Welcome, Guest: Register On Nairaland / LOGIN! / Trending / Recent / New
Stats: 3,168,856 members, 7,872,855 topics. Date: Thursday, 27 June 2024 at 12:17 AM

Mourinho: Genius Or Fluke - European Football (EPL, UEFA, La Liga) (18) - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum / Entertainment / Sports / European Football (EPL, UEFA, La Liga) / Mourinho: Genius Or Fluke (28813 Views)

Poll: Mourinho is

Over-rated: 36% (4 votes)
Simply good: 63% (7 votes)
This poll has ended

Is Louis Van Gaal Still A Tactical Genius? / Genius Messi Breaks Another Record Set By Raul. / Cesc Fabregas - The Spanish Genius At The Heart Of Arsenal (2) (3) (4)

(1) (2) (3) ... (15) (16) (17) (18) (19) (20) (21) ... (28) (Reply) (Go Down)

Re: Mourinho: Genius Or Fluke by dayokanu(m): 5:31pm On Mar 17, 2010
I don't get this hate.
What has SAF, Wenger, Ancellotti, De Bosque, Rijkard etc won that he hasn't?
A man who won 67% of his games and lost only 11% in his career is a fking GENIUS !!!

Where is the hate?

I dont see one I only see overhype

Del Bosque won 2 CL, Hitzfeld won 2 CL in 2 different clubs, SAF won 2 CL, Carlo won 2 CL

Yet somone says Mourinho is top 2.
How is he better than Rijakaard, Pep(Who won treble).

He is better than Wenger no Doubt but top 5 is pushing it too far
Re: Mourinho: Genius Or Fluke by Nobody: 5:44pm On Mar 17, 2010
his is because Jose Mourinho is a glory hunter who only seeks to work in clubs that are ready to splash top dollar on quality players.
Let him go to Stoke FC or West Brom and start from the scratch like SAF did with United or how Rijkaard did with Barcelona and win with them.

You forget Porto was an average team when they won the CL.

Let SAF go and manage Stoke let's see where they'll end up.
Every manager with pedigree will look out for standard teams, it's only logical.

Why isn't Pep a glory-hunter? Winning six trophies with a ready made team.
Yet you call JM a glory-hunter.

Where is the hate?

I dont see one I only see overhype

Del Bosque won 2 CL, Hitzfeld won 2 CL in 2 different clubs, SAF won 2 CL, Carlo won 2 CL

Yet somone says Mourinho is top 2.
How is he better than Rijakaard, Pep(Who won treble).

He is better than Wenger no Doubt but top 5 is pushing it too far

Who is to say JM won't win it 2wice or 3ice in his career?
The man is still young, he still has things to prove.
Re: Mourinho: Genius Or Fluke by Wahala90: 5:56pm On Mar 17, 2010
GoatCrants claim that Mourinho succeeded because Chelsea had the best players. Now Mourinho used a different team (Inter) to "disgrace" the Chelsea team, beating them home and away. GoatCrants are now bloating that the Chelsea team is not a strong one and there is nothing special about beating them. GoatCrants, you know what? Give Mourinho this Chelsea team and he will beat this Inter side mercilessly. Jose is a special coach, whether in Porto or Calabar Rovers. The guy has proved it. Or what do you think, GoatCrants? Anyway, being GoatCrants that you are, I expect you to be stubborn, obstinate and obstreperous.
Re: Mourinho: Genius Or Fluke by Sauron1: 6:02pm On Mar 17, 2010
BlueDiva:

You forget Porto was an average team when they won the CL.

They were not. . . . . .Porto are the biggest team in Portugal.
Porto had won Champions League and countless league titles before Jose's arrival. . . .They have won countless league titles after Jose's exit.
With or without Jose Mourinho, Porto are a great side.


Let SAF go and manage Stoke let's see where they'll end up.
Every manager with pedigree will look out for standard teams, it's only logical.

United were swimming in relegation waters before SAF's arrival.
The club had gone a massive 34 years without a league title until SAF won it for Man Utd.
Go and read a book.


Why isn't Pep a glory-hunter? Winning six trophies with a ready made team.
Yet you call JM a glory-hunter.

Pep isn't a glory-hunter.
He is managing a team he once played for. . . . .He has not jumped from Lyon to Liverpool to Real Madrid.
Jose went from Porto to Chelsea to Inter Milan. . . . . .Which of these teams are small minnows?


Who is to say JM won't win it 2wice or 3ice in his career?
The man is still young, he still has things to prove.

When he wins it twice or thrice more in his career, come back to us then and we shall applaud his brilliance but for now. . . . . .He is overrated.
Re: Mourinho: Genius Or Fluke by Nobody: 7:06pm On Mar 17, 2010
They were not. . . . . .Porto are the biggest team in Portugal.
Porto had won Champions League and countless league titles before Jose's arrival. . . .They have won countless league titles after Jose's exit.
With or without Jose Mourinho, Porto are a great side.

Good side my foot.
When last did they reach the semis in the UCL?

Which other decent competitors do they have in their league.
Portuguese league is not amongst the top 5, sorry!!!

According to you guys, without the UCL a team ain't great.
JM made Porto great. i don't see Porto winning the UCL in the next 20years.

Pep isn't a glory-hunter.
He is managing a team he once played for. . . . .He has not jumped from Lyon to Liverpool to Real Madrid.
Jose went from Porto to Chelsea to Inter Milan. . . . . .Which of these teams are small minnows?

What does that mean?

Amodu will win six trophies with the Barca team.
Pep is a glory-hunter too, using your theory.

Someday, JM will manage the United team.
then i trust you to start hyping him. cheesy
Re: Mourinho: Genius Or Fluke by chic2pimp(m): 7:29pm On Mar 17, 2010
dayokanu:

And he couldnt win with a bunch of millionaires in Chelsea.

Del Bosques real Madrid of 2000 was one of the worst teams in Europe. They had lost 8-3 in the groups to Bayern and needed a last day win at Rosenburg to qualify.

Hitzfeld won with Dortmund.

Ancelotti won with AC Milan the same AC Milan that was disgraced 7-2 last week
Give it a rest will ya.
It ain't the same side.
The Milan team of 2003-2007 is the best we've had since the 1994 team.


BlueDiva:

You forget Porto was an average team when they won the CL.

Let SAF go and manage Stoke let's see where they'll end up.
Every manager with pedigree will look out for standard teams, it's only logical.

Why isn't Pep a glory-hunter? Winning six trophies with a ready made team.
Yet you call JM a glory-hunter.

Who is to say JM won't win it 2wice or 3ice in his career?
The man is still young, he still has things to prove.
Porto weren't an average side ooo.
Not With The likes of Carvalho,J.Costa, and Ferreira in defence plus Maniche,costinha and Deco in Midfield
Re: Mourinho: Genius Or Fluke by Nobody: 7:36pm On Mar 17, 2010
Porto weren't an average side ooo.
Not With The likes of Carvalho,J.Costa, and Ferreira in defence plus Maniche,costinha and Deco in Midfield

So? Big names don't matter.
They would have achieved nothing in Europe without JM.

Madrid has stars yet they can't deliver.
Throw in a world class manager (like JM) and watch them conquer Europe.
Re: Mourinho: Genius Or Fluke by chic2pimp(m): 7:44pm On Mar 17, 2010
BlueDiva:

So? Big names don't matter.
They would have achieved nothing in Europe without JM

Madrid has stars yet they can't deliver.
Throw in a world class manager (like JM) and watch them conquer Europe.
I agree.
However to call that Porto side average is really pushing it.
I won't Mourinho a flukey manager neither will I Label him a Genius just yet. Give it 5 years and we'll see,
Re: Mourinho: Genius Or Fluke by Sauron1: 7:46pm On Mar 17, 2010
BlueDiva:

Good side my foot.
When last did they reach the semis in the UCL?

When last did Bayern Munich reach the semis in the UCL?
Does that mean they are not a great side?


Which other decent competitors do they have in their league.
Portuguese league is not amongst the top 5, sorry!!!

It is not their league that won it. . . . .Porto won it and they were a decent side in 2004.


According to you guys, without the UCL a team ain't great.
JM made Porto great. i don't see Porto winning the UCL in the next 20years.

It's the other way round. . . . .Porto made Jose Mourinho great!!!
He has not played in a European final since he left Porto. . . .



Amodu will win six trophies with the Barca team.
Pep is a glory-hunter too, using your theory.

The season before Guardiola arrived, Barcelona did not win any title in Spain.
Guardiola arrived and tweaked the squad a bit and they won six trophies in 12 months.


Someday, JM will manage the United team.
then i trust you to start hyping him.  cheesy

We don't want bad publicity.
Guardiola will manage Man Utd before Jose Mourinho.
Re: Mourinho: Genius Or Fluke by Nobody: 8:07pm On Mar 17, 2010
I agree.
However to call that Porto side average is really pushing it.
I won't Mourinho a flukey manager neither will I Label him a Genius just yet. Give it 5 years and we'll see,

Thanks.
You're reasonable, to call him a fluke is ludicrous.
Re: Mourinho: Genius Or Fluke by A40(m): 8:08pm On Mar 17, 2010
Mourinho is defo World class anyone that argues otherwise think they know but really they have no idea cos the stats and records are there to prove it. He won the UCL with absolute nobodies in 04! Who was Deco, Maniche, Costinha, Aleynichev, Derlei, Carlos Alberto, Carvalho et al the only notable players they had then where an ageing Jorge Costa and Vitor Baia. Porto where shyte before he got there and unto shyte they have returned. He won the UEFA Cup and UCL back to back! Is it beans? Abeg make una pay the man his respects the guy walks his talk and he proved it yesterday
Re: Mourinho: Genius Or Fluke by dayokanu(m): 8:17pm On Mar 17, 2010
He won the UEFA Cup and UCL back to back! Is it beans? Abeg make una pay the man his respects the guy walks his talk and he proved it yesterday

Benitez did this even wth different clubs which is even more difficult

Mourinho is defo World class anyone that argues otherwise think they know but really they have no idea cos the stats and records are there to prove it. He won the UCL with absolute nobodies in 04! Who was Deco, Maniche, Costinha, Aleynichev, Derlei, Carlos Alberto, Carvalho et al the only notable players they had then where an ageing Jorge Costa and Vitor Baia.

WHy hasnt he been able to repeat the feat even with more resources and better players than he had at Porto
Re: Mourinho: Genius Or Fluke by chic2pimp(m): 8:19pm On Mar 17, 2010
BlueDiva:

Thanks.
You're reasonable, to call him a fluke is ludicrous.

Don't mind Dayo,Sauron , Eastbay and co.
The dude won two european trophies back to back and he is labelled a Fluke, How so?

A-40:

Mourinho is defo World class anyone that argues otherwise think they know but really they have no idea cos the stats and records are there to prove it. He won the UCL with absolute nobodies in 04! Who was Deco, Maniche, Costinha, Aleynichev, Derlei, Carlos Alberto, Carvalho et al the only notable players they had then where an ageing Jorge Costa and Vitor Baia. Porto where shyte before he got there and unto shyte they have returned. He won the UEFA Cup and UCL back to back! Is it beans? Abeg make una pay the man his respects the guy walks his talk and he proved it yesterday
True Talk!!!!
He walks the walk and talks and talk.
Re: Mourinho: Genius Or Fluke by Nobody: 8:25pm On Mar 17, 2010
Benitez did this even wth different clubs which is even more difficult

Benitez who hasn't managed the EPl in six yrs?
The same man battling for 5th place?

JM never goes to any club without winning the league.
At worst, he'll come 2nd.

JM haters have no case abeg.
Re: Mourinho: Genius Or Fluke by Sauron1: 8:29pm On Mar 17, 2010
BlueDiva:

Benitez who hasn't managed the EPl in six yrs?
The same man battling for 5th place?

JM never goes to any club without winning the league.
At worst, he'll come 2nd.

JM haters have no case abeg.

This is because he aims for football clubs that work with finished products.
I want to see Jose Mourinho pick a team from scratch and develop them into world beaters like Rijkaard, SAF, Hitzfeld and Wenger have all done.

FFS, i realised Jose Mourinho is a fluke after Avram fuckin Grant took Chelsea to UCL final.
Grant had no coaching badge when he was Terry's penalty kick away from winning the biggest competition in Europe.
Re: Mourinho: Genius Or Fluke by doyin13(m): 8:29pm On Mar 17, 2010
He is not crap but he is not as good as he thinks he is. . . .

He peddles the impression most of what happens on the field
is up to his genius . . .

I wonder what was genius about the disallowed Scholes goal
and useless mitts Tim Howard has for hands that are largely
responsible for his meteoric rise.
Re: Mourinho: Genius Or Fluke by dayokanu(m): 8:30pm On Mar 17, 2010
Benitez who hasn't managed the EPl in six yrs?
The same man battling for 5th place?

Mourinho who hasnt managed a European trophy outside Porto in 7 seasons

JM never goes to any club without winning the league.
At worst, he'll come 2nd.

JM haters have no case abeg.

Benitez never goes to a club without winning a European title

Benitez CL 1 winner 1 runner up. UEFA cup 1 winners title and he has the La Liga title too managing a club outside the big 2.
Re: Mourinho: Genius Or Fluke by dayokanu(m): 8:32pm On Mar 17, 2010
He is not crap but he is not as good as he thinks he is. . . .

He peddles the impression most of what happens on the field
is up to his genius . . .

I wonder what was genius about the disallowed Scholes goal
and useless mitts Tim Howard has for hands that are largely
responsible for his meteoric rise.

Actually I supported FC porto on that day and jubilated crazily when Costinha scored. Right now 7 seasons after seeing how Jose is going about the Chelsea god image I wished Manure had won on that March 2004 night.
Re: Mourinho: Genius Or Fluke by doyin13(m): 8:35pm On Mar 17, 2010
I can never wish Man Utd win anything so no regrets about
jubilating that day. . .

I don't know why he is still strutting around though.

His Inter team still doesn't convince me, although they
are better than last year's.
Re: Mourinho: Genius Or Fluke by Sauron1: 8:35pm On Mar 17, 2010
dayokanu:

Actually I supported FC porto on that day and jubilated crazily when Costinha scored. Right now 7 seasons after seeing how Jose is going about the Chelsea god image I wished Manure had won on that March 2004 night.

We did enough to win but a visually-impaired line assistant made sure United did not progress.
Scholesy's perfect goal was disallowed to have made it 2-0 at OT in the first half.

Porto equalised in the last minute and United couldn't do anything to salvage the match.
Not to talk of the number of times Porto players were diving to stop United's flow throughout the game.
Re: Mourinho: Genius Or Fluke by Nobody: 8:38pm On Mar 17, 2010
This is because he aims for football clubs that work with finished products.
I want to see Jose Mourinho pick a team from scratch and develop them into world beaters like Rijkaard, SAF, Hitzfeld and Wenger have all done.

Can Stoke afford his wages?

Don't blame the player, blame da game !!!  wink
The rich clubs will kill to have him. Ain't his fault.

Mourinho who hasnt managed a European trophy outside Porto in 7 seasons

It took SAF 9yrs to win in Europe again.
Let's don't even go into the luck thing.

Give JM time.
Re: Mourinho: Genius Or Fluke by chic2pimp(m): 8:41pm On Mar 17, 2010
dayokanu:

Actually I supported FC porto on that day and jubilated crazily when Costinha scored. Right now 7 seasons after seeing how Jose is going about the Chelsea god image I wished Manure had won on that March 2004 night.
Who can forget this now legendary celebration cheesy cheesy

[flash=425,344]
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b8gGUwCDMrI&hl=en_GB&fs=1&"[/flash]

doyin13:


I wonder what was genius about the disallowed Scholes goal
and useless mitts Tim Howard has for hands that are largely
responsible for his meteoric rise.
It's all 'IF'S and 'BUT'S'
Re: Mourinho: Genius Or Fluke by dayokanu(m): 8:42pm On Mar 17, 2010
Mourinho who hasnt managed a European trophy outside Porto in 7 seasons
Benitez never goes to a club without winning a European title

Benitez CL 1 winner 1 runner up. UEFA cup 1 winners title and he has the La Liga title too managing a club outside the big 2.
Re: Mourinho: Genius Or Fluke by Sauron1: 8:42pm On Mar 17, 2010
BlueDiva:

Can Stoke afford his wages?

Why not?
Notts County will pay Mourinho's wages.


Don't blame the player, blame da game !!!  wink
The rich clubs will kill to have him. Ain't his fault.

Just like the rich clubs will kill to have Carlos Queiroz but he's an assistant in Man Utd.


It took SAF 9yrs to win in Europe again.
Let's don't even go into the luck thing.

Give JM time.

So how's he special if we have to give him time to play in a European final again?
Special managers should be playing in the final every season.
Re: Mourinho: Genius Or Fluke by dayokanu(m): 8:47pm On Mar 17, 2010
It took SAF 9yrs to win in Europe again.
Let's don't even go into the luck thing.

Give JM time.

If you give a dullard enough time, he would figure out calculus even if its by using bottle corks.

Geniuses, Special ones should actually not take ages to play another CL final
Re: Mourinho: Genius Or Fluke by Nobody: 8:55pm On Mar 17, 2010
If you give a dullard enough time, he would figure out calculus even if its by using bottle corks.

Geniuses, Special ones should actually not take ages to play another CL final

Do we call SAF a dullard?
It took him 9yrs to win again.

His winning was in the hands of the gods, not his own efforts.

Off to tend my flock.
JM rocks !!! cool
Re: Mourinho: Genius Or Fluke by A40(m): 8:55pm On Mar 17, 2010
@Dayokanu
Who cares? Its on record that he won both titles back to back

Secondly na so easy? Even Faggotson has only managed 2 UCL titles in 19years. Mind you it took him 9 years to pick each title so whats the fuss about Mourinho? Benitez has also not won a league since leaving Valencia while Mourinho has won the league in 2 other countries

@doyin13
That Man U team was cadaver and the Scholes excuse is rubbish even if it counted Costinha's goal woulda dragged the game to extras so its no biggie
Re: Mourinho: Genius Or Fluke by Sauron1: 8:58pm On Mar 17, 2010
BlueDiva:

Do we call SAF a dullard?
It took him 9yrs to win again.

His winning was in the hands of the gods, not his own efforts.

SAF has done it TWICE in elite Europe. . . .
Jose should repeat it as well.
Re: Mourinho: Genius Or Fluke by dayokanu(m): 8:59pm On Mar 17, 2010
Secondly na so easy? Even Faggotson has only managed 2 UCL titles in 19years. Mind you it took him 9 years to pick each title so whats the fuss about Mourinho? Benitez has also not won a league since leaving Valencia while Mourinho has won the league in 2 other countries


Benitez won league title with Valencia which was a bugger achievement than winning leagues with Porto, Chelsea or Inter Milan.

Benitez won CL with Liverpool who hardly play CL football this is a greater achievement than winning the CL with Porto who are a regular fixture in the CL.

Mourinho has not played a European final since leaving Porto, Benitez has played twice since leaving Valencia.

Which carries more weight, European stage or local league?
Re: Mourinho: Genius Or Fluke by A40(m): 9:43pm On Mar 17, 2010
@Dayokanu
Valencia where quality then jare! The only other legit teams in Spain where Depor and Madrid so don't make it sound like Valencia where shyte. They made the UCL Finals twice at the turn of the millenium contrast that to a Porto who where European nobodies just there to make the numbers due to their local champion status. Or else you want to tell us Korea are world powers since they have not missed the mundial since 94

Benitez has not managed a league title in 6 seasons since Valencia he only even competed once. The local league may carry less weight but its harder to win than the UCL, Benitez won the UCL and finished almost 50pts behind the winners and even finished 5th thats not good enuff and thats why i would always rate Ancelotti and Rafa below Mourinho the only mordern coach i would prolly take over Mourinho is Rijkaard

A student that goes to Berkeley, Yale and Georgetown and takes first position in each school has to be a genius
Re: Mourinho: Genius Or Fluke by Nobody: 9:49pm On Mar 17, 2010
A student that goes to Berkeley, Yale and Georgetown and takes first position in each school has to be a genius

+1
Re: Mourinho: Genius Or Fluke by Wahala90: 9:49pm On Mar 17, 2010
GoatCrants want Mourinho to use minnows to win the UCL. When asked to name a coach or minnow that has won the UCL before? They mentioned R.Madrid and AC Milan. Na wa o. GoatCrant no dey change.

(1) (2) (3) ... (15) (16) (17) (18) (19) (20) (21) ... (28) (Reply)

Leeds United Vs Manchester City (1 - 1) On 3rd October 2020 / Southampton Vs Chelsea (1 - 1) On 28th December 2014 / Manchester City Vs Real Madrid: UCL (0 - 0) On 26th April 2016

(Go Up)

Sections: politics (1) business autos (1) jobs (1) career education (1) romance computers phones travel sports fashion health
religion celebs tv-movies music-radio literature webmasters programming techmarket

Links: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10)

Nairaland - Copyright © 2005 - 2024 Oluwaseun Osewa. All rights reserved. See How To Advertise. 70
Disclaimer: Every Nairaland member is solely responsible for anything that he/she posts or uploads on Nairaland.