Welcome, Guest: Register On Nairaland / LOGIN! / Trending / Recent / New
Stats: 3,198,108 members, 7,967,128 topics. Date: Saturday, 05 October 2024 at 12:13 PM

Religion: An Illusion That Works Well - Religion (19) - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum / Nairaland / General / Religion / Religion: An Illusion That Works Well (24790 Views)

Free Will Is An Illusion / Back To The Illusion: How Can We Know Our Reality Is An Illusion? / Donald Trump Vs Islam Is An ILLUSION Like Superman Vs Muhammad Ali. (2) (3) (4)

(1) (2) (3) ... (16) (17) (18) (19) (20) (21) (Reply) (Go Down)

Re: Religion: An Illusion That Works Well by jonbellion(m): 10:38pm On Dec 16, 2016
MrMontella:


we cant be on the same level...

You're still evolving at an atomic rate!


switch?
Philosophical propositions?
Religious perspectives?

And you're a stanuch christian?

Indeed your are confused!
lol
Ebuka is obviously a diest
He's just laying low so as not to disappoint his christian pals cool
Ebuka you can join the cool kids cool
Re: Religion: An Illusion That Works Well by damogul: 10:38pm On Dec 16, 2016
winner01:
yes boss cool

God bless you.
Re: Religion: An Illusion That Works Well by damogul: 10:39pm On Dec 16, 2016
jonbellion:
lol
Ebuka is obviously a diest
He's just laying low so as not to disappoint his christian pals cool
Ebuka you can join the cool kids cool

What is this one saying? If they are counting cool kids will you jump out? How much dey your pocket?

1 Like 1 Share

Re: Religion: An Illusion That Works Well by winner01(m): 10:41pm On Dec 16, 2016
dalaman:


You have failed to show me how loving my family is meaningless because I will die someday. How does life after death add meaning to me loving my wife and kids? You haven't demonstrated that at all. Purpose fits very well with my world view. You haven't shown my how the end of life makes me enjoying this life a meaningless venture.
I want to know if you have anything against those who live their lives directly opposite this view of yours. Those who prefer to crack other peoples heads open or blow up buildings. I want to know if you have anything against people who have a different definition of meaning and purpose. undecided

3 Likes 1 Share

Re: Religion: An Illusion That Works Well by jonbellion(m): 10:44pm On Dec 16, 2016
damogul:


What is this one saying? If they are counting cool kids will you jump out? How much dey your pocket?
lol
What does that matter
Re: Religion: An Illusion That Works Well by damogul: 10:46pm On Dec 16, 2016
jonbellion:
lol
What does that matter

Exactly what you read
Re: Religion: An Illusion That Works Well by MrMontella(m): 10:46pm On Dec 16, 2016
KingEbukasBlog:


Read Grizzlybear's threads and see how

https://www.nairaland.com/3498459/think-human-race-needs-stop
https://www.nairaland.com/3479134/meaninglessness-human-existence-immortality-religion

And tell me if anyone who acknowledges the existence of God will have such thoughts
yes..in a way!

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_Bentley_Hart
He's a known christian author
in his webpage he released his views:
some form of ''christian nihilism''

our religion is one of very
comfortable nihilism.
https://www.firstthings.com/article/2003/10/christ-and-nothing




https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nihilism

from wiki's page on nihilism,

[quote]
Søren Kierkegaard (1813–1855) posited an early form of nihilism to which he referred as leveling.[17] He saw levelling as the process of suppressing individuality to a point where the
individual's uniqueness becomes non-existent
and nothing meaningful in his existence can be
affirmed
:

Hes a christian
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Søren_Kierkegaard
Re: Religion: An Illusion That Works Well by MrMontella(m): 10:48pm On Dec 16, 2016
jonbellion:
lol Ebuka is obviously a diest He's just laying low so as not to disappoint his christian pals cool Ebuka you can join the cool kids cool
he maybe a christian...na him know...
I prefer to go by what one classifies themselves to be!
Re: Religion: An Illusion That Works Well by KingEbukasBlog(m): 10:49pm On Dec 16, 2016
jonbellion:
lol
Ebuka is obviously a diest
He's just laying low so as not to disappoint his christian pals cool
Ebuka you can join the cool kids cool

I am not a deist bro . Refuting an atheist argument from different perspectives does not make me any less of a Christian . Its just a way of exposing how specious and tenuous the argument is .

Example The argument from poor design can be refuted from the perspectives of

1. Christianity

2. Theistic evolution

3. Panentheism

4. Deism

Since I can use these perspectives to refute the argument , that means I'm no longer a Christian ? Haba!
Re: Religion: An Illusion That Works Well by jonbellion(m): 10:51pm On Dec 16, 2016
KingEbukasBlog:


I am not a deist bro . Refuting an atheist argument from different perspectives does not make me any less of a Christian . Its just a way of exposing how specious and tenuous the argument is .

Example The argument from poor design can be refuted from the perspectives of

1. Christianity

2. Theistic evolution

3. Panentheism

4. Deism

Since I can use these perspectives to refute the argument , that means I'm no longer a Christian ? Haba!
nor vex
Re: Religion: An Illusion That Works Well by KingEbukasBlog(m): 10:54pm On Dec 16, 2016
MrMontella:

yes..in a way!

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_Bentley_Hart
He's a known christian author
in his webpage he released his views:
some form of ''christian nihilism''

https://www.firstthings.com/article/2003/10/christ-and-nothing




https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nihilism

from wiki's page on nihilism,


In Christian atheism , an atheist can himself a Christian . So there you go .

Christian nihilism is like an oxymoron . grin There is no such thing as that .

Christ :Come unto me all ye that labour and are heavy laden and I will give you rest

Nihilism : Leads to depression , suicide , impulse to destroy and commit so many sinful acts .

Where is the compatibility ?

2 Likes 1 Share

Re: Religion: An Illusion That Works Well by DeepSight(m): 11:00pm On Dec 16, 2016
damogul:
[b]Deepsight allow me to entertain you while you are in the can. Remember this Post? You really took the gloves off that time. It was bare knuckle assault.


The cowardly bann is over. The chap has light skin. Na im get im forum to do as he pleases. In fact e fit ban me again for this statement alone. Im sha know say i no send am.

2 Likes 1 Share

Re: Religion: An Illusion That Works Well by jonbellion(m): 11:00pm On Dec 16, 2016
KingEbukasBlog:


In Christian atheism , an atheist can himself a Christian . So there you go .

Christian nihilism is like an oxymoron . grin There is no such thing as that .

Christ :Come unto me all ye that labour and are heavy laden and I will give you rest

Nihilism : Leads to depression , suicide , impulse to destroy and commit so many sinful acts .

Where is the compatibility ?
actually most athiests subscribe to the view of extentialism
despite the number of atheistic philosophies that still find purpose and joy in life religious people still consider nihilism the logical extension of atheism
Why?
Why?
Re: Religion: An Illusion That Works Well by KingEbukasBlog(m): 11:02pm On Dec 16, 2016
dalaman:


Am not a nihilist so why should I subscribe to anything they posit?

In reality , since you deny the existence of God and believe that life has no general purpose or meaning that you are professing ideas in existential nihilism .

As far as you are without God and trying to invent meaning to your life in a universe you consider purposeless and meaningless then you are an existential nihilist , basically .
Re: Religion: An Illusion That Works Well by MrMontella(m): 11:02pm On Dec 16, 2016
KingEbukasBlog:


In Christian atheism , an atheist can himself a Christian . So there you go .

Christian nihilism is like an oxymoron . grin There is no such thing as that .

Christ :Come unto me all ye that labour and are heavy laden and I will give you rest

Nihilism : Leads to depression , suicide , impulse to destroy and commit so many sinful acts .

Where is the compatibility ?
dont ask me..
Ask them undecided

and dont gimme an atheist can call himself a christian...
Or else
Grizzlybear is a muslim then gringrin


David has books against atheism...he has books affirming his belief in a creator,,

m guessing he doesnt believe god gives meaning to life..

at least you've seen someone can believe in God and harbor such thoughts!
Re: Religion: An Illusion That Works Well by damogul: 11:05pm On Dec 16, 2016
MrMontella:

yes..in a way!

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_Bentley_Hart
He's a known christian author
in his webpage he released his views:
some form of ''christian nihilism''

https://www.firstthings.com/article/2003/10/christ-and-nothing




https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nihilism

from wiki's page on nihilism,


You did not finish the article. Let me help you. Cherrypicking is a bad thing.

Note however that Kierkegaard's meaning of "nihilism" differs from the modern definition in the sense that, for Kierkegaard, levelling led to a life lacking meaning, purpose or value,[20] whereas the modern interpretation of nihilism posits that there was never any meaning, purpose or value to begin with.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nihilism

1 Like 1 Share

Re: Religion: An Illusion That Works Well by damogul: 11:06pm On Dec 16, 2016
DeepSight:


The cowardly bann is over. The chap has light skin. Na im get im forum to do as he pleases. In fact e fit ban me again for this statement alone. Im sha know say i no send am.

grin grin

All of us no send am
Re: Religion: An Illusion That Works Well by MrMontella(m): 11:07pm On Dec 16, 2016
KingEbukasBlog:


In reality , since you deny the existence of God and believe that life has no general purpose or meaning that you are professing ideas in existential nihilism .

As far as you are without God and trying to invent meaning to your life in a universe you consider purposeless and meaningless then you are an existential nihilist , basically .
i dont think the belief in God entails purpose of life..

Not all Gods demand worship..
or have anything to do with us
E.g The deistic God(s)

so what do you say then?
Re: Religion: An Illusion That Works Well by MrMontella(m): 11:10pm On Dec 16, 2016
damogul:


You did not finish the article. Let me help you. Cherrypicking is a bad thing.

[b]Note however that Kierkegaard's meaning of "nihilism" differs from the modern definition in the sense that, for Kierkegaard, levelling led to a life lacking meaning, purpose or value,[20] whereas the modern interpretation of nihilism posits that there was never any meaning, purpose or value to begin with.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nihilism
Sire,,I did not cherrypick...

I bolded where the article said that he held the belief of an early form of nihilism..

And on the levelling,,he posited and advocated for it
Re: Religion: An Illusion That Works Well by damogul: 11:11pm On Dec 16, 2016
MrMontella:

i dont think the belief in God entails purpose of life..

Not all Gods demand worship..
or have anything to do with us
E.g The deistic God(s)

so what do you say then?


A nihilist is a man who judges of the world as it is that it ought not to be, and of the world as it ought to be that it does not exist. According to this view, our existence (action, suffering, willing, feeling) has no meaning: the pathos of 'in vain' is the nihilists' pathos — at the same time, as pathos, an inconsistency on the part of the nihilists.

— Friedrich Nietzsche, KSA 12:9 [60], taken from The Will to Power, section 585, translated by Walter Kaufmann


[b]Stanley Rosen identifies Nietzsche's concept of nihilism with a situation of meaninglessness, in which "everything is permitted." According to him, the loss of higher metaphysical values that exist in contrast to the base reality of the world, or merely human ideas, gives rise to the idea that all human ideas are therefore valueless. Rejecting idealism thus results in nihilism, because only similarly transcendent ideals live up to the previous standards that the nihilist still implicitly holds.[34] The inability for Christianity to serve as a source of valuating the world is reflected in Nietzsche's famous aphorism of the madman in The Gay Science.[35] The death of God, in particular the statement that "we killed him", is similar to the self-dissolution of Christian doctrine: due to the advances of the sciences, which for Nietzsche show that man is the product of evolution, that Earth has no special place among the stars and that history is not progressive, the Christian notion of God can no longer serve as a basis for a morality.[/b]

1 Like 1 Share

Re: Religion: An Illusion That Works Well by KingEbukasBlog(m): 11:12pm On Dec 16, 2016
MrMontella:

dont ask me..
Ask them undecided

and dont gimme an atheist can call himself a christian...
Or else
Grizzlybear is a muslim then gringrin


David has books against atheism...he has books affirming his belief in a creator,,

m guessing he doesnt believe god gives meaning to life..

at least you've seen someone can believe in God and harbor such thoughts!

Nihilism avers that God does not exist or He is dead . Nihilism says that life has no meaning or purpose since there is no creator . The word nihilism comes from the Latin word nihil, which means "nothing" and it shares the same root with "annihilate" , which is "to destroy completely".

Anger , hatred can can induce the urge to destroy and the bible exhorts us to love and be peaceful . The devil in the bible has been associated with destruction .

All these things in Nihilism are incongruous with the teachings of Christ . So how can you subscribe to Nihilism as a Christian ? Show me how intelligent you are and prove to me why 'Christian Nihilism' makes any modicum of sense to any one cognizant of both teachings . undecided

1 Like 1 Share

Re: Religion: An Illusion That Works Well by damogul: 11:13pm On Dec 16, 2016
MrMontella:

Sire,,I did not cherrypick...

I bolded where the article said that he held the belief of an early form of nihilism..

And on the levelling,,he posited and advocated for it
Re: Religion: An Illusion That Works Well by damogul: 11:14pm On Dec 16, 2016
MrMontella:

Sire,,I did not cherrypick...

I bolded where the article said that he held the belief of an early form of nihilism..

And on the levelling,,he posited and advocated for it

If its an early form of nihilism according to him and is not applicable to modern times why then did you push it forward?
Re: Religion: An Illusion That Works Well by damogul: 11:15pm On Dec 16, 2016
KingEbukasBlog:


Nihilism avers that God does not exist or He is dead . Nihilism says that life has no meaning or purpose since there is no creator . The word nihilism comes from the Latin word nihil, which means "nothing" and it shares the same root with "annihilate" , which is "to destroy completely".

Anger , hatred can can induce the urge to destroy and the bible exhorts us to love and be peaceful . The devil in the bible has been associated with destruction .

All these things in Nihilism are incongruous with the teachings of Christ . So how can you subscribe to Nihilism as a Christian ? Show me how intelligent you are and prove to me why 'Christian Nihilism' makes any modicum of sense to any one cognizant of both teachings . undecided

Its an Oxymoron

1 Like 1 Share

Re: Religion: An Illusion That Works Well by KingEbukasBlog(m): 11:17pm On Dec 16, 2016
damogul:


Its an Oxymoron

Hopefully , he will understand that grin
Re: Religion: An Illusion That Works Well by MrMontella(m): 11:24pm On Dec 16, 2016
KingEbukasBlog:


Nihilism avers that God does not exist or He is dead . Nihilism says that life has no meaning or purpose since there is no creator . The word nihilism comes from the Latin word nihil, which means "nothing" and it shares the same root with "annihilate" , which is "to destroy completely"
correct me if im wrong..
But in that wikipedia page...
In all the types of nihilism listed...
None stated God..



Anger , hatred can can induce the urge to destroy and the bible exhorts us to love and be peaceful . The devil in the bible has been associated with destruction .

All these things in Nihilism are incongruous with the teachings of Christ . So how can you subscribe to Nihilism as a Christian ? Show me how intelligent you are and prove to me why 'Christian Nihilism' makes any modicum of sense to any one cognizant of both teachings . undecided
the existence of christian suicide bombers...
You can connect it right?

Also..the existence of ''christian atheism''

also..i dont think ''christ'' defines christianity alone..

The bible is an authority in christianity too


Ecclesiastes 1 Good News Translation (GNT)

2It is useless, useless, said the Philosopher .Life is useless, all useless.
Re: Religion: An Illusion That Works Well by MrMontella(m): 11:30pm On Dec 16, 2016
damogul:



A nihilist is a man who judges of the world as it is that it ought not to be, and of the world as it ought to be that it does not exist. According to this view, our existence (action, suffering, willing, feeling) has no meaning: the pathos of 'in vain' is the nihilists' pathos — at the same time, as pathos, an inconsistency on the part of the nihilists.

— Friedrich Nietzsche, KSA 12:9 [60], taken from The Will to Power, section 585, translated by Walter Kaufmann


[b]Stanley Rosen identifies Nietzsche's concept of nihilism with a situation of meaninglessness, in which "everything is permitted." According to him, the loss of higher metaphysical values that exist in contrast to the base reality of the world, or merely human ideas, gives rise to the idea that all human ideas are therefore valueless. Rejecting idealism thus results in nihilism, because only similarly transcendent ideals live up to the previous standards that the nihilist still implicitly holds.[34] The inability for Christianity to serve as a source of valuating the world is reflected in Nietzsche's famous aphorism of the madman in The Gay Science.[35] The death of God, in particular the statement that "we killed him", is similar to the self-dissolution of Christian doctrine: due to the advances of the sciences, which for Nietzsche show that man is the product of evolution, that Earth has no special place among the stars and that history is not progressive, the Christian notion of God can no longer serve as a basis for a morality.[/b]

in deism...God has nothing do to with humanity...
For materialist deists...he doesnt judge...there is no after life...

They are not nihilists right?

the death of God was on christianity...

Its just a book's label..

Just like dawkins ''the God delusion'' which focused on religious Gods but never a Deistic God...
And many others like that!
Re: Religion: An Illusion That Works Well by KingEbukasBlog(m): 11:33pm On Dec 16, 2016
MrMontella:

correct me if im wrong..
But in that wikipedia page...
In all the types of nihilism listed...
None stated God..

Wikipedia is the only source of information ? Right ? I've told you what Nihilism is and its roots and there is no harmony between Christianity and Nihilism

MrMontella:
the existence of christian suicide bombers...
You can connect it right?

The bible says that all murderers will go to Hell . You cant be a Christian and claim to be a suicide bomber .

MrMontella:
Also..the existence of ''christian atheism''

also..i dont think ''christ'' defines christianity alone..

The bible is an authority in christianity too

Christian atheism accepts the teachings of Christ but reject his divinity as God . The same thing with Christian deism . They all don't represent the truth in Christianity .


MrMontella:
Ecclesiastes 1 Good News Translation (GNT)

2It is useless, useless, said the Philosopher .Life is useless, all useless.

Why did you make use of a different translation ?

That bible verse explains why life is meaningless without God .

You have not shown me the connection between Nihilism and Christianity this guy ! Stop the circumlocution and show me the compatibility .

1 Like 1 Share

Re: Religion: An Illusion That Works Well by oglalasioux(m): 12:30am On Dec 17, 2016
This is a great piece. I commend this writer for the educated analysis. I especially like the part he said both science and religion have done harm and good to the world. I also noted his question on how atheism intends to curtail societal vices.

I believe rebellion against accepted norms and values is a major problem of the society and religion has over millennia put that in check. The problem here is the method religion uses to make people comply with the laws of the land. It uses the blackmail of hell fire and even suffering in this physical world before the hereafter.

Now here are the problems with using religion to control the society :

1. The same religion that preaches peace preaches war. More wars have been fought over religious supremacy than any conflict in human history. Even today, the war on terrorism is overwhelmingly caused by religious differences.

2. Religion is so sectionalized that it's laws apply only to a closed group. If you don't belong to this group, no matter how good your deeds are, you are filthy and condemned.

3. No one can really define good or bad in religion. In a religion a deed is noble and accepted by god/gods. In another religion such deed is abhorred. Take example of marriage among Christians and Muslims.

4. The extravagance of religious leaders drips of doublespeak. Religion preaches heavenly reward but their leaders tend to be more interested in the rewards here on earth.

5. Religion is notorious for false predictions and prophecies. False hope of the Messiah. False hope of a heaven no one has a clue about.

Naturally, a system that govern with lies and doublespeak cannot dictate morality. Religion lacks the credibility to be the yardstick with which morality is measured. It might have worked to control mankind millinia ago but in today's world, there's nothing as false as religion.

Atheists don't claim to have a solution to world problems. But I'll open a thread on how atheism can better our world.
Re: Religion: An Illusion That Works Well by dalaman: 5:19am On Dec 17, 2016
KingEbukasBlog:


In reality , since you deny the existence of God and believe that life has no general purpose or meaning that you are professing ideas in existential nihilism.

I do not believe that life has no general purpose. It is indeed a fact that life has no general and universally accepted purpose. Purpose in life us what ever you chose to make of it. Even among the God believers life has different purposes. The purpose you ascribe to your life isn't the same with that of a muslim,and Ifa worshipper or a Hindu.

As far as you are without God and trying to invent meaning to your life in a universe you consider purposeless and meaningless then you are an existential nihilist , basically .

Again how can the universe be meaningless and purposeless when it has already given us a chance to be alive and survive in it? Religion and God are NOT the only things that give purpose and meaning to life.

1 Like

Re: Religion: An Illusion That Works Well by dalaman: 7:53am On Dec 17, 2016
KingEbukasBlog:


I am not a deist bro . Refuting an atheist argument from different perspectives does not make me any less of a Christian . Its just a way of exposing how specious and tenuous the argument is .

Example The argument from poor design can be refuted from the perspectives of

1. Christianity

2. Theistic evolution

3. Panentheism

4. Deism

Since I can use these perspectives to refute the argument , that means I'm no longer a Christian ? Haba!

But if athiests do same you get irritated and start complaining.
Re: Religion: An Illusion That Works Well by DeepSight(m): 9:27am On Dec 17, 2016
@ Kingebukasblog & Dalaman,

Please see -

https://www.nairaland.com/441220/mazaje-state-purpose-life

Several points of view on purpose in life were canvassed.

1 Like 1 Share

(1) (2) (3) ... (16) (17) (18) (19) (20) (21) (Reply)

Who Is A Lawful Captive? / No Acceptable Reasons For Missing Church Service / Five Types Of Girls You Meet In Church

(Go Up)

Sections: politics (1) business autos (1) jobs (1) career education (1) romance computers phones travel sports fashion health
religion celebs tv-movies music-radio literature webmasters programming techmarket

Links: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10)

Nairaland - Copyright © 2005 - 2024 Oluwaseun Osewa. All rights reserved. See How To Advertise. 79
Disclaimer: Every Nairaland member is solely responsible for anything that he/she posts or uploads on Nairaland.