Welcome, Guest: Register On Nairaland / LOGIN! / Trending / Recent / NewStats: 3,209,457 members, 8,006,165 topics. Date: Monday, 18 November 2024 at 05:25 PM |
Nairaland Forum / Nairaland / General / Culture / Why Are Nigerians So Tribalistic? (14197 Views)
Why Are Nigerians So Tribalistic. / Why Are Nigerians So Funny? / Why Are Nigerians So Abusive And Insulting? (2) (3) (4)
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (Reply) (Go Down)
Re: Why Are Nigerians So Tribalistic? by Nobody: 5:08pm On Oct 05, 2007 |
Real Birthday, no today my mama born me. |
Re: Why Are Nigerians So Tribalistic? by iyaaje(m): 6:34pm On Oct 05, 2007 |
the ansa is simple, we are tribes and not a country,na oyinbo force us to be together,unfortunately the super glue wey dem use to hold us together on october 1 don dry since october 2 1960 |
Re: Why Are Nigerians So Tribalistic? by Kobojunkie: 6:57pm On Oct 05, 2007 |
That was a good way to put it @Iya aje Deep down we are not really a WORLD United, we are made up of human beings who belong to one creed or another, family or another, tribe or another, I believe the issue here remains that this dude called Adeniyi has yet to provide us with substantial evidence that tribalism is at fault in this case. From his post, the woman made her choice and he did not even get more information for us. so again , Tribalism is not the issue here, and please learn to respect people's choices no matter what you would prefer instead in cases like this , simple!! She no won talk to you, would it have been better if she had said something like " Because your teeth crooked" or some other reason there ?? I mean I would expect you as an adult to conduct more research to get to the bottom of the issue. Not jump to conclude what you heard is 100% |
Re: Why Are Nigerians So Tribalistic? by RichyBlacK(m): 7:04pm On Oct 05, 2007 |
Kobojunkie: Kobojunkie: It's hard to decipher where you stand and why you are standing there, but from the post above it seems you're struggling to find a position. I have tried to condense your view on tribalism to a few statements: 1. Tribalism should be encouraged as a form of loyalty to one's tribe (or ethnic group) 2. He should not blame tribalism for her refusing to talk to him. 3. Tribalism is not common in Lagos because Lagos serves as some kind of melting pot of various ethnic groups. 4. Tribalism may not be the cause of her not talking to the guy because we don't have the full story. Of the four statements above, three of them cast tribalism in a negative light. For someone who advocates tribalism, a place like Lagos which guarantees that she "WILL HAVE TO converse with other yorubas", cannot be a good place because its inhabitants "can not be deemed tribalistic at all". On racism, only because your credibility will be seriously at stake (racists loose all credibility - once they are exposed) that you've refused to outrightly say "I support racism!". But why can't you clearly state that you support racism (please don't go on that balderdash of "we are all racist to some extent" - of course we are all animals to some extent; are we trying to advance or retrogress?). The girl has a right to be with whomsoever she wishes to be with, however, using race or ethnicity as the sole basis for choosing a mate is pathetic. And please note that if someone overhears someone else make a statement, it is not "hearsay", that is a first-hand testimony - he is a witness to the statement. She said it was because he was Yoruba. Further summary of your opinion in my opinion (no pun intended): 1. The girl has the right to discriminate based on race/ethnicity 2. The guy is assuming wrongly that she based her refusal to continue the relationship solely based on ethnicity (and race?). Assuming (1), makes (2) moot. This brings us back to your advocacy for tribalism and ethnocentrism, and your still yet-to-be-confirmed support for racism. |
Re: Why Are Nigerians So Tribalistic? by Kobojunkie: 7:08pm On Oct 05, 2007 |
I am sorry if you can not understand my post there. I mean exactly what I stated earlier. STOP BRINGING racism and other issues into it , this is not about it for me and I do not care what you think I think of those. I would however like to focus on the topic here and that is the issue of tribalism being at fault here which I still believe is not the case, Simple!!! if you want to continue to attack my person , you are free to continue but excuse me while I get back to getting more information on the main topic the thread is really about !! In all my posts , I have yet to mention what tribe I belong to and I really do not care what class you would like to shove me so you can feel better, .The fact remains, I do not see what you see as per what Adeniyi posted. Until the man can provide me more than he has, I am sorry I will never see what you seem to see or how you bring racism and the other issues into this. I am sorry !!! I can not help you there !!@Richblack The way this debate is going, the insults and personal attacks reminds me of the ongoing battle for everyone to be PC. If you are not for us, if you do not AGREE WITH US , you are not FIT TO LIVE/YOU ARE STUPID/ YOU ARE EVIL/ YOU ARE WICKED , yet this is coming from people who are trying to claim they are more tolerant than those they are against LOL |
Re: Why Are Nigerians So Tribalistic? by RichyBlacK(m): 7:23pm On Oct 05, 2007 |
Kobojunkie: What is your point? Assuming the girl is an advocate of tribalism, can you tell me how things would have played differently? Anyway, I'm encouraged that you're trying to move away from the tribalism-is-good camp. But your new adeniyi83-is-not-telling-the-truth camp is only less worse. |
Re: Why Are Nigerians So Tribalistic? by Kobojunkie: 7:27pm On Oct 05, 2007 |
Kobojunkie: ttHAT AGAIN IS MY POINT!! |
Re: Why Are Nigerians So Tribalistic? by RichyBlacK(m): 7:33pm On Oct 05, 2007 |
RichyBlacK: Kobojunkie: @Kobojunkie, I have not attacked you personally! Common, why should I do that? I'm only trying to understand your point. This is a forum where our views and ideas should speak for us. I don't know you personally, but I'm trying to understand your position on this issue on this thread. I believe everyone should be confident enough to say what their opinion or view-point is on an issue. I just want to know if you are also a racist. I mean, you've already expressed your strong support for tribalism. If you advocate racism then say so clearly. For example, I am actively against racism. I just made my position clear. You can too. However, you also reserve the right not to declare your position. That would only lead me (and the many reading this thread) to conclude for ourselves what your position is. Why is it difficult to categorically state whether you support racism or not? |
Re: Why Are Nigerians So Tribalistic? by laudate: 7:41pm On Oct 05, 2007 |
Kobojunkie: Hahaha. . . . .make una no stop me, I beg I must laugh well, well because this one na another line of reasoning entirely. So because a person lives in Lagos, he or she cannot be deemed to be tribalistic? Is that what you are saying?? Chei!! I have seen, heard and even met tribalistic people of all shades from various ethnic groups, who live and trade freely in Lagos. In fact, my first encounter with tribalism was in Lagos o! Kai! |
Re: Why Are Nigerians So Tribalistic? by laudate: 7:43pm On Oct 05, 2007 |
RichyBlacK: Richyblack, just save your breath. This is known as the 'beating-around-the-bush' tactic. We can all read between the lines! |
Re: Why Are Nigerians So Tribalistic? by RichyBlacK(m): 8:14pm On Oct 05, 2007 |
iya aje: A clear misunderstanding of the relationship between tribalism and nationalism. Are you trying to say that if we were separate nations then tribalism won't exist? Kobojunkie: Obvious!
Blaming the victim.
People make stupid choices everyday. Are we to respect them too? Some of the choices people make are illegal and immoral, should they also command our respect?
So, he should leave his work and go do research on why she is a tribalist? |
Re: Why Are Nigerians So Tribalistic? by RichyBlacK(m): 8:41pm On Oct 05, 2007 |
laudate: @Laudate, I just want her to make a clear stand. Everyone has a right to advocate tribalism or racism. However, the most harmful to society are those that disguise their true identity. I once had a chat with some skinhead dude at a rally (they were having a rally with full police protection). The guy's stand was clear - "I don't consider blacks, Jews, Asians, Mexicans, and all those other kind of people as equal to Whites. We are the superior race!". The guy made his point. If I meet him tomorrow on the bus, at the mall, in the parking lot, come across his article somewhere, meet him at a party, in the club, anywhere, I'll know what to expect from him. But the ones that don't come out straight, and try to jump from one convenient camp to another, but remaining fixed to a racist world view - deep down in their minds, are the hardest to deal with. People should be proud to express their views or beliefs without being equivocal. But that's just a first-level look, we still reserve the right to judge them by their words and actions, yes we still reserve that right! We humans are biased and potentially evil at heart, however, it's one thing to admit this human flaw, and it's another thing to decide what direction to move from there - advance, retrogress or remain fixed to that primeval state. |
Re: Why Are Nigerians So Tribalistic? by Kobojunkie: 11:07pm On Oct 05, 2007 |
Anyways, No need for the personals. Whenever you want to tell us more of what REALLY happened and how you arrived at your claim that she is TRIBALISTIC. Please Let me know , I know so far you have done nothing but call me names but I am sorry dude, Me and my guys have had this sort of thing happen to us and I for one know that I have my reservations when it comes to who I will go out with and who I will not even bother with but like I have said all along, your story no straight at all @Adeniyi for me to conclude that you are right and so I can not side with you at all based on the limited information you have produced on this. Now you may not like that another dude is telling you this but I have to be honest, I do not believe in taking sides just so I can make you feel good. I don't !!! |
Re: Why Are Nigerians So Tribalistic? by Kobojunkie: 11:07pm On Oct 05, 2007 |
quote author=RichyBlacK link=topic=83196.msg1561502#msg1561502 date=1191609232] @Kobojunkie, I have not attacked you personally! Common, why should I do that? I'm only trying to understand your point. This is a forum where our views and ideas should speak for us. I don't know you personally, but I'm trying to understand your position on this issue on this thread. I believe everyone should be confident enough to say what their opinion or view-point is on an issue. I just want to know if you are also a racist. I mean, you've already expressed your strong support for tribalism. If you advocate racism then say so clearly. For example, I am actively against racism. I just made my position clear. You can too. However, you also reserve the right not to declare your position. That would only lead me (and the many reading this thread) to conclude for ourselves what your position is. Why is it difficult to categorically state whether you support racism or not? [quote][/quote] Actually , I will take it that when you try to JUMP on me and my personal life, leaving the topic aside, you do not see how that could be seen as personal attack I do not understand what BUSINESS of yours what my personal views on these issues are in the first place when the THREAD has Nothing to do with what KOBOJUNKIE feels about RACISM or no RACISM , but more to do with how people see and understand what the initial poster posted up there, Which is what I have been answering for a while now but you seem to have digressed and are more into personal attacks on me than on the main subject at hand. Let me explain myself again, If you DO NOT lIKE that I DO NOT SEE THE WORLD through your eyes, once again, I am sorry I can not help you. I stand firm on my view of what the guy posted and You can look up my History and whatever you want to, I would rather focus on topic than go off on these games with you. If you CANNOT stick to the topic, I would suggest that you please ignore my posts and let me deal directly with those that I wish to. I prefer to talk to people who can stick to topic and argue their points without the many personal attacks which I consider really crude and immature. Trust me, I really do not care what you want to believe of me, I am here to chat with people who are able to do same in a civilized manner and with respect for those who do not share the same views as they do. |
Re: Why Are Nigerians So Tribalistic? by RichyBlacK(m): 11:14pm On Oct 05, 2007 |
Kobojunkie: I'm sorry but you don't sound like a dude. |
Re: Why Are Nigerians So Tribalistic? by Kobojunkie: 11:16pm On Oct 05, 2007 |
AGAIN, If I am a dude or dudette, please , it is NONE OF YOUR BUSINESS!!! Focus on the topic or accept that I am not here to please so and so I am allowed to have a view different from yours, What has my being a dude or not a dude to do with the topic or my discussing the topic?? Is you not thinking me a dude some thing for you to say that would be a reason for my argument not being as valid as yours?? Why in the world would you even raise that as an issue?? |
Re: Why Are Nigerians So Tribalistic? by Ka: 11:22pm On Oct 05, 2007 |
Beneli: Can somebody be "proud" of their ethnic group, while NOT being a tribalist?Well, I don't know exactly what 'tribalist' means. Does it refer to someone who believes that his ethnic group should progress at the expense of other groups? Someone who believes that it is not enough for his group to do well, other groups must do badly? If so, then yes - it is possible to be proud of your ethnic group without being a 'tribalist'. In other words, if i am proud to be a Gwari man, would somebody who doesn't like the GWARI's then assume that I am a tribalist for being proud of my heritage?They might - but what do you care? You're proud of your group - you feel good about belonging to a group that has given you a language to speak, a set of customs to practice and a culture to be part of. As long as your pride in your group does not cause you to act unfairly or unprofessionally, as long as it does not cause you to feel malevolence towards someone not from your group, what's the problem? Do I, because I am NIGERIAN, stop being GWARI or is it alright for me to be proudly GWARI, but also passionately de-tribalised?I don't know if you can be Gwari and detribalised. You can certainly be Nigerian and Gwari, though. |
Re: Why Are Nigerians So Tribalistic? by dtwsola(m): 3:49am On Oct 06, 2007 |
Keep in mind that there is really no such thing as Nigeria. There is Yoruba land, Igbo Land, Hausa Land, etc. Nigeria is a creation of British imperialists who deserted the country after rampaging it, stealing it's resources (both natural and human), and imposing their nonsense religion on it's people,. What do you expect when arbitrary boundaries are drawn up irrespective of the fact that the people living within the boundaries may have different cultures languages and customs. We will one day overcome it all, and learn to respect each other. |
Re: Why Are Nigerians So Tribalistic? by femo01(m): 11:14am On Oct 06, 2007 |
because we are very parochial in our thots |
Re: Why Are Nigerians So Tribalistic? by Kobojunkie: 1:06pm On Oct 06, 2007 |
dtw_sola: but @dtw_sola , does respecting each other mean I do not consider my tribal roots when making decisions at all is that what you are speaking of here?? I do not believe that to respect another's ideology, I have to drop my tribal loyalty/beliefs in other to do so. I happen to be one who respects whatever belief's people choose to ascribe to but have never found my respecting them to conflict in anyway with my tribal beliefs ( if I have any that I cling to, can't think of any at the moment). |
Re: Why Are Nigerians So Tribalistic? by laudate: 2:24pm On Oct 06, 2007 |
Ka: Of course you can be Gwari and detribalised. Same way you can be Gwari and tribalistic. It seems that some folks here have a different understanding of what tribalism means, and what it is to be tribalistic, while others have a different perspective of what tribalism means or what it is to be tribalistic. Tribalism within the context in which it is practised in Nigeria, is totally different from the textbook definition someone was trying to advocate earlier. Tribalism is practised in Nigeria, with a singular motive - to discredit other ethnic groups and scorn their members. In my own view, being 'tribalistic' has the same meaning as 'discrimination', based on ethnicity. Being tribalistic means holding the myopic, ethnocentric view, that individuals from a particular ethnic group would all behave in a certain way based on sterotypes that one has heard about such an ethnic group, without taking into account each individual's personal characteristics, beliefs, attitudes, character and personality traits in order to make a fair judgement. Being tribalistic also means viewing your own ethnic group as superior to others, while putting down other ethnic groups due to some misguided belief that more saints exist within your own group, while more sinners exist in other groups. Being tribalistic also means being parochial and prejudiced against an individual solely on the basis of the fact that he comes from an ethnic group, that is different from your own. Being tribalistic also means promoting members of your own ethnic group, and advancing their own prospects at the expense of those from other ethnic groups. Being tribalistic has nothing to do with being nationalistic, as nationalism includes being proud of your own nation, ethnic group or linguistic heritage, without denigrating or putting down other ethnic groups, and it allows you to exhibit a sense of patriotism and offer equal esteem/respect to other ethnic groups. With nationalism, you do not see other ethnic groups from the perspective of stereotypes. Neither do you think they have to be bad, for your own nation or ethnic group to be better. Tribalism is closely linked to racism and homophobia. And I see nothing good in all these three! |
Re: Why Are Nigerians So Tribalistic? by Kobojunkie: 2:27pm On Oct 06, 2007 |
Yet Webster defines those words differently , interesting , I smell a Nigerian dictionary of English words coming soon !!! |
Re: Why Are Nigerians So Tribalistic? by laudate: 3:47pm On Oct 06, 2007 |
Kobojunkie: If you feel Webster's Dictionary is the sole authority on the definition of tribalism, you are free to hold on to your views. New words find their way into various dictionaries all the time. Even existing words have their meanings revised and expanded from time to time. A few years ago the word "bootylicious" did not exist in the English lexicon. But today, thanks to Beyonce and some American stars, the word has found its way into many dictionaries, and is now a synonym for sexual attractiveness, especially around the rear end of the feminine gender. A large number of researchers are still trying to grapple with the definition of the word "tribalism." Many of them do not merely rely on the simplistic definition that dictionaries like Webster, have given. They have recognised that its' effects permeate the daily lives of several people, and it goes far beyond that simplistic definition. Let me give you a few examples: In its' reference to tribalism Wikipedia states that: wikipedia: While ethnocentrism is one of only a very small handful of human cultural universals, the term "tribalism" has become nearly synonymous with it. This is largely due to the Eurocentrism of early anthropologists who forced tribal societies into a simplistic model of cultural evolution. Many tribes refer to themselves with their language's word for "people," while referring to other, neighboring tribes with various epithets. For example, the term "Inuit" translates as "people," but they were known to the Ojibwe by a name translating roughly as "eaters of raw meat." This fact is often cited as evidence that tribal peoples saw only the members of their own tribe as "people," and denigrated all others as something less. In fact, this is a tenuous conclusion to draw from the evidence. Many languages refined their identification as "the true people," or "the real people," suggesting that there were other people, who were simply inferior .http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tribalism Other researchers have described tribalism in other ways. In an article on the Tegloma tribe of Sierra-Leone, a writer J.L Musa - in a critique of the assesment given by a scholar Prof. Kamara - had this to say: J.L Musa:http://www.sulima.com/afvision/newsroom/newsroom.shtml Another scholar yet again describes it like this: Hutcheon: Let me stop here. You can see that the definition of tribalism should not be restricted to just what Websters dictionary has to say. |
Re: Why Are Nigerians So Tribalistic? by laudate: 3:55pm On Oct 06, 2007 |
Oh, one last word: Lindeke:http://www.polytechnic.edu.na/echoes/story1.htm This is just to show another definition or description of tribalism. You can take your pick. Just remember that "a little learning is a dangerous thing." |
Re: Why Are Nigerians So Tribalistic? by redsun(m): 4:11pm On Oct 06, 2007 |
Tribalism just like racism is due to stack ignorance,limited horizon,people dread what they don't understand and fail to inquire.It's like africans calling oyibo man racist,while in africa people live like cats and dogs,yoruba man calling ibo man OKORO,genocide in rwanda, in that small vicinity they still can't understand one another.By and by,tribalism and racism are part of man's primitive instint and territorial nature that refuse let go even with the so-called advancement,still living like hunter gatherers worldwide.Imagine,John Lennon. |
Re: Why Are Nigerians So Tribalistic? by faketan(m): 5:13pm On Oct 06, 2007 |
Redsun, you are spot on. I have tried to say something like this before but men you put it exactly the way it is. |
Re: Why Are Nigerians So Tribalistic? by beneli(m): 6:28pm On Oct 06, 2007 |
If tribalism AKA "us-versus-them thinking" is a primordial instinct, and if my understanding from the discourse so far is correct; then identifying with ones own cultural group and taking pride in it, may not be that bad after all. Along the lines of the Nationalism thing that laudate mentions. In other words one can still be proudly Gwari and still be passionately Nigerian. But if it is, then this is were educating ourselves becomes vey important. But unfortunately, nothing much is being done in that sphere. Once upon a time the government had promoted that students learn at least one other Nigerian language other than there own. I don't know how that's worked out so far. But I think it was a laudable thing. Even the NYSC as originally concieved was supposed to have also helped, as the objective had been, in my understanding, to get people to live in communities other than their own, to try to understand a bit more about these communities and perhaps learn that underneath all those -isms, that we are, after all, all the same. This was again another laudable idea. But one wonders if it has been living up to those objectives. I know that Nigeria is at a crossroad. But i still believe that one day we will be able to learn to live together in a new Nigeria, a Nigeria in which we have internalised the fact that the "others" are not always wrong or bad and in which we have come to appreciate that those who are not of our "culture" are actually a lot more like us than we had once wanted to believe. |
Re: Why Are Nigerians So Tribalistic? by MP007(m): 1:31am On Oct 07, 2007 |
please shut up, we are stil dealin with racism ok, tribalistic whatever, am sure u got hometownism 2 coming up, ".CANT WE ALL JUST GET ALONG"(QUOTE FROM THE MOVIE COLOR PURPLE) |
Re: Why Are Nigerians So Tribalistic? by Bosdem(f): 10:18am On Oct 08, 2007 |
It sad but what can we do, even we the so called literate are tribalistic |
Re: Why Are Nigerians So Tribalistic? by mufikings(m): 12:27pm On Oct 08, 2007 |
This is it,its simple and precise. Tribalism,racism,hate and whatever you want to call it are all rooted from "Hell" these are simply mechnisms of the devil to cause human hate !! The greatest commandment is LOVE,and love in totality,I don't understand all this grammar here and there,if you are Igbo,Yoruba,Hausa or whatever,you need to get born again,bacos any one with a tribalistic heart has no place in the body of christ. That's one of the reason alot of Nigeria Christains will miss heaven,"not my prayer" Our diverse groups and nature came about through man's sin remember the old testament "Nimroid" it's a cause upon man that people hold so close to their hearts. I just don't understand how a lot of parents who are supposedly elders in churches encourage their children to hate vis a vi "Tribalism" it's crazy,you miss heaven,seriously. You have no place in God's family being tribalistic,its a one way ticket to everlasting damation"Period" God help us all !!!! I rest my case. |
Re: Why Are Nigerians So Tribalistic? by champredd(m): 6:58pm On Oct 08, 2007 |
We must strive to overcome tribalism so as to work together for the betterment of our country, Naija. |
Re: Why Are Nigerians So Tribalistic? by imelachi(f): 12:39pm On Oct 09, 2007 |
this is common among the yorubas . they feel superior to other tribe.especially on education they only want them to be in the university. so that is nature |
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (Reply)
Nigerian Men Vs Black-American Men! / Rare Yoruba Gods / Orishaa / Ise! Does Every Group In The Igboid Language Group Use It.
(Go Up)
Sections: politics (1) business autos (1) jobs (1) career education (1) romance computers phones travel sports fashion health religion celebs tv-movies music-radio literature webmasters programming techmarket Links: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) Nairaland - Copyright © 2005 - 2024 Oluwaseun Osewa. All rights reserved. See How To Advertise. 131 |