)
Daddy Freeze: "I Have Prayed For An Enemy To Die Before, I Won’t Lie" / Are All Wordly Songs WrongTo Listen To? / Lagos Prostitutes: We Pay Tithes And Offerings To Enhance Our Business
(Go Up)
Sections: politics (1) business autos (1) jobs (1) career education (1) romance computers phones travel sports fashion health religion celebs tv-movies music-radio literature webmasters programming techmarket Links: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) Nairaland - Copyright © 2005 - 2024 Oluwaseun Osewa. All rights reserved. See How To Advertise. 61 |