Stats: 3,183,679 members, 7,921,455 topics. Date: Thursday, 15 August 2024 at 05:31 AM |
Nairaland Forum / Nairaland / General / Religion / Islam for Muslims / Misconception: Death For Apostasy (3128 Views)
Misconception Of Salat Tarawih: Bid'a or Sunnah? / The Punishment Of Apostasy In Islam Part I: By Dr. Ahmad Shafaat / Misconception In Islam: Alcohol Is Forbidden In All Forms (2) (3) (4)
Misconception: Death For Apostasy by Rilwayne001: 5:28pm On Nov 08, 2013 |
Misconception: Death for apostasy Background: Some think that once you are a "muslim" if you decide to change your beliefs you are considered an apostate, an act punishable by death! The Quran clearly states there are those who believe then disbelieve, then believe again, then disbelieve again. This proves death for apostasy simply did not exist, because if it did, it would be impossible to believe again after unbelief, as they would have been put to death after the first unbelief: Surely (as for) those who believe then disbelieve, again believe and again disbelieve, then increase in disbelief, God will not forgive them nor guide them in the (right) path. [4:137] This is further proven by the following verse: How can God guide a people who have rejected after believing, and they witnessed that the messenger is true, and the clarity had come to them? God does not guide the wicked people. [3:86] The Quran states, in no uncertain terms, that there is no compulsion in religion: Let there be no compulsion in religion: Truth stands out clear from Error: whoever rejects evil and believes in God has grasped the most sure hand-hold, that never breaks. And God is Hearing, Knowing. [2:256] The Quran states that God could have made all those on earth believe, thus asks who is man to enforce such a thing if God did not: And if your Lord had pleased, surely all those who are in the earth would have believed, all of them; will you then force men till they become believers? [10:99] The Quran states there were those who believed part of the time, then disbelieved part of the time in order to confuse and sow discord amongst the believers of the time. If death for apostasy existed, no sane minded person would attempt to do this as they would be killed the very first time they tried it: A section of the People of the Book say: "Believe in the morning what is revealed to the believers, but reject it at the end of the day; perchance they may (themselves) Turn back. [3:72] Please also see the clear example set out in 4:88-91, in which the believers are told to offer peace with those who became hypocrites/apostates (i.e. were Muslim in name only but did not follow through with action during hostilities/fighting in this case) if they also offer peace. To conclude, it is clear that 'death for apostasy' does not exist in The Quran. People are free to believe and live their lives accordingly or not. If a community or system or any structure deprives its members of this basic freedom, it will produce hypocrites and suppressed people who have no strength of belief or goals to work for and will likely result in a weak system or community. Freedom of belief is the air that healthy and just communities breathe. |
Re: Misconception: Death For Apostasy by usermane(m): 6:42pm On Nov 08, 2013 |
Thanks man. I hope those muslims who subscribe to teachings that condemn apostates to death will learn. Killing apostates was actually an innovated jewish ruling which 'muslims' who did not truely accept the Qur'an, adopt post prophet Muhammad 's death. Last week i watched a gruesome video of muslims slaughtering an apostate while chanting: "Allahu akbar" and reciting their "khuthba". And long before then i 've been hearing of countless of such satanic acts perpeterated by the so called muslims. Only disbelievers, evil and wicked persons believe in killing of apostates. |
Re: Misconception: Death For Apostasy by Rilwayne001: 7:31pm On Nov 08, 2013 |
There are two Islams in the world today. (1) There is the Islam of the Qur'an, which is one of the great religions of the world. It is a religion of peace (not of pacifism nor of aggression) and of divine justice (not of divine tyranny nor of divine intimacy). (2) There is also the Islam of the terrorists, who are murderers and assassins, especially murderers of their fellow Muslims. Shiites and Sunnis hate each other for their "heresies" more intensely than either hates the West. (The London bombings deliberately targeted Muslim neighborhoods.) Which of these two Islams (of the Qur'an or of the terrorists) will prevail? God only knows. But to whateverextent the first Islam is from God, it will prevail because God will prevail. |
Re: Misconception: Death For Apostasy by Rilwayne001: 7:33pm On Nov 08, 2013 |
May God Guide us to his Right Path, not of those who went astray |
Re: Misconception: Death For Apostasy by usermane(m): 7:15am On Nov 09, 2013 |
Rilwayne001: There are two Islams in the world today. (1) There is It is an understatement to say that only those who turn to christianity or atheism get put to death. Shocking enough, orthodox or traditional muslims consider even "Qur'an alone" muslims as apostates and mark them for killing. This is why you hardly find scholars of Qur'an alone,the true Islam openly preaching except on internet and a few cases in the West where Qur'an 2:256 is applied even more than the Middle east. Such muslims put their life at a risk because they are termed as apostates to be killed by traditional muslims. |
Re: Misconception: Death For Apostasy by tbaba1234: 7:42am On Nov 09, 2013 |
I think it is important that people get proper knowledge in Islam before talking. What are 'Quran only' muslims? That is against the Quran itself. Usermane, You can not seperate the Quran from its context or the example of the messenger (peace be upon him). @Rilwayne.. I think you should get deeper understanding on these issues first before making posts. |
Re: Misconception: Death For Apostasy by usermane(m): 8:16am On Nov 09, 2013 |
tbaba1234: I think it is important that people get proper knowledge in Islam before talking. What are 'Quran only' muslims? That is against the Quran itself. Brother, what is "ahlul sunna" or "sunni?", it goes against the scriptural teachings. Please address the OP, let us not derail the thread. "Killing of apostates by muslims", that is the bone of contention. Peace. 1 Like |
Re: Misconception: Death For Apostasy by tbaba1234: 8:26am On Nov 09, 2013 |
usermane: Ahlul sunnah means those that follow the way of the messenger. The quran tells us that we should follow the best of examples. You can choose not to use labels, but the quran asks you to follow the example. As regards the topic, the op has not presented the full picture. |
Re: Misconception: Death For Apostasy by usermane(m): 8:48am On Nov 09, 2013 |
tbaba1234: Ok tbaba12345, the name you call yourself is irrelevant. The question is what do you believe and preach. What more do we need from the OP? Is there anything like "Death for apostates/murtads" in the System of God? Also isnt it true that majority of muslims and their clergymen who claim to follow the messenger, put apostates to death? Is there a single verse in the Qur'an that orders for killing apostates? All through the narrations in the final testament,killing in the name of religion is a common practice of disbelievers. 'Abraham', the pagans wanted to kill for rejecting their religion,Moses, Jesus, and even Muhammad face death threats from the disbelievers. 1 Like |
Re: Misconception: Death For Apostasy by tbaba1234: 9:14am On Nov 09, 2013 |
usermane: Question: What was the punishment in the Quran for those who worshipped the calf amongst the children of Israel? Answer that first... After that we can delve into a proper understanding of what this means. |
Re: Misconception: Death For Apostasy by usermane(m): 9:59am On Nov 09, 2013 |
tbaba1234: There are lots of multiple meaning words in the Qur'an. The Isrealites who worshipped the calf were not ordered to be killed as the verse 54 of chapter 2 is traditionally mistranslated. Moses asked them to turn in repentance to God and deal with their idolatory ego or tendencies. Don't forget that God already forgave them in verse 52. How then after God forgave them could they still be killed? Then again Moses asked them to repent, and what next? Kill them? That is impossible. So the Qur'an nvr penalised apostates with death. U can answer my questions and address the issue on ground. Am upset that you agree that muslims who turned away from Islam should be killed. But you don't agree that those who leave Christianity for Islam should be killed by christians. |
Re: Misconception: Death For Apostasy by Nobody: 10:13am On Nov 09, 2013 |
tbaba1234: It sounds like you believe Apostates should be murdered,If that is so;let's hear it,Opinions you can't state confidently and straight-forward are not worth having;trying to talk from both sides of the Mouth only makes you look like a Fool. |
Re: Misconception: Death For Apostasy by usisky(m): 10:45am On Nov 09, 2013 |
tbaba1234: koonbey: Of course he does. In spite of the countless quranic evidences given in the op, you still would hear Tbaba and his ilk retort by citing their much chrished HADITH(mismash of hearsay literature) as their response. They do not follow the message(Quran) delivered by prophet Muhammad(this is prophetically put in Quran 25:30-31). Instead, they follow some conjectural works of men that surfaced some two centuries after the death of Muhammad- they call it Hadith/Sunna. Anyways, i have challenged him to a debate on few occasions, but he wouldn't man-up and accept it simply because he has no proof for what he follows. They call us who acknowledge the message of quran alone heretics. My challenge still stands........ |
Re: Misconception: Death For Apostasy by usisky(m): 11:11am On Nov 09, 2013 |
[size=13pt] Peace to all!! @op. Thank you for this wonderful exposé. In fact, i had plans to initiate a thread on the subject, but you beat me to it. I am glad to see some people embracing rationality over illogicalities. This subject is very important, as this alone can clearly indicate to learned audience on who are the ones that represent GOD and those that represent the DEVIL. Even without a scripture or religion, commonsense as well as our innate knowledge of what's wrong or right dictates to us that it's inhuman to put death another person simply because he/she denounces your way of faith(unconditionally). Your exposition above is sufficient for the open-minded ones. My only pity is for the millions of muslims around the globe who have no shred of idea the religion they're professing. Here is an earlier thread on the same subject. Hear what sheikh Tbaba and sheikh Maclatunji have to say: tbaba1234: ^ So what have you proven with your post? This kind of ignorance worries me. I don't know if you are a christian, but if you are, you do know that the christian nation practiced a far more brutal aspect of the law for centuries. maclatunji: culled from: Kill Anyone who backslides from Islam [/size] 1 Like |
Re: Misconception: Death For Apostasy by tbaba1234: 2:26pm On Nov 09, 2013 |
usermane: ![]() ![]() There are no multiple meanings here.. The leaders of those who worshipped the calf were killed. Apostacy law is still in the Jewish scriptures and was practiced in Christianity for centuries. In Islam, it is not black and white. The first thing to say is that in islam, there is no compulsion in religion, The Quran(translated) states: Let there be no compulsion in religion: Truth stands out clear from Error: whoever rejects evil and believes in Allah hath grasped the most trustworthy hand-hold, that never breaks. And Allah heareth and knoweth all things. (Quran 2:256) However in an Islamic state, there are certain conditions where conversion is accompanied with acts that could be considered treasonable by the state. The punishment for treason is death. The act of just conversion is not punishable in most cases, however if that conversion is accompanied by an attempt to discredit Islam or propagate another religion within the islamic state, It is considered treasonable. The apostacy law came about during the time of the prophet; In order to discredit Islam, some Jews in medina would accept islam in the day and leave by sunset; They continued to do so until the law was put in place. Guess how many people did so the next day? None, Look at the apostacy law this way; Acts against the nation are considered treason aren't they? what is punishment for treason in 9ja? The constitution of an Islamic state is based on Islam; If i live in the state, i abide by its laws; If someone leaves Islam in an Islamic state for whatever reason, as long as he doesn't go around opening flaunting his belief/unbelief or trying to convert muslims. He is fine. Otherwise, It is treasonable. He can live his life, he doesn't have to pray or fast if he doesn't want to.. Besides, the person is not just executed, he speaks to the scholars about his doubts and is provided evidences about the divinity of the Quran so as to convince him, (for three days) if that fails, he is threatened basically to shut him up from proselytizing disbelief in an Islamic state. If he relents, he is let go and can continue in his disbelief and live his normal life. |
Re: Misconception: Death For Apostasy by usermane(m): 3:28pm On Nov 09, 2013 |
tbaba1234: You should know by now, that the Jews distorted verses of the Torah. The first five books of the Old testament is not the exact book Moses received. And the Christians,neither have to follow the Torah nor are they following the true Gospel. They are following the teachings of St. Paul. None of the four gospels in the new testament order killing apostates. And Final testament 2:51-54, didn't tell us that Moses killed the leaders of the apostates. Even mere reading the verse chronologically will tell you this. Moses had them repent and God forgave them. Every idol worshipper is responsible for his disbelief. There is no such excuse as; "he was the one who lead us to it". You see why i said understanding the Qur'an has more to do with critical thinking and sincerity than learning arabic? For whatever reason killing of apostate is not by any means in accordance with Qur'anic teachings, Qur'an 2:256 sums it up. That is why you can't find a single verse to support that innovation. Who cares whether they balge in and out of Islam with hypocrisy, certainly there are other means of tackling that aside killing, in which case even innocent apostates that mean no harm get killed too. God even permit people to believe, then disbelieve,beleive again, then disbelieve(Qur'an 4:137) and you still support killing apostates? And then call yourself a muslim? |
Re: Misconception: Death For Apostasy by usermane(m): 4:04pm On Nov 09, 2013 |
Even if a person leave Islam and start preaching against Islam, there is no injunction according to God 's revealations to kill such a person for as long as he kills nobody. How can you kill me for turning away from your religion? Religion is not based on blind faith and constantly defending clearly evil doctrines. Religion is based on empirical evidences and morality. If you truely accept the scripture,obey and love the messenger, you cannot advocate for killing an apostate. |
Re: Misconception: Death For Apostasy by tbaba1234: 4:47pm On Nov 09, 2013 |
![]() ![]() Read the piece carefully.. I. The punishment is not just for changing your religion. Ii. It is for making a public show of it. No one will drag you out of your house if you refuse to pray. Just live with your disbelief without disturbing people. The wisdom in this is simple. Imagine there are five apostates who left islam discretely without making a show of it this year. Next year, there might just be five more etc .. There is no exponential rise. If those five make a public show of this.. Next year, there will be 10 or 15 and it grows exponentially. A perfect example is the growth of homosexuality in the west. An Islamic state is there to protect the faith and interests of muslims and provide the best environment to practise faith. The only arguments against this can only be emotional not rational. 2 Likes |
Re: Misconception: Death For Apostasy by khattab02: 12:25am On Nov 10, 2013 |
As salamu alaikum wa rahmatullahi wa barakatuh to all. Jazakallahu khairan too. This is a very very important topic. Will be back. |
Re: Misconception: Death For Apostasy by cloudstar: 3:00am On Nov 10, 2013 |
So, how do we explain verses in the Hadith that state otherwise. For example: Bukhari, volume 9, #17 "Narrated Abdullah: Allah's Messenger said, "The blood of a Muslim who confesses that none has the right to be worshipped but Allah and that I am His Messenger, cannot be shed except in three cases: in Qisas (equality in punishment) for murder, a married person who commits illegal sexual intercourse and the one who reverts from Islam (Apostate) and leaves the Muslims." Bukhari, volume 9, #57 Narrated Ikrima, "Some atheists were brought to Ali and he burnt them. The news of this event, reached Ibn Abbas who said, "If I had been in his place, I would not have burnt them, as Allah's messenger forbade it, saying, "Do not punish anybody with Allah's punishment (fire)." I would have killed them according to the statement of Allah's Messenger, "Whoever changed his Islamic religion, then kill him." Bukhari, volume 9, #58 Narrated Abu Burda, "Abu Musa said.....Behold there was a fettered man beside Abu Musa. Muadh asked, "Who is this (man)?" Abu Musa said, "He was a Jew and became a Muslim and then reverted back to Judaism." Then Abu Musa requested Muadh to sit down but Muadh said, "I will not sit down till he has been killed. This is the judgment of Allah and his messenger," and repeated it thrice. Then Abu Musa ordered that the man be killed, and he was killed. Abu Musa added, "Then we discussed the night prayers ..... These verses confirm that when a muslim changes his religion, he should be killed. This is contrary to the OPs post. Can anyone shed some light on this |
Re: Misconception: Death For Apostasy by cloudstar: 3:06am On Nov 10, 2013 |
usermane: Even if a person leave Islam and start preaching against Islam, there is no injunction according to God 's revealations to kill such a person for as long as he kills nobody. The hadith of Al-bukhari states otherwise. |
Re: Misconception: Death For Apostasy by cloudstar: 3:14am On Nov 10, 2013 |
usisky: Islamic teachings are not based on the Quran alone. Simple example: 1. Praying 5 times a day is not in the Quran but the hadith, yet every muslim including you obey this teaching 2. Going on the Hajj is another example and there are many other examples So, it's not correct to say true muslims use the Quran alone to know it's teachings. |
Re: Misconception: Death For Apostasy by tiarabubu: 8:32am On Nov 10, 2013 |
tbaba1234: Tbaba cannot clearly defend his position without saying "Christians too did it". Well, Usermane, a Muslim, has given you a very good answer. And I hope you can learn from him the fine art of focused debates. I find this debate really interesting because the killing of apostates is one of the major source of friction between Islam and the rest of the world. It doesn't shock me that in this day and age tbaba will believe in these inhuman, violent and cruel practices - threatening and killing apostates. I cant imagine how confusing a man can be trying to project the benevolence and beauty of Islam and at the same time agreeing that apostates could be threatened and killed. I have been following Usisky and Usermane for sometime. I intend to research their opinions deeper. interesting...... |
Re: Misconception: Death For Apostasy by Rilwayne001: 10:59pm On Nov 10, 2013 |
cloudstar: So, how do we explain verses in the Hadith that state otherwise. For example: Read the post very well, only the quran is the right source for islamic matters, we cant depend on the hadith bcourse it has been distorted...peace. |
Re: Misconception: Death For Apostasy by Rilwayne001: 11:03pm On Nov 10, 2013 |
tbaba1234: Imagine wat you just said, if the xtianx have been practisin the same abeg what will be your reaction? |
Re: Misconception: Death For Apostasy by usermane(m): 11:09pm On Nov 10, 2013 |
tbaba1234: The hadith books rejected by the messenger and God Almighty(Qur'an 6:112-116, 7:185, 31:6, 45:6) did not list any condition to be met before killing apostates unlike some traditional muslim clergy apologists like those in this section tell us. As far as i can tell, the hadiths are explicit; 'Kill anyone who leave Islam'. But am glad tbaba had the gut to address the Op,even though he failed to defend his man-made rulings. No better than he are his likes out there who boycott threads like these that exposes their faults but rush to threads that praise them and their man-made beliefs. In accordance with the Qur'an, Islamic state or not, apostates are not penalised with death. OP has quoted enough verses. If a person leaves your religion, preaching and criticizing it, the best you can do is to begin preaching for your religion and refuting the apostates 's criticism. If you are upholding the TRUTH, the apostate will never succeed in leading believers astray. Truth is always distinct from falsehood. God promised to establish his religion above all the others. Start killing apostates and you end up with hypocrites who will silently and secretly corrupt your religion, eventually turning away multitudes of believers. Clearly tbaba1234 cannot prove with a substantial or even meagre evidence from the only message of the messenger of God: Qur'an, that death for apostate is part of Islam. In essence tbaba and his likes disbelieve in Qur'an and according to their sunni religion, they are apostates and should be killed. 1 Like |
Re: Misconception: Death For Apostasy by usermane(m): 11:22pm On Nov 10, 2013 |
cloudstar: Dear, what you will do for the sake of keeping this thread focused on it topic is to go and get your answers from here: https://www.nairaland.com/1493271/ten-misconception-among-muslims |
Re: Misconception: Death For Apostasy by cloudstar: 4:17pm On Nov 11, 2013 |
Rilwayne001: Which of the Hadiths has been distorted? 1 Like |
Re: Misconception: Death For Apostasy by cloudstar: 4:25pm On Nov 11, 2013 |
usermane: It is not my intention to derail it, I am asking simple questions. Thanks |
Re: Misconception: Death For Apostasy by Rilwayne001: 8:49am On Nov 15, 2013 |
cloudstar: Any hadith that doesnt get it source from the Quran Especially those hadith dat support what is absent in the Quran |
Re: Misconception: Death For Apostasy by cloudstar: 8:23pm On Nov 15, 2013 |
Rilwayne001: Please list the hadiths |
Re: Misconception: Death For Apostasy by beejaay: 5:12pm On Nov 17, 2013 |
tbaba1234: are u directly saying that Meccans agression towards the prophet during the early days of Islam was right cos he Muhammed was also commiting Treason by preaching that which contradict the practise of the traditional meccans..... there is a saying that says"he who want equity must come to equity wth clean hands".. if the early muslim fight against their persecution by meccans because they are propagating their own religion (if God could called the meccans unbelievers for persecuting the early muslim as apostate), people should have right to accept or de-accpet (english hard ooo) whatever they want and they have the right to propagate that which they believe in without persecution (cs Prophet Muhammed also said unpainted words to the pagans of meccans threatening them will hellfire of different kinds)... there is nothing like Islamic state (Islamic state simply means no free-will again which go against the preaching of the Quran) |
Allah Said Muhammad Is In Jews And Christians Scriptures: Is It True? / Explaining The Fundamentals Of Faith : Shaykh Ibn Uthaymeen Chapter 2 / Pray For the Palestinians-Gaza Under Renewed Israeli Aggression
(Go Up)
Sections: politics (1) business autos (1) jobs (1) career education (1) romance computers phones travel sports fashion health religion celebs tv-movies music-radio literature webmasters programming techmarket Links: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) Nairaland - Copyright © 2005 - 2024 Oluwaseun Osewa. All rights reserved. See How To Advertise. 139 |