LifeSite nav
NEWS FAITH,

California court of appeal bans prayer, Bible reading at school board meetings
California court of appeal bans prayer, Bible reading at school board meetings
Shutterstock.com
Calvin Freiburger

Wed Aug 1, 2018 - 12:13 pm EST


CHINO, California, August 1, 2018 (LifeSiteNews) – A three-judge panel of the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals has forbidden prayers, proselytizing, or scripture readings at Chino Valley school board meetings, in a ruling the board’s lawyer says is broad enough to ban “anything that might resemble a prayer.”

The July 25 ruling affirms a 2016 injunction by a California district court, in a suit brought against the Chino Valley Unified School District by the Freedom from Religion Foundation (FFRF), an atheist group that seeks to eliminate most benign, voluntary, and unofficial expressions of religiosity from every level of the American public sphere.

FFRF legal director Rebecca Markert celebrated the ruling as a “solid victory for state-church separation,” a commonly-misunderstood concept that does not appear in the Constitution.

According to the Daily Bulletin, the board has opened meetings with prayers unofficially since 2010 and officially since 2013, a practice that later expanded to include mid-meeting prayers, Bible readings, and statements by board members FFRF and the 9th Circuit took to constitute proselytizing.

The group cites examples such as Board President Andrew Cruz’s practice of closing meetings with Bible readings, and Board Vice President James Na (an active member of the Calvary Chapel Chino Hills Watchman Ministry) urging “everyone who does not know Jesus Christ to go and find Him.”

In its defense, the board cited Supreme Court precedent establishing that Christian prayers were permissible at public meetings as long as the local government body didn’t compel participation or discriminate against minority faiths. But the 9th Circuit disagreed.

“The prayers frequently advanced religion in general and Christianity in particular,” the panel ruled. “The prayer policy’s purpose is predominantly religious in violation of the Establishment Clause.” The decision was unsigned, but Judges M. Margaret McKeown, Kim McLane Wardlaw, and Wiley Y. Daniel comprised the panel.

“These prayers typically take place before groups of schoolchildren whose attendance is not truly voluntary and whose relationship to school district officials, including the board, is not one of full parity,” they claimed. “Unlike a session of Congress or a state legislature, or a meeting of a town board, the Chino Valley board meetings function as extensions of the educational experience of the district’s public schools.”

Robert Tyler, an attorney who represented the district, told the Bulletin that passage was flat wrong, noting that students could opt to go to school board meetings for extra credit but weren’t required to, and city council meetings could get them the extra credit as well. He added that disciplinary hearings, where attendance isn’t voluntary, aren’t heard in the same sessions where prayer takes place, and the board’s student member is permitted to leave during prayer.

“Where does this stop?” Tyler asked, noting that the ruling applied to community members speaking during public comments as well as the board itself. “This is a very dangerous ruling.”

Advertisement

“This requires the board to censor or otherwise remove individuals who attempt to say a prayer, or anything that might resemble a prayer, during the public comment period,” Tyler told WND. “Such an overbroad injunction is a clear violation of the right of private citizens to address their local representatives in public meetings and is dangerous to the First Amendment.”

WND notes that outgoing Justice Anthony Kennedy, far from a conservative or originalist, nevertheless acknowledged in 2014’s Town of Greece v. Galloway that “[c]eremonial prayer is but a recognition that, since this Nation was founded and until the present day, many Americans deem that their own existence must be understood by precepts far beyond the authority of government.”

Tyler says his law firm plans to meet with the school board to discuss its next move, which could include filing for the 9th Circuit to reconsider or petitioning the Supreme Court.



Subscribe to Pro-Life & Pro-Family News
View full site
All Content Copyright 1997-2018 LifeSiteNews.com.
All Rights Reserved.

How much is it?

please help me check WBAHG61050GB69437. omerese@yahoo.ca

thanks for all your contribution. this topic came about because of the ban of religious symbols in some US schools and some civic institutions trying to be religiously neutral, i thought it would be good as most contributors have noted that our faith be strong enough to thrive even in the face of the worst atrocity. the word of God should be written in our hearts and we should be able to pass it from generation to generation. may God bless us all and keep us strong. amen

when is the next Eagles's match?

Beinsportplay.ca

why male only?

i require 5 male and 5 female attendants for a car wash in Abuja and Benin. they must be ready to learn, part time and full time, no qualifications except willingness to work as a team and please the customer. remunerations are above competition with many benefits including assistance in starting your own business.
call Eric 08033298686

in the breakdown groups you metioned could you include legal/reseach, so we dont go against any laws?

Please send account information

where are you located in nigeria? how urgently do you need it. if shipping it you can get it next week thru a courrier company. if no rush, then i have someone coming to Lagos on the 26th of Dec, you can email (omerese@yahoo.ca) me with more specifics, as in extra accessories you may need but you will be looking at from $350-600 for D40 and $800-1400 for D90 depending on the lenses and accessories.

ise82, will you be intrested in a Nikon D50? $350.00 PM me to discuss details.

to God be the Glory! we have our first child, a baby boy healthy and bouncing with energy. may God answer all our prayers especially those seeking the fruit of the womb. Amen

what is the name of this brasilian company? has anybody any information about their history in the energy sector? Are they are front to another entity? what is their plan or modus operandi? until we know all this and more all above arguement is nothing.
lets research and find out more before we continue the discussion.
stay blessed

my brother, you can PM me for my ph# , my email is on my profile too. i am in calgary SW.

welcome to canada! hope you are adjusting to the cold. maybe you can hook up for christmas with the family.

try this website, they say it will be showing soon. i'm still searching.
http://www.nenggeulis.com/watch.php?livestream=4145

anyone with another link?

eusebio from mozambique stands out. he was ahead of his time.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OE6fIA8BMa0

anyone knows a website to watch the match?

www.myp2p.eu
live sports
football

does anyone know where one can watch this match again? Nigeria/Argentina.

if you dont have any files you seriously need, just get a new hard drive.

i need a caregiver for my parents in Benin City.My parent are mostly independent.
responsibilities include preparing meals, shopping for groceries, laundry, supervising househelp, ensuring medication is taken as and when due and other household work. the person must me friendly ready to engage in conversation, patient, being able to drive is an advantage.
you will be doing maximum 30hours a week (4-5hrs a day) flexible schedule. (e.g. 3days/week)
sundays off. this can be done as a second job or part time.
Salary is negotiable, depending on whether live in or walk in. (as from N12,000/ month).
i can be reached on omerese@yahoo.ca or call my wife at 08073583819. you can also live a number to be reached with and some background information.

though i don't fully understand the stages you mean. i will refer you to this website. it show applicants in their various stage of the process.http://www.immigration.ca/discussion2/default.asp

http://www.canadavisa.com/

please! its true we are all disgusted at this blatant diregard of the people by the so called leaders, but is it not possible for us to stop this trend legally? is there no way we can get an injunction?legal guys what can we do apart from venting?

i request your prayers for success in my end of semester exam coming up mid april and for financial stability, health of my wife. God bless you all, in Jesus name.

@ oby1

Knights of Columbus is a society similar to the knights of Mulumba or St John in Nigeria. they most ly defend the church intellectually, financially and socially.
The Knights was formed to render financial aid to members and their families. Mutual aid and assistance are offered to sick, disabled and needy members and their families. Social and intellectual fellowship is promoted among members and their families through educational, charitable, religious, social welfare, war relief and public relief works.
they are in the fore front of anti - Abortion movement, youth development and charity worldwide. Currently we are a distributing wheelchairs to areas of need worldwide.