Welcome, Guest: Register On Nairaland / LOGIN! / Trending / Recent / NewStats: 3,208,590 members, 8,003,057 topics. Date: Friday, 15 November 2024 at 06:06 AM |
Nairaland Forum / Nairaland / General / Religion / What Kick-started My Atheism: The Stumper Questions. (2942 Views)
Is Atheism The Way? I Am Searching For Answers / From Atheism To Jesus: My Testimony / Atheism : The Actual Fulfillment Of This Prophecy (2) (3) (4)
What Kick-started My Atheism: The Stumper Questions. by Nobody: 10:34am On Jan 06, 2015 |
Those who know me personally (especially those who knew me 3-2 years back) can't stop to wonder how I, the once chivalrious youth who defended and preached the gospel as though I had been told that the rapture was the next minute, would suddenly become an Atheist. Even if I took a time travel back to inform the ME of 3-2 years ago that I'd eventually lose faith in the Jewish Deity, I would've given 'ME' a hot slap. The current and incessant inquiry I keep getting from my friends and family is "What changed you? What took you away from God?" I must say, I've lost a huge number of my friends due to this and sadly, won't be getting them back any time soon but I will not pretend to believe in what is proven to be outrightly false and ridiculous just because I wish to keep my friends. How long will it last? It's only my true friends (some of whom are Muslims, Christians, Agnostics, Atheists, Trad, e.t.c) that I have left. So, back to the reason for the thread, WHY did I lose faith in the Jewish Deity? What triggered that effontery? Admittedly, it was really hard thinking back to where it all started. I mean, I didn't give it much thought until recently when I got an eureka moment after viewing one of my old Facebook profiles and viewed all my messages (old and lost) before stumbling upon that wonderful conversation. It was filled with familiar questions that I believe at least 90% of Christians have [at one point] had troubles answering but shoved aside. 1.) "Where did Cain get a Wife?" My reply [as most honest Christian replies would be] was: "I dunno, but I believe God must have created them (the nations he went to) aside for him or perhaps, the people of those nations were also descendants of Adam" Then he threw some Nagasaki bombshells: "If they were created aside, that is to say, not born of Adam who is purported to be the Father of mankind, why is the Adamic Curse such as Death, Labour pain, e.t.c equally binding on them as well since they neither tasted the forbidden fruit nor were they born of Adam (thus inheriting the sin and the curse)?? And if they were indeed Adam's Descendants, does it mean that during Adam's lifetime he was able to give birth to nations and Cain, being the first son, witnessed this happening and was still a marriable youth when they had grown to marriable ages (since he went to get a wife from from a people he watched grow) And yes, does it mean that the world was populated by the means of in-cest??!" 2.) Lastly, you want me to believe that in the course of Human history; which your Bible says is just 6000 years ago, over 75 Billion People descended from just two Humans Think about it Oh boy, that was evidently too much for me but I made it appear as though it was nothing (most Christians do that) so I shoved it aside and gave him the "God works in mysterious ways" kind of answer. But deep down, I knew it made absolutely no sense at all; it was too absurd to come from an All-Knowing God. I traced that conversion to have been the start of my journey out of the age-old delusion. 1 Like |
Re: What Kick-started My Atheism: The Stumper Questions. by Nobody: 10:42am On Jan 06, 2015 |
and you have chosen the wrong part 1 Like |
Re: What Kick-started My Atheism: The Stumper Questions. by tonnieblaise(m): 10:42am On Jan 06, 2015 |
**clears throat**....so o what do you want us to do now? 2 Likes |
Re: What Kick-started My Atheism: The Stumper Questions. by Nobody: 10:48am On Jan 06, 2015 |
Have a chat with a real Jehova Witness and you'd get the answers to these questions. Trust me. |
Re: What Kick-started My Atheism: The Stumper Questions. by malvisguy212: 10:55am On Jan 06, 2015 |
I copy the answer I reply to an atheist, about Cain and hia wife; it's a choice,you love God or you Reject Him,concerning the wife of cain;bible does not specifically say it only cain and abel was the son of adam,. Although Cain does seem to be the firstborn, the text is not clear that Abel was the second born, but only that he was the second son. Later, the narrative indicates that Adam and Eve produced "other sons and daughters." So, it is possible that Adam and Eve produced daughters between the births of Cain and Abel. It is also likely that others sons and daughters were produced after the birth of Abel. We don't know how old Cain and Abel were when Cain murdered his brother, but they seem to be at least young adults, since they are both engage in a trade. for their living. Although the period of time between the birth of Cain and the death of Abel is not given in the Bible, it would seem that this period was probably over 100 years, since the birth of Adam's next son, Seth is said to have occurred when Adam was 130 years old. Adam and Eve could have produced many daughters during that period of time. It is possible cain would have marry one of this sister, the law of incest was not giving meaning it not a theological problems, Paul say''as long as there is no law there is no violation of law or sin. Adam and his children does not have genetic defeat in them because they are in a state of perfection Adam,eve,methusalah, Cain,Noah ,seth, all died at a goog old age around 900years upwards because they are in a perfection,but when there genetic defeat started, Abraham,Isaac,Jacob and Moses died below 200,infacte it was the time of Moses God oder him to number isreal and each man with his family after that God gave the law of incest. |
Re: What Kick-started My Atheism: The Stumper Questions. by spacyzuma(m): 10:55am On Jan 06, 2015 |
This is gonna be interesting. I'm curious to read the rest of Reiyvinn's story. |
Re: What Kick-started My Atheism: The Stumper Questions. by Hiswordxray(m): 10:55am On Jan 06, 2015 |
I'm just wondering, why did you write this post? To me, no amount of Bible contradictions or inaccuracies can annul my encounter with God. When you don't know somebody and all you have is a written book about him there is a high tendency to disbelieve his existence. But how can you meet a person and still believe he doesn't exist. Tell me that God doesn't exist is like saying the father who gave birth to you, took care of you, watch you grow up does not exist. It absolutely ridiculous. How can you see, touch, feel, hear and know somebody and yet still believe he doesn't exist because a book written about him is inaccurate. Your problem my friend is that you didn't know God, all you knew was the Bible. It a pity. I grieve for you my friend. 3 Likes |
Re: What Kick-started My Atheism: The Stumper Questions. by Nobody: 10:56am On Jan 06, 2015 |
lilmaxfidel: The last time I checked, there are over 4200 "paths" (or religious beliefs) and mathematically speaking, chosing the right path will be 1/4200. (Even worse than "baba ijebu" premium lotto) Furthermore, if there was a god out there who wants humans to worship only him/her/it and disregard the over 1 Millions god of many other religions, that god would have to come out with significantly irrefutable proof of his/her/its existence rather than leave humans to kill themselves and each other over books written by scientifically and intellectually fact-deficient Stone Age goat rearers. 6 Likes |
Re: What Kick-started My Atheism: The Stumper Questions. by Nobody: 11:09am On Jan 06, 2015 |
No10: That's the same response I get from JWs I meet online. I didn't tell you that I have 3 Uncles who were one Rank-and-File and two Elders. I have had discussions with lots of them on this topic and of course, added nothing but more salt to the wound. There's alot you don't know about what you believe in and the Watchtower Organization will do everything in their power to make sure you don't find out. Recommended reads: JWFacts, SilentLambs, [url=http=http://jwsurvey.org]JWSurvey[/url] and Watchtower Quotes (I know you won't even dare click them, you're programmed to run away from them so never mind) 2 Likes |
Re: What Kick-started My Atheism: The Stumper Questions. by undercat: 11:12am On Jan 06, 2015 |
You're being a little too hasty here. There are religions other than christianity. Non christian does not equal atheist, you know. If you reject YHWH, what about the other forms of God? Your bible based objections certainly don't apply to them. If these are the only objections you have, I'm afraid you are not atheist. And how sure are you that atheism is not the delusion? You know that once you admit to the possibility that God exists, you admit that you might be wrong, at the very least. At most, you would have conceded that God exists, according to one nasty variant of the ontological argument. The issue of whether Adam and Eve could have populated the earth in 6000 years was recently raised on here, and it was discovered that they can, mathematically. Assuming that they have two children who both go on to have two chlidren each who also go on to have two children each, and assuming they do this every 30 years, then in 6000 years the offspring of Adam and Eve would have become 2^200, which is probably enough to populate even Jupiter. This is why you need more objections. Reiyvinn: 1 Like |
Re: What Kick-started My Atheism: The Stumper Questions. by Busybody2(f): 11:14am On Jan 06, 2015 |
Hiswordxray: To answer your query in bold - it's because they need a hand behind their back to gently guide then and steer them in the right direction. So you are on the right path by telling Mr Reiyvinn that God is not just an entity in the Bible alone so he should desire a personal encounter with him 2 Likes |
Re: What Kick-started My Atheism: The Stumper Questions. by Nobody: 11:17am On Jan 06, 2015 |
Hiswordxray: But you'd cry "foul!" when a Muslim, Buddhist and Hindi tell you the same about his/her encounter with his/her God(s). Sounds legit! When you don't know somebody and all you have is a written book about him there is a high tendency to disbelieve his existence. But how can you meet a person and still believe he doesn't exist. Same as above. I believe Buddhist shouldn't be wrong in saying that Buddha is the Almighty God of the Universe, right? How can you see, touch, feel, hear and know somebody and yet still believe he doesn't exist because a book written about him is inaccurate. Now that's absolutely ridiculous! Tell me, how does God fell? Is he soft or hard? Is he light skinned or dark? Pleeease! 2 Likes |
Re: What Kick-started My Atheism: The Stumper Questions. by Nobody: 11:18am On Jan 06, 2015 |
Reiyvinn:. Hahahhaha. What makes u think I won't? . Am not a witness btw,jst love their articles and the way they seem to have answers to some of these questions. I'd certainly click those links. |
Re: What Kick-started My Atheism: The Stumper Questions. by Hiswordxray(m): 11:30am On Jan 06, 2015 |
Reiyvinn:I won't cry foul if a person of another religion claim the same thing. I would simply tell them my God is the Almighty not theirs and if they argue then we can go into a contest to prove which God is stronger. But anyway, you can believe what you want to believe. I just want you to know that the God you claim does not exist is my friend and we walk together. Just because you didn't see something doesn't mean it does not exist. You can't claim to have seen everything that exist in this world but you can choose to believe what you want. 1 Like |
Re: What Kick-started My Atheism: The Stumper Questions. by johnydon22(m): 11:43am On Jan 06, 2015 |
Hiswordxray:And how did you know yours is the almighty and not theirs? This is what the op means ever religion think theirs is the almighty and they all claim to have a personal encounter with this their friend and walk with him.(whatever that means) Anyways no emotional strings attached or sentiments... am just pointing out a few points for you! carry on bro 4 Likes |
Re: What Kick-started My Atheism: The Stumper Questions. by Nobody: 11:45am On Jan 06, 2015 |
undercat: I didn't say this was the sole reason for my Atheism. I said this was the kick-starter. The seed of doubt planted gave me the effontery to research into Theism in general. Remember I said this was 3 to 2 years ago. Alot can happen within that time. However, I'm even considering being a Pastafarian. I'd rather worship the Flying Spaghetti Monster than love a god that kills innocent children just to prove a point; I'm to humane for that! (fortunately, such a god only exists in books and minds, not in reality: i.e. A fairy-tale) |
Re: What Kick-started My Atheism: The Stumper Questions. by Weah96: 11:57am On Jan 06, 2015 |
Mary told her boyfriend that she was impregnated by God. And the nigga believed it, because he allegedly had a dream and God spoke to him in the dream. That was the one that I couldn't overlook. It made me realize that whoever wrote the book expected a sheep like audience. How can married men believe that rubbish story? 4 Likes 1 Share |
Re: What Kick-started My Atheism: The Stumper Questions. by spacyzuma(m): 11:58am On Jan 06, 2015 |
Reiyvinn: hahaha. I'm agnostic, but I am kinda a fan of the Invisible Pink Unicorn: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Invisible_Pink_Unicorn "Invisible Pink Unicorns are beings of great spiritual power. We know this because they are capable of being invisible and pink at the same time. Like all religions, the Faith of the Invisible Pink Unicorns is based upon both logic and faith. We have faith that they are pink; we logically know that they are invisible because we can't see them." — Steve Eley I believe all religion is man-made. Created to explain the things in their environment that they did not understand. And somehow, some smarter people used religion and idea of all-powerful, invisible deities to control and manipulate people around them. And somehow, it got out of control. I mean, I just had to research the history of Invisible Pink Unicorn, or Scientology, or Mormons (Latter Day Saints) or some Nigerian churches to realize this. One common factor is that they are all founded by one/few strong persons with larger-than-normal charisma with a lust/desire for power/control over other people. 2 Likes |
Re: What Kick-started My Atheism: The Stumper Questions. by johnydon22(m): 11:58am On Jan 06, 2015 |
Reiyvinn:Hahahahahahaha pastafarian atleast u will be worshipping something u can eat...spaghetti... hahahahahahaha 2 Likes |
Re: What Kick-started My Atheism: The Stumper Questions. by Nobody: 12:04pm On Jan 06, 2015 |
malvisguy212: Now here is the problem. God exiled Cain to NATIONS!! To purport that Adam and Eve could've produced Nations between Cain and Abel would make it even weirder. Do you know how many years it takes to raise such multitude? Hey. How old would Cain be by then-- even to the point of being able to till the ground!? Think again, dude. It's obvious the writers of that account were presenting Cain and Abel as the first two children of Adam before any other. Furthermore, why would the Children between Cain and Abel be sent away from their family to make up a Nation (or Nations) elsewhere? Have you forgotten that according to that same account, when Yahweh cursed Cain, he placed a mark on his; an identifying mark to the Nations so that he doesn't get killed when seen?? Does that sound like Cain being sent to his distant Family members . . .the law of incest was not giving meaning it not a theological problems, Paul say''as long as there is no law there is no violation of law or sin. That's laughable at all levels because if every human that exists is a descendant of Adam and Eve, there will forever be in-cest. Regarding Adam being a perfect being, do you seem to make it that Adam retained his perfection even after falling in the garden? Are you really preaching the Bible or something else Lastly, let me reiterate this again: Do you want us to believe that over the course of just 6000 years, over 75 Billion people had descended from just two humans [with a ratio of over over 75 Million per Year since the days of Adam]? 3 Likes |
Re: What Kick-started My Atheism: The Stumper Questions. by godsgift233: 12:17pm On Jan 06, 2015 |
Reiyvinn: good write up. i concord bro 3 Likes |
Re: What Kick-started My Atheism: The Stumper Questions. by godsgift233: 12:34pm On Jan 06, 2015 |
undercat: When you understand why you dismiss all the other possible gods, you will understand why we (atheists) dismiss yours. 2 Likes |
Re: What Kick-started My Atheism: The Stumper Questions. by malvisguy212: 1:01pm On Jan 06, 2015 |
Reiyvinn:you can't comperd. The days of Adam with present days,I gave you an example, men can stay long uptil 900 years, DO YOU THINK THIS IS NOT ENOUGH TO FILL IN A NATION? Brother 900 years is enough for a nation to be filled up. Cain dos not have genetic defeat in him, so I repeat, that is not a theological problems. I gave you a prove of perfection, man adam and the rest die at a good old age but Abraham downward die 200 downward, still bible say they died good old age, Adam were in a state of perfection step by step, he loos everything. |
Re: What Kick-started My Atheism: The Stumper Questions. by Weah96: 1:05pm On Jan 06, 2015 |
malvisguy212: Which kyn technology was keeping human beings alive for 1000 years? Did they have different cells in their bodies from our own human cells? |
Re: What Kick-started My Atheism: The Stumper Questions. by malvisguy212: 1:10pm On Jan 06, 2015 |
Weah96:you can google the scientists that are around during that period. |
Re: What Kick-started My Atheism: The Stumper Questions. by malvisguy212: 1:16pm On Jan 06, 2015 |
Reiyvinn:I copy this from one of my thread. Agnostics often fall into two camps - those who believe that all religions can lead to God or those who believe that true religion cannot be discerned. This page examines both positions in an attempt to determine where the truth may lie. Logically, there are several possibilities. Atheists would say that no religion leads to God, since He doesn't exist. It is possible that one, several or all religions lead to God. ALL WAYS LEAD TO GOD: There are hundreds of religions in the world today, and many ancient religions that are no longer practiced. It is possible, and perhaps likely, that all religions contain some truth and/ or good moral advice. However, in examining religious teaching, it is important to examine the fundamental beliefs of each religion and compare those to each other. When this is done, it is apparent that primary religious teachings contradict each other. Judaism says that the Messiah is coming, Christianity says that He has come, and Islam says that Mohammad provided all the information necessary for religious life. Obviously, these truth claims cannot be simultaneously true, since they contradict each other. Logically, we must reject the idea that all religions lead to God. TRUE RELIGEON:IS IT POSSIBLE TO DISCERN? I believe that there are some things that we can discern about God from the nature of the universe. The universe demonstrates some remarkable evidence of design. What kind of God designed all this, and how can we know His true identity? Most people who believe God exists would agree with the argument that the God who designed the universe must be a personal God. For God to put so much time and care into the design of the universe and life, it would seem logical to conclude that God really cared about His creation, and was personally involved in it's creation. A God who did not care about his creation would never be expected to spend 14 billion years of development just so that humans would have a nice place to live for a few thousand years. Therefore, it would seem likely that the true God must be a personal God, and not the God of deism, pantheism, Buddhism, etc. So, it would seem that these religions probably do not represent the true nature of God. ELIMINATE THE ILLOGICAL: The powerful and personal Creator God of the universe would probably want to reveal Himself to His spiritual creatures. So, it seems likely that God would have revealed His true nature to one or more of the peoples of the earth. Are all the revelations of the world religions a reflection of God or just certain one(s)? This is the difficult question that cannot be answered in merely one short page. However, I believe one can come up with a best answer through much study and through the process of elimination. For example, some religions make truth claims that are obviously false. The LDS church (Mormons) claims that gods are created through procreation and that creatures created by those gods can eventually become gods themselves. However, this religion suffers from the problem of how the first god came into existence. Logic would dictate that God is eternal and uncreated. All religions that claim otherwise would seem to be logically flawed. BASIC RELIGEON CLAIM: Since many religious claims contradict one another, it would seem that not all religions could be simultaneously true. How can we tell which religion(s) are true? If you examine the world religions, most describe ethical and moral laws that are ascribed to God. Breaking of those laws is an offense to God. How do different religions handle that problem? Many religions say that if one tries to obey God's laws most of the time, God will accept you. However, I believe that we can eliminate that idea as being true of the Creator God of the universe. God designed physical laws of the universe. These laws are constant and unbreakable. God Himself, seems to break those physical laws only rarely. I propose that this God would not accept the breaking of His moral laws so easily. In fact, from the nature of the physical laws, it would seem that God would not accept the breaking of His moral laws at all. Nearly all religions claim that God will ignore our breaking of His moral laws as long as we try our best. This is where Christianity differs from all other world religions. Christianity says that our good works cannot erase our bad moral choices. Think of it in terms of our legal systems. We are convicted of crimes on the basis of breaking the law. If we break a law, we are found guilty under the law. It doesn't matter what good things we have done in our lives, if we break the law. We might get a lesser sentence, but we will still be convicted of a crime. So, God cannot simply ignore our crimes against Him. We will be found guilty, despite our good works. Christianity says that our bad deeds (sins) must be eliminated in order to be acceptable to God. The elimination of sins was accomplished by the sacrifice of the Savior (Jesus Christ). Jesus Christ is God Himself, who came to earth, led a sinless life, and died on the cross as a sacrifice to take the sins of mankind. So, God Himself provided a means of eliminating our sins against Him. However, the elimination of sins is not automatic. Since God will allow people into His presence after death, they must agree to His terms. This contract is executed through faith in the sacrifice of Jesus Christ to eliminate our sins. By accepting God's terms, our sins are erased and we can stand in the presence of God without any sin. Only our good deeds will be counted for our judgment. Those who don't accept God's terms will be judged on the basis of God's laws - and will be found guilty. CHRISTIANITY IS DIFFERENT : No other religion provides a provision for God's forgiveness of sin, which is why I believe Christianity to be the only true way to God. Jesus said He is the only way to God and that all people must follow Him to enter heaven. All other religions are man's attempt to become acceptable to God. Only Christianity says that God alone provides the only means to be acceptable to Him. So, either Christianity is true and all other religions are false or Christianity is false and God does not hold people accountable for law breaking. Personally, I would not want to rely upon God ignoring His own rules. It doesn't seem to be logical reasoning. This is the choice you must make. CONCLUSION: So, I encourage you to examine the world religions to see if what I am saying is true. Don't give up on the ability to separate the truth claims of the world's religions. If Christianity is true, you must make a choice or you will be judged on the basis of your sins against God. Let me know if you have any questions. 1 Like |
Re: What Kick-started My Atheism: The Stumper Questions. by Nobody: 1:36pm On Jan 06, 2015 |
malvisguy212: 1.) Even as silly and mythical as it sounds, I'll play along with the folly and debunk the folly from its very own folly. According to Genesis 5:3, Seth who came long after Cain and Abel was born when Adam was 130 years old. Thus, to hammer more nails to that Coffin, Adam was around (i.e slightly under or over) 100 when he had Cain and Abel. Again I ask, Did Adam and Eve Conceive A Whole Nation Within This Period don't forget that Adam didn't produce Cain when he was 1 or 10, and since Cain and Abel had already become men long before seth was born, it's apparent that least 40 should be cut from Adam for Cain, being the firstborn and at least 12 for Abel thus, even the 130 is under reduction; leaving the NATIONS with about 130 - (40 + 12) = 130 - 52 = 78 to be raised from just one generation Can anything be more ridiculous than this I hope you're seeing the balderdash yourself. 2.) Regarding in-cest, you still don't get the point, do you? Ignoring the fact that you presented no evidence of in-cest being once-not-a-gentic-problem, you seem to forget that if all men descended from Adam, every marriage (including your mum and dad) is incest. 5 Likes |
Re: What Kick-started My Atheism: The Stumper Questions. by godsgift233: 2:40pm On Jan 06, 2015 |
An atheist doesn’t have to be someone who thinks he has a proof that there can’t be a god. He only has to be someone who believes that the evidence on the God question is at a similar level to the evidence on the werewolf question. 6 Likes |
Re: What Kick-started My Atheism: The Stumper Questions. by undercat: 2:46pm On Jan 06, 2015 |
godsgift233: Meaningless statement. The rationale for atheism is very clear. Unless you are assuming that anybody who understands it must then become an atheist, that statement is so meaningless. Not everybody is easily swayed, man. |
Re: What Kick-started My Atheism: The Stumper Questions. by undercat: 2:56pm On Jan 06, 2015 |
Reiyvinn: You are probably right, but even within this your reply you are still referencing the christian God. However, I'm even considering being a Pastafarian. I'd rather worship the Flying Spaghetti Monster than love a god that kills innocent children just to prove a point; I'm to humane for that! (fortunately, such a god only exists in books and minds, not in reality: i.e. A fairy-tale) Then worship the Flying Spaghetti Monster, if you must. You don't have to worship anything at all, however, being an atheist. |
Re: What Kick-started My Atheism: The Stumper Questions. by godsgift233: 3:04pm On Jan 06, 2015 |
undercat: To understand via the heart is not to understand. A favorite of mine, in a similar vein to the Seneca the Younger quote: “If we go back to the beginning we shall find that ignorance and fear created the gods, that fancy enthusiasm or deceit adorned them, that weakness worships them, that credulity preserves them, and that custom respect and tyranny support them in order to make the blindness of men serve their own interests". 6 Likes 1 Share |
Re: What Kick-started My Atheism: The Stumper Questions. by spacyzuma(m): 3:10pm On Jan 06, 2015 |
godsgift233: I love, LOVE!, this statement! Thanks for sharing it. 1 Like |
5 Solid Proves That God Exists / The Atheists Were Right! / Evolution And Christianity. Hold It Right There!
(Go Up)
Sections: politics (1) business autos (1) jobs (1) career education (1) romance computers phones travel sports fashion health religion celebs tv-movies music-radio literature webmasters programming techmarket Links: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) Nairaland - Copyright © 2005 - 2024 Oluwaseun Osewa. All rights reserved. See How To Advertise. 130 |