Stats: 3,190,136 members, 7,939,575 topics. Date: Wednesday, 04 September 2024 at 08:34 AM |
Nairaland Forum / Nairaland / General / Religion / Atheism Is 'Personal Rebellion 'Against God,Says Philosopher(a damning verdict) (1394 Views)
Atheism Is Frustrating. / Atheism Is A Religion: Kolooyinbo Explains. / Even Water Proves That Atheism Is False. (2) (3) (4)
Atheism Is 'Personal Rebellion 'Against God,Says Philosopher(a damning verdict) by Nobody: 10:09pm On Sep 28, 2011 |
James S Spiegel has an uncomfortable thesis to propose. He contends: Religious skepticism is, at bottom, a moral problem. A professor of philosophy and religion at Taylor University in Upland, Indiana, Spiegel has written a 130-page book, The Making of an Atheist, in response to the New Atheists. But unlike the numerous responses that have emerged from Christian apologists, Spiegel's book focuses on the moral-psychological roots of atheism. While atheists insist that their foundational reason for rejecting God is the problem of evil or the scientific irrelevance of the supernatural, the Christian philosopher says the argument is "only a ruse" or "a conceptual smoke screen to mask the real issue – personal rebellion". He admits that it could appear unseemly or offensive to suggest that a person's lack of belief in God is a form of rebellion. But he said in a recent interview with the Evangelical Philosophical Society that he was compelled to write the book because he is convinced that "it is a clear biblical truth". His goal in writing the book is neither to provoke people nor show that theism is more rational than atheism. Rather, his aim is to direct people to "the real explanation of atheism". "The rejection of God is a matter of will, not of intellect," he asserts. "Atheism is not the result of objective assessment of evidence, but of stubborn disobedience; it does not arise from the careful application of reason but from willful rebellion. Atheism is the suppression of truth by wickedness, the cognitive consequence of immorality. "In short, it is sin that is the mother or unbelief." God has made His existence plain from creation – from the unimaginable vastness of the universe to the complex micro-universe of individual cells, Spiegel notes. Human consciousness, moral truths, miraculous occurrences and fulfilled biblical prophecies are also evidence of the reality of God. But atheists reject that, or as Spiegel put it, "miss the divine import of any one of these aspects of God's creation" and to do so is "to flout reason itself". This suggests that other factors give rise to the denial of God, he notes. In other words, something other than the quest for truth drives the atheist. Drawing from Scripture, Spiegel says the atheist's problem is rebellion against the plain truth of God, as clearly revealed in nature. The rebellion is prompted by immorality, and immoral behaviour or sin corrupts cognition. The author explained to EPS, "There is a phenomenon that I call 'paradigm-induced blindness,' where a person's false worldview prevents them from seeing truths which would otherwise be obvious. Additionally, a person's sinful indulgences have a way of deadening their natural awareness of God or, as John Calvin calls it, the sensus divinitatis. And the more this innate sense of the divine is squelched, the more resistant a person will be to evidence for God." Spiegel, who converted to Christianity in 1980, has witnessed the pattern among several of his friends. Their path from Christianity to atheism involved: moral slippage (such as infidelity, resentment or unforgiveness); followed by withdrawal from contact with fellow believers; followed by growing doubts about their faith, accompanied by continued indulgence in the respective sin; and culminating in a conscious rejection of God. Examining the psychology of atheism, Spiegel cites Paul C Vitz who revealed a link between atheism and fatherlessness. "Human beings were made in God's image, and the father-child relationship mirrors that of humans as God's 'offspring'," Spiegel states. "We unconsciously (and often consciously, depending on one's worldview) conceive of God after the pattern of our earthly father. "However, when one's earthly father is defective, whether because of death, abandonment, or abuse, this necessarily impacts one's thinking about God." Some of the atheists whose fathers died include David Hume and Friedrich Nietzsche. Those with abusive or weak fathers include Thomas Hobbes, Voltaire and Sigmund Freud. Among the New Atheists, Daniel Dennett's father died when Dennett was five years old and Christopher Hitchens' father appears to have been very distant. Hitchens had confessed that he does not remember "a thing about him". As for Richard Dawkins and Sam Harris, there is very little information available regarding their relationships with their fathers. "It appears that the psychological fallout from a defective father must be combined with rebellion – a persistent immoral response of some sort, such as resentment, hatred, vanity, unforgiveness, or abject pride. And when that rebellion is deep or protracted enough, atheism results," Spiegel explains. In essence, "atheists ultimately choose not to believe in God," the author maintains, and "this choice does not occur in a psychological vacuum". "It is made in response to deep challenges to faith, such as defective fathers and perhaps other emotional or psychological trials," he states. "Nor is the choice made in a moral vacuum. Sin and its consequences also impact the will in significant ways. "These moral-psychological dynamics make it possible to deny the reality of the divine without any (or much) sense of incoherence in one's worldview." The Making of an Atheist: How Immorality Leads to Unbelief is out now. |
Re: Atheism Is 'Personal Rebellion 'Against God,Says Philosopher(a damning verdict) by joyuchesun: 10:27pm On Sep 28, 2011 |
@frosbel I ask you this not in a contentious way but truly out of curiosity. It appears that your intent in your posts is to show that belief in Jesus Christ is the way to salvation. That Atheism and Islam are false. I offer this to you. many on here that are atheists may fall moreso in the realm of agnostic meaning we don't know but the evidence points moreso to the non-existence of a God of the bible. unlike many of the Christians on this site who are closed minded and will never question their beliefs, atheists and agnostics are saying show me, prove it to me, and then I can know it is true. what a wonderful chance you have to prove it. But, the only answers we receive are it is a feeling, only the chosen or the elect will understand, we humans cannot understand God, questioning is rebelling, etc. Can you blame people for not believing? I once followed Christianity. And it was nice to think I could pray and there was a father in heaven listening. But as I began to question, and look at things objectively, it became clearer to me that this was just not true. The real rebellion is in ignoring the truth and following blindly. It is a rebellion against common sense, against oneself. My point is your article here has not shown anything. Many atheists and agnostics were once believers, some even christian fanatics. So, if you are able to show concretely that what you say is true, all atheists and agnostics will have nothing else to do but believe. But unfortunately, this level of evidence does not exist. Most likely because it is not true. I just wanted to share this. If you are going to respond with a snarky one liner, you can save it. |
Re: Atheism Is 'Personal Rebellion 'Against God,Says Philosopher(a damning verdict) by manmustwac(m): 10:44pm On Sep 28, 2011 |
Frosbel I read it all and its all nonsense. Don't you ever get tired? Or do you really believe deep down that you will e eventually manage to convert all athiests catholics and muslims to the religion that you were born and bred into? |
Re: Atheism Is 'Personal Rebellion 'Against God,Says Philosopher(a damning verdict) by thehomer: 10:49pm On Sep 28, 2011 |
frosbel: Wow. Its quite curious to see these sorts of materials released by these Christian philosophers. This is quite an incoherent article. |
Re: Atheism Is 'Personal Rebellion 'Against God,Says Philosopher(a damning verdict) by Nobody: 10:52pm On Sep 28, 2011 |
I concur with his beautifully laid out article !! |
(1) (Reply)
I Need Your Help! . : What Was Jesus Christ,s Life In Exile In Egypt? / John 3:8: What Does This Scripture Mean To You? / Whitney Houston: A Biblical Perspective On Addiction
(Go Up)
Sections: politics (1) business autos (1) jobs (1) career education (1) romance computers phones travel sports fashion health religion celebs tv-movies music-radio literature webmasters programming techmarket Links: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) Nairaland - Copyright © 2005 - 2024 Oluwaseun Osewa. All rights reserved. See How To Advertise. 35 |