Welcome, Guest: Register On Nairaland / LOGIN! / Trending / Recent / New
Stats: 3,173,170 members, 7,887,404 topics. Date: Friday, 12 July 2024 at 08:28 AM

The Hajj Stampede - A Fluid Dynamics Problem - Religion - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum / Nairaland / General / Religion / The Hajj Stampede - A Fluid Dynamics Problem (972 Views)

Hajj Stampede: “he Stoned Them Back To Death” – Nigerian Transgender Blames God / Nigerian Hajj Stampede Victim In Critical Condition At Saudi Hospital [photo] / Bilikisu-Yusuf, Nigerian Journalist Dies In The Hajj Stampede (2) (3) (4)

(1) (Reply) (Go Down)

The Hajj Stampede - A Fluid Dynamics Problem by llaykorn: 7:07am On Sep 26, 2015
MECCA IS THE holiest city in Islam, the storied site of key locations from the Quran and, once a year, center of the hajj, a sacred pilgrimage that brings upwards of 3 million people to Saudi Arabia from all over the world. This week Mecca was also the site of a tragedy—nearly 800 people killed in a stampede in Mina, the semi-permanent tent city that houses tens of thousands of pilgrims. It wasn’t the first time something like this has happened during the hajj, and just as before, the causes remain the same: physics and evolutionary psychology.

This isn’t a new problem. One of the first documented human stampedes happened in 1896, at the coronation of Tsar Nicholas II outside Moscow; 1,000 people died after rumors spread that the concession stands were running out of souvenirs. They’ve happened at mass religious gatherings in India, football games in Europe, rock concerts in the US. One epidemiological study found 215 stampede events between 1980 and 2007.

The hajj, site of Thursday’s tragedy, has for decades been particularly deadly. As the numbers of pilgrims have risen, so too have the mass casualty events. In the 100 years before 2009, five of the 10 deadliest human stampede events happened in the Mina Valley.

After one in 2006, Saudi authorities instituted single-direction pathways, visitor counts, and theme park-like scheduling of visits. The Jamarat Bridge, location of three pillars that represent the devil, at which pilgrims are supposed to throw stones, was the site of a stampede that killed over 1,000 people; today it’s a multi-level, multi-exit complex designed to keep people moving. In the past decade or so, the Saudi government has worked with a wide variety of architects and designers, including the famed international firm Gensler, to improve flow and safety at all of the hajj’s major sites, from the central mosque to the tent city.

Put that many people in so confined a space, though, and preventing stampedes will always be a challenge. Part of the problem is fluid dynamics—except people are the fluid.

Panic Mode:

The problem starts with either a “craze,” in which people are all trying to get to a destination, or “escape panic,” in which they’re all trying to get away. In both cases, movement is unidirectional, as in, everyone is trying to move in the same direction. Unidirectional flows typically aren’t much of a problem until they encounter an obstacle—a narrow door, let’s say, or a tight turn.

The other option, “turbulent,” is when people are trying to get to a bunch of different places at once, or when crowds moving in two different directions collide. Reports from Mina suggest that’s what happened here—crowds were moving along two different streets in the tent city and ran into each other at a bottlenecked intersection.


Both modes can be deadly under stampede conditions. Six to seven people pushing continuously in a single direction have, in some cases, exerted enough force to bend steel railings. Researchers have hypothesized that during turbulent stampedes the forces are actually lower, because the multiple vectors—which is to say, people pushing in all different directions—cancel each other out.

On the other hand, if all those vectors are pushing inward … well, cause of death in stampedes tends to be either crush trauma from being trampled or asphyxiation. Autopsies of people who suffocated in stampedes show pressures as high as 6.4 psi exerted on the chest—that’s nearly half an atmosphere. Some people have died where they stood, trapped against other people until the pressure released. It’s a bad, bad way to go.

“Densities get so high that there’s just one body next to each other, and any little movement creates a force exerted on adjacent bodies,” says Dirk Helbing, a computational social scientist who studies crowd dynamics at ETH Zurich. (Helbing was involved in early work on the Jamarat Bridge, but hasn’t been directly involved with Mecca for years.) “You’re exposed to this random pushing. As a result you might lose your balance and fall to the ground, and what happens is a hole opens up in the crowd. Those standing around it lack counterforce, and they fall on top of the person.”

That event then propagates outward, though not evenly in every direction. According to Helbing’s model, pedestrians are essentially just trying to avoid obstacles—including other pedestrians—while making their way to a given destination as quickly as possible. At low densities, which is to say no crowds, you get laminar flow, as smooth as a flat-bottomed, fast moving river.

As density goes up, the number of times an individual pedestrian has to slow down or stop outright goes up, too—which forces all the pedestrians trying to get around that person to do the same. Stop-and-go waves start to propagate outward from each choke point.

Pretty soon all the slick avoidance moves everyone has been making switch to unintentional ones. The classic coordinated moves that crowd dynamics researchers recognize from sidewalks, like spontaneous organization into directional lanes and platooning according to walking speed, break down. Order flips to chaos. That’s turbulence.


The critical density for when a crowd goes critical varies according to average body size and weight of the people involved, Helbing says, but it’s usually somewhere between five and 10 people per square meter.

Social Animals:

But why are people so vulnerable to catastrophe when crowds get thick enough? Other creatures, from anchovies to slime molds to starlings, manage to pull off dazzling feats of coordination when they’re crowded together. In fact many of those collectives share similar mathematical characteristics, says Iain Couzin, a biologist at Princeton who studies collective behavior.

“When we see a coordinated bird flock or fish school, these things have evolved to do this,” Couzin says. “Unfortunately, we have not. We’ve evolved to be in small family groups.”

More and more, human beings live in crowded cities. But the human brain may not have quite caught up to what it built. “We don’t know how to behave in these scenarios,” Couzin says. “These situations do not allow us to naturally feel that we can understand what’s going on.”

That’s not to say that under certain circumstances human beings won’t engage in classic collective behavior. People do—they follow leaders, for example, or make any of those classic pedestrian moves that Helbing studies. But the kinds of sets of small, simple rules that lead to spontaneously self-organized flocking just don’t kick in. “Not all the time, but most often it’s about the spread of panic, not an actually dangerous environment,” Couzin says. “The response creates the danger. The strong collective response is a very dangerous thing in certain circumstances.”

That’s the lesson the organizers of the hajj have been trying to unpack. This week they learned they hadn’t—and that they have to keep trying.

http://www.wired.com/2015/09/hajj-stampede-fluid-dynamics-problem/

1 Like

Re: The Hajj Stampede - A Fluid Dynamics Problem by munchfani: 7:09am On Sep 26, 2015
.
Re: The Hajj Stampede - A Fluid Dynamics Problem by llaykorn: 7:15am On Sep 26, 2015
Cc:

Empiree
Rilwayne001
AllNaijaBlogger
Lalasticlala
dominique
leunamme93
Re: The Hajj Stampede - A Fluid Dynamics Problem by AllNaijaBlogger(m): 7:24am On Sep 26, 2015
I find this to be ridiculous.

Stop using scientific excuses to cover up the failings of the Saudi government.

What we need is an investigation and solutions on how to avoid this tragedy next year and the other years to come.
Re: The Hajj Stampede - A Fluid Dynamics Problem by llaykorn: 7:35am On Sep 26, 2015
AllNaijaBlogger:
I find this to be ridiculous.

Stop using scientific excuses to cover up the failings of the Saudi government.

What we need is an investigation and solutions on how to avoid this tragedy next year and the other years to come.




Shhhh! Read what you wrote again. undecided cheesy
Re: The Hajj Stampede - A Fluid Dynamics Problem by AllNaijaBlogger(m): 7:49am On Sep 26, 2015
llaykorn:



Shhhh! Read what you wrote again. undecided cheesy


Maybe you should look at the sentences you bolded in the article. Seems like a pro-Saudi government bias is inherent.
Re: The Hajj Stampede - A Fluid Dynamics Problem by llaykorn: 8:24am On Sep 26, 2015
AllNaijaBlogger:



Maybe you should look at the sentences you bolded in the article. Seems like a pro-Saudi government bias is inherent.

If your inherence of a pro-Saudi bias is recognized by my highlight of the cause of catastrophe and the prior efforts of the Saudi government in having it prevented, then, yes it is. smiley
Re: The Hajj Stampede - A Fluid Dynamics Problem by Empiree: 11:37am On Sep 26, 2015
Time will tell who's to blame. It's normal to hold Saudi responsible.
Re: The Hajj Stampede - A Fluid Dynamics Problem by leunamme93(m): 9:07pm On Sep 26, 2015
Empiree:
Time will tell who's to blame. It's normal to hold Saudi responsible.
True talk. But if not Saudi authorities who should be held accountable?
Re: The Hajj Stampede - A Fluid Dynamics Problem by Empiree: 10:58pm On Sep 26, 2015
leunamme93:

True talk. But if not Saudi authorities who should be held accountable?
are u muslim?
Re: The Hajj Stampede - A Fluid Dynamics Problem by Nobody: 11:42pm On Sep 26, 2015
Excellent piece! Love the fluid dynamics approach.

I hereby postulate that "As the number of people gathered in a given space increases per square metre, the danger inherent in such gathering increases exponentially" - 0rex (2015).

2 Likes 1 Share

Re: The Hajj Stampede - A Fluid Dynamics Problem by leunamme93(m): 2:36pm On Sep 27, 2015
Empiree:
are u muslim?
I'm not sure how answering that will make you answer the question I asked.
Re: The Hajj Stampede - A Fluid Dynamics Problem by Empiree: 4:48pm On Sep 27, 2015
leunamme93:

I'm not sure how answering that will make you answer the question I asked.
Well, one of the qualities of being muslims is to submit to Allah - The Creator. The incidents during Hajj is extraordinary event. Muslims know too well that hajj related incidents (death) are rewardable afterlife. This is common knowledge.

One of the purposes of hajj is unification of adherents of islam. There should be absolutely no room for bickering if we truly believe. Death incidents at Arafah is of two (2) realities that are opposite of each other.

First reality is that of painful deaths with bodies everywhere, whether it was mistake, negligence or deliberate. Loved ones sob, morn and count their lost. This is material reality.

Second reality is base on iman (faith) and (qadar) fate. Muslims know too well the "benefits" of dying in Islam Holiest site especially during Hajj. There are tremendous rewards for those people. There are evidences in islamic text to support this.

Hajj Wipes Off Past Sins:

Abu Huraira reported that the Prophet (SAW) said: "He who performs Hajj for Allah's pleasure and avoids all lewdness and sins will return after Hajj free from all sins as he was the day his mother gave birth to him. " (Bukhari & Muslim)


Abdullahi in Mas'ud narrated that the Prophet (SAW) said: "Alternate between Hajj and Umrah (regularly), for these two remove poverty and sins just as the blacksmith's bellows removes all impurities from metals like iron, gold and silver. The reward for Hajj Mabrur is nothing short of paradise. " (Nasai and Tirmizhi, who what's it sounds hadith)

The Reward For Hajj Is Paradise:

Abu Huraira reported that the Prophet muhammad (SAW) said: " All sins committed in between the performance of one Umrah and another are expiated and erased, and the reward of Hajj Mabrur is nothing save Paradise."

In another sound hadith in Jorail relates from Jabir that the Prophet(SAW) said: " This House of Allah (the Ka'bah) is the pillar of islam, so whoever heads to it with the intention of performing Hajj or Umrah is under Allah's security. If he should die (during his trip) he is granted Paradise, and if he returns home safely, he returns with reward and gain. "

The above are enough evidences to do away with silly politics, blame games and sectarianism.

In islamic epistemology, the dead bodies of pilgrims we saw are nothing but shells. The souls of the dead looked at it and snubbed. They smile and rejoice at great rewards ahead while you and I critisize, cry, mourn and bicker. But the Angels are saying to them (the dead) "fear not this is the reward which you are promised"

That said, does that mean investigations should be avoided and possible negligence, mistakes etc should not be persecuted?, no sir. Investigations should proceed. If it was act of negligence by entity responsible, or that a Prince who thinks he's above the law caused stampede surge should be brought to book.

I do not buy the idea that pilgrims did not follow instructions. They are thousands of people at the Arafah and I can't stomach such a silly lie. I also frown at the way bodies piled up showing less regards for them. Bodies should be treated with respect. If this had been non-religious related issues, I would support blaming govt outright. But this is extraordinary event (Hajj) where muslims converge and set aside differences. Its purpose must be fulfilled.

In conclusion, you may say everything I said up there is bs, that's your prerogative.


Eld Mubaraq!
Re: The Hajj Stampede - A Fluid Dynamics Problem by vooks: 5:06pm On Sep 27, 2015
This is just about as helpful as drowning is basically denying your body oxygen.

More intelligent question is,what were you doing in the water body?

What on earth are they doing worshipping idols?

(1) (Reply)

How A Pastor Befriended Me Because Of My 3k Offering, Read What He Did Later. / Debunking The Religious Lie About Hell. / @ CCT Renunciation & Deliverance Brings Freedom Read This

(Go Up)

Sections: politics (1) business autos (1) jobs (1) career education (1) romance computers phones travel sports fashion health
religion celebs tv-movies music-radio literature webmasters programming techmarket

Links: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10)

Nairaland - Copyright © 2005 - 2024 Oluwaseun Osewa. All rights reserved. See How To Advertise. 79
Disclaimer: Every Nairaland member is solely responsible for anything that he/she posts or uploads on Nairaland.