spillo1:

LMFAO.....Ferdinand is always rated above Vidic by United fans and will make a United greatest xi before Vidic.

nitrogen:


Lol, you sha don agree that VVD is a point and shout defender.

raumdeuter:


Everybody knows that one already, that is why they try to package him under Leadership when no be Abba Kyari we dey talk of

raumdeuter:


That is a big fallacy, You play football its not powerpoint presentation. You go out there and put your body on the line. Its easy to point here and there

Shebi all of us go dey studios and viewing centers pointing what this person should have done or not. Shebi all dem Neville go dey carry touchpad dey talk what someone should have done or not

Remove these so called brains and the agressive partners can still hold the defence like Vidic showed in Man Utd, but any defender whose game is based on pointing and pointing how will he cope

nitrogen:
He is rated above Vidic because he is English. Vidic was better.

spillo1:

LMFAO.......It's obvious you have never played football. It's no wonder you just keep analysing like a typical keyboard warrior. You are all about brute force and diving in rather than being smart and composed. If you were a defender you will be worst a version of Phil Jones.

nitrogen:


He is rated above Vidic because he is English. Vidic was better.

raumdeuter:


Xavi left there was still Busquets and Iniesta.

With your logic was it Johnny Evans or Oshea that was reading the game for Vidic to win the league

raumdeuter:


Xavi left there was still Busquets and Iniesta.

With your logic was it Johnny Evans or Oshea that was reading the game for Vidic to win the league

spillo1:

And you are doing the exact opposite by underating him because he is English. it goes both ways bro. Vidic was better that's your opinion. others have theirs.

raumdeuter:


These category are those who hide from the ball and claim they are organising defence, When Ferdinand left who was organising Man Utd defence? Was it Evans or Oshea

Football is an activity not a presentation where you will be pointing and organising

How come Chelsea won the CL without their so called brain of the defence

Between Ramos and Varane who won 3 CL, who was the brain of the defence?

When Kompany paired Mangala, Lescott, Otamendi Demichelis who was the brain of the defence? Does it sound right that Mangala, Otamendi Demichelis or Lesscott were the brain of anything? When they left City how is that brain working for them

nitrogen:


Forget opinion jare, we watched both of them.

We all know that English players get hyped big time....

raumdeuter:


You that you have played ball and won balon dor 10 times

I have asked you who was the thinker between Varane and Ramos
Who was the thinker between Kompany and Lescott, Demichelis, Mangala Otamendi

Expert17:


Smalling organized the defence under Vangaal/Mourinho..
Maguire is doing same now........

Some players can play both 5 & 6.....Maguire, Ramos....

Thats why Man city best partnership to me was Kompany and Laporte....... Man city defensive issues is one of the reasons Liverpool is strolling to the title

Man Utd also won 1999 UCL without Scholes and Keane.......... So terry not playing in 2012 doesn't change anything abt his quality

spillo1:

LMFAO..And in your thick Head you believe players can't have both abilities.

Leyqute:


What about Van Dijk?

Always pointing fingers like Sanwo-Olu .
He's a very good defender who reads the game well and leads the back line very well.

nitrogen:


Lol, you sha don agree that VVD is a point and shout defender.

spillo1:

We also know people like you who are there to downgrade them. I am not even castigating you for saying vidic is better as its totally valid same as well is saying Ferdinand was better.

Expert17:
Ferdinard, Terry, also point and shout very well.... they are like the coach in the field

CB position is sensitive,....the 2 CBs cant just dive into tackles/interception/Aerial battle the same time..

Show me any GREAT CENTER BACK PARTNERSHIP, i will show you the 5 & 6 there...

spillo1:

LMFAO.....Ferdinand is always rated above Vidic by United fans and will make a United greatest xi before Vidic.

raumdeuter:


How many games did Kompany and Laporte even play together? Laporte joined January 2017. City had already won 2 league titles before then

So if Kompany was the aggresive partner and needed a brain and thinker, who was thinking for him before Laporte got there? Was it Mangala, Demichelis, Otamendi or Lesscott

raumdeuter:


Then you tell us who was acting as the thinker in those scenarios

Defenders will be on the field forming activiy and claim to be thinking and doing leadership. You think Vidic Carvalho Ramos and Kompany getting stuck were also not thinking and leading their defence? But all dem Rio Terry and VVD that have no function on the field will claim their major job is to point like yellow fever

larride:


Lol. You must be trolling.

nitrogen:


He is rated above Vidic because he is English. Vidic was better.

raumdeuter:


No one is downgrading them, we all watched them from the beginning of their careers and we knew some of them were bang average who are just trying to launder their images post retirement

Na new generation youtube fans like you think football is played by pointing

spillo1:

LMFAO. ....Oga defenders are not restricted in their abilities. They can poses both and excel in one or both. Ramos is a perfect example of that You are not the governor of football and people that have to follow your biased Phil Jones sense in rating defenders.

spillo1:

LMFAO. ....Stop showing your young age small boy. People like you who don't know anything will be the first to type rubbish about generation. It's young boys like you that believe every defender should be diving into reckless challenges all the time. Guy rest. You rate vidic keep it to yourself and let others rate who they want.

raumdeuter:


Interesting

I am sure I have forgotten more football than you have watched

Tell me your first football game you watched, I will tell you I have been watching since the 80s before LMFAO became a thing

raumdeuter:


Organizing is what all top defenders can do. Its now left if when called to act and get stuck can you do it without faltering or you will be running from attackers like VVD and Rio

Boateng Nesta, Canavaro Maldidni, Ramos, Puyol, Pique Vidic Carvalho can all organize and can still excel in getting stuck in, Its useless defenders that claim their key strenght is organizing defence

raumdeuter:


Interesting

I am sure I have forgotten more football than you have watched

Tell me your first football game you watched, I will tell you I have been watching since the 80s before LMFAO became a thing

raumdeuter:


These category are those who hide from the ball and claim they are organising defence, When Ferdinand left who was organising Man Utd defence? Was it Evans or Oshea

Football is an activity not a presentation where you will be pointing and organising