Welcome, Guest: Register On Nairaland / LOGIN! / Trending / Recent / New
Stats: 3,174,475 members, 7,891,982 topics. Date: Wednesday, 17 July 2024 at 12:01 AM

Senate Can’t Summon IGP - Falana - Politics (6) - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum / Nairaland / General / Politics / Senate Can’t Summon IGP - Falana (22527 Views)

Ondo: Wike Blast IGP, Falana Over Harassment Of Deputy Governor / Accidental Discharge: Reps Summon IGP, NSCDC Boss / Why Senate Can’t Impeach Buhari – Senator Ahmed Lawan (2) (3) (4)

(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (Reply) (Go Down)

Re: Senate Can’t Summon IGP - Falana by deomelo: 6:43pm On May 12, 2018
aribisala0:


You are a dunce ,get out of my face .

Jackass!

Can you tell your parents they are childish?

M.oron!!



No need to downgrade into gutter insult and childish tantrums because you couldn't come up with any credible and intelligent comeback per the poster's superior argument.

1 Like 1 Share

Re: Senate Can’t Summon IGP - Falana by aribisala0(m): 6:53pm On May 12, 2018
deomelo:




No need to downgrade into gutter insult and childish tantrums because you couldn't come up with any credible and intelligent comeback per the poster's superior argument.


Are you gay?
Re: Senate Can’t Summon IGP - Falana by deomelo: 6:59pm On May 12, 2018
Contempt of Congress

Definition

Congress has the authority to hold a person in contempt if the person's conduct or action obstructs the proceedings of Congress or, more usually, an inquiry by a committee of Congress.

Contempt of Congress is defined in statute, 2 U.S.C.A. § 192, enacted in 1938, which states that any person who is summoned before Congress who "willfully makes default, or who, having appeared, refuses to answer any question pertinent to the question under inquiry" shall be guilty of a misdemeanor and subject to a maximum $1,000 fine and 12 month imprisonment.

Before a Congressional witness may be convicted of contempt, it must be established that the matter under investigation is a subject which Congress has constitutional power to legislate.

Generally, the same Constitutional rights against self-incrimination that apply in a judicial setting apply when one is testifying before Congress.


https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/contempt_of_congress



1. In America where we borrowed and copied democracy from, they have within their constitution what they call, Contempt Od Congress to specifically address and discipline people when they transgress against summon orders issued by the Congress.

2. The Nigerian Senate has similar authority, so why are they not sitting any relevant part of our constitution that says the IG must appear before them or face contempt charges?


3. They know they have zero jurisdiction based on the highlighted in the above quote and this is what Mr. Falana highlighted, the Nigerian senate obviously saw their own transgressions and shortcomings, hence their inability to sanction the ID or charge him with contempt.


4. It is very sad that this grossly incompetent Nigerian Senate is wasting our time and resources on silly and self-serving issues on an ongoing criminal investigation and trial of one of their members, something they should be a million miles away from, something they shouldn't be in any way talking about because of appearance of partiality and conflict of interest.

4. The Senate is off base because this issue has nothing to do with the Senate, Dino can address any ill-treatment by the Nigerian police by presenting his case before the judiciary for redress.

Mr. Falana ave the clueless, ignorant and incompetent Nigerian Senate a face-saving way out and they really need t thank him.

1 Like 1 Share

Re: Senate Can’t Summon IGP - Falana by BRIGHT180(m): 6:59pm On May 12, 2018
Amacaco:
Someone should tell Falana that he is lying and turning the constitution upside down. He should apply for the position of a Judge and give his interpretations of the law the way he likes but as a lawyer he is deceiving the unlearned and playing politics. He is so so so so wrong on this.
Am not a lawyer so If you say he his wrong show sections of the constitution to back up your claim and correctly interpret the sections he misinterpreted

1 Like 1 Share

Re: Senate Can’t Summon IGP - Falana by deomelo: 7:01pm On May 12, 2018
aribisala0:

Are you gay?



The fact that you are gay and you feel threatened by superior arguments doesn't mean other people are gay. Curb your gay outreach and tendencies.

1 Like 1 Share

Re: Senate Can’t Summon IGP - Falana by Twy: 7:21pm On May 12, 2018
jamace:
Well, that section is clear enough that the IGP can be summoned by the NASS except our lawyers have special interest to make it ambiguous. grin
the truth is that it is not clear, the only wording supporting them is inefficiencies and others relate to waste or misuse of funds. Why I said it is because that constitution was a military imposed constitution and there are some ppl who believe it needs many adjustments. I see some even writing America, they know little about there country. The constitution is not perfect and has never been perfect. I can honestly tell you that the word inefficiency is ambiguous out of the four reasons given, three are about corruption or waste.

1 Like 1 Share

Re: Senate Can’t Summon IGP - Falana by wirinet(m): 8:33pm On May 12, 2018
If you read the wordings of the letter to the IG, it was primarily to embarrass the IG over the treatment of Dino Melaye by the police, it has nothing to do with carrying out their legislative duties

The Senate went further to implicate itself by stating that the case is already before a competent court of law. The Senate is prohibited from deliberating on any case already before a competent court of law.

1 Like 1 Share

Re: Senate Can’t Summon IGP - Falana by Lordspenzo(m): 9:51pm On May 12, 2018
aribisala0:


How is he an authority? based on what?

Even if he is a socalled authority
Don't these "authorities" regularly adopt different positions in court?

If he was correctly quoted then indeed he misquote the constitution by omission and incompletely quoting it as i have already posted earlier on this thread.

The Senate is empower to summon ANY PERSON IN NGERIA for investigation on any matter which it has the power to make laws for the purpose of exposing corruption as Falana said but also exposing inefficiency or waste which he omitted.


It is very clear

1. Power to summon ANY PERSON in Nigeria
2. For invstigation of
3 > any matter on which it has legislative competence.


The summons ticks all the boxes and the ssummons is in order constitutionally
bro its ok,no need of pouring water on stone..even u explain til tomorow dey wil refuse to understand...zombie dats wat de are..cant imagin nigerians saying senate have no power to summon d i.g a pubic servant..even wen its clearly stated in d law..realy at any cost education is cheaper dan ignorance
Re: Senate Can’t Summon IGP - Falana by Lordspenzo(m): 9:57pm On May 12, 2018
wirinet:


Extend your bolded words a bit and you will understand what Falana (SAN) is talking about.

The powers conferred on the National Assembly under the provisions of this section are exercisable only for the purpose of enabling it to -

expose corruption, inefficiency or waste in the execution or administration of laws within its legislative competence

Now was the IG invited to expose corruption, inefficiency or waste in the execution or administration of laws or even in the disbursement or administration of funds? NO! They invited the IG to come and explain the inhumane treatment given to Dino Melaye. Now how is Dino Melaye inhumane treatment a legislative affair. It is more of a judiciary affair than a legislative affair. Or is the senate now taking over the functions of the judiciary?
bro the matter under discourse is if d nass have jurisdiction to summon d igp, a govt appointee..forget d dino wahala..he can choose to ignore questions regarding dino
Re: Senate Can’t Summon IGP - Falana by lumenkristy: 10:09pm On May 12, 2018
My greatest joy in all these is that one day IGP will account of his stewardship before his Maker then he will left with no choice. Amend your life while you have time
Re: Senate Can’t Summon IGP - Falana by SirBunky85(m): 11:53pm On May 12, 2018
Pierohandsome:
I disagree with Falana on this, Senate cn summon the president not to talk of ordinary IGP .

The Senate arm is for checks and balances, the IGP is an appointee who is answerable to the people and can be summoned by the people thru the senate.

Mr Falana, i disagree with u on this.
abeg shift.so u now sabi the constitution pass prof.ben nwabueze who said same thing dat falana just said?una go just dey form online constitutional lawyers
Re: Senate Can’t Summon IGP - Falana by SirBunky85(m): 11:55pm On May 12, 2018
GavelSlam:


Provide sections of the constitution to back your claim.
dont mind dat attention seeker
Re: Senate Can’t Summon IGP - Falana by SirBunky85(m): 11:59pm On May 12, 2018
anibirelawal:



As in extremely worst, set of Selfish power mongers.
atymes,I dont blame bukky for all dese nonsense from the senate cuz,I feel d pdp senators and some rebel apc senators who made him d senate presido always threaten him to do dia bidding or risk being removed through same coup dat brought him in
Re: Senate Can’t Summon IGP - Falana by anibirelawal(m): 6:32am On May 13, 2018
SirBunky85:
atymes,I dont blame bukky for all dese nonsense from the senate cuz,I feel d pdp senators and some rebel apc senators who made him d senate presido always threaten him to do dia bidding or risk being removed through same coup dat brought him in


So, he is a puppet senate presido.
Re: Senate Can’t Summon IGP - Falana by SirBunky85(m): 9:42am On May 13, 2018
anibirelawal:


So, he is a puppet senate presido.
sth like dat

(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (Reply)

APC Primaries: Tinubu Ill Informed About Oshiomhole - Okorocha / Isaac Fayose: Atiku Plans To Install Emirs In Southern Nigeria / Pictures From PDP Presidential Rally In Katsina

Viewing this topic: 1 guest(s)

(Go Up)

Sections: politics (1) business autos (1) jobs (1) career education (1) romance computers phones travel sports fashion health
religion celebs tv-movies music-radio literature webmasters programming techmarket

Links: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10)

Nairaland - Copyright © 2005 - 2024 Oluwaseun Osewa. All rights reserved. See How To Advertise. 31
Disclaimer: Every Nairaland member is solely responsible for anything that he/she posts or uploads on Nairaland.