Welcome, Guest: Register On Nairaland / LOGIN! / Trending / Recent / NewStats: 3,207,451 members, 7,999,066 topics. Date: Sunday, 10 November 2024 at 04:04 PM |
Nairaland Forum / Nairaland / General / Religion / Why Did The God Tell Abraham To Sacrifice His Child (10958 Views)
Job 22:28: Did God Tell Us To Decree And Declare When We Pray? / Patrick Henry Edet Dedicates His Child / Does God Tell Us Who to Marry? (2) (3) (4)
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (Reply) (Go Down)
Re: Why Did The God Tell Abraham To Sacrifice His Child by CreepyBlackpool: 12:57am On Feb 01, 2019 |
MuttleyLaff: And the only test he could possibly give him was to ask him to commit murder, a sin? And goes on to reward him for attempting to commit sin? 2 Likes |
Re: Why Did The God Tell Abraham To Sacrifice His Child by budaatum: 2:15am On Feb 01, 2019 |
CreepyBlackpool:And somehow, I shouldn't feel insulted when Im caught bowing down and worshipping such a god? I guess it would make sense to me if I park my brain away and refuse to use it like muttley does. |
Re: Why Did The God Tell Abraham To Sacrifice His Child by frank317: 3:34am On Feb 01, 2019 |
budaatum: Exactly... I wonder how sensible it is that the new God is testing him with the same instruction that an old God would give. Abraham should have known that something was fishy 3 Likes |
Re: Why Did The God Tell Abraham To Sacrifice His Child by Rextizz(m): 7:56am On Feb 01, 2019 |
XxSabrinaxX:Are you ignoring me |
Re: Why Did The God Tell Abraham To Sacrifice His Child by orisa37: 8:14am On Feb 01, 2019 |
To establish a Covenant on Isaac. Isaac was Abel revived and Jesus resurrected |
Re: Why Did The God Tell Abraham To Sacrifice His Child by MuttleyLaff: 9:20am On Feb 01, 2019 |
frank317:Do you see what one of the stand-offs is about here frank317? What is the wrong, frank317, in commanding another to carry out an act on something that you own? frank317:So? What's the wrong in that frank317? Did God ask anyone else to go kill their children for Him? No, he didnt and hasnt ever did I have a case and a very valid case for that matter. I earlier asked you: "Do you remember how Isaac came about? Do you remember the circumstances before and up until his birth?" but you ignored that comment frank317:I will test you on things I know you're used to, I will test you on things you are familiar with. I will test you based on your past antecedents. I will test and confirm to you, whether or not you are susceptible to be avaricious, by feeding your greed. Feeding your greed, will be a good test and it wouldnt necessarily be criminal for me, to do so Now, frank317, tell what exactly, is the bad deed, in God telling Abraham to go kill Isaac, his son there as a sacrifice for God, and this same Isaac, Abraham's only son, the one he love, should be used as a burnt offering on one of the mountains God said He will point out which to Abraham? frank317:That would be resounding YES. Of course, God was satisfied that Abraham was will and prepared to obey His instruction to kill his son, Isaac. God was deed chuffed with Abraham. He was actually pleased for Abraham's sake, that Abraham considering the tricky and awkward situation, Abraham came through passing with flying colours frank317:It is the truth and fact that the killing never happened. Now if the kiiling didnt happen, I wonder why you guys have an extremely nervous and sensitive temperament to the escapade. Even budaatum, in chillax mode, actually saw the whole affair as a God prank frank317:Now that you are aware, at least, you'll take more care, so I dont agree with you that it is irrelevant. frank317:That is exactly what they've both done frank317. Have you heard or seen God after theirs ask anyone else to go to kill their son for God? frank317:God will never ask anyone to do bad things frank317. God telling Abraham to kill is son is not a bad thing nor is it wrong for God to do or ask frank317:Cant you see this is not worthy of comparison. For starters, why are you encouraging someone to go steal another person's property? frank317:I do get your point. I really do but your point is skewed and I empathise with you on that frank317:Of course I responded and did because I didnt want you to accuse me of being evasive. You think it is funny, me saying, you are using a wrong and invalid scenario. You think it is funny, me asking you: "Why would you tell him to go and steal someone else's property?. Is the property his or yours?" huh? Like I said, earlier, you arent seeing the forest because of the trees, and that is why it's actually you guys, and especially you, who are throwing up funnies of all sorts Yes frank317, it will be right for the boy to even attempt to steal them, because you told him to go do stealing, you gave him express authorisation to go steal from you. In some parts of world, there is a name for something like that, it is called social experiment frank317:It sure does seem like that, dont you think frank317 frank317:Yes, it does not make Abraham a murderer because there is no dead body, besides, Abraham was following a God command to kill, and so this absolves Abraham of any culpability, blame or wrong. frank317:Yes, it does not make Abraham a murderer because there is no dead body. It doesnt matter, how many ways you want to pan this, the answer always will be "it doesnt make Abraham a murderer" frank317:Number 1, I dont do argument and there is a very good reason for that, to me Number 2, unlike you, I dont have a truculent bone in my body Number 3, truth needs no argument frank317:I am just being real, trutful and facing the facts. Wish yo could and are able to frank317 frank317:I wouldnt like you, stretch and/or go as far as saying God loves the act of killing, but can confidently say I know God is not averse to killing, and you can take that comment to the bank frank317 1 Like |
Re: Why Did The God Tell Abraham To Sacrifice His Child by MuttleyLaff: 9:21am On Feb 01, 2019 |
budaatum:Nobi today, yansh don tey for chicken back, of course I know your position or stance on Abraham, the testee and the Tester but hypotheticall speaking, was only after, what personally and exactly, do you think Abraham was being tested on? budaatum:Bullseye! and so we have one of the many birds, killed with one stone, in this macabre social experiment adventure of a thing 1 Like |
Re: Why Did The God Tell Abraham To Sacrifice His Child by MuttleyLaff: 9:21am On Feb 01, 2019 |
frank317:It is not a bad deed, if God Himself auhorises you to do it budaatum:Abraham passed in flying colours frank317 and budattum, Abraham was following instruction, whose instructions where others following when they were practising all those child sacrifices and/or ritualistic killing of children? frank317:If I were to test you both youse budaatum and frank317, the test will have to involve something you cherish, something you hold dearly, it will have to be with something they'll will have to kill you first and the prise your clinging on to fingers, off before they'll take the thing off you. You know thats how the cookie crumbles now. I will test you both on things I know you're used to, I will test you on things you are familiar with. I will test you on something you are used to. Like may for example, child sacrifices and/or ritualistic killing of children? I will test you based on your past antecedents. If I am to test and confirm to you, whether or not you are susceptible to being avaricious, then I will test you, by feeding your greed. Feeding your greed, will be a good test and it wouldnt necessarily be criminal for me, to do so CreepyBlackpool:It is not murder. It isnt murder budaatum:You are letting your emotions get the better of you 1 Like |
Re: Why Did The God Tell Abraham To Sacrifice His Child by CreepyBlackpool: 9:49am On Feb 01, 2019 |
MuttleyLaff: so Islamic terrorists are not commiting murders ba? all the people they're kiling, its sacrifice? The military shouldn't fight Boko haram since they're not doing any bad deeds? 2 Likes 1 Share |
Re: Why Did The God Tell Abraham To Sacrifice His Child by JujuSugar(f): 9:50am On Feb 01, 2019 |
LordReed:I prefer Jephthah's story to Abraham's as an example because God doesn't intervene and the child is sacrificed. 1 Like |
Re: Why Did The God Tell Abraham To Sacrifice His Child by JujuSugar(f): 9:55am On Feb 01, 2019 |
CodeTemplar:Are you trying to say God did not know that Jephthah's daughter was the first person Jephthah would see? 1 Like |
Re: Why Did The God Tell Abraham To Sacrifice His Child by MuttleyLaff: 9:55am On Feb 01, 2019 |
CreepyBlackpool:Keep on jumping from pillar to post with invalid comparisons JujuSugar:I am sorry to be the one bursting this bubble of ill-information, a victim of bad and/or false teaching, for you, that the child sacrificed as perpetual dedication to God's work, similar way Samuel the priest was, and that she wasn't given up as a barbecue or burning sacrifice |
Re: Why Did The God Tell Abraham To Sacrifice His Child by MuttleyLaff: 9:57am On Feb 01, 2019 |
JujuSugar:Bring out one single verse and not more than one verse, you are basing this assumption on, and let's both give it a critical look over together |
Re: Why Did The God Tell Abraham To Sacrifice His Child by JujuSugar(f): 9:58am On Feb 01, 2019 |
MuttleyLaff:Its not an invalid comparison, bro. There's a little something called "God's plan" MuttleyLaff:Doesn't justify anything. Thanks for quoting me to say nothing. |
Re: Why Did The God Tell Abraham To Sacrifice His Child by JujuSugar(f): 9:59am On Feb 01, 2019 |
MuttleyLaff:Which one is assumption? Is God not supposed to be omniscient? |
Re: Why Did The God Tell Abraham To Sacrifice His Child by MuttleyLaff: 10:21am On Feb 01, 2019 |
JujuSugar:What has his comparison in common with God asking Abraham to sacrifice Isaac? JujuSugar:How do you mean doesnt justfify anything and saying thanks for quoting you, to say nothing?. I am telling you that the Jephthah story is not an example God intervening to any child getting being barbecued sacrificed and you are giving off attitude JujuSugar:Your assumption that Jephthah was thinking about his daughter, as the first person Jephthah would see when returning back from fighting the enemies? Jephthah wasnt even thinking about any human being when he promised a barbeque Of course God supposedly and surely is omniscient, but are human beings omniscient? Do you know everything annd all that could be known about you yourself? If put under pressure, do you know with 100% certainty, whether or not you will stand and remain firm and resolute or if or not, you'll buckle and/or give in? |
Re: Why Did The God Tell Abraham To Sacrifice His Child by JujuSugar(f): 10:35am On Feb 01, 2019 |
MuttleyLaff:According to you christians, God always has a plan. And every event is part of this plan, so automatically, he's responsible for Boko Haram. And then you claimed that a deed isn't bad if God authorizes you to do it. So now how do you justify the deeds of the Boko Haram? MuttleyLaff:Did God know that Jepthah's daughter will be the first person Jephthah would meet at home? Yes or No. MuttleyLaff:I'm not assuming that Jephthah was thinking of his daughter. In fact i don't know where you pulled that from. What I'm saying (and its not an assumption by the way), is that God could have easily spared Jephthah the pain of killing his own daughter since he's omniscient and clearly knew before hand that Jephthah would end up killing her. |
Re: Why Did The God Tell Abraham To Sacrifice His Child by CreepyBlackpool: 10:48am On Feb 01, 2019 |
MuttleyLaff: What they have in common is that just like Jehovah asked Abraham to kill Isaac and rewards him for trying to do so, Allah also rewards Islamic terrorists for killing. Except that being a hypocrite, you have termed killing for Jehova a sacrifice and not a bad deed, while killing for Allah is terrorism 3 Likes 1 Share |
Re: Why Did The God Tell Abraham To Sacrifice His Child by MuttleyLaff: 11:02am On Feb 01, 2019 |
JujuSugar:Anyone who hasn't a plan, plans to fail, it's as simple as that I am glad, you are willing to engage, and engage without personalising. I don't give a hoot what or what not you believe, all we are doing here, is just having a mature, honest, factual and truthful conversation. Now having said all that, please tell where and when God authorised anyone in particular about Boko Haram? JujuSugar:Of course, God knows and knows everything, but Jephthah wasn't even talking about human being as what he is willing to barbecue. This is the point, truth and fact eluding you JujuSugar:I am categorically telling you, an issue of Jephthah having or planned to sacrificing his daughter as a barbecue is a non-story. None of this rubbish is found in the Jephthah narrative. This is why I asked you to provide a single verse that you are hinging this assumption on, mind you, a single verse and not more than a single verse. You guys are so fond of being argumentative just for argument sake, eh. |
Re: Why Did The God Tell Abraham To Sacrifice His Child by MuttleyLaff: 11:07am On Feb 01, 2019 |
CreepyBlackpool:See what I mean. Shifting and swinging over to Allah is the next clutching at straws thing to do now. Please can you give me one person's name God told, as regards to terrorism, to go kill and what the reward was he promised or gave this person? |
Re: Why Did The God Tell Abraham To Sacrifice His Child by JujuSugar(f): 11:15am On Feb 01, 2019 |
MuttleyLaff:If God is not responsible for Boko haram, then he is neither omniscient nor omnipotent MuttleyLaff:Good. I'm glad we agree on this. MuttleyLaff:Wrong. Judges 11: 30-35: 30 And Jephthah vowed a vow unto the Lord, and said, If thou shalt without fail deliver the children of Ammon into mine hands, 31 Then it shall be, that whatsoever cometh forth of the doors of my house to meet me, when I return in peace from the children of Ammon, shall surely be the Lord's, and I will offer it up for a burnt offering........ 34 And Jephthah came to Mizpeh unto his house, and, behold, his daughter came out to meet him with timbrels and with dances: and she was his only child; beside her he had neither son nor daughter. 35 And it came to pass, when he saw her, that he rent his clothes, and said, Alas, my daughter! thou hast brought me very low, and thou art one of them that trouble me: for I have opened my mouth unto the Lord, and I cannot go back. Don't try to twist it. You know damn well what Jephthah meant in this passage. MuttleyLaff:If you're trying to suggest that God's hands were tied with regards this issue, i'd like to know why. MuttleyLaff:I've gone through the four pages of this thread and this description best fits you, Mr. Muttleylaff 1 Like 1 Share |
Re: Why Did The God Tell Abraham To Sacrifice His Child by CreepyBlackpool: 11:20am On Feb 01, 2019 |
MuttleyLaff: Did your bible not say your God pulled down the walls of Jericho so Joshua could commit mass murders in the book of Joshua chapter 6. Joshua 6:24 and they burned the city with fire, and all within it. Only the silver, gold and the vessels of bronze and of iron, they put in the treasury of the house of the Lord. Joshua 8:2 and you shall do to Ai and its king as you did to Jericho and its king.....lay an ambush against the city, behind it. these ones are not murders ba? and I only involved Islamic terrorist because of your assertion that killing for a God is a good deed and not murder |
Re: Why Did The God Tell Abraham To Sacrifice His Child by MuttleyLaff: 11:43am On Feb 01, 2019 |
JujuSugar:Is God also responsible for your sins too Madam JujuSugar? JujuSugar:The feeling is mutual. JujuSugar:I am sorry, it is too strong for you to stomach the truth. Weren't you warned to put forward just one verse? You want to hide the truth under an avalanche of verses, right? JujuSugar:It didn't get to God's hands being tied JujuSugar. Jephthah knows as a rule, that God is not into that wicked and cruel business of nonsense, he wasn't even thinking of a human being. The clue is in the kind or type of pronoun Jephthah used in Joshua 11:31 JujuSugar:If you really and truly read the four pages objectively, you would have noticed that I am not being opinionated but I am having an unbiased conversation dealing with truth and facts I can back the truth up with |
Re: Why Did The God Tell Abraham To Sacrifice His Child by MuttleyLaff: 11:49am On Feb 01, 2019 |
CreepyBlackpool:They are not murders, that was God carry out and/or executing judgement. Now God specifically personally and directly authorised those people to carry out His command Since you are shifting and swinging over to Allah as the next clutching at straws thing to do now, then please can you give me one person's name, in modern history, God told, as regards to terrorism, to go kill and what the reward was he promised or gave this person? |
Re: Why Did The God Tell Abraham To Sacrifice His Child by CreepyBlackpool: 12:04pm On Feb 01, 2019 |
MuttleyLaff: Shifting, swinging, clutching straws, its like they just taught you those words in this week's reading comprehension passage. You asked for where God asked his people to kill, I quoted your bible for you your best defence is still that it is not murders Now you're asking for Chriatian killings in morden times, nigga have you heard of the christian crusades. Those too are not murders ba? no matter what you say it doesn't change the fact that your God is a bloodthirsty genocidal maniac. Keep shifting and swinging inugo |
Re: Why Did The God Tell Abraham To Sacrifice His Child by MuttleyLaff: 12:11pm On Feb 01, 2019 |
CreepyBlackpool:When you are done having a hard on, will you then please give me the names of those people that committed those acts in the Christian Crusades that God authorised. You have mentioned Joshua and Jericho and we both agree that God commanded him to do those killings, so please give an do same here |
Re: Why Did The God Tell Abraham To Sacrifice His Child by JujuSugar(f): 12:17pm On Feb 01, 2019 |
MuttleyLaff:Yes MuttleyLaff:Cool MuttleyLaff:Cry me a river. I gave you those verses to debunk your claim that Jephthah wasn't thinking of a human being when he made the vow. Now, you want to dance around the fact. Do keep dancing. MuttleyLaff:I've addressed this statement already MuttleyLaff:The pronoun isn't really the issue. One thing to understand concerning Jephthah's vow is that he did not expect some type of animal or household pet to burst forth from the house upon his return. This makes sense for a couple of reasons. First, in 11:31, the verb "to meet", in the bible, is always used for people, never for a person encountering an animal. Second, in the ancient world, when men returned from battle, women would customarily come forth in procession in order to participate in celebratory dancing. Given the cultural context in which these events transpired, Jephthah likely assumed that a woman would come out from the house to meet him, perhaps a servant girl or, even better, his mother-in-law, but certainly not an animal. MuttleyLaff:Your "truth and facts" have been weak thus far. If not, I wouldn't even be having this conversation. |
Re: Why Did The God Tell Abraham To Sacrifice His Child by CreepyBlackpool: 12:33pm On Feb 01, 2019 |
MuttleyLaff: In 1095, Pope Urban II called for the First Crusade in a sermon at the Council of Clermont. He encouraged military support for the Byzantine Empire and its Emperor, Alexios I , who needed reinforcements for his conflict with westward migrating Turks colonizing Anatolia Peter the Hermit led thousands of mostly poor Christians out of Europe in what became known as the People's Crusade. He claimed he had a letter from heaven instructing Christians to prepare for the imminent apocalypse by seizing Jerusalem. Germany witnessed the first incidents of major violent European antisemitism when these Crusaders massacred Jewish communities in what became known as the Rhineland massacres . Should I continue I will keep serving you as e dey hot 1 Like |
Re: Why Did The God Tell Abraham To Sacrifice His Child by MuttleyLaff: 12:56pm On Feb 01, 2019 |
JujuSugar:Classic! I love this. JujuSugar:Coolio JujuSugar:He was in the first part of the vow thinking of whatever comes to meet him, human being or otherwise, and then clarified his intention in the second part of the vow what he will do, if what comes out happens to be an animal JujuSugar:That's what you made yourself to believe that you've addressed it JujuSugar:It is the issue. The pronoun is a game changer. The pronoun is truth standing and on steroids. JujuSugar:I literally laughed out loud at this comment. Would you kindly please tell all and remind others, what is the pronoun used in Judges 11:31b Madam JujuSugar? JujuSugar:That's because you are in denial |
Re: Why Did The God Tell Abraham To Sacrifice His Child by MuttleyLaff: 1:05pm On Feb 01, 2019 |
CreepyBlackpool:Without their names specifically being mentioned in the Bible, anyone that claims, those that believe in their claims and people like you regurgitating this rubbish, getting hard ons from it, should all together be put in a loony house and the key thrown away |
Re: Why Did The God Tell Abraham To Sacrifice His Child by LordReed(m): 1:23pm On Feb 01, 2019 |
JujuSugar: Yeah but you still get attempts to wash the story. Even on here you see MuttleyLaff challenging the narrative that Jephthah actually roasted his daughter. |
Re: Why Did The God Tell Abraham To Sacrifice His Child by Dantedasz(m): 1:43pm On Feb 01, 2019 |
LordReed: NOT CHALLENGING,rather STANDING LOGIC ON IT'S HEAD. 1 Like |
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (Reply)
How You Can Help Your Children Follow The Growth Pattern Of Jesus / Why Do Christians Hate Homosexuals If God Created Them That Way / Adeboye Holds Fellowship With Prisoners, Guards At Kirikiri Maximum Security Pri
(Go Up)
Sections: politics (1) business autos (1) jobs (1) career education (1) romance computers phones travel sports fashion health religion celebs tv-movies music-radio literature webmasters programming techmarket Links: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) Nairaland - Copyright © 2005 - 2024 Oluwaseun Osewa. All rights reserved. See How To Advertise. 148 |