Welcome, Guest: Register On Nairaland / LOGIN! / Trending / Recent / New
Stats: 3,218,132 members, 8,036,765 topics. Date: Wednesday, 25 December 2024 at 07:57 AM

Supreme Court Rejects GOP's Bid To Nullify Biden's Win In Pennsylvania - Foreign Affairs - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum / Nairaland / General / Politics / Foreign Affairs / Supreme Court Rejects GOP's Bid To Nullify Biden's Win In Pennsylvania (22036 Views)

At Least 3 Dead In Snowy Pileup Of Dozens Of Vehicles In Pennsylvania, Usa(Pics) / Pence Hits Breaking Point With Trump In Blessing Biden's Win / Nevada Supreme Court Rejects Trump Campaign's Appeal, Affirms Biden's Win (2) (3) (4)

(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (Reply) (Go Down)

Supreme Court Rejects GOP's Bid To Nullify Biden's Win In Pennsylvania by vixpal: 12:30am On Dec 09, 2020
The US Supreme Court on Tuesday rejected a bid by Pennsylvania Republicans to nullify President-elect Joe Biden's victory in the Keystone State, dealing another blow to the long-shot legal effort by President Trump and his allies to overturn the election in the courts.

The Tuesday order, which was unsigned and included no noted dissents, came ahead of the midnight “safe harbor” deadline, which provides states a kind of immunity from congressional oversight into election results that are certified in time.

The justices’ move leaves intact Pennsylvania Gov. Tom Wolf’s (D) late November certification of Biden’s victory in a state he won by more than 81,000 votes.
It also represents the latest in a lengthy string of defeats for Trump and his allies amid their increasingly implausible legal campaign, which is largely premised on unsupported claims that the election results are invalid due to widespread fraud.

Among the plaintiffs in the Supreme Court petition were Trump ally Rep. Mike Kelly (R-Pa.).

The challengers’ original complaint, filed in Pennsylvania state court late last month, sought to strike down an expanded mail-in ballot policy that Pennsylvania put in place in 2019 after it was passed by the state's GOP-held legislature.

Biden won three of every four mail-in ballots cast in the state, according to an analysis of Pennsylvania Department of State data by The Philadelphia Inquirer.

The Pennsylvania Supreme Court tossed the case late last month, citing the litigants' undue delay in bringing the challenge, prompting the petition to the U.S. Supreme Court.

Attorneys for Kelly and the other Pennsylvania Republicans argued that the top state court had violated their due process and other constitutional guarantees.
Lawyers representing the state of Pennsylvania countered that the lawsuit was meritless and cautioned the justices against granting relief.

“No court has ever issued an order nullifying a governor's certification of presidential election results,” they argued in a brief. “The loss of public trust in our constitutional order resulting in this kind of judicial power would be incalculable.”

The emergency application was addressed to Justice Samuel Alito, who handles emergency petitions from Pennsylvania and the surrounding region. Alito could have acted on the request alone, but instead referred the matter to the full court. The court’s denial means that fewer than five justices supported the GOP bid.

The court’s denial came just hours after Trump expressed hope that the Supreme Court would embrace his dubious claims of having won the election.

“Let’s see whether or not somebody has the courage, whether it’s a legislator or legislatures, or whether it’s a justice of the Supreme Court or a number of justices of the Supreme Court,” Trump said during a coronavirus vaccine summit. “Let’s see if they have the courage to do what everybody in this country knows is right.”

Earlier Tuesday the state of Texas filed a lawsuit in the Supreme Court against four battleground states in an effort to overturn Biden’s win.

Election law experts who predicted Kelly’s case would be dismissed by the court offered a similar prognostication in the Texas lawsuit.

“I may need to take back what I said about Rep. Kelly’s [Pennsylvania] suit being the dumbest case I’ve ever seen filed on an emergency basis at the Supreme Court,” Rick Hasen, a law professor at the University of California Irvine, wrote on the Election Law Blog. “This new one from the indicted Texas AG Ken Paxton probably should win that prize


https://thehill.com/regulation/court-battles/529334-supreme-court-rejects-gop-bid-to-nullify-biden-win-in-pennsylvania

8 Likes 1 Share

Re: Supreme Court Rejects GOP's Bid To Nullify Biden's Win In Pennsylvania by jfking2005(m): 12:33am On Dec 09, 2020
Wasted effort detected earlier but he refused to listen

40 Likes 4 Shares

Re: Supreme Court Rejects GOP's Bid To Nullify Biden's Win In Pennsylvania by flemsy15(m): 12:44am On Dec 09, 2020
I used to think US elections were 100 percent transparent and have no need for questioning

15 Likes 3 Shares

Re: Supreme Court Rejects GOP's Bid To Nullify Biden's Win In Pennsylvania by Emmaxx: 12:48am On Dec 09, 2020
Still on this matter?

1 Like

Re: Supreme Court Rejects GOP's Bid To Nullify Biden's Win In Pennsylvania by hakeemhakeem(m): 1:49am On Dec 09, 2020
flemsy15:
I used to think US elections were 100 percent transparent and have no need for questioning

No election in this world is 100% transparent but 70 to 85% is statistical significant trump is just a bad loser

98 Likes 6 Shares

Re: Supreme Court Rejects GOP's Bid To Nullify Biden's Win In Pennsylvania by Freestainworld(m): 2:23am On Dec 09, 2020
Trump losing the more, bad advisers are destroying his reputation if he still got one now.

15 Likes 4 Shares

Re: Supreme Court Rejects GOP's Bid To Nullify Biden's Win In Pennsylvania by juman(m): 2:55am On Dec 09, 2020
flemsy15:
I used to think US elections were 100 percent transparent and have no need for questioning

The election was 100 percent transparent, but trump reduced america to his level.
Trump is agbero, he live as tout all his life.
Somebody that declared bankruptcy six times.

Trump never cared about the image of the country.
Any of our bad african president is better than trump.

107 Likes 10 Shares

Re: Supreme Court Rejects GOP's Bid To Nullify Biden's Win In Pennsylvania by juman(m): 2:59am On Dec 09, 2020
Freestainworld:
Trump losing the more, bad advisers are destroying his reputation if he still got one now.

I laugh.
What concern trump about reputation.
He never cared about that.

35 Likes 3 Shares

Re: Supreme Court Rejects GOP's Bid To Nullify Biden's Win In Pennsylvania by Johnnyessence(m): 4:17am On Dec 09, 2020
vixpal:
The US Supreme Court on Tuesday rejected a bid by Pennsylvania Republicans to nullify President-elect Joe Biden's victory in the Keystone State, dealing another blow to the long-shot legal effort by President Trump and his allies to overturn the election in the courts.


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9W-ZNqQB1pY

The Tuesday order, which was unsigned and included no noted dissents, came ahead of the midnight “safe harbor” deadline, which provides states a kind of immunity from congressional oversight into election results that are certified in time.
The justices’ move leaves intact Pennsylvania Gov. Tom Wolf’s (D) late November certification of Biden’s victory in a state he won by more than 81,000 votes.
It also represents the latest in a lengthy string of defeats for Trump and his allies amid their increasingly implausible legal campaign, which is largely premised on unsupported claims that the election results are invalid due to widespread fraud.

Among the plaintiffs in the Supreme Court petition were Trump ally Rep. Mike Kelly (R-Pa.).

The challengers’ original complaint, filed in Pennsylvania state court late last month, sought to strike down an expanded mail-in ballot policy that Pennsylvania put in place in 2019 after it was passed by the state's GOP-held legislature.



Biden won three of every four mail-in ballots cast in the state, according to an analysis of Pennsylvania Department of State data by The Philadelphia Inquirer.

The Pennsylvania Supreme Court tossed the case late last month, citing the litigants' undue delay in bringing the challenge, prompting the petition to the U.S. Supreme Court.

Attorneys for Kelly and the other Pennsylvania Republicans argued that the top state court had violated their due process and other constitutional guarantees.
Lawyers representing the state of Pennsylvania countered that the lawsuit was meritless and cautioned the justices against granting relief.

“No court has ever issued an order nullifying a governor's certification of presidential election results,” they argued in a brief. “The loss of public trust in our constitutional order resulting in this kind of judicial power would be incalculable.”

The emergency application was addressed to Justice Samuel Alito, who handles emergency petitions from Pennsylvania and the surrounding region. Alito could have acted on the request alone, but instead referred the matter to the full court. The court’s denial means that fewer than five justices supported the GOP bid.


The court’s denial came just hours after Trump expressed hope that the Supreme Court would embrace his dubious claims of having won the election.

“Let’s see whether or not somebody has the courage, whether it’s a legislator or legislatures, or whether it’s a justice of the Supreme Court or a number of justices of the Supreme Court,” Trump said during a coronavirus vaccine summit. “Let’s see if they have the courage to do what everybody in this country knows is right.”

Earlier Tuesday the state of Texas filed a lawsuit in the Supreme Court against four battleground states in an effort to overturn Biden’s win.

Election law experts who predicted Kelly’s case would be dismissed by the court offered a similar prognostication in the Texas lawsuit.

“I may need to take back what I said about Rep. Kelly’s [Pennsylvania] suit being the dumbest case I’ve ever seen filed on an emergency basis at the Supreme Court,” Rick Hasen, a law professor at the University of California Irvine, wrote on the Election Law Blog. “This new one from the indicted Texas AG Ken Paxton probably should win that prize


https://thehill.com/regulation/court-battles/529334-supreme-court-rejects-gop-bid-to-nullify-biden-win-in-pennsylvania

Rushing To Judgement And Media Gaslighitng.
Guys, do not let the mainstream media gaslight you concerning
the SCOTUS case filed by some Republicans in Pennsylvania.
Note that this is separate from the one filed by Texas now
joined by other States (more on that later).
The media is now GASLIGHTING people that the SCOTUS has
thrown out the case of these Republicans. They are
desperately doing their best to dampen the spirit of
Republicans.
That is simply not true. The case is still alive and well before
SCOTUS.
Yes, the SCOTUS has DENIED a big ask made by the
Republicans to "overturn" the election result in the
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania.
The Apex Court denied the "emergency injunctive relief"
because it was too radical and would be unprecedented for a
Court to "overturn" the result of an election. But you need to
know that the substantive case is STILL PENDING before the
Court because it has not been heard on the merit.
The injunctive relief was denied by Justice Alito (and not by
the Full Court). Justice Alito denied the injunctive relief to
pave way for a determination of the case on the merit.
See photos 1 and 2 attached below.
Photo 2 is the injunctive relief denied.
In other words, for emphasis, the substantive case has not
been thrown out. Senator Ted Crus will still get to argue before
SCOTUS.
See this link to show that it is still on the Court's schedule;
https://www.supremecourt.gov/search.aspx?filename=
%2Fdocket%2Fdocketfiles%2Fhtml%2Fpublic%2F20a98.html
Interestingly, the Republican Plaintiffs in their Appeal have
also asked the SCOTUS to ADVISE THEM ON OTHER RELIEFS
THAT MAY BE AVAILABLE TO THEM.
That general prayer or ask is what we should watch out for.
What reliefs would the SCOTUS be willing to grant if their case
succeeds on the merit?
SCOTUS could rule that the case succeeds on the merit and
then restore power to appoint Pennsylvania Electors back to
the Pennsylvania Legislature as per the US Constitution under
the Electors Clause instead of the Pennsylvania Secretary of
State.
Guys, this case is not over!
Immediately the news broke that SCOTUS has thrown out the
case in its entirety, I knew something wasn't right.
Why would SCOTUS accept to hear the case on the merit,
docket it and then dismiss it without a hearing?
It just didn't make any sense.
It didn't make sense because it never happened.
The case is still pending. The Court merely denied one radical
injunctive relief preliminarily. Period.
More information to come on the new States that joined Texas
in their lawsuit at the SCOTUS.

13 Likes

Re: Supreme Court Rejects GOP's Bid To Nullify Biden's Win In Pennsylvania by Johnnyessence(m): 4:18am On Dec 09, 2020
Senate resolution to recognize Joe Biden as the real president-elect failed to pass. The Inaugural Committee voted down a resolution by House Majority Leader Steny Hoyer (D-MD) on Tuesday naming Democrat presidential nominee Joe Biden president-elect, with all three Republican members voting against it.
Re: Supreme Court Rejects GOP's Bid To Nullify Biden's Win In Pennsylvania by Johnnyessence(m): 4:21am On Dec 09, 2020
The US Supreme Court has just accepted and will hear the lawsuit that the State of Texas is taking against Pennsylvania, Georgia, Michigan and Wisconsin for electoral fraud !! GREAT DAY !!

10 Likes 2 Shares

Re: Supreme Court Rejects GOP's Bid To Nullify Biden's Win In Pennsylvania by sanemind5(m): 5:32am On Dec 09, 2020
ok,hard one for trump
Re: Supreme Court Rejects GOP's Bid To Nullify Biden's Win In Pennsylvania by Nobody: 5:32am On Dec 09, 2020
grin
Re: Supreme Court Rejects GOP's Bid To Nullify Biden's Win In Pennsylvania by enemyofprogress: 5:36am On Dec 09, 2020
flemsy15:
I used to think US elections were 100 percent transparent and have no need for questioning
it is, except this one that was conducted for them this year by our INEC

2 Likes 1 Share

Re: Supreme Court Rejects GOP's Bid To Nullify Biden's Win In Pennsylvania by peacettw: 5:37am On Dec 09, 2020
flemsy15:
I used to think US elections were 100 percent transparent and have no need for questioning

Such a shame the depth the country has plunged into.

For some of us still wondering out there if a man is capable of wrecking this much havoc, there you have your answer.

For the disbelievers wondering who the real anti-christ of our time is, well, look no further than Donald Trump. He fits the bill perfectly.

12 Likes 2 Shares

Re: Supreme Court Rejects GOP's Bid To Nullify Biden's Win In Pennsylvania by Anaerobi(m): 5:37am On Dec 09, 2020
Okay
Re: Supreme Court Rejects GOP's Bid To Nullify Biden's Win In Pennsylvania by obonujoker(m): 5:40am On Dec 09, 2020
These Republicans should forget about all this legal suits, and prepare for the next election...

And moreover since the mercy period of some people have ended with Trump losing, they shouldn't be worried, as they believe the last Trump will be blown before Biden"s inauguration..lol

3 Likes 2 Shares

Re: Supreme Court Rejects GOP's Bid To Nullify Biden's Win In Pennsylvania by NdigboWorldwide: 5:44am On Dec 09, 2020
Johnnyessence:
The US Supreme Court has just accepted and will hear the
lawsuit that the State of Texas is taking against Pennsylvania,
Georgia, Michigan and Wisconsin for electoral fraud !!
GREAT DAY !!
Are you with us?

1 Like

Re: Supreme Court Rejects GOP's Bid To Nullify Biden's Win In Pennsylvania by Nobody: 5:46am On Dec 09, 2020
Why is Mr. Balloon wasting his time and everyone's time?
Biden to the world.

5 Likes 1 Share

Re: Supreme Court Rejects GOP's Bid To Nullify Biden's Win In Pennsylvania by HAJJIMUKHTAR: 5:47am On Dec 09, 2020
flemsy15:
I used to think US elections were 100 percent transparent and have no need for questioning
ok.......
Re: Supreme Court Rejects GOP's Bid To Nullify Biden's Win In Pennsylvania by Lifeisgoody: 5:50am On Dec 09, 2020
Trump is gone already
Re: Supreme Court Rejects GOP's Bid To Nullify Biden's Win In Pennsylvania by Aufbauh(m): 5:50am On Dec 09, 2020
Trump is just fighting a lost battle.
Re: Supreme Court Rejects GOP's Bid To Nullify Biden's Win In Pennsylvania by ponziponzi(m): 5:51am On Dec 09, 2020
Johnnyessence:
The US Supreme Court has just accepted and will hear the
lawsuit that the State of Texas is taking against Pennsylvania,
Georgia, Michigan and Wisconsin for electoral fraud !!
GREAT DAY !!
That’s not true. The US Supreme Court just acknowledged that they received the filings.

9 Likes 1 Share

Re: Supreme Court Rejects GOP's Bid To Nullify Biden's Win In Pennsylvania by Bigchristo: 5:51am On Dec 09, 2020
Johnnyessence:


Rushing To Judgement And Media Gaslighitng.
Guys, do not let the mainstream media gaslight you concerning
the SCOTUS case filed by some Republicans in Pennsylvania.
Note that this is separate from the one filed by Texas now
joined by other States (more on that later).
The media is now GASLIGHTING people that the SCOTUS has
thrown out the case of these Republicans. They are
desperately doing their best to dampen the spirit of
Republicans.
That is simply not true. The case is still alive and well before
SCOTUS.
Yes, the SCOTUS has DENIED a big ask made by the
Republicans to "overturn" the election result in the
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania.
The Apex Court denied the "emergency injunctive relief"
because it was too radical and would be unprecedented for a
Court to "overturn" the result of an election. But you need to
know that the substantive case is STILL PENDING before the
Court because it has not been heard on the merit.
The injunctive relief was denied by Justice Alito (and not by
the Full Court). Justice Alito denied the injunctive relief to
pave way for a determination of the case on the merit.
See photos 1 and 2 attached below.
Photo 2 is the injunctive relief denied.
In other words, for emphasis, the substantive case has not
been thrown out. Senator Ted Crus will still get to argue before
SCOTUS.
See this link to show that it is still on the Court's schedule;
https://www.supremecourt.gov/search.aspx?filename=
%2Fdocket%2Fdocketfiles%2Fhtml%2Fpublic%2F20a98.html
Interestingly, the Republican Plaintiffs in their Appeal have
also asked the SCOTUS to ADVISE THEM ON OTHER RELIEFS
THAT MAY BE AVAILABLE TO THEM.
That general prayer or ask is what we should watch out for.
What reliefs would the SCOTUS be willing to grant if their case
succeeds on the merit?
SCOTUS could rule that the case succeeds on the merit and
then restore power to appoint Pennsylvania Electors back to
the Pennsylvania Legislature as per the US Constitution under
the Electors Clause instead of the Pennsylvania Secretary of
State.
Guys, this case is not over!
Immediately the news broke that SCOTUS has thrown out the
case in its entirety, I knew something wasn't right.
Why would SCOTUS accept to hear the case on the merit,
docket it and then dismiss it without a hearing?
It just didn't make any sense.
It didn't make sense because it never happened.
The case is still pending. The Court merely denied one radical
injunctive relief preliminarily. Period.
More information to come on the new States that joined Texas
in their lawsuit at the SCOTUS.
stop wasting your time writing full episodes,Trump has lost the election it’s so difficult for him and the republicans to concede defeats he is only trying to make gullible people like you to believe his illegal claims about electoral fraud, he doesn’t have any tangible evidence to backup this claim that’s why his entire lawsuit are being tossed out of court room

36 Likes 1 Share

Re: Supreme Court Rejects GOP's Bid To Nullify Biden's Win In Pennsylvania by Authoreety: 5:54am On Dec 09, 2020
E no concern me
Re: Supreme Court Rejects GOP's Bid To Nullify Biden's Win In Pennsylvania by Simplebeauty: 5:55am On Dec 09, 2020
grin
Re: Supreme Court Rejects GOP's Bid To Nullify Biden's Win In Pennsylvania by sandland: 5:55am On Dec 09, 2020
After the safe harbor day, Dec. 8th, no court in Us can overturn a certified result.
Re: Supreme Court Rejects GOP's Bid To Nullify Biden's Win In Pennsylvania by RuddyFusion(m): 5:58am On Dec 09, 2020
Johnnyessence:
Senate resolution to recognize Joe Biden as the real
president-elect failed to pass.
The Inaugural Committee voted down a resolution by House
Majority Leader Steny Hoyer (D-MD) on Tuesday naming
Democrat presidential nominee Joe Biden president-elect,
with all three Republican members voting against it.
yes the Texas case is different but will be treated same by Supreome Court as it seeks same end. Even the drama of GOP Senate and House lawmakers won't change anything ,......

10 Likes

Re: Supreme Court Rejects GOP's Bid To Nullify Biden's Win In Pennsylvania by sandland: 5:59am On Dec 09, 2020
After the safe harbor day, Dec. 8th, no court in Us can overturn a certified result. That is why they requested for the injunctive suit which have failed.

4 Likes 1 Share

Re: Supreme Court Rejects GOP's Bid To Nullify Biden's Win In Pennsylvania by Lifeisgoody: 5:59am On Dec 09, 2020
Trump chasing shadows

2 Likes

Re: Supreme Court Rejects GOP's Bid To Nullify Biden's Win In Pennsylvania by bluefilm: 5:59am On Dec 09, 2020
Of course, they don't want to expose how DEAD people voted for Biden.

Evil Satanists.

2 Likes

(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (Reply)

Kenya's Supreme Court Upholds William Ruto's Presidential Victory / USS Abraham Lincoln Aircraft Carrier Exits Red Sea After Attacks Off Yemen Coast / Jan 6: Donald Trump Has Absolute Immunity On Official Acts - US Supreme Court

(Go Up)

Sections: politics (1) business autos (1) jobs (1) career education (1) romance computers phones travel sports fashion health
religion celebs tv-movies music-radio literature webmasters programming techmarket

Links: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10)

Nairaland - Copyright © 2005 - 2024 Oluwaseun Osewa. All rights reserved. See How To Advertise. 49
Disclaimer: Every Nairaland member is solely responsible for anything that he/she posts or uploads on Nairaland.