freecocoa: Wait o, he has no legs does that mean his girlfriend was safe if it was really a case of burglary that would make him forget they were two in the house? He must really be a selfish person and the gun would be in the bedroom joor let's be real.

Coogar be honest, you were with a woman you loved in the house and an intruder came, what would you do?

I don't quite understand the your last paragraph, he knew she was in the bathroom and still shot?

slim poppa: Its nothing but premeditated murder.
He woke up, didn't bother to check the woman sleeping beside him, put on his prosthetic legs, armed himself and went towards the bathroom and fired four shots. He didn't also hear scream from the bathroom, went back to the room only for him to discover that the woman wasn't there. He's a POOR LIAR.
Witnesses testified they heard loud arguements followed by gunshots, loud scream and more shots seventeen minutes later.
He killed that woman intentionally. Forget!

that there was no urine in her bladder at 3am suggests pistorious' story was correct that she was in the bathroom. humans would normally have urine in their bladder at 3am - the only puzzle is if he pulled the trigger intentionally or accidentally....

Lord_Reed:
Please post a link.

ItsModella:
He's INNOCENT until proven guilty...go figure!!

whealthy:

If found guilty at trial, Pistorius faces a life sentence.
What do you think? Premeditated murder or not?

chukkynwob: Sincerely if my girlfriend was in bed with me and I suspect the house is being burgled the 1st thing to do LOGICALLY

1. Grab my piece
2.Ascertain the relative position of my girlfriend so she won't be cut in the crossfire that might ensue.
3.Warn the intruder that I am armed
4. Fire awayyyyy!!!!

Personally I think the evidence and circumstances against Oscar suggests premeditated murder.I don't believe his story.

He is still assumed innocent until proven guilty,for it is better to let 1000 guilty people free,that to wrongly convict an innocent man

exxell:

Not Funny... Try harder next tyme. Like my comment if you think that this gif is plain over used and dull!

RICHIE BOI:

You go fear some forensic experts for NL . this guy story just doesn't add up. some grey areas and holes in his story. a well orchestrated one i must say.

Lord_Reed:
Please post a link.
Look at this pix of Pistorius' house:

[img]http://static.independent.ie/incoming/article29078253.ece/ALTERNATES/h342/pistorius-house.jpg[/img]

You can see it flanked by 2 other houses. So how can his neighbours be 600m away?

Josh316:

God bless your brain cells...

Afam4eva:
You can only not believe him if you were there when it happened. He's innocent until proven otherwise. It's because of this reason that there's jungle justice in Nigeria because instead of finding out if someone is innocent or guilty, you just rush the person chanting kill am, catch am, die.

ELgordo: Damn! I hate to be the Judge buh its like that white dude killed the white purrtty lady . . . He's a cold KILLA!

freecocoa: Agreed, it may have been pitch dark and he might have thought she was in bed.

Now a man with someone in the house, not just anyone but his girlfriend o, hears a sound in the bathroom, suspects burglary and he goes shooting without alerting his woman?

I'd like to think that what any normal person would do then is, tell whoever you are at home with to be on the alert or possibly go into hiding, before going on a shooting spree.

Now since there was no urine in her bladder, what was she doing in the bathroom? I'm tempted to believe a version of this story that says he pursued her there. No?

freecocoa: Wait o, he has no legs does that mean his girlfriend was safe if it was really a case of burglary that would make him forget they were two in the house? He must really be a selfish person and the gun would be in the bedroom joor let's be real.

Coogar be honest, you were with a woman you loved in the house and an intruder came, what would you do?

I don't quite understand your last paragraph, he knew she was in the bathroom and still shot?

Sybellah:

why? following your logic, i can only believe him if i was there as well
not believing and judging are 2 different things.
"i do not believe him" is different from saying "he is guilty"
in order to convince, he need to bring some evidence on the table
even the judge who will be in charge of the case have an initial opinion, still he wasnt there during the crime
and his decision would be based on further evidence, not on the fact of if "he was there or not"
somebody also said on this thread "the neighboor were lying about hearing screams from his house"
this person already judged the neighboors as liar
again did he need to be there before giving his opinion as well? no

Sybellah:

why? following your logic, i can only believe him if i was there as well
not believing and judging are 2 different things.
"i do not believe him" is different from saying "he is guilty"
in order to convince, he need to bring some evidence on the table
even the judge who will be in charge of the case have an initial opinion, still he wasnt there during the crime
and his decision would be based on further evidence, not on the fact of if "he was there or not"
somebody also said on this thread "the neighboor were lying about hearing screams from his house"
this person already judged the neighboors as liar
again did he need to be there before giving his opinion as well? no

andyanders: Pistorious has no excuse at all to say he mistook her to be an intruder when he knew it was only two of them in the house as at the time he said he mistook the person to be an intruder. He has n explanation to do. How can he kill an unarmed lady and started crying only when he was arrested? That goes to show that he is a complete fool and should not be given any sympathy. He knew what he was doing= Jealousy. He was too possessive hence his action.
I believed that he must have been having an argument with the lady, he used the baseball bat to heat her and she rushed into the toilet. He now went for his gun and shot her 4 times.
In fact, this has taught me something in life and that is never to love out of sympathy as you will end up regretting it. This lady loved him out of sympathy and ended up paying with her life.

Another lesson is never we blame God the way he created us because He has reasons for every of the creature He made. This man never took his state of health into consideration and thank God for helping him to be who he is, but ended up allowing devil to use him.
Pistorious came with a disability, the world stood by him and this lady gave her life to him despite his state of health and he ended up showing the world who he is and as such, must also be given the maximum sentence for his action.

iyabde: He did it!!!!

coogar: his explanation makes loads of sense......
this is why he's likely to be bailed tomorrow when the court proceeds. he's disabled and he was without his prostheses when he got up in the night to close the windows. a man without his artificial legs who perceives there's an intruder in his house would feel vulnerable. getting his gun and shooting is very reasonable!

coogar:

except that the autopsy has been done and there was no single sign of assault on the body of the girlfriend. if you are not an eye witness, you are a lie witness. repent and delete the nonsense you typed above.

coogar:

i don't work with assumptions - you are clearly assuming the gun was in the bedroom - something you are not sure of. if the gun was in the bedroom, how did he find the gun when he already explained the room was dark? he could find a gun in the bedroom and yet he couldn't tell if his girlfriend was there? freecocoa, you really think the gun would be in the bedroom? seriously - you need yoghurt.



i doubt anyone would accurately tell you what they would do in this situation. unless you have been placed in the situation, forget this question. besides, that you would choose another method to deal with the situation does not mean your twin sister would do the same. people react differently to emergency situations!



i am saying the autopsy report said the girlfriend had no urine in her bladder which is contrary to what the prosecution is saying. if pistorious chased her girlfriend into the bathroom before shooting her at 3am then she should have urine in her bladder, no?

freecocoa: As far as I'm concerned, his excuse doesn't make enough sense.

Correct me if I'm wrong though.

-You got up to close window or whatever.

-Closed the window and was going back to bed then heard some noise.

-Went back to the room to get your gun.

-Went straight to the bathroom and fired 4 shots.

Now how can someone go to get his gun from the bed and not notice his girl wasn't there?

When he shot, didn't she shout or something?

I have too many questions but I don taya joor.