Welcome, Guest: Register On Nairaland / LOGIN! / Trending / Recent / New
Stats: 3,218,538 members, 8,038,271 topics. Date: Friday, 27 December 2024 at 12:21 PM

Test Your English Proficiency Here (picture) - Education (5) - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum / Nairaland / General / Education / Test Your English Proficiency Here (picture) (55504 Views)

LAUTECH Online Transcripts And Letter Of English Proficiency / 7 Keys To Writing A Story That Scores High In Your English Exams / Test Your English Proficiency Here (2) (3) (4)

(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (Reply) (Go Down)

Re: Test Your English Proficiency Here (picture) by RabbleRouser1: 10:41pm On Jan 06, 2018
BiafraBushBoy is needed here.
Re: Test Your English Proficiency Here (picture) by femeritus: 10:44pm On Jan 06, 2018
ExplicitContent:
Simple -The daughter was the one drunk.

In the sentence it says, 'beat her daughter because she was drunk' .

"because" serves as a conjunction between "daughter" which is a noun following over with the word "she which is an adverb all referring to the daughter..

So the person drunk was the daughter.
"she" is not an adverb please. It's a pronoun.
Re: Test Your English Proficiency Here (picture) by eminent007(m): 10:48pm On Jan 06, 2018
okonja:
The mother is drunk because a mother in her right sense would not beat her daughter for no reason. cool

Bros, r u Nigerian?
Re: Test Your English Proficiency Here (picture) by marischerry(f): 10:50pm On Jan 06, 2018
it is either the mother was drunk or the daughter got beaten by the mother because she was drunk, in English it is called ambiguity
Re: Test Your English Proficiency Here (picture) by Eazy08100(m): 10:52pm On Jan 06, 2018
Check dis out frm my student

1 Like

Re: Test Your English Proficiency Here (picture) by bigtt76(f): 10:55pm On Jan 06, 2018
A mother beat up her daughter because she was drunk ....replace the phrase 'she was drunk' with an adjectival noun phrase 'of something', the new sentence becomes

"A mother beat up her daughter because of something" ....what is that 'something' ==> Getting drunk which qualifies the reason behind her daughter getting a beating ....her daughter was drunk cheesy



igraman:
Check this out.
Let's have your answer.
it has generated a lot of arguments here.

2 Likes

Re: Test Your English Proficiency Here (picture) by femeritus: 10:55pm On Jan 06, 2018
This is ambiguity in action and contrary to what some have said, the sentence is grammatically correct but semantically ambiguous.

The pronoun, "she" can semantically refer either to the mother or the daughter and that's why one of the best ways to disambiguate a sentence is by rephrasing the whole sentence or by repeating a part of the sentence.

Using repetition method, the sentence would be,

The mother beat her daughter because the daughter was drunk.

Or

The mother beat her daughter because the mother was drunk.

2 Likes

Re: Test Your English Proficiency Here (picture) by molesky(m): 10:56pm On Jan 06, 2018
Its very obvoius that this is ambiguous statement with a dangling modifier,so the person drunk here is not certain, its like saying "SLOW DOWN MEN AT WORK" who suppose to slow down,motorist or men at work?
Re: Test Your English Proficiency Here (picture) by Nobody: 10:58pm On Jan 06, 2018
HeyCorleone:
Obviously it's the mother.

"a woman beat her daughter because she was drunk". Drunk qualifies the woman.
The daughter.
Re: Test Your English Proficiency Here (picture) by deeLima86(m): 10:59pm On Jan 06, 2018
All these niggas wey dey form English tutor and 'rip english' on top people head for this forum nor of dem waka come. grin
Re: Test Your English Proficiency Here (picture) by Nobody: 11:01pm On Jan 06, 2018
molesky:
Its very obvoius that this is ambiguous statement with a dangling modifier,so the person drunk here is not certain, its like saying "SLOW DOWN MEN AT WORK" who suppose to slow down,motorist or men at work?
It's not ambiguous. Use a cause and effect to determine the answer.

Who was beaten? The daughter
Why was she beaten? Because she was drunk

The "because" there already tells us why the action took place. The daughter is on the receiving end. Slow down men at work doesn't fit with this. The "because" changes the whole thing
Re: Test Your English Proficiency Here (picture) by Nobody: 11:03pm On Jan 06, 2018
One of the many reason i don't like english
Re: Test Your English Proficiency Here (picture) by nduchucks: 11:03pm On Jan 06, 2018
The person who constructed the sentence has already failed the proficiency test.

A proficiently constructed sentence is typically devoid of ambiguities which fail to effectively communicate the message which the writer put forth.
Re: Test Your English Proficiency Here (picture) by Reeberry: 11:06pm On Jan 06, 2018
I see no sense in it when you beat a drunk person. Wait till the drunkness is over the person.

Na who drunk Sabi inself.grin
Re: Test Your English Proficiency Here (picture) by alexmakaay(m): 11:07pm On Jan 06, 2018
had it been it says "THE" mother.. it means the daughter is drunk but it says "A" mother, it is still talking about the mother.. so the mother is drunk.
Re: Test Your English Proficiency Here (picture) by momove4real25(f): 11:11pm On Jan 06, 2018
lipsrsealed lipsrsealed
Samirana360:
d two both of them join together d mother and the daughter

.....
buh its d mother dats drunk coz u can't beat ur daughter becoz she(ur daughter) is drunk
bad niga spotted
Re: Test Your English Proficiency Here (picture) by Reeberry: 11:12pm On Jan 06, 2018
sway112:
All of them are drunk...
The mother ooo
The daughter 000
The bar man* ooo
Even Okada man that dropped the drunkard
All of them... Drunk
I take God beg you. I no wan laugh abeg.grin
Re: Test Your English Proficiency Here (picture) by momove4real25(f): 11:12pm On Jan 06, 2018
Eazy08100:
Check dis out frm my student
F9 parallel
Re: Test Your English Proficiency Here (picture) by Lucky1981: 11:14pm On Jan 06, 2018
It is syntactically right but grammatically assumes two meanings i.e, it is ambiguous.
Re: Test Your English Proficiency Here (picture) by LustreChris(m): 11:15pm On Jan 06, 2018
As a linguist, this is what we call Structural Ambiguity, where the sentence construction, I mean, the way and manner a sentence is structured brings about more than one meaning.

There is no definite answer. It depends on the way one goes about to analyse the sentence.

#TreeDiagram...
Re: Test Your English Proficiency Here (picture) by Shafiiimran99: 11:16pm On Jan 06, 2018
Mother or daughter. Because she (mother) was drunk. Correct . Because she (daughter) drunk. Correct also. Either way
Re: Test Your English Proficiency Here (picture) by donaldfafree(m): 11:16pm On Jan 06, 2018
Oga don't take it personal
Elesu:
I think it's the foolish daughter that drank till she became drunk.

Cc: Lalasticlala
Re: Test Your English Proficiency Here (picture) by skot: 11:26pm On Jan 06, 2018
She is the answer cos it was SHE that was drunk
Re: Test Your English Proficiency Here (picture) by isahkadir1(m): 11:29pm On Jan 06, 2018
This is an ambiguous statement, it could be the mother or the daughter since the pronoun "she" qualified both the mother and her daughter.
Re: Test Your English Proficiency Here (picture) by Birminghamvirgo(m): 11:34pm On Jan 06, 2018
i think it's the mother coz If it was to be the daughter the it would have been "she got drunk" and not bcoz "she was drunk "
Re: Test Your English Proficiency Here (picture) by stieyven(m): 11:36pm On Jan 06, 2018
Elesu:
I think it's the foolish daughter that drank till she became drunk.

Cc: Lalasticlala
He who calls his brother a fool shall be in danger of hell. Matthew 5 :22
Re: Test Your English Proficiency Here (picture) by longleg(m): 11:40pm On Jan 06, 2018
A MOTHER
Re: Test Your English Proficiency Here (picture) by chronique(m): 11:49pm On Jan 06, 2018
A mother beat her daughter cos she was drunk. Daughter is the one being spoken/talked about.

A mother, beat her daughter, cos she was drunk. Mother is the one being spoken about.
Re: Test Your English Proficiency Here (picture) by notoriousbabe: 11:53pm On Jan 06, 2018
Wetin concern me,if she like make she kill am
Re: Test Your English Proficiency Here (picture) by guiddoti: 11:57pm On Jan 06, 2018
Inglish dey one kind sha
Why would the woman beat her daughter because she (the woman) is drunk or it's proper for the woman to beat her daughter because she (the daughter) is drunk
When I examined these two ladies- the woman and her daughter, both are "stupid". How do we decide who is drunk? grin
Re: Test Your English Proficiency Here (picture) by woodfrank(m): 11:59pm On Jan 06, 2018
HeyCorleone:
Obviously it's the mother.

"a woman beat her daughter because she was drunk". Drunk qualifies the woman.

Correct.
Re: Test Your English Proficiency Here (picture) by BrotherJesu(m): 12:02am On Jan 07, 2018
Elesu:
I think it's the foolish daughter that drank till she became drunk.

Cc: Lalasticlala




nawa o, u don vex. Its jst an example ehn.

(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (Reply)

Lagos Shuts Down Chrisland School Indefinitely Over Sex Tape Of Minors / No Reopening Of Schools For Now – Presidential Taskforce On COVID-19 / 2013 Jamb Results Remarked???

(Go Up)

Sections: politics (1) business autos (1) jobs (1) career education (1) romance computers phones travel sports fashion health
religion celebs tv-movies music-radio literature webmasters programming techmarket

Links: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10)

Nairaland - Copyright © 2005 - 2024 Oluwaseun Osewa. All rights reserved. See How To Advertise. 32
Disclaimer: Every Nairaland member is solely responsible for anything that he/she posts or uploads on Nairaland.