Welcome, Guest: Register On Nairaland / LOGIN! / Trending / Recent / NewStats: 3,207,503 members, 7,999,250 topics. Date: Sunday, 10 November 2024 at 10:05 PM |
Nairaland Forum / Nairaland / General / Politics / Presidential Race Declaration: Gej Caught In Plagiarism (1654 Views)
GEJ Caught Again Bribing Pastors For 2015 / GEJ Caught Again Bribing Pastors For 2015 / Certificate Saga: Withdraw From Presidential Race, PDP Tells Buhari (2) (3) (4)
Presidential Race Declaration: Gej Caught In Plagiarism by Nobody: 1:06am On Sep 20, 2010 |
SaharaReporters, New York A day after President Goodluck Jonathan formally declared his bid for re-election, Saharareporters has discovered that a part of the speech he read at the official launch of his campaign was substantially lifted from a 2006 address given by former Vice President Abubakar Atiku when he announced his entry into the 2007 presidential election. Mr. Jonathan yesterday announced his presidential bid at Eagle Square, Abuja in a ceremony graced by crowds mobilized by state governors, featuring masquerades, musicians and half-naked men. In the 30-paragraph speech delivered with the aid of a teleprompter, amid loud cheers from his supporters, Jonathan said, “Our country is at the threshold of a new era; an era that beckons for a new kind of leadership; a leadership that is uncontaminated by the prejudices of the past; a leadership that is committed to change; a leadership that reinvents government, to solve the everyday problems that confront the average Nigerian.” The rhetoric resonated with the crowd, which cheered him on. The crowd was obviously unaware that the paragraph was a plagiarized version of an old speech by Atiku. The former vice president used similar phrases in a speech he read at the Old Parade Ground in Abuja on November 25, 2006. In paragraph nine of his four-year-old speech, Atiku declared: “Today, as we stand on the threshold of a new era Nigeria requires a new kind of leadership, a leadership committed to this change process. , http://www.saharareporters.com/news-page/presidential-race-declaration-jonathan-caught-plagiarism |
Re: Presidential Race Declaration: Gej Caught In Plagiarism by Alxmyr(m): 1:38am On Sep 20, 2010 |
Where did Atiku copy his speech from? I can bet my life that punk who does not know how to switch on a laptop is a dumb-ass. He can never write the speech credited to him. |
Re: Presidential Race Declaration: Gej Caught In Plagiarism by Beaf: 1:46am On Sep 20, 2010 |
There is so much jealousy over GEJ's beautiful speech! While GEJ spoke to the soul of the country, IBB's speech was like a malevolent odour; it was something like, "Nigerians will forgive June 12," "I did not kill Dele Giwa!" What a fcker! |
Re: Presidential Race Declaration: Gej Caught In Plagiarism by IbroYaya: 1:58am On Sep 20, 2010 |
All these people talking about Plagiarism. Do they know what Plagiarism is? Some people just want to talk. |
Re: Presidential Race Declaration: Gej Caught In Plagiarism by Nobody: 11:11am On Sep 20, 2010 |
If that was plagiarism without holding a paper and the lenght of the speech ---------THEN THAT GEJ MUST BE A FUCKING GENIUS |
Re: Presidential Race Declaration: Gej Caught In Plagiarism by Nobody: 11:28am On Sep 20, 2010 |
Ibro Yaya:Is plagiarism not the same thing as '' COPY and PASTE '' ? |
Re: Presidential Race Declaration: Gej Caught In Plagiarism by naso2(m): 11:29am On Sep 20, 2010 |
There is nothing that has never been said before all you have to do is to coin it you own way. This is simply a case of mere coincidence of thought within the confnes of permissible originality in academic writing. Obama, Clinton, Bush, Blair and other world leaders and their speechwriters frequently review several famous speeches and quotes for parallel incidences in design and delivery. |
Re: Presidential Race Declaration: Gej Caught In Plagiarism by roots: 1:11pm On Sep 20, 2010 |
The North Introduced it and GEJ is learning from, them. |
Re: Presidential Race Declaration: Gej Caught In Plagiarism by Solomon227(m): 1:53pm On Sep 20, 2010 |
janus05:Enough of allegations without proofs. How on Earth are these two statements "soooooooo close"? |
Re: Presidential Race Declaration: Gej Caught In Plagiarism by IbroYaya: 3:19pm On Sep 20, 2010 |
~Bluetooth:You see what am saying. Plagiarism Is Not COPY and PASTE my brother. Plagiarism is copy and paste without Citing You can Copy and paste any amount of words as far as it cited . Secondly it depends on the percentage of words that you directly lift without putting quotation mark. This was a speech that wasn't written but just spoken. How can GEJ cite something was not directly paraphrased or quoted. Those two statements are just coincidence I tell you. Look at the length of the statements and compare what they have in common. Well |
Re: Presidential Race Declaration: Gej Caught In Plagiarism by Nobody: 3:35pm On Sep 20, 2010 |
Ibro Yaya:if you look at both statement from a logical view,you will agree that the translation and interpretation looks similar irrespective of whether one is long or the other is short.the opening sentence are alike while jonathan's other part were further modified but still not from from the point in Atiku's word. |
Re: Presidential Race Declaration: Gej Caught In Plagiarism by slap1(m): 4:16pm On Sep 20, 2010 |
I believe plagiarism does not come into play; research does. When you get your text from different sources -- including your own effort -- it is called research. Plagiarism is more closer to regurgitation. |
Re: Presidential Race Declaration: Gej Caught In Plagiarism by Nobody: 4:26pm On Sep 20, 2010 |
slap1:What if research takes you into another person's work without getting the person's consent ? |
Re: Presidential Race Declaration: Gej Caught In Plagiarism by Solomon227(m): 4:28pm On Sep 20, 2010 |
SaharaReporters, New York The highlighted clauses are the only things 100% common to both speechs. I have googled the clauses to see how often they have been used b/4, these are my findings:
|
Re: Presidential Race Declaration: Gej Caught In Plagiarism by Solomon227(m): 4:50pm On Sep 20, 2010 |
SaharaReporters, New York “Our country is at [size=16pt]the threshold of a new era[/size]; an era that beckons for [size=16pt]a new kind of leadership[/size]; a leadership that is uncontaminated by the prejudices of the past; a leadership that is committed to change; a leadership that reinvents government, to solve the everyday problems that confront the average Nigerian.” The rhetoric resonated with the crowd, which cheered him on. The crowd was obviously unaware that the paragraph was a plagiarized version of an old speech by Atiku. The former vice president used similar phrases in a speech he read at the Old Parade Ground in Abuja on November 25, 2006. In paragraph nine of his four-year-old speech, Atiku declared: “Today, as we stand on [size=16pt]the threshold of a new era[/size] Nigeria requires [size=16pt]a new kind of leadership[/size], a leadership committed to this change process. The highlighted clauses are the only things 100% common to both speechs. I have googled the clauses to see how often they have been used b/4, these are my findings:
|
Re: Presidential Race Declaration: Gej Caught In Plagiarism by Solomon227(m): 4:57pm On Sep 20, 2010 |
Solomon227:
|
Re: Presidential Race Declaration: Gej Caught In Plagiarism by slap1(m): 5:31pm On Sep 20, 2010 |
~Bluetooth:We don't know for sure if Atiku was consulted or not. |
Re: Presidential Race Declaration: Gej Caught In Plagiarism by Nobody: 5:48pm On Sep 20, 2010 |
slap1:how does that sound to you;that the president consulted Atiku for copyright of his speech ? It doesn't make any sense. |
Re: Presidential Race Declaration: Gej Caught In Plagiarism by slap1(m): 6:36pm On Sep 20, 2010 |
~Bluetooth:I agree with you on this (I typed dat in a hurry coz I was listening to the testimony of a friend's dad who just came back from the kidnapper's den. Horrible tale!). @ Topic.To write a speech, research must lead you to previous speeches. Moreover, I think Sahara Reporters are just making a mounatin out of a mole hill. |
Re: Presidential Race Declaration: Gej Caught In Plagiarism by slap1(m): 6:41pm On Sep 20, 2010 |
And, please, what percentage of GEJ's speech was made up by 'Atiku's speech'? |
Re: Presidential Race Declaration: Gej Caught In Plagiarism by Beaf: 7:14pm On Sep 20, 2010 |
Can you guys imagine that dunce Atiku, attempting to big himself up that a PhD has copied his work? Another dream in vain! They really say, "anything can happen in 9ja;" thank God GEJ is here to change that crap. |
Re: Presidential Race Declaration: Gej Caught In Plagiarism by Nobody: 7:28pm On Sep 20, 2010 |
slap1: slap1:Words may mean nothing but the intention carries a lot of weight cuz it really looks like jonathan portrays what was ordinarily an Atiku idea. ''I HAVE A DREAM '' and '' YES WE CAN '' are four and three worded sentences which are synonymous with Martin and Obama respectively,so any modification of whatsoever to these sentences amounts to plagiarism irrespective of the percentage or weight of such new sentence. |
Re: Presidential Race Declaration: Gej Caught In Plagiarism by slap1(m): 8:13pm On Sep 20, 2010 |
If the sentences: " the threshold of a new era" and "a new kind of leadership" are the only 'guilty' words in GEJ's speech, don't you think it smacks of mischief-making for Sahara Reporters to accuse him of plagiarism? They should go get a life on the double! |
Re: Presidential Race Declaration: Gej Caught In Plagiarism by Nobody: 8:21pm On Sep 20, 2010 |
slap1:That is the evil of politics for you couple with the fact that Ibb has bought the souls of media executives. |
Re: Presidential Race Declaration: Gej Caught In Plagiarism by 13volts(m): 3:19pm On Apr 24, 2012 |
I just remember once upon a time GEJ copied from Atiku. |
Re: Presidential Race Declaration: Gej Caught In Plagiarism by Fhemmmy: 3:37pm On Apr 24, 2012 |
But i thought GEJ said, he will not seek re-election before the last election . . . What happened? |
Re: Presidential Race Declaration: Gej Caught In Plagiarism by egift(m): 5:54pm On Apr 24, 2012 |
13volts: I just remember once upon a time GEJ copied from Atiku. At least now we now know he got no skill set of his own - He has Fishery in BSc and Zoology in PhD, just imagine what you can do with that when leading 160 million people? |
Re: Presidential Race Declaration: Gej Caught In Plagiarism by Fhemmmy: 6:30pm On Apr 24, 2012 |
egift: Take am easy oh, Na person papa and husband oh |
Re: Presidential Race Declaration: Gej Caught In Plagiarism by egift(m): 7:08pm On Apr 24, 2012 |
Fhemmmy: But na lie? |
Re: Presidential Race Declaration: Gej Caught In Plagiarism by Fhemmmy: 8:19pm On Apr 24, 2012 |
egift: No be lie oh, My brother |
(1) (Reply)
Loss Of Voter's Registration Card in Abuja / Government Is Underestimating Boko Haram's Support-says Cpc National Secretary! / British Citizen Seeks Justice Against Nigeria Police Through Facebook
(Go Up)
Sections: politics (1) business autos (1) jobs (1) career education (1) romance computers phones travel sports fashion health religion celebs tv-movies music-radio literature webmasters programming techmarket Links: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) Nairaland - Copyright © 2005 - 2024 Oluwaseun Osewa. All rights reserved. See How To Advertise. 46 |