Re: Chinua Achebe VS Wole Soyinka by Benwallt(m): 5:55am On Jun 10 |
Makavelli001: I think the comparision of Wole Soyinka and Chinua Achebe is mischievous at best.
There is no comparison really.
I like to think that what makes someone a SPECTACULAR writer is their ability to tell stories that finds a home in your heart.
I left secondary school MANY YEARS AGO, and I can tell you, that there are literatures I read back then, that I can still remember today... I can remember the dialogues... Incidents...Names... And even the pictures I created in my mind of what I think the writer was trying to portray.
I only read Wole Soyinka because I needed to pass my literature exams. I remember how we had to debate The Lion and the jewel in our literature class... Soyinka portrayed Africa like a helpless continent that needed western civilization to survive. I have never opened any of his books since after secondary school.
But I have read Things fall apart by Chinua Achebe more than 10 times. I have read The Concubine by Elechi Amadi more than 15 times.
I mean, from start to end.
I have replayed different scenarios and different endings in my head.
I have thought about A Things Fall Apart where Ikemefuna did not die... A concubine where Ihuoma's children didn't hunt lizards on the very day Ekwume came visiting...
These are memories that will remain with me forever because a writer dared intrude my subconscious and made a home there. . . . I will chose to read Efuru by Flora Nwapa over any of Woke Soyinka "finest works".
There are at least 10 African writers who I'll read first before I pick any Wole Soyinkas books, like; Ngugi wa Thiongo Cyprian Ekwensi Mongo Beti Buchi Emecheta Aye Kwei Armah Etc.
And No, my submission is NOT because of the politics of "ANYWHERE BELLE FACE' Wole Soyinka has subjected himself to, which has made him a nuisance/laughing stock right now, it's just how I have always felt about his works. I never connected to ANY of his books, I had to struggle to read, to relate, or even understand them and I have read over 200 books from African writers series alone.
Many Nigerians will easily remember Ikemefuna and Okonkwo more than they can remember any character in Wole Soyinka's books, this is because of RELATABILITY, a writer speaking to the reader in a familiar language.
Chinua Achebe is NIGERIA'S GREATEST LITERARY EXPORT to the world and there is a reason he is called THE GODFATHER OF AFRICAN LITERATURE...
I mean, THINGS FALL APART alone has been translated into 57 Languages!!!
It is not news that the reason why Achebe was snubbed for a Nobel Prize for literature was because he was too committed in his support of African culture and the oppressed, instead of using his platform to serve the interests of big powers in the west who were and are still our puppet masters.
Like the late Nelson Mandela once said; paraphrased, Achebe is the writer in whose company the prison walls fell down.
Achebe is THE GOAT. There is NO COMPARISON. Kapish? Woke soyinka is a literary eagle, his prowess is second to none while Achebe is a literary parrot that yap nonsense to get children attention. 7 Likes |
Re: Chinua Achebe VS Wole Soyinka by mrvitalis(m): 6:29am On Jun 10 |
EmperorCaesar:
Didn't Marie and Pierre Curie win the prize? How about Einstein? Tesla?
So whats your claim exactly
And how's Hawkings ahead of Tesla and Einstein?? Marie won for accidental discovery ooh Yes in the world of physics Hawkins is seen by some as higher than Einstein Telsa never won it |
Re: Chinua Achebe VS Wole Soyinka by Beebling: 6:45am On Jun 10 |
pharmagba:
Stop this childish nonsense The West hates this, the west hates that Yet they gave Nelson Mandela
You are the child here , so at your age you still don't know what Google is used for Chia . Let me school you cause i know you are an liitrate. When ever you read any post you are not sure of use Google You are a big disgrace to your family and tribe Shame on you |
Re: Chinua Achebe VS Wole Soyinka by seunowa(f): 6:46am On Jun 10 |
melow666:
To summarize, Achebe writes to tell a story, Soyinka writes with big grammer to showcase his dexterity of the English language and maybe win awards. I think you are getting it wrong somewhere especially in that direction you are always hammering on. Writing a book with complex English grammar is not the reason one is being given a Nobel prize. It also encompasses other genres of literature such as drama, poem, prose, playwright and others alike. I immensely appreciate both works. They are exceptional and distinctly different in the way their writings are projected to targeted audience. These targeted audience are different on the basis of their cognitive capacity. Soyinka wrote plays and acted in drama. He even directed many songs. It is not just about writing novels but embracing other genres. Those who sat on the committee of Nobel prize were not just random fellows but global intellectual icons in literature fields. 10 Likes |
Re: Chinua Achebe VS Wole Soyinka by Beebling: 7:01am On Jun 10 |
Donald7610:
Your bitterness gets grade Same way your ignorance has grade. A man that has destoryed many souls ,and also supporting this messup government that's the man you are clapping for Chia Sorry for you |
Re: Chinua Achebe VS Wole Soyinka by ObaOfBeninNahMu: 7:32am On Jun 10 |
Beebling:
Omoale that's your father's name You see why we don't support mad people giving birth? You are the reason |
Re: Chinua Achebe VS Wole Soyinka by ObaOfBeninNahMu: 7:33am On Jun 10 |
Stone03:
Na only 'mgbati mgbati' wide mouth you get. The OP has laid down convincing points, let's here yours of your cursed ideas I don't engage Osu 2 Likes |
Re: Chinua Achebe VS Wole Soyinka by melow666: 7:59am On Jun 10 |
Let's ask chat GPT, i believe it is neutral enough and has the objectivity to tackle this. |
Re: Chinua Achebe VS Wole Soyinka by melow666: 8:03am On Jun 10 |
seunowa:
I think you are getting it wrong somewhere especially in that direction you are always hammering on. Writing a book with complex English grammar is not the reason one is being given a Nobel prize. It also encompasses other genres of literature such as drama, poem, prose, playwright and others alike. I immensely appreciate both works. They are exceptional and distinctly different in the way their writings are projected to targeted audience. These targeted audience are different on the basis of their cognitive capacity. Soyinka wrote plays and acted in drama. He even directed many songs. It is not just about writing novels but embracing other genres. Those who sat on the committee of Nobel prize were not just random fellows but global intellectual icons in literature fields.
Achebe wrote poems and fictional and non-fiction work, he also was a radio presenter at one time in his career. The ability to raise from the dead, a once lost civilization, dead and misconstrued is why i would prefer him. A told an African story, the way it should be told. Well, i have my own bias and the non-extant Prof Soyinka with his recent politics and antics coupled with his indigestible work does not put him in my favor, thus i am not neutral nor objective, but i believe AI might provide some bit of objectivity and remove any inherent bias as it cannot have one. So let us ask Chat GPT then. Find attached. |
Re: Chinua Achebe VS Wole Soyinka by melow666: 8:08am On Jun 10 |
melow666: Let's ask chat GPT, i believe it is neutral enough and has the objectivity to tackle this. |
Re: Chinua Achebe VS Wole Soyinka by seunowa(f): 8:40am On Jun 10 |
melow666:
Achebe wrote poems and fictional and non-fiction work, he also was a radio presenter at one time in his career. The ability to raise from the dead, a once lost civilization, dead and misconstrued is why i would prefer him. A told an African story, the way it should be told.
Well, i have my own bias and the non-extant Prof Soyinka with his recent politics and antics coupled with his indigestible work does not put him in my favor, thus i am not neutral nor objective, but i believe AI might provide some bit of objectivity and remove any inherent bias as it cannot have one. So let us ask Chat GPT then. Find attached. Thanks for acknowledging that everyone has his or her bias towards both literature giants. Like I said in my earlier submission, those who were on the committee for the Nobel prize award were not random fellows but global intellectual icons. I appreciate your opinion...... 1 Like |
Re: Chinua Achebe VS Wole Soyinka by maestroferddi: 8:42am On Jun 10 |
KoshCAD: Keep quiet,
Talk about your so called Achebe.
Did he tick every boxes to win it and they did not give him.
The fact is Achebe does not worth being given nobel prize and that is final.
If it pains Una, you all can create your own in ala Igbo and go give him in his grave. And I thought I was debating someone with a minutiae of quality grey matter in their head without knowing that I have been wasting my energy on an Ojota motor park agbero who appears capable of stringing one or two disjointed words together to complete sentences.... Look at the trash you are putting up....even a palm wine tapper from your village could do better... 1 Like |
Re: Chinua Achebe VS Wole Soyinka by KoshCAD: 8:47am On Jun 10 |
Paystack:
Achebe and Soyinka no be mate my boy.
Soyinka only got recognition after the works of Achebe brought limelight to Africa
No be only limelight, it is lemondarkmess. |
Re: Chinua Achebe VS Wole Soyinka by KoshCAD: 8:51am On Jun 10 |
Qadaffi2idiamin: You talk too much...
Most of you from the are enjoying the dividends of Achebe's patriotism but you know not. Do you know what it means to be bitter?
You think because the white bearded cultist won a Nobel laureate makes him better than most African artists?
You are too young to point such finger at an accomplished man like Achebe.
All these nonsense would have been laid down if your grandfather Awolowo allowed the Eastern region to break away as agreed but he became an opportunist just to gain meager favour which has led your region no way.
Shut up if you don't know what to say! Mumu, go and tell EPL that Arsenal is better than city, so they should give them the title. |
Re: Chinua Achebe VS Wole Soyinka by maestroferddi: 8:52am On Jun 10 |
pharmagba:
Don't glory in error It was "Ake" that won him the Nobel laureate Stop carping arrant nonsense... How many intellectual journals or research work has referenced the Ake you are talking abot? Is Ake a notable literary work beyond its influence in the Yoruba domain? How many people in this forum have heard about Ake apart from Yorubas but someone has to be a visitor from Mars or some other outer planet to not have heard of Things Fall Apart... Get the context, ogbeni... 1 Like |
Re: Chinua Achebe VS Wole Soyinka by KoshCAD: 8:53am On Jun 10 |
Qadaffi2idiamin: You talk too much...
Most of you from the are enjoying the dividends of Achebe's patriotism but you know not. Do you know what it means to be bitter?
You think because the white bearded cultist won a Nobel laureate makes him better than most African artists?
You are too young to point such finger at an accomplished man like Achebe.
All these nonsense would have been laid down if your grandfather Awolowo allowed the Eastern region to break away as agreed but he became an opportunist just to gain meager favour which has led your region no way.
Shut up if you don't know what to say! A fool like you can never have sense. Go and exhume Azikwe and ask him why he went against secession clause that Awolowo proposed because of his greediness. 1 Like 1 Share |
Re: Chinua Achebe VS Wole Soyinka by maestroferddi: 8:57am On Jun 10 |
melow666:
Achebe wrote poems and fictional and non-fiction work, he also was a radio presenter at one time in his career. The ability to raise from the dead, a once lost civilization, dead and misconstrued is why i would prefer him. A told an African story, the way it should be told.
Well, i have my own bias and the non-extant Prof Soyinka with his recent politics and antics coupled with his indigestible work does not put him in my favor, thus i am not neutral nor objective, but i believe AI might provide some bit of objectivity and remove any inherent bias as it cannot have one. So let us ask Chat GPT then. Find attached. Big ups brother! This is how we engage and not blowing hot air to campaign for likes from people majorly driven by primordial sentiments.... Once again, big ups... |
Re: Chinua Achebe VS Wole Soyinka by Afamsi: 9:08am On Jun 10 |
KoshCAD: Mumu, master of known but won the greatest award.
Wetin your so called master in story telling win? Goat, nobel prize is not the true measure of greatness because it is subject to sentiments. It is not everybody that earned it. Soyinka is a boy to Chinua Achebe. Deal with it |
Re: Chinua Achebe VS Wole Soyinka by sweetrace(f): 9:56am On Jun 10 |
BlowYourMind: Chinua Achebe died miserable, full of confusion and anguish, he was attacking wole Soyinka and yorubas because he could reach the height WS got to, what a life, that is the same thing that happened to the bitter grieving obi, he too is on bitterness and anguish on rampage and his people with them, Achebe full of wrath and depression thought he deserved the prize Wole Soyinka got with his mediocrity and bitter grieving obi thought he deserved presidency by causing mayhem and chaos, no mediocre can go through the backdoor to get anything. God bless Wole Soyinka the nemesis of bitter grieving obi. |
Re: Chinua Achebe VS Wole Soyinka by Antivirus92(m): 10:15am On Jun 10 |
KoshCAD: Lol, he's unpopular,
It is your father that is popular.
Why are we not talking about your father and his work today? Abi he's not man like Soyinka? we are talking about Achebe and Soyinka, stick to the topic. |
Re: Chinua Achebe VS Wole Soyinka by hafeeanubasy: 10:20am On Jun 10 |
kettykin:
How many of these sold upto 100,000 copies outside the shores of Nigeria. Most of these are short poems and drama and not novels . It is novels that rule the world of literature and not poems.nibhave friends and relatives that have written more poems than this. In this artificial intelligence age , I can surpass this poems and plays in 24 hours Is it commerce or substances? So zaazu is a better son than Agba baller because he had more commercial success? |
Re: Chinua Achebe VS Wole Soyinka by whippersnapper(m): 10:40am On Jun 10 |
Soyinka was not even better than okigbo to begin with 1 Like 1 Share |
Re: Chinua Achebe VS Wole Soyinka by whippersnapper(m): 11:14am On Jun 10 |
raskymonojendor: Even the prolific writer, Chimamanda, gave Soyinka the flowers. She knows no one comes close to Prof Soyinka in literature in Nigeria. Soyinka's works are advanced university level stuff for brilliant minds. Similar to the likes of advanced stuff from einstein and other Nobel laureate. Low IQ people find them hard to understand.
The only book I read of Achebe was Chike and the river in primary school where he portrayed Ibo people as lowly people that needed Lagos to survive. but how comes i finished ABU Zaria read literature I never read any Soyinka work 1 Like |
Re: Chinua Achebe VS Wole Soyinka by Raf4: 4:42pm On Jun 10 |
gistray:
It is Soyinka who was bitter.
He held more than 100 interviews trying to demarket Achebe after taking Cannabis. That's a statement of facts. Was Achebe father of African literature? |
Re: Chinua Achebe VS Wole Soyinka by Raf4: 4:58pm On Jun 10 |
Paystack:
They gave it to him with a white man by his side my boy.
To tell you the award 🥇 is shyte
That award was created by one individual Alfred Nobel who didn't know what to do with his ill gotten wealth
Envy has totally devoured your weak and bitter soul. |
Re: Chinua Achebe VS Wole Soyinka by Putinofrussia: 6:13pm On Jun 10 |
The defining qualities for the Nobel are high intentions, intelligent and brilliant execution, and seriousness about mankind and our ideals and situation.
A lot of bestsellers don’t make the grade. It’s not because they are popular. It’s because you got them at McDonald’s. It’s not McPoisonous, because it’s made to a certain McStandard of hygiene, but it’s not wonderful.
Don’t try to call it gourmet dining. Embrace the fundamental tackiness and enjoy it, but don’t demand elevation to the pantheon of honour in modern literature. These books were not written with serious literary intentions.
They were written with a goal to entertain, often to entertain within the confines of some genre, and even when they are intelligently told, it is not the job of such writers to think below the surface of their material. 2 Likes |
Re: Chinua Achebe VS Wole Soyinka by Makavelli001: 4:36am On Jun 11 |
Soyinka got the Nobel award because Awolowo was the finance minister. He used state money to buy the award for him. Chikina! |
Re: Chinua Achebe VS Wole Soyinka by confusedlady(f): 6:06am On Jun 11 |
Putinofrussia: Achebe was just a mere story teller. Soyinka is more of a genius. This is Soyinka's showcase: Plays
Keffi's Birthday Treat (1954) The Invention (1957) The Swamp Dwellers (1958) A Quality of Violence (1959)[134] The Lion and the Jewel (1959) The Trials of Brother Jero (1960) A Dance of the Forests (1960) My Father's Burden (1960) The Strong Breed (1964) Before the Blackout (1964) Kongi's Harvest (1964) The Road (1965) Madmen and Specialists (1970) The Bacchae of Euripides (1973) Camwood on the Leaves (1973) Jero's Metamorphosis (1973) Death and the King's Horseman (1975) Opera Wonyosi (1977) Requiem for a Futurologist (1983) A Play of Giants (1984) Childe Internationale (1987)[135][136] From Zia with Love (1992) The Detainee (radio play) A Scourge of Hyacinths (radio play) The Beatification of the Area Boy (1996) Document of Identity (radio play, 1999) King Baabu (2001) Etiki Revu Wetin Alapata Apata (2011) "Thus Spake Orunmila" (in Sixty-Six Books (2011)
Novels
The Interpreters (1965) Season of Anomy (1973) Chronicles from the Land of the Happiest People on Earth (Bookcraft, Nigeria; Bloomsbury, UK; Pantheon, US, 2021)[138][139] Harmattan Haze on an African Spring Short stories
A Tale of Two (1958) Egbe's Sworn Enemy (1960) Madame Etienne's Establishment (1960) Memoirs
The Man Died: Prison Notes (1972) Aké: The Years of Childhood (1981) Ibadan: The Penkelemes Years: a memoir 1945–1965 (1989) Ìsarà : A Voyage around Essay (1989) You Must Set Forth at Dawn (2006) Climate of Fear (Literature) (2005) Poetry collections
Telephone Conversation (1963) (appeared in Modern Poetry in Africa) Idanre and other poems (1967) A Big Airplane Crashed into The Earth (original title Poems from Prison) (1969) A Shuttle in the Crypt (1971) Ogun Abibiman (1976) Mandela's Earth and other poems (1988) Early Poems (1997) Samarkand and Other Markets I Have Known (2002) Essays
"Towards a True Theater" (1962) Culture in Transition (1963) Neo-Tarzanism: The Poetics of Pseudo-Transition A Voice That Would Not Be Silenced Art, Dialogue, and Outrage: Essays on Literature and Culture (1988) From Drama and the African World View (1976) Myth, Literature, and the African World (1976) The Blackman and the Veil (1990)[141] The Credo of Being and Nothingness (1991) The Burden of Memory – The Muse of Forgiveness (1999) A Climate of Fear (the BBC Reith Lectures 2004, audio and transcripts) New Imperialism (2009) Of Africa (2012)[143] Beyond Aesthetics: Use, Abuse, and Dissonance in African Art Traditions (2019)
Films
Kongi's Harvest Culture in Transition Blues for a Prodigal Translations
The Forest of a Thousand Demons: A Hunter's Saga (1968; a translation of D. O. Fagunwa's Ã’gbójú Ọdẹ nÃnú Igbó Irúnmalẹ̀) In the Forest of Olodumare (2010; a translation of D. O. Fagunwa's Igbo Olodumare) ..
How someone can ever compare Achebe to Soyinka beats me hollow.... In fact no proper student of literature can ever do this because Soyinka transcends all genre of literature while Achebe is grossly limited in his range. Soyinka writes prose,poetry and drama. Achebe is limited to prose and a few poems.... In fact while Soyinka was at the University as a lecturer,his books were being used as basis for awarding doctorate degrees to professors. Achebe is a good prose writer but Soyimka writes prose,poetry and drama. This is a no brainer. There is just no basis for comparism. 4 Likes |
Re: Chinua Achebe VS Wole Soyinka by Beebling: 10:45pm On Jun 11 |
ObaOfBeninNahMu:
You see why we don't support mad people giving birth? You are the reason
Oh you mean your father is mad , thank you for telling me |
Re: Chinua Achebe VS Wole Soyinka by ObaOfBeninNahMu: 7:38am On Jun 12 |
Beebling:
Oh how do know my father is mad ? thank you for telling me |
Re: Chinua Achebe VS Wole Soyinka by melow666: 5:13pm On Jun 12 |
confusedlady:
How someone can ever compare Achebe to Soyinka beats me hollow.... In fact no proper student of literature can ever do this because Soyinka transcends all genre of literature while Achebe is grossly limited in his range.
Soyinka writes prose,poetry and drama.
Achebe is limited to prose and a few poems....
In fact while Soyinka was at the University as a lecturer,his books were being used as basis for awarding doctorate degrees to professors.
Achebe is a good prose writer but Soyimka writes prose,poetry and drama. This is a no brainer. There is just no basis for comparism. So a generalist makes a better writer not content. I guess, if tomorrow I writes poems, prose, novellas and dramas It might be said that I am a better writer than Soyinka. We are talking about content not versatility. |
Re: Chinua Achebe VS Wole Soyinka by melow666: 5:16pm On Jun 12 |
Raf4:
That's a statement of facts. Was Achebe father of African literature? Basically, if you do a Google search without putting achebe or soyinkas name, and ask Google the father of African literature, Google brings up achebe and Wikipedia brings up achebe. Soyinka is not comparable to achebe when it comes to writing. The only reason he won the Nobel prize is activism. |