Expert17:


So i should put Arsene Wenger's engine room (Viera) ahead of Fergie's engine room (Roy keane) ??

For now G.Neville is the no 1 at RB,....... ahead of Lee dixon then ivanovic.

No EPL best 11 without Paul scholes

Ogbeni, no need for all this shalaye. You're a Manchester United fan, your bias is expected.

That's why in a list like this I prefer to list Two or three credible players per position like afrodoc2 did.

Godx:

I was surprised the amount of people putting Keane over Vieira.

The only EPL trophy that Arsenal won over Manure in Keane's prime was in 2001. In 1998, Keane missed the whole season with injury.

Keane was a boss. They know him in Turin and SanSiro.

Unlimited22:
Lol. Manchester United fans will pick Schmeichel and Evra, and Chelsea fans will pick Cech and Cole.
Evra and Cole are debatable, very debatable, but here's why I think Cech just edges it.

I saw a post recently saying he faced 1250 shots or so, and conceded around 250 goals. Including his twilight years at Arsenal.
Holds the clean sheet record in the epl Era, both all time and in a season.

Conceded 15 Abi 19 goals in the entirety of one season in 2004/05.

Schmeichel is a beast, but based on these, Cech just edges it for me.

You should provide similar stats for Schmeichel. And then judge.

Ibime:


Scholes has never been a top 3 or sometimes top 5 player in his own team.

In mid 90s, Cantona, Giggs, Keane, Schmeichel were above him.

In late 90s, Keane, Beckham, Giggs, Yorke, Schmeichel were above him

In early 2000s, RVN, Giggs, Keane, Beckham were above him

Mid-late 2000s, Ronaldo, Giggs, Rooney, Vidic were above him.

You can't join EPL all-time 11, having not been the top 3 player for your team in any era.

All those players are not CENTRAL MIDFIELDERS...........that is what you face, if you play among stars

But he was among the 10 nominated for EPL player of the decade..........from 1992-2003.........

Also nominated among the 10 for EPL player best player from 1992-2013 (20 years anniversary)....

Leyqute:


You should provide similar stats for Schmeichel. And then judge.

You ignored the other criteria abi

Anyway the same post said he had the highest save percentage of keepers in the EPL era. I don't know how true, but it's up to you to disprove it.

Unlimited22:
Lol. Manchester United fans will pick Schmeichel and Evra, and Chelsea fans will pick Cech and Cole.
Evra and Cole are debatable, very debatable, but here's why I think Cech just edges it.

I saw a post recently saying he faced 1250 shots or so, and conceded around 250 goals. Including his twilight years at Arsenal.
Holds the clean sheet record in the epl Era, both all time and in a season.

Conceded 15 Abi 19 goals in the entirety of one season in 2004/05.

Schmeichel is a beast, but based on these, Cech just edges it for me.

Cech over Schmeicel

Unlimited22:

You ignored the other criteria abi

Anyway the same post said he had the highest save percentage of keepers in the EPL era. I don't know how true, but it's up to you to disprove it.

What I know of is his clean sheet record. I acknowledge that.

Expert17:


All those players are not CENTRAL MIDFIELDERS...........that is what you face, if you play among stars

Lampard, Keane, Vieira and Gerrard are central midfielders and have always been top 3 players in their team, if not the top player for many seasons.

There is no way you sneak a Scholes who has never been a top 3 or top 5 player in his own team into an EPL 11. It is only longevity that is counting for him cos there is an element of carry-along in his career if he was never one of the top go-to guys in his own team in 20 years of playing football.

Leyqute:


What I know of is his clean sheet record. I acknowledge that.

That's why I mentioned all three. However, I also acknowledge that a credible case can be made for both, just like it can for Ashley Cole and Evra.

Just like Vieira, Scholes, Lampard, Keane and Gerrard are all worthy of a mention in the CM position. The differences are very small.

Ibime:


Lampard, Keane, Vieira and Gerrard are central midfielders and have always been top 3 players in their team, if not the top player for many seasons.

There is no way you sneak a Scholes who has never been a top 3 or top 5 player in his own team into an EPL 11. It is only longevity that is counting for him cos there is an element of carry-along in his career if he was never one of the top go-to guys in his own team in 20 years of playing football.

What i know is that...............no EPL best 11 without Paul Scholes

Expert17:


What i know is that...............no EPL best 11 without Paul Scholes

For you oo

Expert17:


What i know is that...............no EPL best 11 without Paul Scholes

I Dan know this scholes dragging will end in tears, see as ibime embarrassed your legend.
Give a break you can't put scholes in best EPL 11 unless you want to remove Keane for him no problem.
Scholes should be in bench with Steven g

Leyqute:


What I know of is his clean sheet record. I acknowledge that.

Respeck...

Some other scummies would attribute it to the Chelsea defence then and Mourinho's defensive taktiks.

iamoyindamola:

I Dan know this scholes dragging will end in tears, see as ibime embarrassed your legend.
Give a break you can't put scholes in best EPL 11 unless you want to remove Keane for him no problem.
Scholes should be in bench with Steven g

EOD

iamoyindamola:

I Dan know this scholes dragging will end in tears, see as ibime embarrassed your legend.
Give a break you can't put scholes in best EPL 11 unless you want to remove Keane for him no problem.
Scholes should be in bench with Steven g

Go and remove scholes from EPL official team of the decade(1992-2003) and EPL all time best 11 ( 1992-2013)..

Just so painful that nobody is mentioning Hazard’s name despite spending 7yrs in the league.

thorrvik55:


Respeck...

Some other scummies would attribute it to the Chelsea defence then and Mourinho's defensive taktiks.

It also played a major role ............ remember wat happened at Arsenal

Ibime:


They should manage it like that. I can't leave out those guys just to add Man Utd version of Azpilicueta

Lol Neville must enter. Longevity gives him the edge.
So that na why you remove Cashley? How can your cut off your nose to spite your face?

Expert17:


What i know is that...............no EPL best 11 without Paul Scholes

What I know is that in Scholes prime, we only talk of Keane vs Vieira.

And after they left, we only talked of Lampard vs Gerrard

Scholes has always been a 3rd wheel in midfield and a 5th or 6th wheel in any Manure team in any era

He is deserving of a place on the bench. Top player, but he has neither the statistical records, nor status in his own team to help his argument.

afrodoc2:


Lol Neville must enter. Longevity gives him the edge.
So that na why you remove Cashley? How can your cut off your nose to spite your face?

I have to remove Cashley if I remove Neville

Also I can't leave out any of Vidic, Adams or Terry

odizeey:
In my opinion, Ronaldo has to be included. Not only did he win the world best, he also won the premier league best twice. How many did his contenders win?

God bless you. That was why i wanted to know who and who godx wanted to put in his epl11.

Ronaldo's best 3yrs for Man utd in epl, was more outstanding than Schole's 19yrs. If Ronaldo won't make it, 60% of names people dropped shouldn't make it.

Now i could see the likes of expert and afrodoc changing positions after your post, after they had called hardeycute names for defending Ronaldo. '2face' people.

Ibime:


What I know is that in Scholes prime, we only talk of Keane vs Vieira.

And after they left, we only talked of Lampard vs Gerrard

Scholes has always been a 3rd wheel in midfield and a 5th or 6th wheel in any Manure team in any era

He is deserving of a place on the bench. Top player, but he has neither the statistical records, nor status in his own team to help his argument.

To make it easy for you

Keane and Viera are defensive midfielders.

Lampard attacking midfielder

Scholes Central midfielder...... ( @45 years old, he will start at Chelsea right now) and please dnt make me pull out Scholes statistics and trophies

so no need to compare them.

Ibime:


I have to remove Cashley if I remove Neville

Also I can't leave out any of Vidic, Adams or Terry

Okay. But that team no balance at all. Abeg put jara. Nobody go accept Ronaldo for wingback. Try find solution to it.

Expert17:



To make it easy for you

Keane and Viera are defensive midfielders.

Lampard attacking midfielder

Scholes Central midfielder...... ( @45 years old, he will start at Chelsea right now)

so no need to compare them.

Vieira was not a defensive midfielder.

433
cech
ivanovic terry ferdinand evra
keane lampard scholes
ronaldo shearer thiery.
bench(aguero,vidic,ashley cole,giggs,schmeichel,vierra,D Bruyne,rooney) with a good coach,this team go kari league taya

Good morning my neighbors.

Expert17:


It also played a major role ............ remember wat happened at Arsenal

Most scummies are scums...

Nothing new

airmark:


God bless you. That was why i wanted to know who and who godx wanted to put in his epl11.

Ronaldo's best 3yrs for Man utd in epl, was more outstanding than Schole's 19yrs. If Ronaldo won't make it, 60% of names people dropped shouldn't make it.

Now i could see the likes of expert and afrodoc changing positions after your post, after they had called hardeycute names for defending Ronaldo. '2face' people.

I told you already if you can't name the Ronaldo exploits in the league that gives him a spot forget about it.

airmark:


God bless you. That was why i wanted to know who and who godx wanted to put in his epl11.

Ronaldo's best 3yrs for Man utd in epl, was more outstanding than Schole's 19yrs. If Ronaldo won't make it, 60% of names people dropped shouldn't make it.

Now i could see the likes of expert and afrodoc changing positions after your post, after they had called hardeycute names for defending Ronaldo. '2face' people.

You are an illiterate. I criticized him for saying Fergie played Ronaldo out of position.

In my own list of contenders which i posted earlier Ronaldo was on it.

Expert17:



To make it easy for you

Keane and Viera are defensive midfielders.

Lampard attacking midfielder

Scholes Central midfielder...... ( @45 years old, he will start at Chelsea right now) and please dnt make me pull out Scholes statistics and trophies

so no need to compare them.

Vieira was central midfielder oga.

Scholes was attacking midfielder for half his career

Expert17:



To make it easy for you

Keane and Viera are defensive midfielders.

Lampard attacking midfielder

Scholes Central midfielder...... ( @45 years old, he will start at Chelsea right now) and please dnt make me pull out Scholes statistics and trophies

so no need to compare them.

Lemme help u out..

Paul Scholes -> 55 Premier League assists after 19 years of PL footie at a top club

Ur welcome

If all you need is 2 and half season of playing good in England to be guaranteed a spot in an all time best Eleven then Salah and Suarez should be the first name on your teams.