Welcome, Guest: Register On Nairaland / LOGIN! / Trending / Recent / NewStats: 3,207,778 members, 8,000,265 topics. Date: Tuesday, 12 November 2024 at 07:01 AM |
Nairaland Forum / Nairaland / General / Politics / Foreign Affairs / Who Has The Strongest Military In Africa? (4565066 Views)
Iran Vs Israel: Who Has The Strongest Military ? / Evidence That Putin Is Strongest Man And Obama Is A Filthy Whimpering Dog / Which Country Has The Strongest Economy In Africa. (2) (3) (4)
(1) (2) (3) ... (107) (108) (109) (110) (111) (112) (113) ... (2991) (Reply) (Go Down)
Re: Who Has The Strongest Military In Africa? by andrewza: 8:32am On Mar 18, 2013 |
agaugust: south Africa is wasting its time and money to modify and upgrade a half d.ead Rooivalk helicopter gunship project. You cannot compete in international market against Russia and America. South Africans always over- rate themselves, that's why they always get disappointments and final defeat. The rooifalk was only ever marketed to turky but lost due to them wanting somthing used by NATO. No other county was in the market for a fresh production helicopter while the production line was open. The sytems used on the rooifalk form the bass of the Hind upgrade program that we do. So it was not a waist. No one bought our airfram yes but they have bouth every thing else. |
Re: Who Has The Strongest Military In Africa? by Nobody: 8:38am On Mar 18, 2013 |
agaugust: Awesome new air power of great Nigeria Giant Of AfricaThis shiit is cray |
Re: Who Has The Strongest Military In Africa? by andrewza: 8:40am On Mar 18, 2013 |
Henry120: I do have to agree with my compatriot agaugust. Why has the south african rooivalk failed so much. Apart from south africa and maybe zimbabwe, I do not know of any other country in africa that use the rooivalk or even the lynx for that matter. They have the same sytem has the hinds agreia uses. We upgraded them. The airfram has not sold but all the sytems, avionics, wepaons, rotar blads, seat extra have been put in hinds. They called Supper hinds. The hind used in the movie blood diomonds and lord of war belonged to SA. It even flown by SAAF so we know what the hind can and can not do. The super hind (the SA upraded hinds) are even better than some of the russian hinds. Though russia has started a upgrade program. The rooifalk was all so upgraded last year. |
Re: Who Has The Strongest Military In Africa? by agaugust: 8:44am On Mar 18, 2013 |
. |
Re: Who Has The Strongest Military In Africa? by agaugust: 8:45am On Mar 18, 2013 |
. |
Re: Who Has The Strongest Military In Africa? by andrewza: 8:48am On Mar 18, 2013 |
agaugust: . Source. |
Re: Who Has The Strongest Military In Africa? by andrewza: 8:50am On Mar 18, 2013 |
pleep: Do you guys know what kind of heavy bombers (like the b52) the Nigerian a/o south African militaries have? saaf had a few canbra and buccernia they not B52 size but are classed has bombers. There are still a few that can fly but non are in active servise and the gripen/hawks can cary LGBs and other pression guided ground attack muntsions so there is no need for a bomber |
Re: Who Has The Strongest Military In Africa? by Nobody: 9:18am On Mar 18, 2013 |
Capnd143: I beg to disagree with a few point of yours. The rooivalk is a good helicopter, though nt to international taste! The SA guys overate the weapons, thats an established fact, the tried marketing their goods in the international arena when the didnt try getting the african market first [ especialy nigera and ethiopia as at then] bt the chose to play white guys, and the got isolated. We african have such a love hate relationship that we barely trade more than 20% of GDP within the continent. The Rooivalk issue had some sabotage along the way also especially from the US when when Turkey wanted to by them, but US and Italy gave them more lucrative defense deals and there membership with NATO, including Turkeys long-term ambition to join the EU was also a blow to international marketing of the gunship. I will give the the specifications on the top 5 helicopters in the AH class later so that we can clerify this propaganda that only the west and russia can build the best helos |
Re: Who Has The Strongest Military In Africa? by Nobody: 9:23am On Mar 18, 2013 |
agaugust: . Source please. By the way most countries rely on multi role aircraft today not on single platform systems. Lastly fool the leopard is not a long range bomber how the hell will you reach SA from which is ± 8000km away |
Re: Who Has The Strongest Military In Africa? by hiuser(m): 9:23am On Mar 18, 2013 |
Forensic science detectives/researchers..after the dead body even in a foreign nation we find our inheritance..that is all. When you don't ever we hear it..are you a forerunner? |
Re: Who Has The Strongest Military In Africa? by agaugust: 9:44am On Mar 18, 2013 |
. |
Re: Who Has The Strongest Military In Africa? by andrewza: 9:54am On Mar 18, 2013 |
agaugust: You sure it can take that many heavy loads on it's hard points. And with only 2 AAMs and over a country with a masive ground nbassed radar the hawks would be enough. And with out any LGB's or ASMs it will have to come in close to be threat. Great targets for the radar guided 35mm AAA and starstreak SAMs. Please use logic. Any case you going yto just fly over SADC. Angloa MIG23 fleet alone will handel nigeria. |
Re: Who Has The Strongest Military In Africa? by Nobody: 9:58am On Mar 18, 2013 |
snydergp: EH you do have a point there. Now if you don't mind please go to the sexuality section *Kails* as a matter of a fact i think i'll stay here. agaugust: lmao. na wa o. 1 Like |
Re: Who Has The Strongest Military In Africa? by agaugust: 10:03am On Mar 18, 2013 |
. |
Re: Who Has The Strongest Military In Africa? by Nobody: 10:22am On Mar 18, 2013 |
hiuser: Forensic science detectives/researchers..after the dead body even in a foreign nation we find our inheritance..that is all. When you don't ever we hear it..are you a forerunner? Scram person |
Re: Who Has The Strongest Military In Africa? by Nobody: 10:29am On Mar 18, 2013 |
MsDarkSkin: You're welcome to stay, but we also wanna know about the Caribbean military from a females perspective ok. 2 Likes |
Re: Who Has The Strongest Military In Africa? by Nobody: 10:35am On Mar 18, 2013 |
agaugust: Scamster you have nothing to contribute now you wanna claim you have leopard jets. Anyway the leopard is no match for our air defense systems land or sea. |
Re: Who Has The Strongest Military In Africa? by Nobody: 12:19pm On Mar 18, 2013 |
Since there's been a lot of nonsense talk about the ROOIVALK and its systems versus other helicopters I will now give the specs of 4 AH-attack helicopters and so the public can judge. I left the Mi-24/35p out because its not in the class of the others. This will include the A129-Mangusta which Turkey chose over the Rooivalk due to politics. MI-28 -Crew, 1 pilot -Length, 17,01m (55ft) -Max take of weight, 11,500kg(23,590lb) -Max speed, 320km/h (172knots, 199mph) -Cruise Speed, 270km/h (145nmi,168mph) -Range, 435km (234nmi, 270mi) -Combat radius, 200km (108nmi, 124mi) -Ferry range, 1,100km (593nmi, 683mi) -Rate of climb, 13,6m/s (2,677ft/min) -Combat (depends on mission statement) AH-APACHE(long-bow) -Crew, 2 (pilot and gunner) -Length, 58,17ft (17,73m) -Max take of weight, 10,433kg (23,000lb) -Max speed, 293km/h (158knots, 165mph) -Cruise speed, 265km/h (143nmi, 165mph) -Range, 476km (257nmi, 295mi)with long bow radar mast -Combat radius, 480km (260nmi, 300mi) -Ferry range, 1,900km(1,024nmi, 1180mi)with external fuel -Rate of climb, 12,7m/s (2500ft/min) ROOIVALK -Crew, 2 (pilot and gunner) -Length, 18,73m (61ft) -Max take of weight, 8750kg (19,290lb) -Max speed, 309 (167knots, 193mph) -Cruise speed, 278km/h (150nmi, 173mph) -Ferry range, 1335km (720nmi, 829mi) -Range, 740km (386nmi, 437mi) -Combat radius, 700km (346nmi, 407mi) -Rate if climb, 13,3m/s (2,620ft/min) Agusta A129 Mangusta -Crew, 2 (pilot and gunner) -Length, 12,28 (40ft) -Max weight, 4600kg (10,140lb) -Max speed, 278km/h (148knots, 170mph) -Cruise speed, 229km (135nmi, 155mph) -Range, 510km (275nmi, 320mi) -Combat radius, (same as range) -Ferry range, 1000km (546nmi, 620mi) -Rate of climb, 10,2m/s (2,025ft/min) Overall Ratings -Max speed: Mi-28 is faster (320km/ -Cruise speed: ROOIVALK is faster (278km/h) -Range: ROOIVALK is by far better(740km) -Combat radius: ROOIVALK is by far better (700km) -Ferry range: APACHE is by far better (1,900km) -Rate of climb: Mi-28 and ROOIVALK are equal (13,6m/s-2,677ft/min) and (13,3m/s-2,620ft/min) -Max take of weight: Mi-28 is better (11,500kg-23,590lb) Source wikipedia.org Overall on points the Rooivalk and Mi-28 are far better machines. Now you work out why Turkey chose the Agusta A129 Mangusta and not the Rooivalk was it because of avionics or NATO/EU political reasons. I hope this settles the issue.
|
Re: Who Has The Strongest Military In Africa? by andrewza: 12:27pm On Mar 18, 2013 |
snydergp: Since there's been a lot of nonsense talk about the ROOIVALK and its systems versus other helicopters I will now give the specs of 4 AH-attack helicopters and so the public can judge. I left the Mi-24/35p out because its not in the class of the others. This will include the A129-Mangusta which Turkey chose over the Rooivalk due to politics. Why no werwolf or euro tiger. And the apachy has one very strong point. The longbow radar. |
Re: Who Has The Strongest Military In Africa? by Nobody: 1:04pm On Mar 18, 2013 |
andrewza: This was a comparison between what others have posted here. On the long bow yes its a stronge point but this was a answer to question about whether the rooivalk is a outdated attack machine. |
Re: Who Has The Strongest Military In Africa? by Nobody: 1:42pm On Mar 18, 2013 |
now here is the other two helicopters in the AH category Kamov ka-50 Black Shark -Crew, 1 -Length, 16,0m (52ft) -Max take of weight 10,800kg (23,810lb) -Max speed, 320km/h(170knots, 196mph) -Cruise speed: 270km/h (145knots,168mph -Range, 545km (339mi) -Ferry range, 1,160km (720mi) [b]Eurocopter Tiger -Crew 2 (pilot and gunner) -Length, 14,08m (46ft) -max take of weight, 6000kg(13,000lb) -Max speed, 290km (with mast 315km) (157knots, 181mph) -Rang 800km, (430nmi, 500mi) combat with external tank. -Range of climb, 10,7m/s (2,105ft) Now in comparison with my previous post here's the overall capabilities based on avionics. -Lenght: ROOIVALK is the largest (18,73m-61ft) -Max speed: Mi-28 faster (320km/h) -Cruise speed: ROOIVALK is faster (278km/h) -Range: Eurocopter is better(800km) including external tank inboard/ excluding external tank the Apache and Rooivalk is better. -Combat radius: Rooivalk is better (excluding external tank) -Ferry range: Apache is better -Rate of climb: both ROOIVALK and Mi-28 is better and equal. Overall all helicopter posted has its strengths. The Rooivalk which is a third world machine still remains a formidable helicopter by any standard in its class. |
Re: Who Has The Strongest Military In Africa? by agaugust: 3:08pm On Mar 18, 2013 |
please stop wasting our time here with south African Rooivalk helicopter that no country wants to buy and it has never been battle tested. South Africa made strategic business mistake by producing a helicopter with no market to sell it, and more photos of it were made than number of real life physical production of the Rooivalk. Next time learn to walk before you run. Please do us favour here and stop wasting our time on a half d.ead south African helicopter project. Thanks |
Re: Who Has The Strongest Military In Africa? by Nobody: 4:13pm On Mar 18, 2013 |
agaugust: please stop wasting our time here with south African Rooivalk helicopter that no country wants to buy and it has never been battle tested. Has Nigeria ever built or upgraded anything that can fly. Everything you buy must be sent to Europe for simple modifications. Atleast we in SA use and build our own. SA don't by old outdated second hand 737-500 planes. What have you posted here that's worth mentioning Leopard-II which only came into service late 2011 and no one has bought it yet you claim NAF already flies them you are a LIAR AND FRAUD just shut up. You have never worked a day in your life in the security industry. Show us the freakin link of the leopard being in service in the NAF, FRAUDSTER. |
Re: Who Has The Strongest Military In Africa? by andrewza: 4:47pm On Mar 18, 2013 |
agaugust: please stop wasting our time here with south African Rooivalk helicopter that no country wants to buy and it has never been battle tested. You showing your level of ignorince. The rooifalk was devloped during the border war. And incoperats many of the lesones learned from the fighting there. The rooifalk was never ment to be a export item. It was built because SA was under sactions and unable to buy any thing. Learn to think before speaking(typing) It far from dead. The rooifalk have just been upgraded. |
Re: Who Has The Strongest Military In Africa? by pleep(m): 6:51pm On Mar 18, 2013 |
andrewza:100% lies. You don't spend 1$ billion dollars on a military project that is not for export...that is the only way these military companies are able to recoup their losses from production. The rooivalk is the biggest military flop in African history. 1. You spend 7 billion rand to develop a helicopter design and only end up building 12. (none of which are fully operational) 2. have not managed to export a single one 3. It took yall almost a decade to create, by the time it was finished the technology was already obsolete 4. It uses 20 year old computers 5. There is no support system...(many of the support manufacturers are invested in competitors.) 6. It cost $40 million each unit. More than a brand new Apachi! FAIL. http://www.engineeringnews.co.za/article/what-went-wrong-with-the-rooivalk-2007-06-08-1 1 Like |
Re: Who Has The Strongest Military In Africa? by pleep(m): 7:04pm On Mar 18, 2013 |
But ill admit that you guys are light-years ahead of Nigeria when it comes to actual hardware development and military infrastructure. .... The Nigerian military is just a straw stabbed in the back of the country sucking money for Europe and Asia. Agaugust & Co' we havent created anything so we really have nothing to be proud of here... the Nigerian military is a joke. |
Re: Who Has The Strongest Military In Africa? by andrewza: 7:12pm On Mar 18, 2013 |
pleep: 100% lies. You don't spend 1$ billion dollars on a military project that is not for export...that is the only way these military companies are able to recoup their losses from production. you are a fool We had a need during the border war and back then it was a war money was not a issue. By the time the war was over the production was so far in it was better to finish the deal wrong all where just made operational They where only overd to turkey and they where just upgraded has i said they where just upgraded and we could not buy them since we where under sanction. pleas think before you speak. |
Re: Who Has The Strongest Military In Africa? by Nobody: 7:23pm On Mar 18, 2013 |
pleep: 100% lies. You don't spend 1$ billion dollars on a military project that is not for export...that is the only way these military companies are able to recoup their losses from production. Are you stup*d or just plane ignorant, did you even read the follow up report on the same article which I posted from engineeringnews.co.za even wiki has the latest report on the rooivalk. I even gave u the specifications on the rooivalk vs the apache and mi-28. You said none of them are operational yet the same sites 2013/03/14 report said the upgrades where complete and the SAAF has the full complement of the rooivalks available. Stop showing your foolishness, reading is free if you have the brain to comprehend simple English. |
Re: Who Has The Strongest Military In Africa? by agaugust: 7:57pm On Mar 18, 2013 |
pleep: But ill admit that you guys are light-years ahead of Nigeria when it comes to actual hardware development and military infrastructure. you are wrong. Nigeria manufactures weapons from machine guns to mortars to night vision equipment to bullet proof vests to armoured personnel carriers to unmanned air drones, and all productions are increasing every day, also we will soon manufacture heavy artilery. Many years ago Nigeria produced the air beetle aircraft we stopped due to government lack of support from the military politicians of those past years. Try spend time to see their posts and photos from pages 15 to 95 page of this thread topic, you missed the action those days. Air beetle aircraft was not posted but I can do that tomorrow, its a Nigerian light aircraft air force trainer produced some years ago |
Re: Who Has The Strongest Military In Africa? by Nobody: 8:38pm On Mar 18, 2013 |
Its official, pleep is on drugs |
Re: Who Has The Strongest Military In Africa? by Capnd143(m): 8:44pm On Mar 18, 2013 |
pleep: But ill admit that you guys are light-years ahead of Nigeria when it comes to actual hardware development and military infrastructure.what the bleeb is wrong with pleeb? Pleebing is just and bleebing, so dont bleeb, Mr. Pleep! Go check weapons manufactured by nigeria, and who said we havnt manufactured something that can fly? You must be a sacarcissistic saidist! The air beetle trainer whose productiom was stoped nko? What of the under-development, ameobo drones? Go do some googling bro! Last i check google is free. |
Re: Who Has The Strongest Military In Africa? by pleep(m): 9:36pm On Mar 18, 2013 |
agaugust:Dude. The air beetle, seriously I love my people, but i'm sorry that is a joke. The air beetle is a homebuilt kit aircraft that teenagers in the united states make in their garage for science projects! and to make matters worse it was designed by van, a foreign company, not even by Nigerian technology. As for the armoured personnel carriers they are just Toyotas with extra armor melded on. The chasies, powertrain, engine etc was made in foreign countries. Look at this thing, its a joke! https://www.nairaland.com/309607/yaradua-inspects-nigeria-made-armoured-personnel I know we manufacture the AK-47, but that is only from 1 factory, say a missile hit that factory.... pwaam we have to import guns again. And that technology in itself is not impressive because not only are small arms obsolete, but the AK is probably the easiest and cheapest gun on earth to manufacture. Is this toy something to be proud of?
|
(1) (2) (3) ... (107) (108) (109) (110) (111) (112) (113) ... (2991) (Reply)
African Militaries/ Security Services Strictly Photos Only And Videos Thread / Kenya Is Ahead of Nigeria In All Aspect (Facts Don't Lie)
(Go Up)
Sections: politics (1) business autos (1) jobs (1) career education (1) romance computers phones travel sports fashion health religion celebs tv-movies music-radio literature webmasters programming techmarket Links: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) Nairaland - Copyright © 2005 - 2024 Oluwaseun Osewa. All rights reserved. See How To Advertise. 103 |